Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>pamom - if he decides to apply ED to Elon - I am 100% thrilled. But I don’t want him to do that unless he is really positive - and so far I still see signs that he is not sure of what he wants.</p>

<p>I know it is not always a great thing when a kid has a “dream school” or falls in love with one school - but the opposite is not a lot of fun either. Still hoping that once the academic year is over he will show signs of enthusiasm about picking potential colleges.</p>

<p>momjr:</p>

<p>glad your D had such a wonderful experience going to Israel. Amazing how much they pack in 10 days, huh? glad it finally worked out that she could go.</p>

<p>My one & only trip to Israel was when I was in college and I spent a 3 month summer there…also a fabulous experience. I hope to go back again one of these days. Meanwhile, if I can send my kids over, that would be awesome.</p>

<p>[Students</a> hope for Jewish fraternity on Elon campus | elon, jewish, students - Burlington Times News](<a href=“http://www.thetimesnews.com/articles/elon-44261-jewish-students.html]Students”>http://www.thetimesnews.com/articles/elon-44261-jewish-students.html)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Nice article about the growth in Jewish life at Elon from the local community newspaper. Credit to Rodney for finding this one.</p>

<p>Shattered Dreams:</p>

<p>Are any of you familiar with the Shattered Dreams program? It is a 2 day program that can be done within a HS to help bring home the message of not drinking and driving. It is hard to assess the effectiveness of programs like this one but some students in our HS’s class dedicated community service organized this and it was a very powerful touching program. The program is very involved but key aspects of the program included:
:
-A realistic mock wreck on campus complete with EMS and lifeflight
-A group of selected couples (sibblings, best friends, boyfriend/girlfriend). One of each couple became the “living dead” or “broken hearted”. Throughout the day one living dead student was pulled from a classroom and the broken hearted read a mock obituary that was prepared by that student’s parents.
-A meeting for students involved at the end of the day
-The next day there was an assembly which featured familes of people killed in such accidents. Those involved included a sibbling of a drunk driver, a parent of an uninvolved killed student and a parent of a killed student who was in a car with a drunk driver but had not been drinking himself.</p>

<p>I am pasting a link to a guideline to a program done by another school but if you are interested in bringing this type of program to your school it is a good starting point.
<a href=“http://www.waco-texas.com/pdf/fire/prevention/Shattered-Dreams-Program.pdf[/url]”>http://www.waco-texas.com/pdf/fire/prevention/Shattered-Dreams-Program.pdf&lt;/a&gt; </p>

<p>I was just distantly involved in the organization but if you have any questions feel free to PM me.</p>

<p>Wow, spectrum, that sounds like quite a program. I am grateful to live in an area where kids don’t really drive that much - they are able to walk or take the bus most places they want to go.
Rockvillemom, I think that you are honing in on this if you can eliminate schools that are too big and/or too urban for your son. Perhaps posters here can suggest the schools that are most similar to Elon, if this is what your son likes.
And, people who WANT bigger or more urban could go “opposite” of Rockvillemom!
Rockvillemom, I still think that you should visit Muhlenberg. And perhaps you could compromise on location and visit Brandeis. I really think that your son would like these! One person that I know who liked Elon also liked Ohio Wesleyan, Pitzer, and St. Lawrence. I know that this is geographically spread far and wide! Are any posters familiar with these?</p>

<p>spectrum - thanks for posting this info. It sounds lke a great program - although I am not sure how much any of these help. In our area, there are generally several fatal crashes every spring (seems to be the most common time) - three teens were killed just 2 weeks ago. But given that it happens again and again, not much seems to change.</p>

<p>levirm - agree with you on Muhlenberg. I think S2 considers it “too Jewish” - but then again - I really have no idea. He just crossed it off without explanation. (it’s like those courtroom tv shows when they are picking the jury and one is dismissed for no reason and you always wonder why that juror did not make the cut) Anyway…I’m just in a holding pattern for another few weeks. And if initially we start with just a few - Towson, Susquehanna, Elon and JMU - that’s fine - I’m ok with him applying to those 4 and then we can decide what to do next, if anything.</p>

<p>spectrum - our HS does this program every few years. They last did it D1’s freshman year. I do remember hearing her and her friends talk about it. I think it had an impact on them. D1 still mentions it.</p>

<p>levrim, my son considered Ohio Wesleyan. We did not look into the Jewish life aspect, so I would not be of help in that department. We liked the school very much. The one thing that I did not like was that dorms and academic buildings were far apart and I was picturing how miserable that walk might be during the cold winter/snowy months and during heavy rains. We visited twice on warm sunny days! Even our tour guide commented that her father asked her not to go back to the dorm between classes because she might not leave the dorm again to go to her next class! The distance could be an advantage if one leaves the dorm for the day (less temptation to waste time IMO). My son chose another school because even with merit aid/financial aid, it was too pricey for us.</p>

<p>Rockvillemom, the comment about Muhlenberg being “too Jewish” is puzzling to me because you have indicated that your son is in school with a lot of Jewish kids now, and his major activities are Jewish activities!
There is no way that I can read minds. But, I am just wondering this - could it be that he fears that there are too many kids from New York and he also fears that he will be intimidated because he thinks that these kids are way more sophisticated than he is?
Of course, if you ask him, he would not admit to this sentiment. But, my impression of that school is that none of this is true! He would not be intimidated by anyone and the kids are not that sophisticated. And, stereotypes of New Yorkers are also false.</p>

<p>RVM: I know these accidents do continue to happen and its a easier to identify what messages were not effective based on the accidents that occur than what messages did get through and accidents were averted. The only thing we can do is try and influence as many kids as possible as profoundly as possible. This program was the most powerful don’t drink and drive message that I have encountered. But even not drinking and driving and not texting and driving will not stop young new drivers from getting into serious accidents. That message came accross loud and clear to me earlier this year. BTW in that accident I don’t think I mentioned that I am sure that all involved walked away because all wore seatbelts. Without a doubt it would have been a different story if this were not the case. I have a heightend sensitivity about teen driving and accidents this year.</p>

<p>levirm - believe me - it is puzzling to me too! I’m just thinking of how he reacted when I described Muhlenberg to him - and something that I said just did not go over well - and that’s all I can come up with. But - I would love to take him to see it if he is willing.</p>

<p>spectrum - I agree with you - all we can do is keep educating and keep reinforcing these messages. S2 gets his license very soon - and I am not thrilled.</p>

<p>RVM: Good luck with that! As I dreaded my S’s getting their licenses in HS, I also thought that I preferred for them to learn to drive while they were still at home and not away at college. My one tidbit of advice with my 20/20 hindsight would be to try and know exactly where your new driver is driving so you can warn them about less then obvious difficult situations that they might encounter. We’ve tried to do that since S2’s accident. Don’t you know the intersection that he wrecked on is now getting a much needed traffic light.</p>

<p>So, those of you whose kids went on Birthright trips, (or haven’t yet) you should let them know that there’s a whole lot more to see and do in Israel. Even if they are not BBYO or USYers (as my kids are not). There’s so much to see and it’s great even for vacation. My son was first there when he was 10 and we were doing a three week family tour for his sister’s Bat Mitzvah. He went back for a Birthright trip last summer, so he’s definitely seen a lot of the historic and religious spots, but he chose to go back for a week after finishing up his semester abroad in Spain. I just got an incredibly enthusiastic e-mail from him a fews days ago, of which I’ll share a few parts:</p>

<p>"Israel is really really just a fantastic place, I plan on making frequent trips over my life time and hopefully being able to lead another birthright trip next year. Since I saw all the sights less than a year ago I have been just chilling and partying with my friends here. I have spent pretty much all my time in Tel Aviv, my friend’s family… has an awesome apartment with a rooftop balcony view of the beach its gorgeous. I have been beaching and have eaten tons and tons of delicious food. One of my friend’s friends is in the army and has taken us spear fishing which was awesome, its basically snorkeling with fishing, but with a spear gun instead of a rod. I also went to Yafo to check out the parks and streets. Today I’m going to the Jerusalem to see the wall again and some other stuff. We also plan on going to Haifa tomorrow… Afterwards they took me to a very local Israeli bar which was a nice change of pace. I was speaking English, Spanish and Hebrew with the locals and with them. </p>

<p>There’s a whole other world there which kids really seem to take to.</p>

<p>For those who are worried about their kids starting to drive check in your area to see if a teen car control clinic is offered. In our area the local Audi club along with the local hospital offers clinics twice a year. The kids learn to control their own car over an obstacle course, the fire dept lays down foam to make a slick surface and they go over some classroom work as well. My son balked at going but by the end of the day he was having fun and I felt much better about his driving.</p>

<p>mhc - that sounds so fabulous! You know I have a cousin who went to Israel on Birthright and never returned! Well - she did come back to the US for a while - but always intended to live in Israel and she has been doing so now for 2 years. If S2 ever goes - he will have family to visit.</p>

<p>proudwismom - thank you for mentioning that. I have seen ads for special one day clinics in our area as well. Never did it with S1 - but if I see it offered - might try to get S2 to do it. It certainly can’t hurt.</p>

<p>[College</a> merit aid produces bidding wars - The Washington Post](<a href=“http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/college-merit-aid-produces-bidding-wars/2011/05/17/AG7JwzEH_story.html]College”>http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/college-merit-aid-produces-bidding-wars/2011/05/17/AG7JwzEH_story.html)</p>

<p>Interesting article on a student who chose CofC over American after being awarded good merit aid at CofC. No brand new info - but more support for going with the safety/match school that offers merit aid rather than assuming going to a reach school is the objective.</p>

<p>MHC how wonderful that your child had such a great experience on Birthright and continues the love for Israel. It is such an amazing country.</p>

<p>My S has been driving for 3 months. Scares me completely. He pulled his car in to the driveway and sideswiped my husband’s car. UGH. Maybe this was his wakeup call and that will be his first and only accident. Driving in Jersey is scary.</p>

<p>RVM, had a VT student come to the door today soliciting for clean air organization. Loves VT. Said most of his classes were 12-15 kids. Just 2 of them were large. He said he did well with the math setup. His close friend went to Elon! Small world.</p>

<p>samtalya - interesting about VT - I’m still not convinced it is too big for S2. I don’t think I have come across anyone yet who went there and was unhappy. Given that they don’t offer EA - and the regular deadline is not until January - I’m not worrying about this one right now - but would be happy to reconsider it if he wanted to. </p>

<p>When it comes to size - is there any real difference between say 16,000 and 23,000? In other words - does it make any sense to say JMU is not too big but VT is too big? I don’t really think so - S2 seems to feel differently.</p>

<p>And one more interesting update - S2 struggled so much with precalc in the fall - getting a B for the semester by the skin of his teeth - he now is just shy of an A! While it still is by no means a done deal - he could do it - which would be pretty cool. Of course, when I tried to compliment/encourage him just now by pointing out how close he is to an A - my response was a lot of eye rolling and groaning. But however it turns out - I’m pleased with his grades this semester and that is a relief.</p>

1 Like

<p>RVM, great news on the math!</p>

<p>As for school size, I don’t think there is a difference between 16,000 and 23,000. Where there is a difference is when you get upwards of 30,000 plus. If the campus is situated nicely and the student understands the system of getting in to classes, then I just don’t see that big a difference. </p>

<p>I was impressed with student we met yesterday. He is a rising sophomore and he was giving tours his 2nd semester. He obviously loves VT.</p>

1 Like

<p>Rockville - my D is in the same position as your S in math. I got the same response when I mentioned how close she was to an A! She feels so much better about math now, she said she is going to switch from Statistics to honors calc for next year. She said she heard that honors calc is more along the lines of 2nd semester precalc. </p>

<p>Regarding VT - Once the school hits a certain size, I am not sure it matters. To me at that point what matters more is the layout of the campus. Is the campus so spread out that they have to take buses everywhere, or can you get around most of the time by walking?</p>

<p>I wish D would consider VT, but she won’t. Her answer belongs on the other thread of why kids take schools off of their list!</p>