<p>RVM, is College of Charleston really that much of a safety to American? I always thought they were about the same level. It’s not exactly like comparing it to Harvard.</p>
<p>Not sure I’d agree that there’s not much difference between a 16k and 23k student body. At some point (for me around 5-7, 15-16, 20 -30) there becomes an order of magnitude difference in the feel and operation of a college or university. If it’s relevant in the decision for you, there was a listing a few years back (2008) on Forbes of colleges and universities by freshman class size which might be helpful.</p>
<p>[America’s</a> Best Colleges - Forbes.com](<a href=“Forbes List Directory”>Forbes List Directory)</p>
<p>Queens Mom, subjectively we here may have differring views about schools, but from the standpoint of a WaPo article, American at #79 in the US News National University Ranking would probably outrank CofC at #11 in the South Regional University Ranking.</p>
<p>It’s an interesting question really exactly how (or if) the two: National vs Regional rankings, should correlate. Where would a # 1 or 2 Regional rank if placed in the National poll as far as “prestige” for those following such. I remember reading a lot of posts last year with people giving numerical concordances and formulas to compare the two, but I never saw one that I thought was right on.</p>
<p>I have a question for MHC…if I understood your post correctly, you mentioned that you son went to Israel at the age of 10 and then on a BirthRight trip more recently. I thought BR trips were only for first timers. The reason I’m asking is that my older two went on post-confirmation trips the summer after 10th grade and the third (9th grader) will as well. I’ve never looked at BR for the older two as I thought they weren’t eligible. Would love to hear I’m mistaken.</p>
<p>Can’t speak to the 16k vs. 23k but my D, who attends a school with 10,000 undergraduates, is in a new living situation for the summer where she, unexpectedly, finds herself living with several girls, all sublets in a 5 bedroom apt, where none of the girls previously knew one another. When I commented that it was so nice she was meeting new people, she said that she would expect to continue to meet new people throughout her senior year. This is from a girl who was very active in her freshman dorm (still gets together with many people from her floor), joined a sorority and is very active in that as well and also gets together with people she meets in class. Don’t know why but I guess I had a sense that she had a well developed community and that she wouldn’t necessarily meet a lot more new kids during her last two years.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>I think that’s probably because the ranking themselves are not really “right on” either. I like to think of the rankings as a guide to a general idea of where a particular school “might” fit. </p>
<p>collage1, birthright is for those who have not been on an “organized” as in sponsored trip. Going to Israel for your sister’s Bat Mitzvah at 10 wouldn’t count; a USY trip, would.</p>
<p>Collage, Birthright says that they believe in peer trip experiences. So if your child has been to Israel before with family (as my son was when we took him at 10) then they are still fully eligible. But if they’ve been to Israel as part of a tour group, educational program, study program etc. since they were 12, they are not eligible. I’m pretty sure that my two daughters who remained in Day School and both went on trips with their school in 12th grade are not eligible (actually my youngest is still there on her Senior trip and is coming home Sunday). If the post confirmation trip was with a Temple group etc, you’d have to check it that counts as a prior visit. If it was not considered a peer educational trip they are eligible. But there are other ways you can go more than once. If the child went on a March of the Living trip in high school, they can go on a Birthright trip when they turn 22. And even if they’ve gone on a Birthright trip before, they can “organize” a group and go again with the group. That’s what my son is planning to do.</p>
<p>I don’t think Temple trips eliminate the possibility to go on Birthright…</p>
<p>I did not know, MHC, that they can “organize” a group and go again?..talk to me…very curious…</p>
<p>mdmom - S2 is also taking honors calculus next year - I wish they offered an “on-level” calculus - but since they don’t - he’s giving the honors class a try. I think if your kid can do it - calculus looks good on the transcript - there’s that rigor colleges say they are seeking. So - maybe they will be in the same class!</p>
<p>Queen’s Mom - I do perceive CofC to be a much easier admit than American. I checked national naviance - CofC accepted 69.5% of 11,083 apps last year - average ACT score of accepted students was a 25. American accepted 43% of 16,926 apps and the average ACT score of accepted students was a 28.</p>
<p>On the size of school issue - one thing I think is hard for kids to grasp is how they may “grow into” a school. A school that seems too big to a hs junior - might be slightly big to a college freshman and feel just fine to a college junior. </p>
<p>It’s just frustrating that it is so hard to find schools in the middle range - it seems like you either have to consider very small schools or large schools. Or widen your geographic range. Or just not be so picky.</p>
<p>^^it was shocking to us when we started this process how few schools actually exist that are between 5-7,000 students in fact…</p>
<p>on a very different note, there was a thread elsewhere about the tuition increase at IU-Bloomington that really shocked me; their OOS tuition and fees for 2011-2012 is close to $32,000 without room and board (extra charges apply for Kelly school of business and other special programs)…</p>
<p>does anyone else find that obscene for a public school? total COA has to be close to $45,000/year???..I have ALWAYS found UMICH COA to be ridiculous for OOS but others on CC have made excuses for the quality of education…</p>
<p>but how many schools can you say that about?</p>
<p>Agree completely - and if you need FA or merit aid - it’s the OOS publics that will provide the least. Just for kicks - I did a FA calculator at James Madison - as we will have an overlap of 2 in college for S2’s freshman year and a pretty darn low EFC that year. As an OOS - the calculator predicts we will get next to nothing. In our scenario - either staying in-state or more generous privates look better for FA. Now JMU is “only” $30,000 for total COA - so it’s not out of the question - but I agree with Rodney - paying $40,000+ for an OOS public is ridiculous.</p>
<p>rodney, I don’t know the facts about organizing a Birthright trip in order to go a second time, my son has all that info. Both he and his sister will be coming back from on Sunday albeit at very different times (5:00 am and 8:00 pm), PM me next week and I’ll ask him.</p>
<p>Vermont OOS is $47,524: [Costs</a>, Financial Aid and Scholarships : Undergraduate Admissions : University of Vermont](<a href=“Undergraduate Admissions”>Undergraduate Admissions)</p>
<p>The reports I hear about it are quite positive, nonetheless.</p>
<p>Wow! Making $30,000 or so for OOS at JMU and VT seem quite reasonable.</p>
<p>Only one of my kids was eligible for Birthright - because the second intifada prevented his eighth grade Jewish day school class from going to Israel that year. He went on Birthright and then went again as a “group leader” (this was actually his third trip to Israel, as he had gone on a Meor trip after the first Birthright trip). I don’t know how he got to be a “group leader”, but he has been organizing people his whole life, and he was a “recruiter” for Chabad classes (he said it was the easiest recruiting he has ever done) so I think that the organizers of the trip saw this in him.
My other kids weren’t eligible for Birthright, as they had gone on their eighth grade trips and a couple of them went again during high school on trips, but they managed to go on Meor trips, volunteer trips, leadership trips, etc. during college, multiple times, for very little money.</p>
<p>I just happened to find this link about applying to be a Birthright group leader which may answer some of the questions:</p>
<p>[Apply</a> to Staff](<a href=“http://taglit.israelexperts.com/alumni/apply-to-staff]Apply”>http://taglit.israelexperts.com/alumni/apply-to-staff)</p>
<p>You can add Penn State to the skyrocketing OOS tuition costs!</p>
<p>cherryhillmom- has Penn State published their tuition for next year?</p>
<p>About three or four schools which D applied to but didn’t choose sent her e-mails over the past few weeks asking that she fill out surveys telling them why not. Since she’s away and I know the reasons, I filled them out. Some were short, some overly long and intrusive. But I filled them out as a matter of courtesy. Then I realized that no school who had rejected her ever offered the chance to find out more about why.</p>
<p>And she had been invited to join the wait list at Tulane. She did and sent follow ups to the Ad Com. An e-mail said: “Every student on the waitlist will be notified of his or her status no later than June 1, 2011.”.</p>
<p>Yesterday came and went without an e-mail or letter. She hadn’t expected to be admitted off the waitlist and didn’t even call or e-mail from Israel to ask. But I thought it quite rude and insensitive that the promised response never came.</p>
<p>I don’t think they have. I have friends whose children are starting this Summer/Fall. Tution, fees, room & board are hovering at the list price of 40,000!</p>
<p>mhc: thanks for the link; but according to that, a previous Birthright trip does not qualify one to be hired as a staff member…if I remember, I’ll PM you next week…</p>
<p>Penn State apparently was already over $40,000 last year according to family members who attend…</p>
<p>So, the list grows: Publics greater than $40,000/yr</p>
<p>IU-Bloomington
UVermont
Penn State
UMich-Ann Arbor (OOS close to or over $50,000 depending on incoming AP credits)
UCBerkeley (someone posted elsewhere that it is over $50,000)</p>
<p>Can someone post about other state schools in these states if they know? Pittsburgh, Mich State to be specific?</p>
<p>Given that there are privates around that are now less expensive (even at full pay) than the growing list, I need to re-evaluate recommended lists…</p>