Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>RVM - My goals for son and son’s goals are not yet on the same track. My son’s plan for this summer is to wake up at noon and play video and computer games until midnight. My plan is that he complete the common application and its essay, complete and send his applications to his Florida (instate) schools (4) and read and complete his summer reading assignment (massive) for AP Literature before July 15 (our family summer vacation). </p>

<p>On a positive note, he did better this semester than last semester and ended up with 5 A’s and 2 B+'s. His GPA and class rank place him in the “A” student category but his EC’s and test scores are not in line with this…so the colleges discussed on this thread still are his match schools. I am anxiously awaiting his June SAT scores so that we can sit down together and make a final college list. I am not sure how many schools he will ultimately apply to (in addition to the 4 instate schools) since his SAT’s will be his gatekeeper. </p>

<p>I would appreciate if any of you “mom’s of stubborn, smart but procratinating boys” could teach me the magic method of how to get him moving on the above. I went through the entire process with my two elder daughters but this is Mars not Venus here. DS speaks an entire different language! HELP!</p>

<p>seiclan, what I did was to break down goals (family goals) into small steps. For example, I told my son that I would like to have his long essay for the common app entirely completed by (gave him a date). I told him that meant that the rough draft needed to completed sometime before that, so that he could let it sit for a bit. He did not have anyone edit it, and that was fine with me (he is a pretty good writer). When this was complete, we continued to the next item on his “to do” list (which WE developed). He also received 2 early special apps in the mail, so he put aside the short essay, to complete these (there was a very early summertime deadline for early notification about admission). Breaking things down makes the process much less overwhelming. Also, he knew in advance that when he finished one item on the “to do list” the next item was waiting for him (knowing this in advance will help avoid whining, because he will know what is expected. Understanding why it might be a good idea to complete these items prior to the fall helped my son to work over the summer, and I did not need to nag all summer long. I only made sure that he was working toward goals on his to do list). He got it all done, and this made senior year a pleasure!</p>

<p>Also, I explained briefly about rolling and early action. I told him that he might enjoy having some acceptances in hand by November. When he told me that his friends are not focused on doing anything regarding college apps or tours, I told him that he might see them scrambling just before college admission deadlines to get everything done while still keeping up their school work.</p>

<p>seiclan - I think my D is the female version of your son! Procrastination is her middle name. However, she always seems to pull it out in the end and doesn’t understand why I get so stressed out.</p>

<p>D finished exams on Tuesday and is thrilled beyond belief to have Junior year behind her. I think this was a really good sememster, but we won’t know for certain until some final exam grades are posted. But whatever it is, she is done!</p>

<p>We have set some goals for this summer. D will be working on her college essays and resume next week. She already did a first go round on her main essay in ap lang. Her teacher told her it is one of the best ones he has ever read! Then she is away for 5 weeks. When she gets back the common ap will be up and it will be time to really work on her applications. I am in the process of putting together the dates that she needs to apply to each school by and we will go by that. </p>

<p>D told me that they have set a limit for 500 words for the common ap essay. What was it in the past? </p>

<p>She will see a few more schools this summer and then we will finalize the list. It’s pretty solid now, but may just need a tweak here and there!</p>

<p>I can’t believe they are seniors!</p>

<p>not sure how (and I’m not asking why now), but my daughter was extremely motivated to finish almost all her essays last summer before school started; she did realize that since she played a fall sport, it was going to be VERY difficult to work on them before the deadlines set forth by her school for application/essay submission…</p>

<p>If your kids’ schools have deadlines, find out when they are; alot of HS’s have an Oct 1 deadline for EA/ED apps…doesn’t leave alot of time for essay revision/polishing in September…</p>

<p>that way, it’s not YOU telling your child that they should have a deadline; it’s the school</p>

<p>" I am SO sorry, honey, that you have to work on your essays over the summer but it’s your school that wants the apps completed by Oct 1" (said with an empathetic tone)</p>

<p>^^^
Until the high school arm of Wiki leaks releases that posting.</p>

<p>Right now we’re playing the waiting game. Waiting for the June SAT and ACT scores and waiting for S to take introductionary medical school courses at Georgetown and St. Louis. He plans to go pre-med, and H and I thought it would be a good idea for him to get an idea of what pre-med and med school entails, prior to him officially setting off on that track.</p>

<p>He’ll finish his programs mid-July, then we’ll get back on the college tours to schools where he should interview, as well as ones that I want H to see (i.e., Elon). I’m going to wait until we’ve gotten these tasks done before I nudge him to start the essays.</p>

<p>MY plan is to apply EA to as many schools as offer it from his final list and have the applications ready to go prior to school starting. I have a strong feeling that this will be wishful thinking.</p>

<p>Good luck to those of you with rising seniors. If you are planning summer campus visits, I recommend checking the school’s academic calendar to try to pick a time when summer classes are in session. It’s really hard to get a feel for a college when you see an empty campus.</p>

<p>I had no luck getting my daughters to start their essays in the summer. They did finish their resumes, met with the GC and had a pretty well defined list of colleges by the end of the summer. They wrote their essays in October and made the November 1st deadlines. Our county doesn’t release class rank until October 1st, so the schools can’t send out official transcripts before that date.</p>

<p>Good luck to all of those hoping to get their students to write essays over the summer! I also found it better to break it down into steps, but tinier steps than were described above. The first step was to do the “writing exercise” that I described a long time ago that was on a cc thread. This writing exercise had a time limit of about 40 minutes, and I asked my D2 to do one a day for four days. Her essay (which she did not, unfortunately, complete in the summer) eventually grew out of those exercises. But having done the exercise, she was light-years ahead of the game!
The other “do-able” thing in the summer is to update the resume.
Usually, there is a question about a meaningful EC, so you can just discuss that with your student.</p>

<p>On the common app - I think before the essay was recommended to be 500-750 words and now it is recommended a max of 500. My understanding is that since this is an uploaded Word document - you don’t have to exact. On the other hand - the short answer question about an EC is limited to a certain number of characters - think it is 1500 - and that is a firm limit. Since you are typing that in directly - it will be “truncated” if you go beyond the limit.</p>

<p>I have found it helps with S2 if I give him a task - but let him control when he does it. Lots of good advice here on setting goals and breaking this major undertaking down into bite-sized chunks. I am hoping to sit down with him soon and making a rough calendar of deadlines for July/August and seeing how that goes.</p>

<p>So - I had a brief conversation with S2 - just mapping out what we would do in July and August and reviewing the list of schools with him. Now Tampa is out and Virginia Tech is back on. I asked him why VT was back on, as he said it was too big after we visited in April. His response was that he has friends there who like it. All-righty then!</p>

<p>I am impressed by the collective restraint shown by you guys…in this house, the most effective method was to use a threatening tone and withhold the car keys.
Admittedly, S had an ED deadline, but I was entirely no-nonsense with him. </p>

<p>The common app questions should not change from year to year, so there is no reason to wait for it to go live before starting the essay. The word limit has always been a minimum of 250, with a suggested limit of 500, but kids were going long. Five hundred words, give or take is plenty to say what is needed. Concise, clear writing is always good.</p>

<p>RVM:</p>

<p>A college that seems too big for a high school junior now may not at all seem too big for him as a college junior. Smart for him to keep his options open. They “grow into” the schools. And the school sounds big enough for him to take a variety of neat courses.</p>

<p>My S1 spent a good part of August last year working on his essays, not only the main common app. one, but all the ones for his ED school choice too. He applied ED the 3rd week of September. He must have written and rewritten those essays hundreds of times. He was so careful not to go over the word count and wanted to perfect his essays for that one school. I think it was 4 essays for the ED school, plus the common app. one.</p>

<p>He had 10 schools on his list altogether, and applied to a few RD just in case. Those essays were easier to work on once he was finished with the ones he devoted so much time to. Nothing like having his ED acceptance on Dec. 10th…it was wonderful. However, I’m so very sure we’ll be going to the RD and rolling route next time. I won’t stress about it, cause I’ll be prepared for it! :)</p>

<p>Someone might have mentioned this already, but a reminder for those with rising HS seniors that the Common App website “resets” each summer. Don’t have your kid do a lot of work online, only to lose it in August (or whenever)! </p>

<p>Don’t tell rising sophomore D2, but I’ve started an Excel spreadsheet of possible colleges. I have no idea if the final list will bear any resemblance to this initial list, because she is very much a work in progress. There are ADHD issues, so I’m looking for schools with good support services…but who knows what she’ll really need in a couple of years? Will she be able to do “OK” (whatever that means) on standardized tests, or will her usual freeze-up-in-panic reaction to standardized testing still be an issue? She likes dance and theater and working with children, so it makes sense to check to see if there are at least minors offered in those fields…but will those interests persist? Will she want to be closer to home, or will she be OK with being further away? When she says she wants a school not right in the city, will she really mean that? </p>

<p>She came home from school yesterday saying that she’d seen pictures of Ithaca College, and she really liked what she’d seen and heard. I’m waiting to see what she thinks of cold weather after visiting her older sister in Boston. :slight_smile: I also suspect she doesn’t realize that it’s one thing to fly cross-country, and another thing entirely to fly cross-country and then take a four-hour bus shuttle. What I AM getting from her right now is that she’d like somewhere pretty, and not overwhelmingly huge. Yet one of the places I very much want her to consider is the University of Arizona, because of their highly recommended SALT center for students with learning disabilities/differences. </p>

<p>The CTCL roadshow will be in town in early August, and I want to take her and a friend or two to that to dip toes in the water. And I’ll come up with some reason for day trip to see something near Chapman, so we can casually stroll the campus.</p>

<p>I think having good drafts of essays done over the summer is the best advise I could give. My son told me in June that he would need me to nag him all summer to get them done (which I did, but not too bad), and then he was so glad when school started and a lot of his friends were scrambling to do essays, that his were essentially done. Our school imposes a 9/20 deadline for submitting apps to the 2 state flagship schools, so that makes getting those essays done early, important.</p>

<p>Now that S1 will be going to college in the fall, I’m going to have to lay off college talk for S2 until next summer…all the talk re applications and “getting in” for his brother really stressed him out, so although I’ll be thinking of it, and guiding him to prepare for it, overt college talk is on hold for a while.</p>

<p>chocchip - I agree completely. There was a lot to like about VT and I see the logic in starting out at a “big” school and growing into it vs. starting at a “small” school and feeling that you have outgrown it. It was just a surprise to me that it was back in play - good thing I did not throw out that folder of info. But - doesn’t it seem odd to be applying to both Susquehanna (around 2500 students) and VT (around 25,000 students)! I guess they both have that laidback vibe he wants - good business program - within driving range, etc. I am comfortable with Jewish life at both - cost is ok, etc. Just think it is a funny combination.</p>

<p>SlitheyTove - the new Common App is available online on August 1. But people can print out a PDF of the preview version now and make some notes by hand so as to save time later.</p>

<p>I’m gearing DS up for a busy first half of junior year. Pointing out how stressful spring is with his varsity sport (plus there will be 3 AP tests next May). Big accomplishment this week was finding an SAT tutor (for English only) who will come to my house every week for a price that works for me. We will start after DS gets back from Israel in early August. Gearing him up for SATs in December and March. (Still need to look at ACT schedule.)</p>

<p>For now, he has two NYS regents exams next week. He’s not too concerned about them. He has 2 books to read for AP Lang this summer - trying to get him to read one before he leaves at the end of June. He said he as summer work for AP Physics too - I have no idea what that is. Going to look at one college in August, before his camp reunion (it’s nearby). I feel like this summer is crunched already. </p>

<p>Good luck to everyone who is hoping to make some progress this summer on college apps. Hope your D/S produces for you!</p>

<p>omg, RVM, didn’t know Virg Tech was that large! Some parents will not agree with me, but personally we did not look at any colleges under 5k. And it had to be pretty near a major city. For my S, anything under 5k, was just way too small and high schoolish. I do wonder that even with 5k, he may outgrow that too! But he’ll be in Boston, so there will be a ton of other students all around. If your S is looking at Virg Tech, that’s great! The school will have a ton of things to do, lots of rah rah sports & activities…what’s not to like?</p>

<p>Will you be looking at Susquehanna again? On a second visit, he may feel as if the school would be too small for him afterall, or he’ll decide to apply anyway! I don’t know enough about those schools, but if they are near some sort of city with restaurants, stores, etc. that obviously helps…looking at a college as a sophomore, and then again as a junior could have different outcomes.</p>

<p>UMich and Slitheytove: One thing I can now say for sure is that S2 does not even want to broach the college subject until close to junior year! And why should he, his whole outlook will be much different, depending on his interests at that time. He thinks he’ll know what he’ll want to study, but can easily change his mind…let’s get our older ones settled! </p>

<p>Slithey: Your idea about keeping her “nearby” in Arizona sounds good…especially if they have a center to counsel or work with her individually. However, lots can happen between now and applications the second time around! :slight_smile: She’ll probably grow by leaps & bounds and you could actually throw away your list and start over!</p>

<p>Linymom: Your S does varsity tennis? My S did too. He was a straight A student until he took AP Physics in his Junior year. His teacher left a lot to be desired. (I’m trying to be polite! :rolleyes: My S squeeked by with a B-…now he wants nothing to do with Physics! Too bad because he’s a great Math student, but sometimes the teacher can turn you off to a subject. But since your S is the engineering one, he’ll probably do just fine!</p>

<p>Linymom: I agree with you! This summer is shaping up to be as busy as the school year! :frowning: Need to make sure we all have downtime and suntime.</p>

<p>Last summer we made copies of all essay topics and my S did his essays all on Microsoftword. Nothing was put on the common app. or any other college application until it was finalized on “scrap paper” first. Yeah, UMich: My S was also so glad he worked so hard in August and was in a very good place once school began in Sept. Everyone finds the niche that works best for them!</p>

<p>chocchip, we looked at all size schools for both of our kids. ShawSon chose a school with well under 2000 students total. He’s completed two years and it is fabulous for him and doesn’t feel high school-ish to him. He’s made quite a few good friends. He’s gotten to know professors and better yet, professors know him. He has had two independent studies in his first two years. His advisor suggested that his paper from the last independent study form the basis for his honors thesis and has offered to hire him for the next two years to run his research lab – and is looking for funding for ShawSon’s research. He handed in a paper to a professor in another department and in the following semester, she went over it with him in detail and suggested that he send it in for publication (with the changes she suggested to a particular journal). The school is among the most selective LACs, so he doesn’t feel that he is lacking in bright classmates. He can take other courses at nearby schools but hasn’t chosen to do so. Now, he’s not a city lover, so he doesn’t need or want to be near a city. But the size is not a negative factor for him at all. I’d say it is an advantage. When he applies to fellowships (Gates, Marshall, etc.), he will have a large number of professors who know him well enough to write thoughtful and helpful recommendations. They won’t be heavy hitter researchers, but they’ll be able to say great things about him (as long as current performance continues).</p>

<p>ShawD looked at a school with 2300 kids and felt it would be too small after a couple of years and also felt there were too few Jews in the student body and ended up choosing at a school of 14000. She was concerned about the (extremely) non-urban location of the first school – “Dad, I may never wear a dress there in 4 years and I’m not that outdoorsy a girl.” I actually thought the smaller school would be better for her from an academic standpoint, but I’m happy with where she is going.</p>

<p>Hi- just thought I’d add a comment regarding word count of extracurricular essay. My son had a great essay that he could not condense and which was over the word/character count. We put a reference to the additional info section and put it in it’s entirety there. Did not seem to affect him negatively!</p>

<p>slithey,</p>

<p>Sounds like you live in ca. If so, what is the CTCL roadshow? Just wondering…</p>