Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>slithey, your college list for your D may shift dramatically. ShawD has ADHD issues as well, although we didn’t spot these quickly because she had major-league medical problems that had to be dealt with first. She didn’t do that well on standardized tests. But, her performance improved dramatically with ADHD diagnosis, Ritalin and extra time. Her UW GPA went from 2.98 to 3.1 to 3.6 (senior year probably about 3.5 or 3.6) and her PSAT scores went up 370 points without any studying (just Ritalin/extra time). Her performance in math and science courses improved to top of class (though not the hardest level of courses). </p>

<p>At the beginning, her guidance counselor rated a number of schools on the list we put together as possible and reach and at the end, said all the reach schools were possibles and the possible schools were likelies and wanted her to add reach schools.</p>

<p>Goodmorning Shawbridge!</p>

<p>Yes, I agree completely. We also looked at all size colleges, but in the end, you & your child make a decision most comfortable for them. Too small or too rural did not work for my S1, but it could be completely what my S2 may want in a few years…</p>

<p>I also agree that small colleges work very well for many people…and in this thread we mentioned that finding that medium size seems to be the most difficult. However, again depending on the child, your finances, and a whole slew of other criteria, then perhaps a larger one may work well too.</p>

<p>That’s why these threads are so popular, since us parents are coming up with lists of colleges & then narrowing them down, based on what they & their child think will be best for them! :)</p>

<p>How’s everything going, Socaldad? </p>

<p>Correct me if I’m wrong, but I think CTCL stands for Colleges that Change Lives.</p>

<p>Hi Deb T! My daughter is only interested in a BFA program and most of those, although not all are at art schools. She will look at art colleges that are independent colleges at larger places, but she really wants a small school. So, for instance, she looked at CMU art, Tyler Art (Temple), RIT school of art (can’t remember name). We have also looked at many stand alone art schools around the Eastern/Mid-Atlantic seaboard. We have not looked at Denver, but we can; thanks for the idea. The only places that we really have not explored (either physically or on Naviance are the Mid-west or the West (although she has looked at a couple of California schools). The hardest thing about art, like athletics or music or musical theater, is that one just does not know what will be the ultimate thing that might get you in or out. For example, while one of the East Coast art schools shows grade ranges, there has been at least one girl from our school that got in with a full letter grade below the benchmark (her portfolio must have been terrific!). Or, on the other side, if someone does not like your portfolio at that school, you are out; if it is loved, you could be in! Oy…So, we just keep looking for a great fit and a great school for dd.</p>

<p>I have asked S2 and DH if they would like to re-visit Susquehanna and JMU this fall - since we saw those last year. They are both day trips - so I certainly don’t mind. If we go again - it will be to attend a day long program - either an Open House or something like that - would not repeat the same info session/tour a second time.</p>

<p>CTCL is Colleges that Change Lives - book by the late Lauren Pope. There is also a website under the same name. Mostly small colleges - sort of “hidden gems” - that people might not be that familiar with. Many of these schools will have very small Jewish populations, FYI.</p>

<p>Levirm, do you know where those essay exercises might be described (or is there a search word so I don’t have to read back through the whole thread)? Dd is going on a college program away, and maybe I could get her to work on those on her plane rides, or in some down time (probably wishful thinking). I do feel badly for these rising seniors. Such a hard year and the fun doesn’t stop! Good luck to everyone.</p>

<p>phillyartmom, I see now you’ve already discovered the visual arts forum. Excellent. Have you, by any chance, visited the NASAD website? At the bottom of this page you can do a search by state.</p>

<p>[Member</a> Lists](<a href=“http://nasad.arts-accredit.org/index.jsp?page=Member+Lists]Member”>http://nasad.arts-accredit.org/index.jsp?page=Member+Lists)</p>

<p>chocchip,
Hello. All is well here in So cal. D2 finished junior year yesterday. Happy to have it behind us. Stressful to say the least. D2’s grades were more of the same. All b"S and two A’s. We are waiting to get her most recent ACT scores from June. This summer she is taking Chemistry. She thought it would be better to take it during the summer, rather than this past year. We will see if that works out.
My d and I will be on the east coast for a week this summer. She is going to have a formal interview at U del. She is determined to do everything possible to enhance her long shot chance of getting in. It is all she wants. We may visit another school while we are back there.<br>
Question for group…Should we go look at JMU? How far is it from Philly area? Drive time? Can a real b student get in from OOS? a 3.3 with not so great scores? Opinions?
Thanks all</p>

<p>socaldad, this may not be of interest, but I’ll go ahead and mention it anyway. There’s a Teaching Company chemistry course by Frank Cardulla which your daughter might possibly find helpful. The first couple of lectures move very slowly, but then the pace picks up. He has a gentle way about him and makes concepts easy to understand.</p>

<p>[Chemistry</a>, 2nd Edition](<a href=“The Great Courses”>The Great Courses)</p>

<p>chocchip: My DS (yes, a varsity tennis player) is looking forward to AP Physics. He knows the teacher from Science Olympiad (been doing that for two years already) and has a good relationship with him. Still, it will be challenging to stay on the straight A path with his rigorous schedule next year. I think he can do it, though.</p>

<p>We may be on the path for revisiting schools when the time comes…we’re not there yet… My goal will be to have the list final a year from now, at the end of junior year. Did that with DD and it eased the stress (although the essay stress was still there!).</p>

<p>socaldad - we are about 2 hours from JMU and we are a suburb of DC. So - I would guess about 4 hours from Philly to JMU - but I would Mapquest it to be more certain. The drive down Rt 81 is very pleasant and scenic - it’s not like driving Rt 95.</p>

<p>The admissions part is hard to say - as GPAs vary so much from one hs to the next. They are looking for a mix of A’s and B’s in core classes and want to see some rigor - honors, AP etc. Their mid-range on the ACT is around 24-28.</p>

<p>My personal impression is that JMU is an easier admit than Delaware - so if you can take a look - I would do so.</p>

<p>CCC and shawbridge, it’d be great to throw away my list and start over because D2 ended up growing by “leaps and bounds”…but I suspect that some schools will stay on, no matter what. </p>

<p>socaldad, I also live in SoCal. As others mentioned, CTCL stands for “Colleges That Change Lives”. It’s a consortium of about 30? 40? something like that small colleges. Their admissions representatives tour together (hence my roadshow reference :)) because otherwise they couldn’t afford to tour separately. It’s a nice gentle intro to college selection because they emphasize fit. As RVM mentioned, most have very small Jewish populations. I took D1 to tour Clark, since that has one of the largest. Otherwise, I’m going through the entire list, looking to see which might possibly be of interest to D2 based on availability of possible majors, at least a teeny Hillel, and what the LD support offerings are. This is only for purposes of her picking up info at the CTCL event. If nothing else, she won’t have to bother with the few who have a very strong non-Jewish faith-based component, or those that are highly intellectual (St John’s and Reed). </p>

<p>For those with children starting on essays, I’m sure there’s been a mention before of Harry Bauld’s short book about college app essay writing, but I’m throwing out a reminder. It’s a great little book, amusing to read.</p>

<p>Deb, I will look online for the book. Thanks. It can only help.</p>

<p>Slithey…I will look to find out about the ctcl event. If you have a link…feel free to put it up.</p>

<p>RVM,
I think you are right about JMU. I will discuss with daughter today. I may change plans and fly into D.C. today and drive there. I think size wise it is similar to DEl. Did you observe any other similarities or big differences between Del and JMU.<br>
I somehow feel they may have commonalities. Perspectives?</p>

<p>I took D2 to the CTCL Fair in IL. It was valuable if only for the reason that she heard over and over that Bs and B+s were “great” grades. By the end of the day she believed she would get into a really good college, somewhere. And she did end up applying to 2 of them and considered them strongly, even though she ended up wanting a bigger school (as many kids do - Loren Pope was very openly biased toward the small, nurturing LAC). She did learn a lot about fit, and I would recommend these fairs. They also are very upfront about there being MANY more "CTCL"s than their particular list. Not an exclusive attitude at all.</p>

<p>socaldad, see [Colleges</a> That Change Lives | Changing Lives, One Student at a Time](<a href=“http://ctcl.org%5DColleges”>http://ctcl.org)</p>

<p>socaldad - I have visited both Delaware (with S1) and JMU last June with S2. My memory of Delaware is a little hazy. I would say JMU’s campus is more spread out and has more distinctly different sections to it - and of course it is bisected by Rt 81 and has the train tracks through it. A weird campus - IMO - but S2 still liked it. Very friendly, down-to-earth vibe - which is one of those “fit” things that S2 wants. There is a movie theater on campus and an impressive, new rec center. The food is supposed to be great. If you read the threads on both the Delaware and JMU forums - there are some comparison threads. </p>

<p>I would say that Delaware has more Jewish students and more active Jewish life - but JMU has a reasonable amount. I still have no idea why S2 will not pursue Delaware - it would seem to make sense to include it - but no dice. Both JMU and VT are right about $30,000 for OOS - Delaware is about $36,000 or so.</p>

<p>socaldad, I should clarify. It’s actually a series of lectures on DVD, not a textbook. As I recall, it’s designed to supplement a high school chemistry class, make concepts clearer for students.</p>

<p>Since we’ve been discussing art schools and the topic of college fairs has also come up, I’ll go head and post a link to the NACAC Performing and Visual Arts College Fair Schedule for Fall 2011</p>

<p>[2011</a> PVA Schedule](<a href=“http://www.nacacnet.org/EventsTraining/CollegeFairs/pva/Pages/pvaschedule.aspx]2011”>http://www.nacacnet.org/EventsTraining/CollegeFairs/pva/Pages/pvaschedule.aspx)</p>

<p>socaldad -</p>

<p>I also live in the DC area and am a graduate of U of D. As far as distance goes, I’m guessing it’s about 4 hours from U of D to JMU.</p>

<p>I wish you and your D a great visit to Delaware. In the years since I’ve graduated, they’ve definitely expanded the campus. It looked great when I drove through a year ago.</p>

<p>I think Delaware might be a bit easier to get into OOS than typical state schools b/c Delaware itself is so small. I would play up the diversity your D would bring as being from Ca. U of D has a lot of kids from NJ, Pa and NY. Also, some of the schools (e.g. Engineering, Nursing and Business) are harder to get into than others (i.e., A&S). If your D is interested in Business, but is concerned about chances to get in, she can transfer to the Business school once she’s accepted (obv., meeting their GPA criteria).</p>

<p>A few interesting points about Newark (pronounced: New Ark): Edgar Allen Poe used to hang out at the DeerPark Tavern. Klondike Kate’s used to be the best restaurant in town. I think it’s still there. </p>

<p>Enjoy!</p>

<p>Socaldad: A lot of kids in my area apply to both JMU and UDel. I agree with Rockvillemom that JMU seems a bit less selective. I’ve know of kids from our HS gettin in with low B GPAs and SAT area scores just above 500. I get the impression that it’s easier to get in OOS than it is for kids from the Northern VA suburbs. The kids we know that attend JMU really like it.
Delware has better Jewish life on campus and a different mix of kids.</p>

<p>Socaldad, here too a bunch of the same kids seem to apply to UDel and JMU. I have to agree with what momjr has said about the kids who get in. Our kids are oos for both of these schools, but offer no diversity, because so many Pennsylvania kids go to these schools.</p>

<p>Deb T, thanks for that site. I have never heard of the PVA fair. The only thing we knew about last year was NPD, which we did in Philadelphia and Purchase. If we need more schools come the end of October, we can look over at the PVA fair, and honestly, I might go even if dd doesn’t as I am interested now (sort of hooked!). I am hoping dd will be done with the list before then! One can only hope!</p>

<p>My dd finished her questionnaire for one of the teachers that will be doing her recs. Oy, it took so long for dd to complete, but once she did and we went over it, it seemed good. So off it goes. The art teacher said he will deal with the recs in the fall (what???), so we will relax about that one.</p>