Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Mutti, no worries. I received the messages – one this morning shortly before I needed to leave the house and then the other two a few minutes ago when I returned. They came close to not making it through, though. My PM box is 96% full, and I just cleaned it out the other day, eek!</p>

<p>Thanks for the suggestions! :-)</p>

<p>chocchip - congrats on the 570 SAT II in Bio - off to a good start. I’m not sure that I would submit anything under 600, however. Do you think he could take it again and add a few points? I think that psychologically - there is a big difference between being under 600 and over 600 even if the point spread is small. If the college does not requite SAT IIs - I would not send anything under 600 as I do not think it will help his cause.</p>

<p>choc: I agree with RVM on the SATII Bio score. I wouldn’t send anything under 600 unless you need it to fill an application requirement. At our HS, the only kids who take the Bio SAT II have usually taken 2 years of BIO (Honors/GT and AP).</p>

<p>Like a lot of us, you will need to adjust your thinking with the second kid. Try not to compare S2 to his older brother too much. His grades are very good,and I’m sure that he will have good college choices.</p>

<p>SAT Subject Test Percentile Ranks</p>

<p><a href=“http://professionals.collegeboard.com/profdownload/2010-sat-subject-test-percentile-ranks.pdf[/url]”>http://professionals.collegeboard.com/profdownload/2010-sat-subject-test-percentile-ranks.pdf&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Thanks so much for the suggestions and support, you guys. I know I should know some of these answers, but S1 was so independent and did so much of these collegeboard & other things on his own, so quickly, it was hard to keep up!</p>

<p>Yeah, I have compiled a list of approx. 10 college choices for S2 when the time comes. According to college p<em>r</em>o<em>w</em>l<em>e</em>r they are all in the B to B+ range academically but vary according to size and location. </p>

<p>He does want to study Mechanical Engineering, but I don’t really think the Bio score will need to count. We really did it for practice purposes only, to get him used to taking that type of test. I pulled a list of requirements that each college posted on the Common app. website and most of the colleges on my list require SAT w/writing or ACT w/writing. Very few require SATII’s. If you were me, would you have him retake this test again in the Fall? Or just wait to take others?</p>

<p>Did your children take SATII’s? I remember this discussion once before. Next year after he takes the psat and plan test I will have a better idea of which one to pursue with him further. Although S1 took both, he did much better on the SAT.</p>

<p>Thanks again for your support! (Wish our h.s. had naviance)</p>

<p>Hi Chip, unless there is a specific school that you think he will apply, I wouldn’t make him take it over. Most schools for B students don’t require the subject tests. It seems that only the top level schools do. Why stress him out more unless he truly needs to take it.</p>

<p>cherryhill, what is your list?</p>

<p>My B (B+) student, my DD, didn’t take any SAT IIs. Her test results, in general (unit tests, mid-terms, finals) were the whole reason she was a B student to start with!!</p>

<p>Different story for DS. The chart on the link Deborah posted was interesting. Since the top students are the ones taking the SAT IIs, I’m not really sure what to make of the percentages. Come to think of it, what is the point of the SAT IIs anyway? If so many students taking them are getting in the 700s and even 800, how do they help differentiate candidates? Maybe it’s just a marketing ploy by the college board to generate more income. And here I am wanting DS to re-take Math 2. It feels like I’m planning a wedding. What’s another $$ in the scheme of things?</p>

<p>I saw Brooke Shields on Good Morning America today. As you recall, she’s a Princeton grad. She said something to the effect of, whatever your career throws at you, whatever your employers take away from you, they can’t take away your education. Made her feel good about herself. Even made me want to see her in The Addams Family on Bway!</p>

1 Like

<p>LINYMOM, supposedly the SAT IIs are a better predictor of academic performance than SAT Is. However, there is massive compression at the top end – there is some of that with SAT Is (what used to be 730 in math when we were around now gets an 800) but it is much worse. So, the SAT IIs don’t really help distinguish at the upper end – unless you have all A’s from a school they don’t know and you do badly on the SAT IIs.</p>

<p>On SAT 2’s: I think I mentioned that we had not even heard of them until S1 was applying to top schools. The majority of top schools S1 applied to didn’t require them. There were a couple that did though. I don’t see any harm in a kid taking the test when they complete the course work and if they do well great. That would be the easiest time to take it but I definitely wouldn’t worry about a B student studying for these unless they have a specific goal.</p>

<p>RVM: Also sorry to hear about the lost job and also agree that you would do great in college counseling…I know we could write some wonderful reference letters :).</p>

<p>On Jewish students moving to an unJewish area for school: My kids never lived this but I did as an adult and over time I learned to adjust my mindset. Where do you go to church in a small community is often about trying to identify people that you know in common since “everyone” goes to one church or another. If students are going to an unJewish school it would help them to recognize that they are likely to be the first Jew some will meet and be prepared that things that may seem unaccepting are just people making assumptions about the world based on where they grew up. Once I learned that is is often more about teaching people around me than about resistance to difference my life got better. I’m sure that role isn’t for every kid but for those taking it on it helps to be prepared. </p>

<p>On the SAT: Ohhh so frustrating. Kiddo raised his math 140 points to a 740! His score is 1290, superscore 1300. So what is the problem? His goal is to get into TAMU honors which requires a 1250 but also a minimum of a 560 in math and reading. So this test reading dropped 10 points to a 550 and they don’t superscore. Soooooo close to being done and yet not done. We were contimplating sending him to a class pending his results but it really doesn’t seem there is a reason to review math and writing doesn’t count so it seems that his time would be better spent focusing on reading either with a tutor if we can find one or on his own,or with his brother, I’m really not sure which. I am really proud of him though. I just wish he could be done.</p>

<p>spectrum2 - I am not that familiar with TAMU admissions - is there any leeway in those cutoffs? Since he was so incredibly close? With SAT scores - doesn’t the score report show a range score also? Would it be worth a phone call to admissions before subjecting him to another SAT? Just wondering.</p>

<p>And thank you for your kind words of encouragement.</p>

<p>I just took a look at the FAQ section for TAMU honors and it actually states a 570 - not a 560 - as a minimum for the reading and math sections. But - they also list some situations - such as home-schooled students - that are handled on a case-by-case basis and to consult an honors advisor. Even though the criteria seem to be pretty clearly spelled out - my feeling is it never hurts to call. Maybe some other substitution is possible that would negate the need to repeat the SAT.</p>

<p>Are any of you experiencing some level of insecurity or discomfort as you deal with nosy/well-meaning friends and relatives who want to know where your child is applying to college? I am having a bit of an issue with this for S2. For S1 - I guess I was proud of the schools he was applying to and happy to list them for anyone who asked. Of course, when you do that, then you have to go back and update as to where he did and did not get in! With S2 - I know his list is right for him - I know it makes sense for many reasons - but it is a “B” student’s college list - not an “A” student’s college list and I think I am feeling a little defensive. I am practicing my “dodge and evade” maneuvers - as in - “he wants to head south” or “we are still finalizing his list”. I’m not saying that I am not proud of S2 or optimistic about his prospects - just struggling when cousin X volunteers that her son is applying to Princeton and Harvard and I have to respond with James Madison and Towson!</p>

<p>How about you?</p>

<p>Thanks for checking that out RVM. I remembered incorrectly. But I agree with you I will check to see if there is any wiggle room on this. Both his rank and math score are well above the requirement hopefully that will help. I was really wondering if it was fine for me to make this call or if it is one he should make himself. Any thoughts about that? If the rules aren’t flexible I expect one way or another he’ll be retaking in Oct.</p>

<p>I would have him make the call if he is comfortable doing so - but with you beside him to prompt him (in a whisper) as needed. I think it is good for the kids to handle some of this stuff whenever possible - but so frustrating for the parents when they forget to write down who they spoke with - or they ask a question - but not the next follow-up question, etc. I view it as a team effort.</p>

<p>Or - have him call and obtain the e-mail address for TAMU honors advisor and e-mail his question re qualification - that way you can proofread the email before he hits send - but it is coming from him - which looks better.</p>

<p>On “nosy people”- try doing that with twins! On one you want to sing out all the options and on the other you want to say " I don’t know…he’s so independent and handling it all on his own"!</p>

<p>On SAT 2s- take them. If your child does well, submit ; if not, don’t. For S who will be attending WUSTL in the Fall, I have not spoken to anyone who has not submitted, even tho they do not require. The more selective the school, the higher they need to be. There are some schools that need a score of 700 or more, so make sure and do your homework before submitting.</p>

<p>ShawSon’s school suggested not taking the Chemistry SAT 2 until after taking AP Chemistry. Worked very well for him. I think the same for Bio. Neither kid took that.</p>

<p>RVM and 2flipper, I really don’t think that anyone should be judgemental at all about your college lists! If a person is judgemental, it is his or her problem.
I have friends whose older two daughters were extremely high achieving. When it came to their third daughter, they said, “We’re looking at a different set of schools this time, so we are learning.” Then, they named some of the schools. There is absolutely nothing to be embarrassed about at all! You should be proud that you are looking for fit.
spectrum2, there are highly selective engineering schools that would accept your son based on that amazing math score with the reading score as is. How ironic that TAMU is stating this minimum. I do think that practice, practice, practice on the questions would get that score up the little bit that it needs to go, though.</p>

<p>RVM: I like your idea of being evasive on the college list and just saying “He wants to head South.” As long as your son knows that your are comfortable and proud of his choices, that’s all that really matters. I have found that many people really don’t have a clue about colleges other than the top names and sports powerhouses.</p>

<p>Spectrum: That SAT situation is really frustrating. I like RVM’s suggestion, but if they won’t budge on the minimum reading score, it’s probably worth trying a tutor and having your son prep for the October test.</p>

<p>RVM- I tried to remind myself that people weren’t asking to be nosy (for the most part) but out of genuine interest and concern. Also, I learned to be proud of my d’s list and “smile and nod” at the sometimes insensitive comments made. There is a whole thread on this issue that will make you smile :)</p>