Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Levirm: Right now Rutgers. That’s it. :(</p>

<p>Chocchipcookie…my S1 applied and got into 3 top 10 engineering schools w/out taking any SAT IIs. He was burned out and didn’t want to take any more standardized tests. It did make it so that he couldn’t apply to 1 or 2 schools he was considering, but unless you want to go to one of the few schools that require SAT IIs, they’re not necessary. I wouldn’t put him through taking them again unless he has a school in mind that requires them.</p>

<p>RVM, I get asked all the time where S is applying and I say S wants to go south! When I name the schools, 99% have never heard of them. My response is “I am happy, I know where I am visiting when the winter gets here.” Just smile. Most of S’s friends are staying within two hours. Some of those schools are on the B lists or lower. It’s just that everyone has heard of them. Be confident in your your choices and what it right for your S. </p>

<p>As I am typing, an email came through from telecharge announcing Brooke Shields in the Adams family! What a coincidence.</p>

<p>hollissue - Oh I have seen the “smile and nod” thread - I agree wholeheartedly with that approach. I guess I am just a little more sensitive on this issue with S2 than with S1. I think I am going to stick with being vague for now. One of my pet peeves is that the college admissions process has changed so much in the past 5-10 years - so in most cases - unless you have had a child go through it recently - you really have no idea. There are colleges that would have been a reasonably easy admit 5-10 years a go that are now a reach for most students. Likewise, there are schools that were average regional colleges a decade ago that have since improved dramatically in both quality and selectivity. It just bugs me when people make a critique about a college based on something they heard years ago or their impression of their neighbor’s cousin’s experience 15 years ago, etc.</p>

<p>But you are right - the “smile and nod” thread does cover all such scenarios!</p>

<p>rvm and momjr: I also like the idea of S calling or emailing and being present for it. S2 however is away at camp as an Avodah. He will be coming home over the summer for a few days but I don’t want to wait, I would really like to know where we stand ASAP. My choices are to either call myself or talk to him and have him make the call from camp. I don’t think he has acccess to email. </p>

<p>Levirm: I agree that practice is a big part of it. He didn’t practice really hard for this one but when he did he mostly directed his practice and he more frequently went to his comfort zone, math. (He really did like your suggestion of 20 to 30 minutes at a time, the everyday part was harder to stick to :)) That really did pay off. Reading is a difficult challenge because it is speed vs comprehension. I’m thinking that learning some strategy would also help. S1 practiced with him a little and observed him reading easy questions incorrectly and therefore getting them wrong. On our state tests that are not timed he did very well I’m not sure how one fixes this. I’m looking forward to speaking to him to see if he has any insight into what helped him bring math up so dramatically and see if it helps with reading if it is necessary to retake. I’m thinking that since 1300 is sometimes a threshold for scholarships and since he is so close to that he will probably retake anyway. The question will be how much effort goes into it.</p>

<p>As for being asked about where kids go, I never take offense to that question but there may be less status seeking here. I assume that since I’m always interested in learning about different schools other people are too. :). S1 goes to a highly ranked LAC that no one who doesn’t know LAC’s has ever heard of. The next question is often why there or just, oh. So I often explain or not. Either way it isn’t a problem. I never heard of the school until I did the research either.</p>

<p>Thanks all for your advice & support re: SATII’s.</p>

<p>For now I’ll take 2flipper2’s advice, which is to have him continue taking SATII’s for the practice, and if the scores are decent, we can submit. Almost all schools on the list are more of the B/B+ level and do not require them.</p>

<p>I hate when people ask me about college choices. Usually I feel they are asking because they want to give you their opinion, even though you don’t ask for it. When you start listing colleges, I feel you are opening it up to listen to their viewpoint. Best to stay vague! Or say, “Each child is different and my S seems to be leaning toward schools south of here.”</p>

<p>UMich: What colleges did your S apply to? I seem to be gathering a list of decent schools not too far from our home base in New England. Plenty to choose from without having to go too far!</p>

<p>spectrum2 - given those options - I would call myself. Let us know if they do give you any wiggle room - I am always curious about such situations.</p>

<p>Rockville - I totally get what you are saying about sharing your college list. I think part of it is this area we are in. It seems the majority of kids have some of the elite schools on their list even if they end up at College Park. Which it seems like the majority do! There is a snob factor. I can sense it when I say how much D loves one of her safety schools. You get the ohh…and a look, like that’s the best she can do. However, D doesn’t really want everyone to know her reach schools. So I have started answering it with we have a huge list of schools with a range from x (major reach school) to y (absolute financial and academic safety). Then I say we are really looking for the best fit overall including financial.</p>

<p>Spectrum: I forgot that your son was at camp. Overall, it’s better for the kid to make the call, but I don’t think that it would be a mistake for you to call in this case. Another option would be for you to send an email and sign his name. (I have to confess that I did this with one large school.)</p>

<p>RVM: You are completely correct that most people are out of touch with college admissions. I do think that it’s funny how people just can’t resist offering suggestions. We are friends with a couple who never visited any colleges with their sons. One son got accepted ED to his father’s alma mater, and the other had very disapointing results. However, they gave us lots of suggestions on schools for our daughters after we had visited about 15 schools. We just smiled and nodded!</p>

<p>On nosey people:</p>

<p>I’m not a big sharer of info, but there are certainly people (family, close friends, close colleagues) where questions about college are part of their being interested in you and your family. I also know that some of these people have NO clue, b/c it’s been so long since they’ve gone through it.</p>

<p>In my DS’s case, he had several big transitions in his life being in 7th grade that included moving, my re-entering the workforce and his dad going overseas for a year. This is when we saw our A student become a C student. I shared my frustration and joked how if he didn’t get things together, he never get into any colleges.</p>

<p>As he’s pulled his act together, and you moms/dads know that boys can take a while to mature to the point of understanding that today’s actions impact tomorrow’s consequences, we’ve gotten so excited to imagine his college options. However, that said, his options, in my opinion, really exist at the B+ level, which includes a lot of schools that have more regional than national recognition.</p>

<p>As DS currently plans to go pre-med, I’ve told him and anyone who asks, that the college fit needs to be right, i.e., smaller class size, better prof accessibility and the ability to maintain a decent GPA. I’ve said that were some miracle to happen and he got into a Rice or Wash U type school (which he won’t!), I don’t think that the best place for him and his career intentions. This is what I typically share with enquiring minds.</p>

<p>I also share that we’re making sure to include schools were merit aid is a possibility (and the ivies and top tier schools don’t offer merit aid typically). All you have to do is say that so many schools are priced above $50K and I think the folks that have been out of the college search, their eyes begin to roll back in their heads!</p>

1 Like

<p>Just to update you. I made the calls but didn’t give a name. (they didn’t ask). There was new news. Honors isn’t auto admit anymore. It is dicided by application so while in the past a 550 would have counted him out this year it will not. I think S will still retake SAT but at least we know he won’t be eliminated from consideration because the reading score is 20 points below the cutoff. Of course we haven’t gotten to discuss any of this just texted. Hopefully we’ll speak this weekend.</p>

<p>Chocchipcookie…since we are in the midwest, our lists would probably be different. He applied to Michigan, Illinois and Purdue…all large, big-ten schools. If he had taken the SAT IIs he might also have applied to Carnegie Mellon and Northwestern. But, he’s always wanted to go to Michigan, so fortunately for him, he’ll be going to his first choice school. His plan was to apply to those 3 EA, and if he hadn’t gotten into any of them after the first round of decisions, he was going to apply to his second round of choices of RPI, Case Western and I think, RIT. Those 3 all took the Common App w/out any additional essays :). Since they all had ED, he wouldn’t be any later than other applicants not applying RD.</p>

<p>The “smile and nod” issue in dealing with other people’s comments is definitely something to figure out for yourself - sadly we end up in these positions, and it affects not only ourselves but how our kids think we see them, too. A confident response, whatever it ends up being, is probably best for your kid.</p>

<p>I’ll take it a step further, because we just went through this issue. My B+/A- student (who also ended up with an ACT that gave her a chance at some extra reaches) just went through a much harder decision-making process than we ever expected, and I’d say it was significantly based on “prestige.” So in a lot of ways we had to figure out how to “smile and nod” to our own issues about this.</p>

<p>We had talked all the way through the year about “what ifs” between lots of choices - and having lots of choices in the end was always her goal, so she had lots of “likelies” and did a lot of EA and rolling admissions. She didn’t have to base her decision on finances, fortunately, but of course cost meant something to all of us.</p>

<p>Mostly she had pretty obvious either/or choices, hypothetically - most schools had a “more likely” partner on her list (eg, if she didn’t get into school X, she’d probably go to school Y), and she knew which factors would sway her one way or another: she preferred city access, felt sure she would prefer the auditioned BFA degree over a more liberal arts-oriented BA, and wanted as good academics as possible. She hoped to bring cost down, but that was secondary to these others.</p>

<p>But in many ways our worst “nightmare” happened: She didn’t get into her 4 reach schools (2 each BFA and BA). But she got into the next “best” BA AND the next “best” BFA. BA school WAY trumps BFA school in terms of prestige - we think deservedly, with a very known high academic quality. BFA school offered a huge scholarship, and an honors college that very much enhances her academic opportunities there.</p>

<p>This was the exact pairing I always dreaded. She did feel that she had a duty to go to a “prestigious/known quality” school - nothing we had specifically told her, but in her own mind she did want to be among that group, have that kind of college experience, follow something of a “family pattern,” and she wondered also if it would matter to other people (including getting jobs, grad school, etc.). </p>

<p>We told her we would support anything, and we talked and talked about ups and downs and in betweens of both. The locations were comparable. Cost and the BFA option would sway anyone toward the “less prestigious” school. So it really came down to whether what “prestige” and “quality” meant deep in her heart, in all of our hearts, in how we felt about presenting her (and our) choice to the outside world. Most of all, we all talked about where she would be “happiest,” but that’s of course not so simple.</p>

<p>We learned a lot about expectations we’d expressed, and hadn’t expressed, hadn’t even understood. We learned a lot about what we value. We had to face the idea of taking chances. Fortunately this kid is something of a maverick; she will get a great kick out of bragging about her “lesser-known” school, but on the other hand she was hoping to get a chance for once in her life to have proof that she’d “made it.” </p>

<p>I don’t have any answers. If the cost had been the same, maybe she would have gone with the higher-ranked BA school. Or maybe she would have chosen to pursue the auditioned BFA anyway. She’s still a little bit concerned about the general atmosphere of the student body (really her only true concern about going to a lower-ranked school - her academic stats are very much higher than the mean). Following her heart became meaningless, because her heart had such mixed feelings. Finally she decided that she wanted this particular degree, and she’s giving it a chance.</p>

<p>Since then we’ve had to explain this completely unknown school to people here. Honestly, where we live, the idea that it’s “out east” and especially “near NYC” is enough to impress most people (which makes her laugh - she could be going to a CC there for all they know). And maybe we’re still being too apologetic and explaining too much - maybe it would be healthier for us all just to say, “We’re so excited about this school!” and leave it at that. </p>

<p>The honest truth is that we don’t know how she’ll like this school or how things will turn out, just as it is with every single other kid who goes to college. And she knew that if she chose the “prestige” school, that wasn’t going to guarantee her anything, any more than anywhere else.</p>

<p>Sometimes I fantasize that someday this school WILL be much better known, WILL have more prestige, and she’ll be proud to say “I went there way back when.” But I know that isn’t fair to any of us: we need to be proud and excited NOW, without expecting payback in prestige someday. </p>

<p>I’ve said this before - 3.X students are in a real bind, because they have to make lists like this and they have to make choices like this, by definition. A 4.0/high stat kid who takes a huge scholarship at a “lesser” school usually 1) goes to a higher-ranked “lesser” school, and 2) knows that people know s/he had prestige schools in the bag if wanted. There’s so much more power involved. </p>

<p>The trick is keeping the 3.X kids - and us as parents - feeling powerful in this middle range. It’s not just about nosy people - I think it’s just as much about dealing with one’s own preconceptions, insecurities and prejudices. I’d recommend having conversations about just that issue a lot sooner in the process - if your child is willing. Mine was not - she was too focused on other things, and it really was too emotionally charged to deal with until she absolutely had to. </p>

<p>I’ll let you all know how it goes in a few months. For now, we’re feeling good. And I do feel that having HAD the opportunity to consider, and turn down, a prestigious school, was a good thing for my D. I don’t want to live through those 3 weeks of choosing again, though.</p>

<p>I think that the struggle of prestige schools and other’s perceptions is why I find this thread so comforting, basically. Sometimes I can get myself so anxious when I read the “chance me” threads!</p>

<p>Chiming in on “nosey questioner” syndrome. Most people are really just looking for an opening to talk about themselves, so be brief and let them get on with it.
Do not let anyone make you feel like the schools you’re considering are somehow “less” because they are under the radar. We all know that the college admissions landscape has changed over the past decade.
With regard to SAT2’s, just be sure that your S or D does not have a dream school in mind that may require them. You do not want to have to rush and take them late in the game. Also, while it is one more thing to do at an already busy time, good scores may be just the thing to set your child apart from the other candidates, all else being equal.</p>

<p>Many students will want to include at least a couple of reach schools on their list (however they personally define reach), but there are definitely choices to be made about how much extra effort they want to put in to up their odds of admission to those schools. Sometimes the extra effort exerted along the way would likely truly turn out a student who is better prepared for success in a challenging environment, but there are other times when I think the main benefit would probably be increased chances of being admitted and maybe additional positive self-discipline habits learned (eg hours spent to improve standardized test scores). What do you think? There can also be a cost in terms of time available to devote to other activities, work, rest, or exercise, or stress.</p>

<p>Lordmonty-
Please stop posting this thirteenhorror thing all over cc threads. Thanks</p>

<p>I’ve begun to prioritize the application process thus:</p>

<p>1st: EA target/safety schools
2nd: EA reach schools
3rd: RD target/safety schools: these will be flexible based on the EA decisions</p>

<p>Right now, S doesn’t have any ED schools. This may change after our summer college tours.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>It was clear years ago that DD wasn’t going to able to apply to a top college. I so enjoyed the process of finding the right fit for her. I was thrilled that she had her complete list of where she would apply by end of junior year. It felt so right to me (and, more importantly, to her). I think there were only a couple of people who were judgmental (including some relatives who are so “pro-private” school - esp my SIL - wait till her kids go to college in five years - can’t imagine what the cost will be!). Having done the research with DD, I did not let these people get to me. In fact, their “snobbiness” about it (that’s what it seemed to me) comes from their own issues and is not a reflection on DD. I’m good with that.</p>

<p>In fact, some people around here had a particular snobby attitude toward me because DD wasn’t interested in going to OUR state schools (SUNY). Just this week, I had a close friend (much older) ask about DS’ college list and “isn’t he going to look at any SUNY schools?”</p>

<p>Just smile and nod, smile and nod. :)</p>

<p>Excellent post, Emmybet. Said so eloquently. We can’t wait to hear how your D enjoys her first few months there.</p>

<p>I know, this “smile and nod” stuff is hard! I’m not nearly as patient or as diplomatic as my H, and have to just walk away from the conversations sometimes!</p>

<p>C43 and Linymom: you both raise good points. And everyone else who mentioned being confident in the choices that you as a family make! As we all know, there are so many factors in deciding upon a college for your child. Academics and cost are incredibly important, but so are a dozen other things, so juggling all that info. is really about the right fit for your child and also a choice that the family can afford. Plus, it would be awful for your child to be in a college, struggling to keep up too, just to be in a prestigious name.</p>

<p>UMich: Did you ever visit RPI or RIT? Or anyone else? What were your impressions? RIT seems more even in terms of boy to girl ratios…and a larger school too…heard it was very challenging, though.</p>