Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>chocchip: We are going to RPI for a tour/info session on August 12. Will let you know what we think…</p>

<p>spectrum2 - good news on TAMU honors - glad you called.</p>

<p>Thanks for all of the posts on dealing with nosy questions. I knew I was not the only one struggling with this. It seems to bother me the most with family members for some reason - it just feels very competitive. I just keep repeating this mantra I read somewhere - “college admissions is a match to be made - not a prize to be won.”</p>

<p>EmmyBet, thank you very much for your thoughtful post. It really resonates so I copied it and added it to a college-related word document for future inspiration. It’s quite possible that my D, too, may end up attending a ‘second-choice’ school with some unknowns (well, there are always unknowns, but some can end up being more important than others).</p>

<p>Re nosy questions, our two Ds are quite different in terms of their academic drive, so we’ve known for some time that their college paths would be different. Fortunately, friends who know both girls well recognize their respective strengths. Nevertheless, I expect we’ll be fending off the questions at family/social gatherings this summer and beyond.</p>

<p>Re the pros and cons of visiting/applying to reaches, I’ve been mulling this one over after D and I visited a very appealing reach at the beginning of the week. At her meeting with the GC before school let out, the counselor didn’t discourage her from having this college on the list as a reach. And visiting did give her a better perspective on this size/type/location of college. But the college was even more appealing than we expected, and it was hard for her (and me) not to want to picture her there. Goes back to the point some have made of the dangers of visiting reaches, and the much preferable strategy of visiting/focusing on likelies and possibles. At least this visit has helped D to realize that a school of this size, etc. might work very well for her. We’ve mostly visited smaller schools to date. We weren’t planning to visit many more, but maybe now we need to add a few more larger schools to the list. And of course the goal continues to be an acceptable list of likelies and possibles, and avoiding ending up with a list that is top-heavy with reaches.</p>

<p>Hard to keep up with this thread! I’ve been without internet for the past 3 days due to storms in our area (thankfully we had power) but my big learning experience from THAT: no waiting til deadlines for submissions ANYWHERE! Because if we lost power on 11/30 and something was due 12/1…yikes, it would be mayhem!</p>

<p>From the midwest there’s a whole different ranges of “prestige” schools I think. Everyone recognizes the names of the top Ivies (yes, my husband went to Penn and still gets asked out here about Joe Paterno. Not often but it happens!) Dartmouth being another example. (Is Dartmouth an Ivy? LOL) D is really caught up in the prestige factor because she feels it will give her a leg up in the future, but I really do hate hearing from people that the top tier schools “just aren’t worth it.” Their kids can’t hope to get in. Or they’ll apply anyway even though they have clearly too-low scores and GPAs. We just keep telling everyone who asks that my D will go to the best school that gives her the most money. It’s shut everyone up so far…hope it’s true!!</p>

<p>Trying to find a way to get her interested in some safeties. Said she’d consider Bama after that posting somewhere about merit aid and their desire to get kids from the north. OTOH, she’s said (half jokingly) she’s not sure she could take seriously the southern accents. She’s NOT a snob but it made me laugh and then worried me a little!</p>

<p>D has been in France and returns home Tuesday night. I was getting so excited to see her and now I’m really starting to freak about what the next 6 months are going to look like! I don’t think our counselor at the HS is great. Sigh, wish I’d found this site a few years ago.</p>

<p>Ah well, have a nice weekend everyone.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Or maybe they’re not caught up in the prestige factor…</p>

<p>Fair enough statement Deborah but I’m pretty sure if their kids qualified they’d be sending them to prestige schools. Maybe not all, but certainly a few of them!</p>

<p>The last few days have been some of the most thought provoking posts in a while. Thanks to all for expressing feelings. So many truths.
I am going to skip the prestige conversation for brevity. I will offer a view on reaches. We are currently struggling with it now. I know if my d2 does not get in to her one reach school(Del.) she will be a total mess. I know it is a long shot. However, I encourage her to go for it.
I do believe that you must really try to market yourself for a reach school. The odds are against you. You must figure out how to go from a number to a face with a story. We are trying to do that now. D1 got on a plane to wisconsin, met with our local admissions rep, told her that she got on a plane and flew to madison to personally hand her her application and transcripts. She told her how much she wanted Wisconsin, explained why she belonged, and walked her thru the reasons for one bad semester. The woman told her she was not going to process her application right way, was going to put it in her draw, and would evaluate it in January. She told my daughter to stay in touch. She did. She got accepted in January. She and I knew that the meeting got her in.
D2 will do the similar with her reach. She already met the admissions rep. She had a connection. She has followed up with emails. She will fly back again for an official interview. If she does not get in, she will have felt that she did everything she could. I realize that this os not always practical, but it is what we are doing with a single reach. You will all find out the results in the spring.
Just my two cents.</p>

<p>^^I think that this is a great idea! I wish your daughter a lot of Mazel!</p>

<p>I can tell you that my son spoke on the phone with one admission counselor and that counselor called him on our home phone sometime later. My son was not home so the adcom spoke with me. She told me that she was very impressed that my son called her to ask some questions because in most cases her in depth conversations are with parents and the student! I do believe that your daughter will be a “stand out” by doing this. I hope it will results in a postive outcome!</p>

<p>For any student, there’s something to be said for not rattling off the entire list of schools being considered. If the kid doesn’t get into the (name brand) reaches, and then is asked “Oh, didn’t you say you were interested in going to (reach)?”, it’s painful to have to respond. I do like the approach of giving some generalities. “She’s interested in schools with snow and lots of internship opportunities” or “he’d like somewhere smaller but having lots of different majors” or whatever. And as a parent, I like saying “she’s looking at a lot of great schools, but she’s asked me not to give specifics on her list until she’s actually accepted somewhere.” </p>

<p>I’ve said this on the 2011 parents thread: one of the things I’ve loved about learning about schools is that I can enthuse about just about any school that someone names. A parent will tell me that their kid is going to Lewis & Clark, or McGill, or Oxford College (the program that feeds into Emory), or Muhlenberg, or a SUNY (we’re in California), clearly expecting a blank look on my part…and their faces brighten up because I break into a big smile and start raving about how their kid’s school is great because of A,B, and C. :slight_smile: At the same time, I know that not everyone will have heard of every school, so rather than just give school name when describing somewhere, I’ll say something about the school location and one of its strengths. So much fun to do this!</p>

<p>And now something in line with the thread: at graduation (finally!), D1’s classmates were having trouble keeping on their stoles. D1 told them the reason it wasn’t hard for her was because she’d had lots of practice wearing a tallit. :D</p>

<p>sujormik, if it helps any, I wouldn’t take that comment as meant to be remarking on your child’s choices. Your friends might very well want to be fully supportive of your daughter and could be meaning any number of things that would be very applicable to <em>their</em> situation that have nothing to do with her at all. Examples would be: too expensive for their budget, farther from home than their child wants to be, attracts a different personality type than their son/daughter desires to be around, in an area with weather their child doesn’t like, doesn’t have the particular program their child is looking for, etc. So, <em>for them</em> or <em>their</em> child, it very well might not be worth it. Doesn’t mean it wouldn’t be worth it for your daughter.</p>

<p>Btw, my child finished out hs with a good two years worth of college level work under her belt between her APs and college classes. High grades. AP scholar with distinction. She did not choose to apply to a single ivy.</p>

<p>Chocchipcookie…we only visited the 3 schools he applied to, and Northwestern. We went to a Case Western presentation, and talked w/ admissions reps from RPI and college fairs. We were pretty sure he wouldn’t end up applying, but if he did, we would have visited at a later time.</p>

<p>It’s kind of funny…my son applied to 3 schools and got accepted, and his reaction was that he should have applied to harder schools. My response was that he applied to the right schools for him.</p>

<p>No science to this - and you can only do it one way. D1 applied ED and got in, never got to find out how she’d do anywhere else, and sometimes wishes she had gotten that chance. But she loved the school and it worked for her. D2 wanted lots of choices, and applied to many schools - several EA and rolling, but no ED. She also had auditions and all kinds of strange probabilities (and improbabilities) to deal with.</p>

<p>She had some sad days this spring but doesn’t regret any of the reaches. It was important for her to try and see, which actually kind of surprised me. And she’s encouraging younger friends to have at least one reach school. But it depends on the person.</p>

<p>D applied to a range of schools and has loved it so far at the one she chose. Can’t ask for better than that!</p>

<p>RVM: I’m also glad I called. I guess it is a good reminder to everyone that college websites don’t always have the most up to date information.</p>

<p>Emmybet: I could really feel the pull and tug involved in making that choice. I hope she has a wonderful year!</p>

<p>Levirm, you said “there are highly selective engineering schools that would accept your son based on that amazing math score with the reading score as is”. Are there any schools you could name. S2 seems completely settled on TAMU but is thinking about engineering a little after his math teacher pointed him in that direction, so I’m just curious even though I don’t think he will look at other schools.</p>

<p>Very thoughtful thread by EmmyBet. </p>

<p>On the prestige front, I find the whole thing kind of peculiar. As I’ve written elsewhere, I think there are roughly 15 schools (Ivies, Stanford, MIT, Caltech, Amherst, Williams, Swarthmore, …) that have special clout in the sense that they provide things that go beyond a good education. I don’t think the education is necessarily better at those schools than at many others. But, they give horizons (You leave thinking you want to be the best in the world at what you do and realize that’s feasible), contacts (the alumni networks are very impressive as are your classmates), and a great stamp on the forehead (the international recognition of Harvard is extraordinary) that arises in part because of the selectivity. There are probably a few other schools that function the same way in specialized fields (e.g., RISD for Art, Waterloo or CMU for computer science, etc.).</p>

<p>But, those schools are different. I have a very bright nephew on the Canadian side of my family. All of his Canadian relatives told him to go to McGill and then go to grad school in the states and said, the only thing that matters is where you go to grad school. I told him about horizons. When you go to McGill and you’re ambitious, you are in a sense conditioned to be the best in Canada at what you do, but if you go to the top 15 US schools, you are conditioned instead to want to be the best in the world at what you do. He went to McGill, did very well, is now at Oxford and got one of 8 slots offered to 3000 applicants at a first class investment bank. He’ll start there next month. I recently had lunch with him in London and he told me that he didn’t understand what I meant about horizons and being the best in Canada instead of the best in the world until he was at Oxford. He now realizes he would have really enjoyed going to school in the US (at one of the top schools). He would have liked to have been in a place that helped him set his sights higher and also said that he was under-challenged at McGill, especially by many of his classmates. </p>

<p>Beyond those 15, there are hundreds of really good schools. Most will give you a really good education if you show up. At some, it will require more effort to get it. But, if they don’t operate on the horizons, contacts and forehead stamp, the prestige doesn’t matter. </p>

<p>But, I think kids pick up from others and probably from us as well the fact that people are impressed when someone goes to a more prestigious. It is hard to choose against the thing that you know impresses people.</p>

<p>college4three, I agree that most folks are looking to talk about themselves, so if you don’t want to talk, you can sidestep and let them talk.</p>

<p>shawbridge, it’s interesting reading your thoughts on this. My impression is that prestige tends to be more highly valued in the Northeast than it is on the West Coast.</p>

<p>I’m sure that’s true, Deborah T. Where we live, the lust for Ivies is intense and everybody is analyzing everyone’s college lists.</p>

<p>Deborah T - I think it goes beyond valuing prestige - that sticker on the rear windshield of your car let’s everyone know how successful you are and how accomplished your child is. It tells the world what you can afford or are willing to spend in terms of your child’s college education. At least in this area - people make a lot of judgements about you based on where your children go to college. </p>

<p>Someone a few pages back made the comment about people in the south asking someone where they go to church - that is an acceptable question in that culture - and it is a way of classifying a new acquaintance. In this area - if you meet someone and they determine you have college aged children - it’s all about where do they go to college.</p>