Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>we have discussed reaches in the past on this thread…in our daughter’s case, we personally didn’t think she would thrive at the bottom of the pool; academically or otherwise…</p>

<p>there were a couple of schools on her original list that have had very successful admissions experiences from her HS; she probably could have been admitted and they were both higher in prestige that the schools she unltimately were accepted to (and especially the one she will be attending)…we had a very long and serious discussion with her regarding these two particular schools and she admitted that she would not be comfortable academically having to compete with much higher stat kids…</p>

<p>two of her classmates who have similar profiles happen to be attending these two schools in the fall; it should be interesting to see how successful they are and, more importantly, if they are happy…</p>

<p>there are two types of reaches in my opinion; the first is the one that has a low admission rate but you are at the 50%; the other is one that your stats are at the lower end, but there is something that gets you in (whatever it is: ED, relationship w HS)</p>

<p>the first one is fine…the second one is a very personal decision…</p>

<p>First time on this thread. Hope I can jump in. I totally agree with rodney regarding the two types of reaches. D1 applied to college 6 years ago. She had gone to an overnight at Brandeis and loved it. (I was actually surprised since it seemed very unlike her in many ways). She was a B+ kid and chose to apply ED. As the date for notification got closer, I found myself hoping beyond hope that she would not get in: there was no way she would be able to keep up with those kids. It would be a constant struggle just to hold her place at the bottom of the class. Well, Brandeis did seem interested in her: called her GC to talk about a few things and the GC thought it was a good sign. In the end, she did not get in ED, but was added to the pool of RD applications (from which she was ultimately rejected). Big sigh of relief for me. The last thing I would have wanted to deal with was a child flunking out or looking to transfer after first semester:)</p>

<p>The past few pages of threads have been really wonderful. This prestige thing is interesting and is rampant at our school, to the extent that the gossip flew when a girl turned down Harvard to go to U of Chicago. (Most people cheered that she would be “strong” enough to do this, but still there was talk!) I have also seen the prestige issue from my dd from the other side. She is not really interested in certain schools in art that she considers too prestigious and therefore does not want to apply. She feels that our high school has been this way and she does not want to be put in the same situation again.</p>

<p>I do feel that every child has their own journey, so it does not matter in the end where the child goes as long as they can be successful–no matter how you define that word. This is easier to say of course than to live. That is the challenge!</p>

<p>As far as SATs, dd just got her scores for the second round and she did worse in all three sections. We are done. She just freaked herself out and I know that this is what would happen again. I would have liked her to take the ACT’s but she just refuses to do more, and ultimately, she will have to live with the consequences–I can only push so much. Her first scores, while not high, probably would have gotten her into every school but 1 or 2, because she wants to do an art program. Now, if the schools see the lower scores along with the moderately better first scores, I don’t know…Oh well. Oddly, she took the SATII in bio without taking AP bio and got a 620, better than her other scores!</p>

<p>Thanks again for all the thoughtful writing. It helps to hear what others have to say.</p>

<p>As happy as I was with DD’s college list, after seeing the results (7 acceptances, 1 waitlist, 1 spring admit), I thought that maybe she should have tried for harder schools. While I was thinking this, DS (who was only in 9th grade at the time) actually verbalized this.</p>

<p>I did take her to visit Brandeis (interesting that this was the focus of your experience, mommeleh) because there were a lot of things about Brandeis that she liked. However, during the visit, it became crystal clear that she would have to work super hard to keep up with this student body. I didn’t have to say it though. She told me it wasn’t for her.</p>

<p>In the end, she is at the perfect fit school for her, so no regrets here.</p>

<p>We are taking a different tact with DS; completely different personality and different capabilities. I think that’s what you need to consider, not a formula about how many reaches, matches and safeties. I salute RVM for her approach - knowing her DS and finding “fits” – even though his ACT scores could put him in a whole other category. You have to know your kid.</p>

<p>phillyartmom: Can you not use score choice for the schools your daughter is applying to? I haven’t yet figured out how it works but I believe that since 2010 you could choose to select whichever SAT scores you want to send. As I understand it you could only send the first SAT and the SAT2.</p>

<p>On prestige: It is a very different thing where I live. Very few of our students apply to or get into “prestige” schools and even if they do many still go to the state University. There is still some prestige involved in which of these a student goes to, but I see it more as individual school pride rather than true prestige among the top unis. The needs of students vary so widely. </p>

<p>rodney: It seems to me that even kids with the exact same stats have different needs. There is so much variation among what different kids put into earning their stats and how they perform with different sets of peers. Some kids thrive at the top of the class some hate it. Some are motivated by a stronger peer group and some are overwelmed and don’t fit. Some will take advantage of individual attention of small classes some will be happier anonymous in a lecture hall. All we and our kids can do is take our best guess about what is right for them. What I’m saying is that regardless of how your daughter’s classmates do it doesn’t say anything about your daughter’s choice. It is always interesting to see how the kids we know evolve but don’t second guess your daughter’s choice based on her peers’ good or bad experiences. I’m not saying that you were, it just sounded to me like you might.</p>

<p>Deborah: I have one of those kids too. The terms we used were: “searching for a school that was more collaborative than competitive.” From what he read about the ivy’s he thought that was a more competitive environment than he was after. He was also looking for college to be the best time of his life and for him it didn’t seem that the ivys would bring that for him.</p>

<p>He mommeleh - welcome to the thread! Your Brandeis post was interesting - I actually thought it was going to go in the other direction when I began reading it - that she did gain acceptance and was doing well. But I’m glad it worked out in the way that you thought best.</p>

<p>phillyartmom - agreeing with spectrum2 - you should be able to use score choice and send the higher first SAT sitting and ignore the 2nd lower one. Very few schools negate score choice and insist on receiving all scores - check the college website to be sure.</p>

<p>One thing I have noted with S2 is that his ACT scores exceed his grades. When I look at the Naviance scattergrams - there are more selective schools where his ACT score puts him in the ballpark - but his GPA is too low. My interpretation of this is that he has the intellectual capacity to do more - but he is not emotionally ready or mature enough (at least not yet) to push himself the extra degree needed. I noted to DH last night that while 4 B’s and 3 A’s for the semester is fine - he was very, very close to 5 A’s and 2 B’s - and had he just pushed a little harder - he could have done so. I find it frustrating - but am letting it go as there is nothing to be done now. Hopefully he will find the internal motivation to push himself a little harder at some point - but until I see evidence of that - I know we have the right list of colleges.</p>

<p>Intersting comment from my s (rising Junior CofC) on his grades: no matter how hard he studies, no matter the mix of classes, he gets 3 As and 2 Bs each semester. This has been consistant throughout middle school, high school and college. He is an A-/B+ student. It bugs him because he puts in the time and effort and really wants those As. Poster boy for the Jewish B student. </p>

<p>Re: prestige discussion. Around here, I would put those kind of comments (“Not worth it.” “Oh really, staying in-state”) into the category “Well, bless your heart.” Digs and not nice and not necessary. </p>

<p>Slithey Tove: Love your approach. </p>

<p>My D asked me if she got into Yale, would we be able to pay for it. This is the child who could not read in 4th grade, nearly flunked middle school, barely pulled herself through freshman year as a C student and then emerged at the end of her soph year an A student (after changing schools and focusing on academics only). I told her she’d have to have one heck of an essay. I’m thinking Coastal Carolina and she is thinking Yale! You’all better hang around awhile becase I think I may need some help. Rockvillemom, when are you starting that consulting business?</p>

<p>I would not overthink the Yale vs. Coastal Carolina dilemma. I would allow D to have one or 2 real reach schools–even if they are super reaches as long as she balances it with safeties and matches.</p>

<p>I think in the end, the colleges will be making the decision for your D. No point in trying to talk her out of applying to Yale because you believe it isn’t the right academic fit. There is a very high probability that Yale will be seeing it your way, too.</p>

<p>Case in point with Mommaleh’s D and Brandeis. Ultimately, she was not accepted. </p>

<p>In the end, it would probably be easier for your D to accept rejection from an ivy league school admission counselor than it would be for her to accept a parent’s unwillingness to give it a shot. (Even if you are justified in your assessment of her chances.)</p>

<p>“It seems to me that even kids with the exact same stats have different needs. There is so much variation among what different kids put into earning their stats and how they perform with different sets of peers.”</p>

<p>spectrum2’s comment is so true. And two kids with somewhat different stats may be more similar in terms of college potential than might appear on first blush. Assuming two students are fairly comparable intellectually (perhaps indicated by similar standardized test scores), but one just digs their heels in and works harder in HS and achieves all As while the other earns a combination of As and Bs. Does this mean the straight A student will be more academically motivated/successful in college than the other student? (i.e. past performance IS a reliable indicator of future performance …) In many cases, it probably does. But there are other factors (extracurricular interests, maturity, personality) that may differentiate the students in HS (in terms of grades) but may prove less of a differentiating factor in college. I was sort of a case in point in college vs. grad school. Did reasonably well in college (graduated with honors) but wasn’t a slamdunk admit for grad school (got in off the waiting list). But I finally came into my own in grad school and thrived there, graduating near the top of my class. I guess my point is while the goal is to find a good college fit, our students are still maturing, and it would be unfortunate to underestimate their capabilities and potential.</p>

<p>Psst - is this a Jewish thing, or what? The prestigious school I was talking about was Brandeis, too. How funny!</p>

<p>spectrum2: no second guessing here at all; but I do know (for a fact) that the other students I mentioned were shooting for prestige reaches…I just hope they are successful…</p>

<p>Hi all,</p>

<p>I just want to say how helpful reading this thread and following along has been for me. I may not be Jewish but your perspectives on your kids and your college searches resonate fully with me. You are my people and I am grateful for this thread!</p>

<p>stillnadine - that was a chuckle - I don’t think I have ever seen Yale and Coastal Carolina in the same sentence before! But I agree with uskoolfish - there is no need for you to dash her dream/fantasy - if she wants to apply to Yale - so be it. Isn’t there a saying about how “your reach should exceed your grasp”? I admire her willingness to reach - as long as she understands it is an unlikely admit and has other more reasonable choices on her list.</p>

<p>vandygrad - well thanks - much appreciated. I am flattered to be counted among your people! I’m just procrastinating at the moment - the treadmill is calling me. Ciao!</p>

<p>Wait - before I go (more procrastination) I did hear back from the York Hillel advisor - very nice response. She wrote that they have about 100 Jewish students with about 15-20 actively involved with Hillel. They hold numerous events each year that are open to the entire campus - have weekly meetings and periodic social events. They carpool to go to services at a local Temple. They also do events in conjunction with the York Jewish Community Center. So - that was a little encouraging. Planning to visit in the fall and would hope to meet with some Hillel members at that time if at all possible.</p>

<p>^^oh yea, that post reminded me…there is a very active Jewish community in that part of PA…</p>

<p>vandygrad: Welcome…please feel free to chime in…</p>

<p>the sun is finally shining here in NJ after a hellish week…</p>

<p>I’ve been hanging out on the parents of 2012 hs grads thread and missed so many great posts here! Sometimes I don’t know if I read back far enough to cover all that I missed, and I don’t want to miss anything. </p>

<p>DS’s SAT came back and it is not a game changer for us. He is very lopsided and is below the 25%tile for most of his reach schools in Critical reading and writing, while being at or above the 75%tile in Math for them.
His GPA and class rank somehow survived this year’s onslaught of B’s (guess the 5 AP classes helped that). Now, we need to finalize the college list. This is so tough in his position. There are not that many stats that show us if he really has a chance at most of his schools (because of the lopsided SAT, which he took twice and is unsure if he wants to retake). I heard that Tech schools (like Georgia Tech) may not care about his low reading and writing scores but they have so many more men than women there that I worry about DS ever having a real social life (though I am sure he would find plenty of xbox buddies). Carnegie Mellon might accept him with his scores…or not.
Jewish presence continues to be important but he did not like Brandeis or BU or Tufts when we visited.
It is important that any OOS school be near a MAJOR AIRPORT with a reasonable amount of daily flights to Fort Lauderdale.
This is what I have (posted on 2012 thread but now asking the op of those here):</p>

<p>Columbia University - Very high Reach
University of Pennsylvania - High Reach
Washington University in St. Louis - High Reach
Rice University- Reach
Vanderbilt University - Reach
Carnegie Mellon University - Low Reach
Emory University - Low Reach to Match (and it’s backdoor, Oxford College - match)
University of Florida - Match (not a safety for anyone, they have a quirky admit history)
Georgia Institute of Technological - Match
University of Central Florida Honors Program- safety
University of Miami - Safety
Florida State University - Safety (they also have an Honors Medical Scholars Program)</p>

<p>Our private college counselor thinks we have to take the far reaches OFF the list that he has no chance but some CC’er said to leave them be. HELP</p>

<p>seiclan, here are my thoughts about the far reaches. If your son really wants to apply to these schools (it matters to him) and were he admitted there is a decent chance your family would send him, I think it’s okay to leave far reach schools on his list. I wouldn’t want him to look back later in life and have any regrets that he didn’t try. I might limit how many schools I’d be willing to pay for him to apply to in total or say at minimum so many safeties or matches, though. How many he will be able to keep organized and put full effort into (ie essays, interviews, possible extras like a portfolio, audition, or whatever else unique he has to offer) is another thing to consider.</p>

<p>seiclan- if your son is somewhat interested in carnegie mellon- might you want to check out Case Western?<br>
when we checked out CMU for d# 1, there seemed to be a bit of an overlap in interest and applications between Carnegie mellon, case western and U of Rochester. My gut tells me Case Western may be a bit easier to get into than CMU. I’ll assume transportation is ok between cleveland and florida and I believe there is indeed a Jewish presence in Cleveland.</p>

<p>marny1…I would agree w/ you that Case Western is an easier admission than Carnegie Mellon. Also, it takes the Common App and its supplement doesn’t (at least for this past year) have any additional essays. Something to keep in mind of you’re already applying to other Common App schools.</p>

<p>Chocchipcookie, I have toured RIT. What would you like to know?</p>