<p>seiclan: Having just completed my son’s college apps, here is my take on your list. BTW, he applied to 7 schools: Northwestern (reach, but sister got in), Penn/Wharton (reach), Emory (reach/match), Michigan (reach/match), Tulane (match), Wisconsin (safety) and Indiana (safety). He is going to Michigan. </p>
<p>If your S is really interested in Penn then I suggest he apply ED. Of all the kids who were accepted to Penn that we know, they all applied ED. My S applied to Wharton, which is even tougher, and did not do ED…result…rejected. At Penn you apply to the school you are interested in, unlike Michigan, where you apply to LSA first and if you are admitted, then you do a second essay for the business school. </p>
<p>Wash U is in my neighborhood, and is infamous for putting kids on the waitlist and later rejecting them. D2 applied, but didn’t feel it was right for her. My friend’s kids who attend WUSTL really like it. These kids tend to be the more academically oriented types, where big team sports or a social scene were not things they were looking for.</p>
<p>S liked Northwestern and did all the right things (they love visits and great essays.) Didn’t work for him. I think ED is a good idea for NU, since it has become so competitive. He got into Emory and did all the wrong things, go figure. Didn’t visit until after he got in and didn’t apply until the last minute. None of his classmates who applied to Emory got in.</p>
<p>I highly recommend meeting all the EA deadlines, because it gives you a greater boost in your application. It just means that Fall semester is total chaos at home.</p>
<p>Having said all this, each kid has such a variety of factors to offer, that giving generic advice is sometimes futile. For example, D2 was a recruited athlete and top student. D1 was a B student, but had great ECs and S had sports, ECs and the grades. I also think legacy is a factor in some cases. </p>
<p>So for our S: He was rejected from the 2 reaches, accepted into all the matches and safeties. So our list was pretty accurate. He had Brown and Princeton on his early list, but by the time December rolled around, and all the additional business school and scholarship essays were being written, he hit his limit on anymore apps. The word “essay” was like a four letter word at our house, as in “have you finished the essay for [blank} school?” Usually, followed by a groan from the kid.</p>
<p>As to prestige: My S’s school has a very competitive group of kids and it wasn’t just the parents asking where he was applying. It became a competition among the kids. So he never gave out his scores or GPA (and neither did we, which we have stuck to with all 3 kids and now one going to medical school and everyone asking about her MCAT score! UGH). He also jokingly would tell anyone who asked that he was debating between University of Phoenix (online) and MIT…after a pause where everyone was in awe…he would say…Missouri Institute of Technology (no such school.) So I recommend your kids come up with a similarly fun answer. People laugh and stop asking.</p>