Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>seiclan: Having just completed my son’s college apps, here is my take on your list. BTW, he applied to 7 schools: Northwestern (reach, but sister got in), Penn/Wharton (reach), Emory (reach/match), Michigan (reach/match), Tulane (match), Wisconsin (safety) and Indiana (safety). He is going to Michigan. </p>

<p>If your S is really interested in Penn then I suggest he apply ED. Of all the kids who were accepted to Penn that we know, they all applied ED. My S applied to Wharton, which is even tougher, and did not do ED…result…rejected. At Penn you apply to the school you are interested in, unlike Michigan, where you apply to LSA first and if you are admitted, then you do a second essay for the business school. </p>

<p>Wash U is in my neighborhood, and is infamous for putting kids on the waitlist and later rejecting them. D2 applied, but didn’t feel it was right for her. My friend’s kids who attend WUSTL really like it. These kids tend to be the more academically oriented types, where big team sports or a social scene were not things they were looking for.</p>

<p>S liked Northwestern and did all the right things (they love visits and great essays.) Didn’t work for him. I think ED is a good idea for NU, since it has become so competitive. He got into Emory and did all the wrong things, go figure. Didn’t visit until after he got in and didn’t apply until the last minute. None of his classmates who applied to Emory got in.</p>

<p>I highly recommend meeting all the EA deadlines, because it gives you a greater boost in your application. It just means that Fall semester is total chaos at home.</p>

<p>Having said all this, each kid has such a variety of factors to offer, that giving generic advice is sometimes futile. For example, D2 was a recruited athlete and top student. D1 was a B student, but had great ECs and S had sports, ECs and the grades. I also think legacy is a factor in some cases. </p>

<p>So for our S: He was rejected from the 2 reaches, accepted into all the matches and safeties. So our list was pretty accurate. He had Brown and Princeton on his early list, but by the time December rolled around, and all the additional business school and scholarship essays were being written, he hit his limit on anymore apps. The word “essay” was like a four letter word at our house, as in “have you finished the essay for [blank} school?” Usually, followed by a groan from the kid.</p>

<p>As to prestige: My S’s school has a very competitive group of kids and it wasn’t just the parents asking where he was applying. It became a competition among the kids. So he never gave out his scores or GPA (and neither did we, which we have stuck to with all 3 kids and now one going to medical school and everyone asking about her MCAT score! UGH). He also jokingly would tell anyone who asked that he was debating between University of Phoenix (online) and MIT…after a pause where everyone was in awe…he would say…Missouri Institute of Technology (no such school.) So I recommend your kids come up with a similarly fun answer. People laugh and stop asking.</p>

<p>Moltobene - Why did your son choose Michigan over Emory? Just wondering if it was something about he schools, academics or student body that tipped the scale for him. Did your son have similar stats to mine (good GPA, lopsided SAT)?</p>

<p>I’m sorry to… Intrude? But I was just curious with the upmost respect for everyone I was just wondering what is the big deal about a special school for a Jewish student? I don’t know if I’m phrasing this right but it is important so that there’s a bigger population and they don’t feel like for example a Spanish kid in an all white school? Is it mostly a religious/ faith thing? And again I am sorry if you feel I am intruding I am just genuinely curious and please no one take anything I wrote as a mean spirited comment because in no way was anything I wrote intended to be snobbish or disrespectful</p>

<p>seiclan- so this is a “B” student thread and we haven’t really been discussing the types of schools that are on your son’s list. If your son is mostly B’s but has a lopsidedly high math SAT you might want to look at some lower ranked schools where he might be offered some good merit aid. </p>

<p>I live in Philly so what comes to my mind here is a school like Drexel. Philadelphia has a large and active Jewish community so I think it would fit your profile there. </p>

<p>What other things is your son looking for in a school? What did your son not like about Brandeis or BU or Tufts? Which schools resonate for him so far and why?</p>

<p>Welcome to mommeleh and vandy! (my nephew just graduated from Vandy a month ago)</p>

<p>Jazzii: Your question is valid and has been discussed in this thread many times. Both of your questions/comments are some of the reasons why this thread was started. Yes, it is a social/cultural thing as well as many other things. Your example of a spanish kid in an all white school holds some truth…since our religion is very social, cultural & religious, we tend to gravitate toward meeting kids with common upbringings and interests. That is not to say that we only want to socialize with other jewish kids. My boys, for example, have friends of every race & religion out there…but there is a connection to those that had a similar upbringing, even if they are from another part of the country…this thread is inclusive to everyone (jewish or not) who has children going through the college process, although we tend to talk mostly about “B” level students and their “A” siblings, as well as some jewish programs on the different campuses that others would also have a connection with. </p>

<p>Certainly feel free to contribute if you want to!</p>

<p>Chardo: I would love to hear your viewpoint of RIT! My S2 will be a h.s. sophomore in the Fall, so we have plenty of time. That school is on our list to check out eventually. Whatever info. you can afford me would be most appreciated! (Both positive and negative)</p>

<p>seiclan- further to my comment about Drexel, see this link- I think your son would likely qualify for scholarship as an A.J. Drexel scholar.<br>
[Freshman</a> Class Profile | Undergraduate Admissions | Drexel University](<a href=“http://drexel.edu/undergrad/about/facts/freshman-class/]Freshman”>http://drexel.edu/undergrad/about/facts/freshman-class/)</p>

<p>Drexel is well respected here for engineering and business and since they now have a med school I think it would be a great choice for pre med. Drexel is putting a lot of money into new facilities and they have an internship program. Check it out!</p>

<p>seiclan, I think the odds of the far reach schools are probably low unless there is something incredibly compelling either on the math side (placed in Putnams) or ECs. Otherwise, they can get kids with the same math scores with 75+ percentile verbals and comparable ECs. The good news is that there are a lot of great choices. I think Columbia is a horrible choice for a lopsided kid, if the lopsidedness favors math. The core curriculum probably would be fatal. ShawSon (the A sibling) is also lopsided, but was able to get his scores up to 99+ percentile in CR, M and W. But, he elected to apply to schools that had no distribution requirements or core curricula, or those (like Williams and Dartmouth, whose requirements weren’t particularly onerous). I’d say that going to a school with no real requirements has been highly advantageous for him. </p>

<p>There is a flip side to the prestige thing. ShawSon really felt that there weren’t very many bright, interesting kids at his (highly regarded, affluent, suburban Boston) HS. This is more a reflection of how bright he is and how he defines interesting than the school population. He really values intellectual stimulation and wanted a school where his classmates were more like him. He chose a very highly-ranked LAC over an Ivy at the end of day because they would be much more accommodating of his dyslexia. At the beginning, he didn’t find the kids there as bright as he wished (and he’s getting super-high grades and the recognition of professors) – his idea of a good time is to pose serious philosophical questions and try to wrestle them out in conversation – but he discovered that almost all the kids he knows are pretty bright and incredibly gifted or knowledgeable about something. For example, one kid is creating a Sumerian-English dictionary or vice versa or something like that. Amazingly enough, none exists. [“Drat. I got this email in Sumerian and Google Translate can’t do it. Let’s go to the library and pick up the Sumerian dictionary”]. He’s developed a lot more respect for them.</p>

<p>We live in Ivy feeder central. As I’ve mentioned before, ShawD went to a local private HS and the parents there went to Ivies and will either commit suicide or kill their kids or both if they don’t get into Ivies. ShawD does not like pressure and could really see the pressure mount when she was a junior. It turns out that, when she made and revised her college list for her guidance counselor, her counselor revised what were reaches to matches and said, “You should put some reaches on the list.” ShawD said she had no interest. She finished the tour at ShawSon’s school and said, “I don’t want to go to a school with that kind of pressure.” She was happy when I suggested a way to opt out of the pressure and still go to an excellent school, which was to focus in Canada. She is very happily going to an excellent school in Canada.</p>

<p>So, different kids want different things. Prestige correlates with what some kids want, but is negatively correlated with what other kids want.</p>

1 Like

<p>On SAT score choice - I find this the most confusing aspect of the college application process. I was shocked to learn that many, many institutions do not honor score choice. Here is the link to the score choice practices list:
<a href=“http://professionals.collegeboard.com/profdownload/sat-score-use-practices-list.pdf[/url]”>http://professionals.collegeboard.com/profdownload/sat-score-use-practices-list.pdf&lt;/a&gt;
To make it more confusing, the individual colleges change this all the time and may have changed it since the list came out.
If the colleges say to submit all scores and they will superscore, though, believe them!</p>

<p>Spectrum - the school that immediately comes to mind for your son is Purdue. It has an excellent reputation for engineering - its reputation exceeds the SAT scores of its students. If your son could get his critical reading score up even just a little, or maybe even as his scores are now, he might get into University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, an outstanding engineering school, and maybe even Georgia Tech. Get the CR score up a tiny bit more, and he could get into RPI or WPI. And, has he ever considered the Naval Academy or West Point? He might be able to get in. (I’m taking this from the “M” part of TAMU).
I know that he really, really wants TAMU. But you might want a few more on the list just to have some options or some other matches in case TAMU doesn’t work out.
I’ll PM you too.</p>

<p>Thanks pamom59! I’m adding Drexel to our list for possible choices! :slight_smile: I’ve heard it compared to Northeastern many times…what are your views? It looks like a viable choice for a “B” student wanting to study engineering.</p>

<p>Hi Seiclan! Refresh my memory…what does your S want to study?</p>

<p>jazzii,
I posted this before but I’ll repeat it.</p>

<p>Here are some things a Jewish student may worry about. </p>

<ul>
<li>Will there be religious services on Friday nights/Saturday mornings? High Holidays?</li>
<li>Will my classes be cancelled for High Holidays, and if not, will I be given an excused absence when I miss them? What if there’s a test? Will I be allowed to make it up? </li>
<li>Will I be able to get home for Passover seders? If I miss class to get home will I be excused/allowed to make up? If I can’t go home, will I be able to find a seder to attend?</li>
<li>Will there be kosher food? Kosher-for-Passover food?</li>
<li>If I choose to date Jewish people, will there be enough of a community that I can find someone? If that doesn’t matter to ME, will it matter enough to my classmates that they won’t want to date me because I’m Jewish?</li>
<li>Will opportunities to meet professors outside of class and develop personal relationships with them come primarily in the form of prayer breakfasts, Christian Fellowship activities, and the like? (True story from my medical school experience)</li>
<li>Will my coach expect the team to pray to Jesus before each game?</li>
<li>Will my hallmates bond through Bible study in a way that leaves me out, and leaves me uncomfortable?</li>
<li>Will there be final exams on Shavuot?</li>
</ul>

<p>As already mentioned, most of the most selective schools (the Ivies and top LACs and very selective universities), the ones for “A” students, have a large enough Jewish community that these things are not an issue. However, once you start choosing from the myriad of small LACs that are less selective, you can find yourself at a school where these things are a BIG problem, and even some large universities may leave Jewish kids feeling uncomfortable. (My medical experience was at a major state university.)</p>

<p>Moltobene: LOL! We were so sick of people asking us where S1 was applying to, that finally we just answered, “the local ______ girl’s college”. That shut them up, usually!</p>

<p>Seiclan: I agree with Shawbridge about the reach schools on your list. The top ranked schools have gotten extremely competitive in the past few years. The kids getting accepted to those schools have almost perfect grades, the most rigorous schedules, top scores (2200+) AND a major hook. Hooks include recruited athletes, relatives of big donors, and extra-curricular distinction on a national level. Many of my daughters classmates who were at the top of her class with very good SATs and school leadership did not get accepted to the top schools. They did have good results at slightly less selective schools. </p>

<p>Please make sure that your son applies to some good match schools that he really likes. If he truely loves one of the reach schools, he can increase his chances by applying ED. Also pay attention to size and acceptance rate.</p>

<p>Seiclan: S had a hard time deciding between Emory, Indiana and Michigan. He wants to major in Finance so the business schools were the main attractions. He was a pre-admit at Kelley in Indiana and they were heavily recruiting him (repeated phone calls from professors and business people.) He did like Emory, but he felt that the campus looked a bit sterile, like walking through our own suburban neighborhood (which I happened to love.) The kids were not overly enthusiastic about their school, but liked it well enough. In the end, he felt that Ross at Michigan had better placement with the banks in NYC, and he already knew what a great place it was from his sister having gone there. He also loves sports (we live in the land of Jayhawk March Madness), so football and basketball and hockey were a big draw, which Emory didn’t offer. One thing he wanted out of a college was a sense that the kids who went there couldn’t imagine going anywhere else…aka, great school spirit. He found it at Michigan and Tulane, not so much at Emory. He is also very active in Jewish organizations and really liked the Hillel at Michigan. Although, he said the new Hillel at Emory looked like a country club!</p>

<p>He did not have a lopsided test score. Where I live, kids focus more on the ACT and he had good scores in that, as well as good grades.</p>

<p>Choc, I was surprisingly impressed with RIT. S is in Project Lead the Way, a college level engineering program run by RIT at our high school. S is more of an MIT-caliber student, so RIT is his safety. We incorporated an RIT visit into a road trip last summer to make sure he actually liked it. I had very low expectations, having never actually heard of RIT before he started this program. </p>

<p>Some on CC hate the campus. S and I actually loved it. It’s a very modern brick and glass campus (students call it Brick City). If you like traditional gothic stone and ivy, RIT is not for you. Most majors require a year of co-op work, which often leads to great job offers before graduation (or at least a major plus on the resume). They have many different scholarships. A-students are looking at major merit aid, and the full COA is reasonable (for a private) to begin with. If you factor the earnings during co-op, the net cost of attendance is comparable to many state schools. I wonder sometimes why RIT doesn’t get more love. Anyway, if you have specific questions, ask here or PM.</p>

<p>I hope you don’t mind a little digression… but I ran into DS’ guidance counselor in the parking lot at Target today and chatted for two minutes WITHOUT talking about colleges, test scores, AP classes, etc.! Feel like I deserve a medal. LOL.</p>

<p>DeskPotato, very good list of questions, as it gets to concerns of both more observant kids and less observant kids. My D visited a school that she had spent a summer at in a science program and where she already knew professors and the university president. She was going to get mentoring and I thought it would be a great school. When she visited after acceptance, a girl she knows and respects highly asked her, “If there is anything that might cause you not to come here, what would that be?” ShawD who is not observant, said, “This is a really Christian place. There aren’t any Jews here.” It wasn’t in any way anti-Semitic and it was founded by people to be non-affiliated, but she still felt the strong Christian orientation and style. At the other school, there are a significant percentage of Jews, and when we went (to spend Passover with her grandmother), several of the kids we met were getting rides home to spend Passover with their families.</p>

<p>seiclan, I want to emphasize the distribution requirements/core curriculum issue. It is huge. My son wanted to go to my alma mater (I love it and thought/think it provides an amazing combination of undergraduate-focused education with serious research-oriented faculty, horizons, contacts pedigree plus we’ve taken him to reunions every 5 years). But, it has extensive distribution requirements – you basically can’t avoid humanities courses with 400 pages of reading a week --and I convinced him it would be a bad choice. My son does get accommodations that matter, and his current school is a lot easier to work with than some of the other schools on his list, but even without that, I’d push really hard for schools with distribution requirements that are not too onerous for your lopsided son.</p>

<p>Thanks all, for the welcome. This is a very interesting thread. </p>

<p>If it helps others,regarding our Brandeis experience, I’ll add some info as to why I think my daughter was not accepted. She went to a public high school that was the destination for all the highly capable (top 1-2%) students of the city. Consequently, any student with less than a 4.0 found themselves the owner of a pretty low class rank, as well. Brandeis called the GC to clarify that. But I think the thing that killed it was her SAT2 score in US history. Despite getting a 4 on the AP exam, she got a 530 on the SAT2 (not so good at memorizing facts, she is a great writer, which helped on the AP). That score put her in the lowest 30% or so of kids taking the SAT2 US history. I don’t think they could overlook that. I mention this because i see a post above questioning what to do about a low SAT2 score. I would definitely not send it in, if possible.</p>

<p>Levirm…I was also thinking about Purdue for Spectrum. I mentioned earlier that my S1 applied there for engineering as well as Illinois. Both have great programs for engineering, and Purdue especially tends to be a bit “easier” to get in, although I’ve heard it’s easy to get in, but not necessarily to stay in, since the program is quite competitive. Worth checking out.</p>

<p>A bit of background first: I first entered university 45 years ago; I taught at the university level for 11 years before deciding to go to medical school; I am a retired pediatrician with two children of college age, a son who just finished his BA in history from University College London and who will begin graduate studies at Cambridge in September, a daughter who just graduated from a Catholic high school and who will be attending a LAC in New England. </p>

<p>My son has mild Asperger’s Syndrome and severe dysgraphia. He overcame severe dyslexia after four years at a special school (and by some neurological miracle). He would never have been accepted at an American university as prestigious as UCL. In high school he made A’s in History, English, and Latin; B’s in math and science.</p>

<p>My daughter is a straight-A student who studied ballet intensely until an injury put an end to her aspirations for a career in dance. She is a NMF with an SAT of 2140 and an ACT of 32. She was accepted to our flagship university’s liberal honors program and to three excellent LACs in the northeast.</p>

<p>My sense of the admissions process is that decisions are, of necessity, often made quite hurriedly and are therefore unpredictable. High school grades, scores on standardized tests, and EC’s are used as a means of winnowing out candidates. Then some effort is made to identify students who might be a good fits for the college. I can understand the utility of this procedure, but I think it is flawed because it inevitably eliminates students who may be good fits but lack the requisite ‘numbers’ to make the first cut.</p>

<p>The result is a neurotic scramble for high grades and high SAT scores and a sense of entitlement and injustice when the 2400 SAT student doesn’t get into Harvard. I don’t know of a solution, but I was pleasantly surprised to discover that the LAC my daughter chose seems to have taken the time to get to know her as a person. She hadn’t liked it when we first visited but came away from the admitted students preview very enthusiastic about the students and faculty she met.</p>

<p>There are students who excel in some areas and fall short of excellence in others. There are students who are enthusiastic learners but express themselves in different ways. There are students who, in spite of their talents and best efforts, don’t make top scores on standardized tests. There are also students who have top scores but little or no interest in learning.</p>

<p>Ultimately then, I think it is important for the student to find a college where she will be comfortable and happy, and where she will learn as much about herself and the world as she can. That means looking beyond the HYPSM mentality that consumes so many of the posters on CC, and it points up the strong virtues of this particular thread.</p>

<p>Well said Irish Doctor! There are many merits to this thread, but I think it is mostly about finding the right fit for our kids and not about the prestige factor. </p>

<p>LINY-the fact that your guidance counselor knew who you were is most impressive. I have to reintroduce myself anytime I speak with my S’s counselor!</p>