Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Question about contacting college counselors over the summer: now that school has let out, are your students (or their parents) encouraged/allowed to contact the counselors over the summer if questions arise? Or are they unavailable (or awkward to contact) between now and when school starts again? Thanks.</p>

<p>Any rising seniors looking at schools on the West Coast?</p>

<p>(sorry about the complete disconnect from the post above this, btw – didn’t see it until after I clicked to send and the screen refreshed)</p>

<p>peonies, I vote for letting them rest over break and asking the questions here. :)</p>

<p>Our high school guidance office has summer hours and they implore students who can do so to schedule meetings with their guidance counselors over the summer. This allows the counselors to get some of the work on their letters done ahead of time.</p>

<p>Hello peonies:</p>

<p>If I recall correctly, our S’s guidance counselors were NOT available at all last summer, but we had one question that the Director of Guidance was able to answer, I believe by email.
However, this group here may be able to help you out…</p>

<p>Peonies…I think it has to do w/ your school. Our College Counselors rotate being on call during the summer so that they can answer any questions. You might want to send an email so that it’s not intrusive, but if they want to respond, they can.</p>

<p>peonies - I see no harm in trying to contact the GC over the summer - either by email or phone. If you get a voice mail recording that they are out until mid-August or an email reply of the same nature - you will have your answer. In my experience - most GCs do work at least part of the summer - but that will obviously vary from one school district to another.</p>

<p>Thanks for the different perspectives re contacting GC. This thread is a great resource, and Internet and in-person college research will probably have to suffice for us this summer. :)</p>

<p>I contacted GCs twice over the summer. Once because my son’s year end grade in a core subject was incorrect. The other time was because my son got a special college app that was due by June 30th and it came after school let out for summer. In both cases the GC was helpful.</p>

<p>This thread moves fast and having “graduated” this Spring I don’t visit as often as I did before, but wanted to comment on the prestige and questions vein that has been running through here over the last 10 pages. Some may recall that my older D went to a prestige LAC and my son is going to a prestige public university. Our part of LI is very much like RVM’s part of MD where a child’s school is emblazoned on the rear windshield and a topic of conversation at kiddush or the mall. So I went through those emotions this past year with my “B” daughter.</p>

<p>I think it’s a matter of - you, of us - becoming comfortable with and accepting our child, his or her strengths and their wonderfulness. Knowing that he or she has some qualities the others don’t. Knowing that if you look around in the world (both Jewish where learning is always prized and non-Jewish) many “B” types have more worldly “success” and happiness in the the adult world than other “more intelligent” or “higher achieving” in their youth kids did.</p>

<p>Now that D is looking forward to the school where she was accepted and chose to go, I find myself visiting its website, often reading about it more and getting just as excited and eager and involved in getting ready to send her there and investigating all the options she will have there as I once did with my other two kids.</p>

<p>And I think it was a matter of me realizing and accepting it… and her, to the point where I don’t bat an eyelash proudly telling folks where she’s going this fall. </p>

<p>Your child, who likely has friends they’ve known since kindergarten and who will be applying and getting into prestige schools, is going to be going through all this a whole lot more deeply and intensively than you are. You need to, as soon as you can, get to the point where you can show them that you are proud of who they are, what they’ve achieved, and where they are or may be going, so that they can feel that way too.</p>

<p>mhc - wonderful post - I agree completely. I was helping a friend with some college ideas yesterday - and I said to her that I find it more fun to discuss colleges for the “B” student. The stronger students all tend to apply to the same 25-30 schools, for the most part. But with the “B” students - there really are so many options - as you search for those “hidden gems” and learn more about colleges you have barely heard of - I find it more interesting.</p>

<p>So, that was a bit of an eye-opener. Rather than being a little embarrassed by some of the schools on S2’ s list and their lack of prestige/name recognition - it’s a healthier attitude to extol their virtues and educate those who are unaware. Obviously we see positive attributes for the school - or it would not be under consideration. So - if I need to be a cheerleader for Towson, or JMU or wherever - I can fill that role - without feeling any shame.</p>

<p>Thanks for the pep talk!</p>

<p>This makes me think of something I’ve experienced in another realm. Sometimes when people ask a lot of questions about what you’re doing or hone in with intense interest it’s because it’s something they’re thinking they might want to do, too.</p>

<p>I think you have to consider the source. If we are talking about parents with high school-aged or younger kids - I would agree - they may be genuinely curious and gathering info for their offspring. But when we are speaking of relatives, particularly older ones who have grown children, it just seems to be an extension of sibling rivalry on a grander scale. I have no idea why people feel the need to make such judgments - comparing one family member’s college plans to anothers - as if it is a competition. The same goes for people you barely know - and encounter while you are out and about - it just seems to be a very pervasive line of inquiry - and far too many people seem to feel it is acceptable to render their uninformed opinion on the subject. Again - making a case for a vague response for now.</p>

<p>I hear you, rvm. We get a lot of solicitors in this neighborhood. They’re welcome to knock on the door, but I don’t feel obligated to answer it if I’m not in the mood. Sometimes you don’t want to engage in the conversation. </p>

<p>I would say, though, sometimes when you take the risk and open up to people, you take your relationship to a deeper level. You might get hurt, yes; people can disappoint you. But not always. Sometimes they surprise you.</p>

<p>MHC: great post…and so true…</p>

<p>but it made me realize why I have been so anti-social in my geographic area for the past couple of years…a little sad, but I don’t do well with people trying to compete with me… (especially about my kids)…</p>

<p>RVM: I hear ya about the family difference…</p>

<p>I agree…great post, MHC.</p>

<p>I think this has been posted before, but if not, here’s a link to a list put out by Reform Judaism Magazine of the top schools jews choose, w/ statistics re % of jewish students, greek life etc:
<a href=“http://reformjudaismmag.org/_kd/Items/actions.cfm?action=Show&item_id=1647&destination=ShowItem[/url]”>http://reformjudaismmag.org/_kd/Items/actions.cfm?action=Show&item_id=1647&destination=ShowItem&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Great post MHC. When people ask where my D2 is going, I always answer just as proudly as I did with D1, who attends a more selective school. I have found that when you are upbeat about your child’s choice, people respond favorably. Fortunately, I live in a community where most of the kids attend our state flagship or similar OOS publics. A fair number of kids from our HS also start at community college, so people aren’t too snobby about college choices.</p>

<p>Here’s one idea. When the Joneses are getting to you, volunteer at a food bank, a shelter, or for another organization serving those in need. This will usually help put it in perspective.</p>

<p>I was just sent this article to read. </p>

<p><a href=“http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/sunday-review/26leonhardt.html[/url]”>http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/sunday-review/26leonhardt.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Where are those 2000.00 colleges the author is talking about? :(</p>

<p>The average public college data the author is using (which is also net of aid) probably includes community colleges, which a very large number of kids attend.</p>