Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Well, D2 and I are back from our 2nd trip east. We had a crazy week, but got a lot in. As we went many places, I will briefly give our views of each school.
GEORGE MASON…A quick visit on our way to James Madison. Campus was ok at best. It feels like a real commuter school. Ethnically, very diverse. D2 dismissed within first hour. She felt no connection to the students she saw. Nothing ventured, nothing gained.</p>

<p>JAMES MADISON…A good two hour drive from Washington D.C. A very pretty drive. Harrisonburg is in the middle of nowhere. A very small town, with little to offer. They call it historic, not sure why. The downtown is very small and sleepy. The campus is divided by a highway. While it felt odd at first, it quickly gets lost. One side of the highway has mostly very new buildings. While nice, they are not particularly beautiful. The other side of the highway has the original old campus. Quite nice. The very old quad is really very pretty. We liked the campus. Not many students around. Our Tour guide was a jewish boy from NJ. We spent 15 minutes talking to him at the end. We asked many questions about Jewish life. He said it was almost non existent. He was not in a jewish frat, had few jewish friends, did not know too many, and said if it is important, then don’t go. Students seem happy there. Wherever we went on the east coast, we only heard good things. In the end, I do not see this for my D. Too hard to get to, and too few jews…Not sure she will apply…</p>

<p>DELAWARE…We went back to Delaware for a 2nd time. We were there in April. D fell in love again. This reaffirmed all that she believes. This is the perfect school for her. Size, demographics, proximity to many east coast cities, and a beautiful campus. We went back for her formal interview. She had it with the west coast admission rep. This great lady met her in April. Her interview was great. D felt she was talking to her new best friend. I was in the waiting room. All i kept hearing was laughter. My D left excited. While she is below the academic standards, we think she has a real shot. Being from California helps, she has explained in detail her learning issues, visiting twice really demonstrates her strong desire to be a blue Hen. The wait for her obvious first choice will be a long one. (March 15, 2012). This is her Nirvana. I only hope it happens for her.</p>

<p>PITTSBURGH… What a cool city. Much nicer now then when I was there 25 years ago. Very nice in the summer. The area where the school is well located. Very much a city school. It is a block from a great Art Museum, close to great public gardens, two block to CMU, and adjacent to squirrel hill(the very jewish area of Pitt). I was quite surprised by my d’s reaction. She really liked it. I thought she might not. Cool that has big time sports, and spirit. A very different feel than GWU, BU, NYU… We attended one of their big Saturday presentations. It was very well run. It was impressive. Unfortunately, we learned that it will be a very difficult reach for her. She filled out a free application while we were there. D2 said it was now her second choice. I doubt she will get in. She did not find an angel in admissions office. They had little time for us. They seem rigid in their assessment criteria.</p>

<p>URI… OUr last stop. Thought it might be a good safety. I was wrong. A dumpy campus. Very unimpressive. I wish I could say something good. Sorry.</p>

<p>We are now done with looking. Top two schools are clear. Will not be easy. Nothing clearly stands out after top two. If she has to choose from Plan b, it will require revisits in the spring. Indiana, Boulder, and Kansas will be her backups. Miami, a long shot.
Now for essays, and applications.</p>

<p>Too my east coast friends here, I hope it cools off for you. The heat and humidity were brutal while we were there. </p>

<p>Good Night</p>

<p>socaldad- thanks for your report. We are looking at a lot of the same schools. So far, my D likes Delaware, Pitt, Penn State, and JMU. We are in-state for PA, but Delaware is probably on top of the list her list right now. My older D will be a freshman at Pitt in the fall.</p>

<p>Funny that you mention George Mason. My husband and I were on the subject of colleges tonight, and we were talking about possible safety schools for my D…I tend to think Temple should be my D’s safety …its close, relatively inexpensive, and has all the resources of a major research university, good sports teams, etc. People who go there seem to like it…but, my husband thinks it’s too close (we can drive there in 20 minutes!), and the campus is in a seedy neighborhood… so I threw out George Mason as a possibility. I heard about the commuter reputation, but thought it might have a nicer campus feeling than Temple…do you think it is even worth visiting? URI was also mentioned by D’s guidance counselor-but based on your report it doesn’t sound very appealing.</p>

<p>Have you, or anyone else, visited the main campus of U Conn in Storrs CT?</p>

<p>RVM- since you live relatively nearby George Mason, can you confirm or deny the commuter school reputation?</p>

<p>Socaldad, maybe being oos will help your d at Pitt. It also seemed like a great school to me. From our school, many kids who like Delaware also apply to Pitt. Pamom, it is funny that your H says that Temple is too close. We keep telling dd that even though it is close, we will not see her much and we have had this validated by kids from our high school that have gone there in the past two years. They seem to get too busy to even get on the train to come home! While the area around Temple was bad, we loved the campus and the idea that it is so easy to get on the train or to get to center city made it seem better, not to mention the football stadium lighting all over the campus. Can you tell that I am hoping that my dd will apply and want to go there?</p>

<p>phillyartmom- I know! My neice was at Temple this year and we saw her maybe two or three times the whole school year, even though she could hop on a regional rail train that goes right to our town. </p>

<p>West Chester has also been mentioned as a possible safety- but honestly I’m not sure of the academics and think that a Temple degree would open more doors, at least in Philly.</p>

<p>Yay for everyone who likes UD! Apply early, especially if you are borderline, and then wait (and wait and wait).</p>

<p>pamom asked about UCONN. We visited during DD’s junior year. She liked it (and was accepted) although it was in the middle of nowhere. Seemed like there is a lot going on on campus. Everyone she knows who goes there loves it. I know someone who went there (many moons ago) for their outstanding vet program. Great program (she’s now a successful vet), but she did not like the school - spent as much time as she could in Boston rather than on campus (and it’s close, but not that close). If you have any specific questions, I can try to answer - but our visit there was two years ago.</p>

<p>socaldad: sounds like your trip was successful in determining priorities, options and ruling out others. I bet you had a good time with your DD.</p>

<p>Liny, yes I had a great week with d. We enjoy the looking, and cherish this time together. Both my d’s will remember these trips, I hope. Liny, do you think applying early to udel really matters. Theyndo not review til December. They do not have rolling. Can you shed light?
Pamom, I looked at uconn with d1. I was impressed with the money they invested in upgrading the campus. Very high tech. It was an overwhelming investment. I do not recall exact number, but the results were impressive. There is nothing around the campus. Not even half a block. No stores, restaurants, or bars. My d felt she could not handle then isolation and lack of college town. We thought then students were compatible
I am sorry about uri report. The freshman live in triples. Only two small closets. The dorms were not nice. The campus was poorly kept. Bad landscaping, ugly buildings. They did have one nice quad. Did not get a great feeling about students. Howndo I say this…underachievers. Notnthat my d is a genius, but she aspires to be around smart kids. The tour guides were very unimpressive.
Pamom, did you see JMU? What were your thoughts. Also, I will be anxious to hear your reports about pitt over the year.</p>

<p>SocalDad, your impressions of the schools you visited with your D (and the joy of the trip with her) match so closely with my and my own D’s impressions on our visits last year that I almost feel like I’m reading versions of my own reports. I can’t tell you how much I hope that your D gets into UDel. Yes, it’s a very long wait, and as we did, you will read things on CC that make you doubt her chances. Have your D apply to one or two safeties with early notifications: it will help with the anxiety and tension til March. While I don’t know of any help applying early there, I think in your circumstances and coming from CA, it might be worth it. The adcom may well remember her and set aside a place, at least in her thoughts for your D.</p>

<p>SOCALDAD - Maybe another safety to consider and then an admitted students day might be UMASS Amherst. It’s a great college town.</p>

<p>socaldad- My D had a very favorable impression of JMU- I posted impressions of our visit here <a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/james-madison-university/1114048-jmu-visit-report.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/james-madison-university/1114048-jmu-visit-report.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>we went in March when school was in session. It happened to be a beautiful day and everyone on the campus was out and about. It seemed like a very happy place. Super impressed with the dining facilities and the dorms were some of the nicer ones we’ve seen. The area is scenic, with opportunities for hiking. As I’m sure you saw, the immediately surrounding area is mostly strip shopping centers and fast food- but I think my D would be happy with this. Her favorite restaurant is Wendys. She kept asking if we could stop to eat at a Waffle House. LOL. My problem with the school is 5 hour distance, and no easy public transit to get back home. I have heard that you can get rides. BUT, I’d feel better if there was public transit. With older D going 5 hours away to Pittsurgh I see the benefits of younger D closer to home, like Delaware!! Even Penn State is only 3 hours away. There is megabus service to Penn State and Pittsburgh, and SEPTA to Newark Delaware, but it seems like driving is the main option to Harrisonburg. On the plus side, we do have relatives who live in Charlottesville and could be available in an emergency.</p>

<p>cherryhillmom- now you’ve got me interested in U MASS. Please tell more!! I know it is part of the 5 college consortium. Not familiar with the town of Amherst at all-what’s it like? Does the school have a pretty campus? Is there school spirit, sports teams, etc?</p>

<p>Socaldad: Thanks for the trip report. I’ll keep my fingers crossed that things work out for your daughter at Delaware. I’m sorry that you hit such a horrible week weather-wise. It’s much nicer this week. </p>

<p>We visited UConn and UMass. As others described, UConn has a very nice campus, but it’s really isolated. I was surprised at how much my daughter liked it despite the location. UMass has older facilities and uglier buildings, but the campus has lots of open space, and the town is really cute and appealing. They also offer a shuttle to the other colleges in the 5 college consortium. Northhampton, home of Smith College, has nice restaurants and an Urban Outfitters. </p>

<p>I think that UConn would be a good choice for a student that wants greek life, and a rah-rah sports atmosphere. UMass offers more off-campus life.</p>

<p>socaldad - glad the trip went well. I always find opinions on JMU interesting - you get a wide variety of responses to the split campus and the location. We are visiting again at the end of September - S2 has already submitted his application. I will keep good thoughts in mind for your D and Delaware.</p>

<p>pamom59 - I think George Mason has come up before and my opinion is that it is primarily a commuter school/suitcase school for Virginia residents. While it has probably improved somewhat - not by much. I would NOT recommend for an OOS. Right now - I have a friend whose daughter will be a sophomore. She is seriously thinking about transferring. Her parents live abroad right now but she is considered in-state for Virginia schools and George Mason has the somewhat unusual major she desires. So - it is working out for her academically - but that’s it. She is not happy socially or with weekend life, etc.</p>

<p>Just wanted to add - I appreciate the comments on Jewish life at JMU. I know that in this regard - Virginia Tech would be a better choice. For us - JMU is an easy 2 hour drive and it does offer sports mgmt. Virginia Tech does not - he would probably be a business major there which concerns me a little bit. Of course - this leads me right back in a circle to Elon - which has both the sports mgmt major and active Jewish life - still very much in the running - but he wants to keep his options open and I don’t want to push too hard. </p>

<p>He also has applied to South Carolina - more as a financial safety than anything else - since he can do sports mgmt for in-state rates. The Jewish population is tiny and it is the farthest away of the schools he is applying to - so I’m not sure that we are really all that interested in USC - but we may visit in March.</p>

<p>hello everyone,</p>

<p>got back from our trip yesterday. I would love to say that I can go back and read three weeks of pages, but Whoa too much. So I will just jump back in today.</p>

<p>Amherst area is fantastic. Lots of cultural and social activities, great restaurants, outdoor options, etc. UMASS campus not the prettiest, but everything surrounding is terrific. Great area to go to school and lots of opportunity to take advantages of the other schools in the area. There is an active Hillel and Chabad. I used to go over there on Friday nights for the really good dinners! I also remember many campus wide fairs and rallys.</p>

<p>socal glad you had another nice trip with your daughter. It seems that Del is perfect for her. Have her keep in touch with her admissions “angel” and keep her posted on her Senior year accomplishments. As for a back up, I have a nephew with LDs who attended Boulder and loved it. He published articles with his professors and had many internships. He will be starting a PHD program in the fall there. Bro-in-law said Boulder very very helpful with LD students.</p>

<p>Well the good news is that I got home and my S did write a draft of his first essay. He is doing well in his course he is taking over the summer and he is more than half done the work that he was assigned over the summer for his senior classes. I am thinking I should go away the rest of the summer!!</p>

<p>Hope I have more time in a few days to catch up with the thread.</p>

<p>U Mass.
For a while, U Mass. was on the list for D2. I think Amherst is a great college town. The surrounding solid schools makes for a great collegiate feel. I do not remember it as a nice campus, but I thought it had a lot to offer.
Last September, the Boston Globe ran a series of Articles about U Mass. It caused concern, and we stopped thinking about it. I am not sure sure if we should add it back. The link is below. While I do not remember each article, the first one on Sept. 4th really hit hard. If you are interested, here is the link. You might have to copy and paste.<br>
I would like to hear more about what you all think of the school. We could use one east coast safety.</p>

<p>[An</a> inside look at the University of Massachusetts - Boston.com](<a href=“http://www.boston.com/news/education/higher/specials/111710_UMass_series/]An”>http://www.boston.com/news/education/higher/specials/111710_UMass_series/)</p>

<p>Socaldad, it’s great you guys have been able to do the college visits. I hope you’ve been enjoying the time with your daughter! </p>

<p>I’m curious, how’s the chemistry class been going?</p>

<p>Deborah,
Yes I am enjoying this time. My wife is jealous.
Chemistry is going well. With the help of a daily tutor, she got an A for the first semester. She is now doing 2nd semester. Hoping she repeats the A. Quite honestly, I am not sure what she will retain, I doubt she will ever be equipped to take it in college, but she is getting through it. Thank god for the tutor. He is a former science teacher, who became a lawyer. He is holding her hand, and getting her through. Math and science are her difficulty.</p>

<p>Yay! Congrats to D.</p>

<p>Suggestion: Next trip be a nice getaway weekend for you and your wife. :-)</p>

<p>just home from San Juan Island, ahhhhh…</p>

<p>I agree with all the posting about UMASS. It is a viable safety for B students and for the great college town experience, Amherst is really wonderful. </p>

<p>Rockville - did your son consider Drexel for sports management? He certainly would receive merit money, not too far and does have an active Jewish community. Adding the benefits of co-op this might be another safety to consider.</p>

<p>RVM, My take as a Virginia resident-
UVa is for the top instate students, W & M as well(although seems to appeal more to girls or boys less interested in sports,LAC type environment). VT is very popular, particularly in engineering, need very good GPA and SAT for an instate kid to get into, especially from one of the city schools. JMU kids seem very happy in general. GMU seems to be a backup a good part of the time for kids that don’t get into the top schools. Many Virginia familes stay instate because of the great quality and variety of options.</p>

<p>SOCALDAD- and just for fun and maybe something off the beaten track but rave reviews - Clark in Worcester, MA. This is a great school for a B student.</p>