Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<br>

<br>

<p>LOL, I hadn’t even realized it before reading this, but campuses bound by strip malls and shopping centers with chain restaurants were the chief turn-offs for my D. I guess everyone in my family are pre-Bourdain food adventurists. Non chain or authentic, locally owned Korean, Hispanic, Thai, Chinese (if really unusual), Mediterranian, Hallal, or Vegetarian restaurants are the first things we looked for after checking into a motel or hotel.</p>

<p>At Elon we ignored all the recommendations we got (and Biscuit places) and drove for a long time before finding a small Thai restaurant in a strip mall two towns over and the next day an out of the way local barbeque joint. The one highlight of our JMU tour was dinner the night before in a Thai restaurant down the road (but with lots of JMU students). Not finding any decent places to eat was a major mark against Muhlenberg, F&M, UConn, Hobart and others. </p>

<p>The variety and quality of restaurants we ate in a block away on Main Street in Newark were the closest we saw to Ann Arbor, Tulane etc. and probably what sealed the deal for UDel.</p>

<p>Crester had asked me to report on the Coleman duffel bags when I returned. If you are looking for duffels to pack your kid for college these would be great and will collapse under the dorm bed.</p>

<p>These were ones on Amazon for $49. They are great!! We were three weeks in Switzerland and Belgium switching hotels every couple of days. That meant loading and unloading the luggage and dragging them up and down out of the trains, cable cars, walking thru the cities to our hotels, many times on cobble stone streets and pebble pathways. We overstuffed them in the end. We had 6 flights. They held up better than any other duffles we had in the past. The wheels are fine and there are no material rips.</p>

<p>This looks like it, but the price has gone up a bit:
[Amazon.com:</a> Coleman Excursion Ii Rolling Duffel: Clothing](<a href=“http://www.amazon.com/Coleman-Excursion-Rolling-Duffel-Size/dp/B0027AH33I/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1311787966&sr=8-1]Amazon.com:”>http://www.amazon.com/Coleman-Excursion-Rolling-Duffel-Size/dp/B0027AH33I/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1311787966&sr=8-1)</p>

<p>thanks for that link about U Mass. Now you’ve got me googling U Conn</p>

<p>[UConn's</a> Herbst: University can rival the best in the nation - GreenwichTime](<a href=“http://www.greenwichtime.com/news/article/UConn-s-Herbst-University-can-rival-the-best-in-1560436.php]UConn’s”>http://www.greenwichtime.com/news/article/UConn-s-Herbst-University-can-rival-the-best-in-1560436.php)</p>

<p>[Full</a> impact of higher education budget cuts remains uncertain | The Connecticut Mirror](<a href=“http://www.ctmirror.org/story/13282/full-impact-higher-ed-cuts-remains-uncertain]Full”>http://www.ctmirror.org/story/13282/full-impact-higher-ed-cuts-remains-uncertain)</p>

<p>socaldad, I am so glad that your trip went well, and I am sorry that you hit the heat wave. It is much, much nicer this week!
I agree that your daughter should keep in touch with her UDel admissions “angel”. A good strategy is for her to apply, and then send an email once a month to “update her file” on new accomplishments and activities. (This will keep her active and doing things senior year, too.) At the end of each email, she should ask a question, which will force the admissions “angel” to email her back, and you will have evidence that she actually read your daughter’s email. Your daughter sounds like such a special person and I will also keep good thoughts in my head regarding her application to UDel.
Is there any chance that she might try for the dance team at these colleges? If so, she might want to contact the coaches.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Socaldad: People go both ways on this. I am an obsessive early person. Since DD knew UD was one of her top choices, there was no reason to wait. Since she wasn’t at the top of the application pool stat-wise, better to put everything in her favor that was possible (visit, emails to adcom, apply early - she applied in Oct). I don’t have data, but anecdotally, one of her friends (same HS) who had almost the exact same stats and ECs applied closer to the deadline got waitlisted. (she eventually got in, but didn’t attend) I just don’t see the reason to wait if you know a school is a top choice. Some of her schools were early action (and we applied early action - nonbinding - to all that offered it) so we could get some acceptances in hand early. She heard from URI really early (we never visited) and UCONN in December. Towson and SUNY Albany came in January (UMD at the end of Jan - deferral). So even by New Year’s, (1) she knew she was going away to college and (2) she had acceptances she’d be happy with (UCONN was #1 out of those).</p>

<p>I am definitely having DS do his apps early (fall 2012). Most of the schools he likes so far are end-of-March decision schools (ugh), but Miami (FL) has early action. Still working on his list and hope to find some with early action.</p>

<p>Amherst is a great college town. ShawSon has a friend who attends UMass who takes most of his classes at Amherst College because of the five college consortium. So, he’s getting mostly an Amherst College education at a UMass Amherst price (with a UMass Amherst degree, but his transcript shows where he took his courses). ShawSon does not take advantage of the other schools – I’ve encouraged him to at least visit Smith and Mt. Holyoke – but he says he’s too busy with work and friends and activities and doesn’t want to go to parties where he doesn’t know people (though he knows one or two girls/women (not sure when the transition occurs) at each school. Shawson does not partake of Jewish activities, but they are there at all of the 5 schools.</p>

<p>One potential reason to hold back on filing applications is if you think that something will materialize in the fall that will strengthen the application.</p>

<p>My daughter had some accomplishments in the fall semester that were significant additions to her applications. For schools where she had already sent in the application, she emailed the AO and said, “Here are three significant things I accomplished since submitting my application; for your convenience I’m attaching an updated activities resume.”</p>

<p>Having just attended the admissions info session at UD, I can report that they did not indicate ANY advantage to applying early as along as you meet the priority date of Dec. 1. UD doesn’t make decisions early but waits until Mid-march. They want to see mid-year grads and senior year course rigor. Perhaps that is what helped your D, LINYMOM, vs her friend with similar stats., rather than the fact that her application went in early?</p>

<p>Deskpotato: Good reason to wait.Thanks for pointing that out.</p>

<p>PAmom: Also good info; I didn’t know that. Whatever the reason DD was accepted, we’ll take it! She did well there freshman year and really stepped up the academics. I knew she was capable; she just didn’t care as much in HS!</p>

<p>I can also confirm that mid-year grades are very important to Delaware - they send out a letter to each high school listing the applicants and requesting mid-year grades. A good incentive to keep those grades up in the fall!</p>

<p>Curious to know what comes quickly to mind which schools are not 50-50 ratios. Maybe an “A” school that would want a “B” boy or “B” girl and would offer monetary incentive or easy admission to have them become part of their student body.</p>

<p>This link gives the gender ratio:</p>

<p><a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/776728-gender-imbalance-colleges-its-impact-admission-2.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/776728-gender-imbalance-colleges-its-impact-admission-2.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>At the info session at V Tech this week, gender may help if a female is interested in engineering, but adcom said that they don’t try to balance the class in general.</p>

<p>I’ve read that some schools are trying to create a balanced student body, so maybe there would be an advantage to a male applying to Elon. I’ve used the admissions data from the Common Data Set to get an idea of whether the school favors one gender over another.</p>

<p>cherryhill, the most selective schools can hit 50/50 or whatever they choose because they have so many completely qualified applicants. But, overall and except at the very top, there are many more strong female candidates. So, as you go down the selectivity scale, to get the strongest applicants, schools end up at 60/40 or even 70/30 (Sarah Lawrence, I believe). I suspect that males get some boost, but the cannot get too much or the schools would be at 50/50 or 60/40. Nonetheless, it could be fun for the males to be at 60/40 or 70/30 schools.</p>

<p>That is an interesting question about ratios Cherryhill. At my S’s LAC for as long as I have followed it the ratio has always been close to 50/50 with a few more boys than girls. Every year more girls than boys are accepted but more boys accept the school than girls. I’ve seen this for three years consistently so this has got to be by design and not a coincidence. I’ve never heard anything said but it would seem that girls probably do have an edge with admission to this school. I don’t have any idea what that edge is, my guess is that the considerations are variable.</p>

<p>UMASS: For those considering UMass you should be aware of some of the issues that the university is dealing with at this time. I work on a college campus and have access to the Chronicle of Higher Education which has run several articles on the past president and what he did at the college. Here is a quote from a recent article about the incoming president of the university. Caret was previously the president of Towson. </p>

<p>“Caret will also be inheriting the university system’s problems, along with its promise. UMass has long struggled to raise its profile, consistently battling dwindling state funding, a shrinking number of tenured faculty, low minority graduation rates and growing pains stemming from the diverse five-campus system’s continued expansion.”</p>

<p>Holub, the current chancellor is under fire and may not have a position much longer: “Major projects begun under his watch, some of which have been met with skepticism by taxpayers or system leaders, include a failed effort to open a medical school, an ambitious and costly plan to play big-time football, and significant improvements in facilities at an honors college that he hopes will appeal to nonresidents of the state.”</p>

<p>UMass has a problem getting state monies for these reasons: “As a former dean of the School of Science at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Mr. Birgeneau says he has seen firsthand how the success of private colleges in the state creates the impression among lawmakers and residents that building a strong public system is unnecessary.
More than half of all students enrolled in postsecondary education in Massachusetts attend private colleges, according to the Association of Independent Colleges and Universities in Massachusetts. And 57 percent of state lawmakers attended private colleges, according to a Chronicle analysis. Nationally just 34 percent of state legislators went to private institutions.”</p>

<p>“Faculty numbers are also troubling. Since the late 1980s, Amherst has, like most universities, hemorrhaged tenured and tenure-track faculty positions. In 2010 it had 974 such faculty, down nearly 15 percent from two decades earlier. The flagship has added more than 220 tenure-track professors by 2020, but declining state resources and uncertainty about Amherst’s fund-raising capacity could undermine the goal of reversing faculty losses. Between the 2008 and 2010 fiscal years, public spending on higher education was cut by 20 percent in Massachusetts, second only to Alabama’s reduction during that period, according to the Center for the Study of Education Policy, at Illinois State University, and the State Higher Education Executive Officers.”</p>

<p>These quotes are from a Chronicle article that can only be accessed with a subscription. These are the types of stories that don’t get wide circulation to the general public and Ithought that those of you interested in the school would like to know this information.</p>

<p>moltobene- thanks for sharing this. It certainly makes me think twice about investing time in a trip to visit U Mass. Do you have any inside info on the current state of affairs at U Conn?</p>

<p>panom: I don’t remember reading anything recently about UCONN. One of the reasons UMass was so insistent about a new med school is that it helps them achieve entry into the AAU (Association of American Universities) which is a very selective list of universities around the country. If you want to see if a college you are considering is part of this group go to: </p>

<p>The Association of American Universities (AAU) is a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization of 61 leading public and private research universities in the United States and Canada. Founded in 1900 to advance the international standing of U.S. research universities, AAU today focuses on issues that are important to research-intensive universities, such as funding for research, research policy issues, and graduate and undergraduate education.</p>

<p>[Association</a> of American Universities](<a href=“http://www.aau.edu/about/article.aspx?id=5476]Association”>http://www.aau.edu/about/article.aspx?id=5476)</p>

<p>I just found an article about funding for UCONN next year:</p>

<p>[Full</a> impact of higher education budget cuts remains uncertain | The Connecticut Mirror](<a href=“http://www.ctmirror.org/story/13282/full-impact-higher-ed-cuts-remains-uncertain]Full”>http://www.ctmirror.org/story/13282/full-impact-higher-ed-cuts-remains-uncertain)</p>

<p>Please keep in mind, that parents looking at state universities will read similar articles throughout the country. You should all plan to have tuition rates go up next year from 5-8% (or more if you are in California) so a story like this one is not surprising. I have read countless news stories about tuition going up in almost every state. Higher Education is getting cut big time in state legislatures. What does this mean?–higher tuitions, bigger classes, overworked faculty (I can vouch for this one), less office hours, reductions in external costs (landscaping, forget about it! We now have wildflower/weed gardens), staff reductions (you now work your job plus the one that wasn’t replaced for the same money), etc., etc.</p>

<p>Interesting conversation - it almost makes me think private colleges are the way to go? While the pricetags are higher - the financial aid is generally better. And they have larger endowments to get through tough times. What do you all think?</p>

<p>I can only rely on my own experience - if Wake Forest is having any financial issues - I sure don’t see it. Plenty of amazing new buildings/facilities under construction - no talk of layoffs or dire financial woes that I have read.</p>

<p>RVM: I’m not sure that that can be a general rule of thumb. I think it helps to look at the trends of schools being considered as well as their endowments. But I don’t think we can assume that the COA will turn out to be less at private schools. I know that that can happen but I don’t think we can expect either pricetag will be higher without considering the particular schools in question. So far the increases we’ve seen locally haven’t seemed significant enough to generalize that pivates have the edge. …I may be hoping that isn’t the case because if it is we may have to rethink our entire neat plan of just applying to 2 schools…Of course no telling what we will be looking at if our national budget question doesn’t get resolved…On the otherhand, my son recently told me that he knows of one student, with less than stellar grades and no hook that I am aware of, that got a really nice scholarship at a state school because the university matched a scholarship from a private. I’m not sure if I’m believing this. If I do S2 may have accidentally wrangled himself into a few more applications. :)</p>