Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>911CTS - thank you for those links.</p>

<p>cherryhill: You’re Welcome! :)</p>

<p>College Summer Tour:</p>

<p>We made two road trips over the past two weeks: PA and NC/Va</p>

<p>Our thoughts:</p>

<p>Bucknell: Though it has the same architect as Wake Forest, I thought the campus seemed rather spartan. Of course, the summer weather didn’t do much to help, it seemed very dried out. Info session wasn’t much help, but our tour guide really made a nice impression. S could see himself fitting in socially very well. Also, beautiful science building, though other buildings seemed like they were built in the 1960-70’s. Gorgeous athletic center. Quaint town within easy walking distance of the school.</p>

<p>Dickinson: Didn’t know what to expect and was very impressed. Liked the grey stone buildings and the historic feel of the campus. Very personable tour guide - the best yet. S interviewed (first time ever!) and seemed pleased. Beautiful science building. Didn’t see athletic center. Again, S felt liked this would be a good fit socially.</p>

<p>Gettysburg: Expect more and was disappointed. We didn’t like the layout or the jumble of architecture styles of the buildings. Freshman dorms don’t have A/C. At info session, I asked what sets Gettysburg apart from the LAC competition in PA and adcom said the battlefields that surround the campus and the townspeople that dress in Civil War era costumes. Not exactly the way to inspire my S.</p>

<p>Elon: 2nd visit, this time with hubby in tow. Of course, the campus is gorgeous and green. Flowers and Fountains abound. Highlight was an impromptu meeting with the head of the Pre-Health dept/Biology. Great guy, really eager to talk about Elon and the student/faculty interactions and internship opportunities. This made a very positive impression.</p>

<p>Wake Forest: 2nd visit. Thunder storms pre-empted our campus tour, so we took a self-guided tour. I was surprised that the Chem and Bio buildings (Winston and Salem) were so old. They seem in need of renovation. Lots of construction going on. We all really like the feel of this campus.</p>

<p>V Tech: I was amazed at how nice the campus is! I’ve lived in Va for 5 years, but had never seen Tech. The drill field is huge. The buildings look like something out of 15th century England. The chem and bio buildings again seemed dated (we explored on our own after the info session). Very impressed with Blacksburg as well. I really think Tech has a lot to offer!</p>

<p>UVa: Loved it, just think it’s way out of reach, so trying not to get emotionally tied to it. Class size can run from 550 lectures to 20 student classes.</p>

<p>RVM: I know that S1 goes to Wake and you’re very familiar with the campus. Are you able to comment on the current construction projects and whether there are plans for renovating any existing buildings?</p>

<p>Hi - nice tours! Lots of overlap with schools I have visited with my sons. As far as Wake Forest construction - the newest completed buildings are the amazing admissions center and South Hall - a new freshman dorm. The new business center is under construction - Farrell Hall - and will open Fall 2013. Not sure about anything else - S1 is a finance major - so not sure how familiar he is with chem.bio bldgs - but I will ask. He LOVES Wake - just returned home for a few days - is spending the summer there - took a class and has a job, etc.</p>

<p>We had some of the same reactions as you did - not all that impressed with Gettysburg - the campus did nothing for us and the surrounding area - unless you are a Civil War buff - not much to offer. Virginia Tech, on the other hand, was a lovely surprise. Obviously these 2 schools are at 2 ends of the spectrum in size - but they also serve to highlight how much a good layout can add to a campus - Gettysburg is very scattered - no rhyme or reason that I could detect - while VT has a very logical layout to it - with the drillfield serving as a central location to orient yourself by. VT is my favorite campus so far among the larger schools we have seen.</p>

<p>911C2S, could you elaborate on you/your son’s take on the social scene at Bucknell and Dickinson? These schools occupy an outlying place on S’ radar. We haven’t visited yet, but vague info about heterogeneity and heavy duty Greek influence continue to stand in the way of my getting him to visit. Thanks in advance.</p>

<p>Hope you don’t mind my 2 cents - but I think many people would describe Bucknell, Dickinson and Wake Forest in similar terms - preppy kids - not a lot of diversity - lots of drinking - strong influence of Greek life. In fact, I was pretty opposed to Wake Forest when my son was a hs senior. One thing I have learned is that while that might be an accurate surface description - there are many kids who don’t fit that stereotype as well. I can only really comment on WF - but my son has developed an amazing group of friends - and has plenty to do - all without joining a fraternity or becoming a heavy drinker. I’m guessing that the same scenario exists at Dickinson and Bucknell as well - other options exist - you may just have to look a little harder for them.</p>

<p>Mutti,</p>

<p>One of the things we’ve discovered in this process is that S is interested in going Greek. I think that’s one of the reasons he likes Bucknell. To give some background, we visited Wake and Richmond in April, so we had these to compare to when we saw Bucknell. S also knows a couple of girls that go to Bucknell that had positive things to say. With Bucknell, S felt that the academics were really great, but that the campus would have a more “informal” prep vibe than Wake or Richmond. Bucknell held the number one spot until seeing Wake (again) and UVa (too reachy, unfortunately).</p>

<p>Dickinson’s only about 20% Greek vs. 50% at Bucknell (if memory serves). Evidently, they used to be much more Greek, but I think some houses have closed (double-secret probabtion!). I know we all talk on these forums about how a bad tour guide can ruin a college, but our tour guide at Dickinson had a great sense of humor, was very easy-going, yet is graduating in less than 4 years with a double major (i.e., he’s no slouch). We ran into the president of the college on our tour and he new our guide by name and one of his ECs. Dickinson felt more liberal than Wake or Richmond. The town of Carlisle was nicer than either Lewisburg (Bucknell) or Gettysburg, while also being just steps off the campus (which neither Wake nor Richmond have, although theiy are just outside of nice mid-sized cities).</p>

<p>Thanks RVM. This is such a looming issue for S as he compiles his list. Many, many schools that are remote and/or heavily Greek he will not even consider, narrowing his choices considerably. I’m of two minds of this (as my many posts about this topic can attest) just as you described: how important is a school’s social reputation when they in fact have to have some social diversity just based on the thousands of kids who attend? Your S’ experience at WF is an excellent example.</p>

<p>911, we posted a the same time. Thx for your response. I wanted to see if my interpretation of your “fit in socially” comment = “Greek” re: your S was correct and I guess it was. Maybe we should look at Dickinson; maybe it has more of the LAC feel that S is looking for.</p>

<p>RVM: I seem to recall that the frats at Wake aren’t residential. I think this would also make a big difference as the kids would still live in the dorms and be able to have plenty of non-Greek relationships.</p>

<p>A few kids live in the Greek houses at Dickinson, whereas it seems as though living in the houses at Bucknell is more popular. The houses have their own chefs, so I guess you don’t even need to go to the dining hall. This could give a more isolated environment, but I’m just guessing.</p>

<p>Mutti, BTW, Dickinson isn’t too remote. It’s about 30 min outside of Harrisburg, the capital of PA.</p>

<p>The fraternities at Wake have “lounges” within buildings that house upperclassmen in suite style residences and will often occupy one or more suites. So - you could have a building with 10 suites - and one or two of these would be Greek housing and the rest would be open to any juniors/seniors. I believe there are also Greek houses right off campus. My son’s experience was that about 1/3 of the guys on his freshman hall went Greek - so certainly a strong presence - but not too overwhelming.</p>

<p>Those considering Dickinson/Bucknell may want to look at Franklin & Marshall. My sense is that this generation of kids has more interest in Greek organizations than our generation. I believe “rah rah” atmospheres are also more popular. I think recent media portrayals (and reports from older friends or siblings about wild parties) have convinced them these are essential parts of a fun college experience.</p>

<p>I know a large number of parents who were somewhat hippie or very intellectual in their college days who have shaken their heads at their kids’ eagerness to join frats or their evaluating colleges by the likelihood of games being shown on ESPN.</p>

<p>Dickinson Hillel:</p>

<p>[Dickinson</a> College - Hillel at Dickinson](<a href=“http://www.dickinson.edu/student-life/resources/asbell-center/content/Hillel-at-Dickinson/]Dickinson”>http://www.dickinson.edu/student-life/resources/asbell-center/content/Hillel-at-Dickinson/)</p>

<p>About 250 Jewish students - pretty close to 10% of student population.</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.dickinson.edu/academics/programs/judaic-studies/[/url]”>http://www.dickinson.edu/academics/programs/judaic-studies/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>And Dickinson does offer early action and has good merit scholarships for very strong (generally more of the “A” ) students.</p>

<p>National Naviance:</p>

<p>Freshman Applicants
Received: 5033
Accepted: 2405
Percent Accepted: 47.78%
Enrolled: 658</p>

<p>Test Score Ranges (Mid 50%)
Test Name High Low Avg.
ACT Combined: 30 27 28
ACT English:<br>
ACT Math:<br>
ACT Reading:<br>
ACT Science:<br>
SAT Combined: 2042 1790 1916
SAT I Math: 688 600 644
SAT I Critical Reading: 680 600 640</p>

<p>I believe Dickinson also has kind of an international tilt to their academics - which some kids might really like - others might not - so do look at their foreign language requirements and so forth.</p>

<p>Dickinson and Foreign Language: Our tour guide said that it is possible to test out of some or all of the FL requirement.</p>

<p>RVM,</p>

<p>You’re so generous with your time in posting Naviance data, could I impose on you to post data for Wake and Bucknell? I’m trying to determine how reachy these will be and my S’s school’s naviance data is VERY limited (small school).</p>

<p>Sure - here is Bucknell:</p>

<p>Freshman Applicants
Received: 7178
Accepted: 2253
Percent Accepted: 31.39%
Enrolled: 929</p>

<p>Test Score Ranges (Mid 50%)
Test Name High Low Avg.
ACT Combined: 31 27 29
ACT English:<br>
ACT Math:<br>
ACT Reading:<br>
ACT Science:<br>
SAT Combined: 2060 1820 1940
SAT I Math: 710 630 670
SAT I Critical Reading: 670 590 630</p>

<p>Our large public hs had 0 of 7 accepted in 2010 - but 4 of 7 were accepted in 2011 and 2 of those will be attending this fall.</p>

<p>Wake Forest is test optional - so there is no national Naviance test data. About a 40% acceptance rate. Looking at the Naviance scattergrams just for our hs - the accepted students had at least a 1200 SAT or a 30 ACT. There was one accepted student with a 28 ACT - but his data point was the lowest accepted student so there might be some type of hook. All accepted students had at least a 4.0 weighted GPA - which would translate into straight A’s with all regular classes or mostly A’s and a few B’s with more rigor - honors/APs in the schedule.</p>

<p>Our hs had 14 students apply in 2010 and 5 of those were accepted - only 5 applied in 2011 and 3 were accepted - but ended up sending 2 students to Wake each of those years.</p>

<p>One interesting note - looking at our hs Naviance for 2011 as compared to 2010 - most private colleges rcvd fewer applications from us and the acceptance rates went up. Not surprising given the economy - but it is interesting to look at one hs as a microcosm and really see the changes.</p>

<p>Thanks, so much, RVM. I’ve been using co11ege pr0w1er to estimate S’s chances and based on this data I thought Wake would be more of a match and less of a reach. Oh well. We’ll just have to see how the cookie crumbles…</p>

<p>Some interesting discussion above about Pennsylvania LACs. I will throw in my two cents…</p>

<p>Muhlenberg and F&M are the two most popular PA LACs at our suburban Philadelphia private school. I believe this reflects a couple of things. One, both have a strong Jewish presence. Two, both have friendly students. Muhlenburg is attracting students interested in theater, and F&M has a strong and well supported swim team. I toured Muhlenberg a few years ago and was extremely impressed with the school, it has beautiful dining and athletic facilities, small classes, and a very supportive academic atmosphere. I sense that Greek scene is less of a major factor at Muhlenberg. F&M has a pretty campus and lovely dining facilities as well. They also have a “house system” (think Hogwarts…)</p>

<p>From a location viewpoint, I believe that F&M has the best location (Lancaster), a fairly thriving town, and is also served by public transportation (train). F&M is right in the middle of town and there are also campus shuttles that take you to a nearby mall. Nevertheless, its not a big city by any means, but is only 1 hour from Philadelphia. Lancaster is in the heart of PA Dutch country, a major tourist destination.</p>

<p>My cousin who attended Bucknell said there is just nothing to do there. When they wanted to go somewhere, they drove to State College (home of Penn State). </p>

<p>Dickinson is located in sleepy small town of Carlisle which has a small main street, not too much happening there, though its walkable from campus as mentioned above. Harrisburg is a car ride away. Harrisburg is the state capital, yes, but there is not much going on there apart from state govt. We also toured Dickinson and had a completely different experience, snobbish sorority tour guide, and BTW the dining hall there is TERRIBLE.</p>

<p>Gettysburg is truly in the middle of nowhere and battlefields are unlikely to be of interest to anyone outside of Civil War buffs.</p>

<p>You may also want to consider Lehigh, which is a slightly larger school, and combines engineering with liberal arts.</p>

<p>Other than Muhlenberg I believe that Greek life is very strong at PA LACs. As most of them are in areas where there is little do other than parties, it makes sense that Greeks become a major part of the social scene.</p>