Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>pamom - since you seem very up to date on these smaller PA colleges - have I asked you before your thoughts on Susquehanna? This is the only small PA school S2 is applying to. It fits him better academically than Dickinson or F&M - he did not care for Gettysburg and we never did get to Muhlenberg. We like the strength of the business program - very attractive well-maintained campus - small Jewish population - but with a dedicated Hillel House and a Rabbi - it seems they are putting some effort into it. It seemed to have the friendly casual vibe S2 likes. We are hoping to visit again in October. What is your impression?</p>

<p>Don’t know if this has been addredded previously on CC but my jewish kid is applying to some jesuit schools. She has been brought up a “cultural” jew, had had some experience with the Unitarian church but she tells me she is agnostic. </p>

<p>She told me that on some applications she is asked about “religious” upbringing or preference. She is a bit confused on how to answer because it could be Jewish, Unitarian or Agnostic.</p>

<p>Any suggestions on how to answer this? For a chacne for admission to a jesuit school, does the religious preference make a difference for admission?</p>

<p>rvm- I wish that I could help you, but in the past 5 years no one from our small private school has attended Susquehanna. Prior to reading this thread, I had actually never heard of Susquehanna. I wonder where it draws most of its students from? </p>

<p>I hope you won’t take offense at this, but it seems like $45K is a lot to pay for a degree from a school that most people have not heard of (even people in the same state where the college is located, let alone in MD where you are from). Or do you think that your son would qualify for merit scholarship there?</p>

<p>One of my colleagues at work went to Lycoming, another PA LAC that is relatively unknown. He says that although he felt he got a great education there, if he had it to do over he would prefer to have attended a school like Penn State because it would have had better name recognition for future employers. He feels that he always has to explain where he went to undergrad school. FWIW.</p>

<p>This subject gets endless discussion on CC, but I do want to add some of the chats we’ve had in our family about it.</p>

<p>We have the perspective of a midwest family consisting of H from the Chicago area, 2 Ds who grew up in WI and whose colleges are in the east, and me, who grew up in MA, went to college in IL and has lived in WI for 17 years.</p>

<p>With the exception of HYP, there is NO school that will guarantee you name recognition. Some schools are known within an hour or two’s distance - but many are not, even if they are 2 miles from the person you are talking to. </p>

<p>The only allowance I will make is that schools that have geographic names in them will at least SEEM like they are known - but the only guarantee is that the person can place them in their minds. This can work to your disadvantage as much as to your advantage. For example: my D1 had varying responses when she told people she went to Tufts. She learned that sometimes it was best just to say “out east” or “near Boston.” Depending on the part of the country, she will probably go 50-50 on possible employers knowing where she went to school. Boston University would certainly ring a bell for more people - but should she have rather gone there? H did his residency at Tufts hospitals, and it makes no difference to him that most people don’t understand that he got the same quality training there as at Mass General.</p>

<p>Another example: D2 is going to Adelphi University, on Long Island, for theatre. We are pretty much convinced that even people on LI haven’t heard of it for the most part. She usually tells people she is going to “New York” to study theatre, to save explaining, but most of them then ask, “Oh, NYU?” and she has to clarify anyway. There is a nice theatre program at CW Post, also known as Long Island University. If she said “Long Island University,” she wouldn’t get the “NYU” question - but that doesn’t make her wish she was going there, just for the sake of not having to elucidate.</p>

<p>The classic example is for people who go to UPenn - I bet they get tired of explaining it’s not a state school. But should they be sorry they went there? I went to the University of Chicago; most people on the east coast had never heard of it, and assumed it was a state school, and most people IN CHICAGO thought it was a state school - U of IL in Chicago. Yes, academic people and savvy employers sometimes know the difference, but there is no magic answer past HYP that will guarantee location AND quality recognition. </p>

<p>There is a “New Yorker’s view of the world” (remember that old cartoon/poster?) aspect to college name recognition. In our family we don’t give it a single thought any more. Go where you will be happiest and get the education you want.</p>

<p>Thank you for two very interesting viewpoints on name recognition. When I look at pros and cons for Susquehanna - lack of name recognition is one of the cons. But if he loves it - we would not eliminate it for that reason alone - as many people in the general public have not heard of Muhlenberg, F&M, etc. either. And pamom - no offense taken whatsoever - I would not be willing or able to pay $45,000/year! I’m assuming he would get some combination of merit and need-based aid. I believe Susquehanna gets students from mostly PA and other mid-Atlantic states.</p>

<p>MalibuSky - I have no idea if putting down Jewish would help or hurt at a Jesuit school. I think that unless the question had to be answered I would skip it. Or - put agnostic - and maybe that would help because they would love a chance to convert her? In all seriousness - I doubt the answer would make any difference - but I guess I really have no idea.</p>

<p>Hi Emmybet!</p>

<p>I think that the majority of Long Islanders are familiar with Adelphi. Given that your D is a Theater major, the proximity to the NY theater scene (where Adelphi will have name recognition) will outweigh any possible lack of recognition beyond the tri-state area.</p>

<p>re: Jesuit colleges, I would think that indicating that you are Jewish will not hurt you. In fact, a Jewish student may be welcomed for adding to the diversity of the college!</p>

<p>I may be wrong, but I think that reporting your religion is optional.</p>

<p>"Go where you will be happiest and get the education you want. "</p>

<p>Well said Emmybet!</p>

<p>oh- and one other point made by my Lycoming alumni coleague…at smaller schools the career counseling centers don’t have as much to offer, and a lot of employers won’t do on campus interviews at smaller schools, preferring to recruit from the large state Us. Since RVM’s son want’s to go into a business career, rather than academia, the career counseling and job recruitment issue is fairly key. I would also think that with an interest in sports management, going to a school that has D1 sports would offer student opportunities to be involved inand make connections in the world of college sports, and provide networking opportunities for the future.</p>

<p>You’ve really made a lot of good points and this is why I think schools like Virginia Tech are moving up the list. I did get excited about Univ. of South Carolina for a while there also - great pricetag - great sports mgmt program - great sports - fun location. But the tiny Jewish population - at such a large university - really gives me pause. I just don’t feel comfortable with that scenario at this point. We may visit and seek out some Jewish students and ask questions - but until then - feeling very uncertain about USC.</p>

<p>RVM: I would share your concerns about USC. It’s very popular with kids from our area, but I only know of one Jewish student who chose to attend. And to be honest, most of the kids who attend chose it because they wanted a big rah-rah state flagship and couldn’t get into UMDCP.</p>

<p>I’m with Emmybet on the prestige issue. I’m hoping that it will help D1 with her job search, but overall I think that there are much more important factors involved in picking a school. Affordability aside, the best school is one where the student will flourish socially and academically.</p>

<p>New question: Has anyone looked at Nazareth College in NY state? It seems to be a small LAC in Rochester. The name sounds religious, but the school mission statement and website looks good. I have a friend looking at the school and the girl wants to do art/asian studies. I had never heard of the school, so I wanted to ask my CC friends, as you are all so up to date! Thanks.</p>

<p>momjr, I think the same thing tends to go on in Virginia-kids that don’t feel they can get into VT or UVa but still want D1 big sports scene, seem to look at schools like USC. Seems like a good choice potentially and we (as Virginia residents) considered looking into it when second son initially wa deferred ED from VT. However, we are not Jewish so not sure how that would have played out into applying or not applying if that had been an issue in looking at schools.</p>

<p>rvm- if you are heading north to see Susquehanna in the fall, rather than see another LAC you may want to tour University of Delaware instead. Since your son like the feel of V Tech and JMU, I think he would also like UD. I can’t recall what the concerns were that you or he had about UD, but I think it would definitely be worth a visit.</p>

<p>Haven’t been on the boards in awhile but decided tonight since I had so much free time on my hands to try and catch up . I don’t post very often but find all the information from everyone extremely valuable. My twins just completed their freshmen year at UDel (daughter lived on the same floor as Linymom’s D.) and I have another daughter about to enter 11th grade so I’m back thinking about the college process after taking this last year off. Our college search with my two was BRUTAL, I just needed a break (and so did my family from listening to college talk 24/7). Happy to say Delaware has EXCEEDED every single expectation my kids had. They love it and I’d be glad to answer any questions you might have. My son swims for the swim team so his experience being part of a large D1 team is entirely different from my daughter’s who recently joined a sorority.
I also want to give a counter point to socal dad’s report on URI. Im sure his views of the school are very valid however I hope that not everyone will be turned off by what he said. I live about 15 miles from the school and have the opportunity to be there quite a bit. Not sure why the campus looked the way it did a few weeks ago but typically it is pretty beautiful. While not nearly as gorgeous as Delaware, it still has a very New Englandy (is that even a word?) feel to it. It’s lovely in the fall , students hang on the main quad and is quite picturesque. Additionally I’d like to add that while it is probably a safety school for most B students, it has a very good reputation in RI and there are many many high achievers who attend-the valediction of my kids senior class last year attends , among many other kids I know with high GPA and high test scores- they have a well known marine biology program, nursing program and pharmacy school. I’m not affiliated with URI at all, have no kids there however I thought after socal dad’s review that it might be nice to hear a different opinion of the school. Location wise Delaware has it beat with the wonderful town next to Delaware’s campus, however URI is less than 5 minutes from GORGEOUS beaches so there’s that. Most of the dorms are old but there are a few newer ones. Brand new pharmacy school being built. VERY active hillel on campus also.
It’s definitely not a school for everyone but I wouldn’t dismiss it completely.
Our search is starting for my daughter. On paper Delaware is her dream school (rah rah school spirit, sorority, has her major) however she does not want to go to the same school as her siblings so my job now is to help her find schools that are similar in feel. Academically she is a high b+ maybe even A-. Did just very very average on her PSAT’s so we shall see! Look forward to joining in on the discussions once our search begins in earnest.</p>

<p>pamom - I think our list is done. I do think Delaware would fit in the mix just fine - but he really feels done. I can’t really say that he has loved visiting colleges or discussing various possibilities - he’s just not that into it. I tend to think he will end up at either Elon, JMU or VT - and he is happy with all 3 options - and while I would LOVE to keep looking - it’s his process - and it is what it is. I tell people I sometimes wish I had one more child - one more opportunity to do this - but it would have to be with someone who was really, really into it! </p>

<p>jbevangelista - thanks for the counterpoint on URI - it is good to hear varying opinions - and I have heard good things about URI - particularly for the lower “B” student.</p>

<p>I have never heard of Nazareth College - I looked it up and no one from our hs has ever applied there. Here’s some basics from the website:</p>

<pre><code>Full-time and part-time undergraduate students: 2231
Full-time and part-time graduate students: 1027
Average class size: 14
Male / female ratio: 1:3
Student / faculty ratio: 12:1
The mean high school grade point average is 3.4 (core subjects).
The mean SAT score is 1159.
The average writing score is 560.
12 percent of our students are students of color.
10 percent of our students are from outside of New York State.
18 percent of our undergraduates are the first in their families to attend college.
</code></pre>

<p>Civic engagement is important at Nazareth - so I found this:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>From a Jewish standpoint - I’m guessing one could socialize with Jewish students at University of Rochester, RIT, etc. The Nazareth College Hillel website is not updated:</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.rochesterhillel.org/nazareth/home/[/url]”>http://www.rochesterhillel.org/nazareth/home/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>jb- if you look at this thread I think it will give you some ideas of similar schools to UD <a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/university-delaware/1140860-what-schools-did-you-turn-down-ud.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/university-delaware/1140860-what-schools-did-you-turn-down-ud.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>My D, who likes Delaware, will also apply to: Pitt, Penn State, JMU. And as a safety, probably Temple. </p>

<p>Some schools I thought about, but are too far away for us, are: Clemson, Miami U of Ohio, Indiana U at Bloomington. </p>

<p>Another school that seemed similar is Syracuse- we might still put it in the list there are some negatives: cost and climate!</p>

<p>SUNY Binghamton might also be worth looking at- good value school, respected academics.</p>

<p>I have also thought that UVM woul be a good school, but there again you have to like snow, and it is quite a distance away from where we live.</p>

<p>RVM’s son’s list may also be of interest to you. RVM: now that the list is final, can you let us know which schools made the cut? And which schools you thought about, but ruled out for various reasons? I have really enjoyed following your college research journey.</p>

<p>jb- since you live in New England-can you give some info/impressions on U Conn, U Mass, UNH?</p>

<p>RVM and phillyartmom- one of the few other Jewish girls at D’s HS is heading to Nazareth in the fall. This girl was much more involved “jewishly” than my D was. (BBYO chapter president) I will let you know what she thinks of it. Considered it for D, but she wanted to be a bit further from home and a bit more of a competitive school.
And while the name sounds religiously oriented, it has no religious affiliation. In upstate NY it is known as a solid school for true B students.</p>

<p>pamom - it has been quite a journey! I have been researching schools for S2 for over a year and I do finally feel done - I think we have considered every possible college from PA - FL.</p>

<p>His final list is Elon, VT, JMU, Susquehanna, Towson and USC. My opinions - we love Elon - has everything we want in terms of academics, size, location, climate, Jewish life and on campus housing. Love the 4-1-4 program and the possibility for travel abroad in January. Like VT and JMU - a bit larger than I prefer - and I worry about course registration, size of intro classes and the need to live off campus after freshman or certainly sophomore year. But - good fit otherwise in terms of academics, location and school spirit. Susquehanna is a little smaller than I would prefer - and I guess there is the lack of name recognition - but beautiful campus, lots of personal attention, small class sizes, good business program and small but active Jewish community.</p>

<p>Towson and USC are more for financial safety reasons than any other. Towson reminds me of a blind date scenario - looks good on paper - but there’s no chemistry. By that I mean it fits most of our criteria - but there’s just no Wow! factor. Planning to visit in October to see if impressions change at all.</p>

<p>We looked at but ruled out Gettysburg, American and College of Charleston. Gettysburg just did not seem to have much to do - not a very active Jewish community and the students we met seemed to have this frenzied vibe of double major or double minor that did not fit with S2’s laidback sensibilities. American was judged to be too close to home and he didn’t click with the students he saw. CofC would be a great option for someone who wants city life - S2 just did not care for the campus - otherwise it would be on his list.</p>

<p>We also considered - but never visited - Pitt (too urban), Muhlenberg (too much emphasis on theatre/artsy kids), Delaware (I still have no idea why we never got there), Tampa (I’d still consider this one - but we eliminated Florida in the end), Univ. of Miami (same as previous), Clemson (has a very interesting school that combines business and psychology - but too rural and minimal Jewish life), Roanoke (no Jewish life), Dickinson (not interested in International Business), F&M (no interest), Salisbury (affordable in-state option with good business school - but no Jewish life), York College of PA (too low academically and did not hear much in the way of good reviews), Tulane (too far and too urban), Binghamton and Ithaca (will not venture into NY) and High Point (no Jewish life and questionable academic reputation).</p>

<p>We also decided not to put any reaches on his list - but had we done so - would have considered University of Richmond, Lehigh, Bucknell and Wake Forest.</p>

<p>So - I feel we have done a fairly exhaustive search and while he could have a longer list at this point - he is pretty happy with what he has and now he just has to get the apps done and see what happens.</p>

<p>RVM- I think your list is great! At a certain point, I know that kids get tired of investigating colleges, especially as your son already had 3 great choices that he likes- VT, JMU and Elon. I’d be surprised if he didn’t get accepted at all of those, so he’ll have great choices.</p>

<p>I don’t know that I’d bother to make a trip back to PA just for Susquehanna- why not wait until the acceptances roll in and see whether it remains a choice he’s seriously considering? BUT…should you decide to make the trip in the fall- it seems like it would be worthwhile to stop by at least one other college on your way…</p>

<p>My brother’s son visited Lehigh and the whole family was favorably impressed- he is interested in engineering and business. I think the school is fairly strong on athletics and has a big Greek scene. I don’t know that it fits the “laid back” vibe your son is seeking. I also think it lacks a certain diversity being heavily white, upper middle class, PA/NY/NJ.</p>