Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Housing issues at VT continue to concern me. First the university made a plea asking students who had signed up for on campus housing - including freshmen - to consider moving off campus. They apparently did not get enough volunteers as there is now a thread with one student who is in a converted study lounge that is now a triple and another student who is being placed in an RA’s room that was meant to be a single as a double! Not good!</p>

<p>pamom - Susquehanna is a day trip for us - the date we have in mind is a long weekend for S2 and I’m thinking of it as a nice fall weekend for a drive. I think that seeing it again now while we have the time might make for fewer rushed trips to accepted students days in April. I was very impressed with this school when we saw it last fall and I am curious to see how we all react to it again a year later. The size issue still puzzles me - given that he has Susquehanna and VT/JMU on his short list - I am thinking that seeing JMU and SU again this fall might give him more insight as to what size school might fit him best.</p>

<p>Sounds like housing is truly an issue at VT- are they planning to build more dorms?</p>

<p>One of the things that I love about Pitt is their on-campus housing guarantee for 3 years. I believe that Delaware also guarantees housing- and for all 4 years. I have in my notes that JMU guarantees housing for 2 years … do I have that right? JMU dorms seemed nicer than most, and I heard great things about the off campus apartments.</p>

<p>I heard that at Penn State if you dont put down your deposit early, you can get put in supplemental housing like you described- converted lounges used by 3-4 students. But a lot of students end up liking the lounges because they are more spacious, even though they have to share the room with more students. My sense is that kids find these issues less concerning than us parents!</p>

<p>A drive through Central PA would certainly be scenic in the fall- though with a long weekend and a 3 hour drive each way, why not stay over? You could do a side trip to Amish country.</p>

<p>We really liked Susquehanna and think it is well worth the trip. I would try to combine it with another school as well (unless your son just won’t add another school, which is how my son felt at some point). Bucknell, if my memory is correct, is right there. </p>

<p>The only thing that gave us pause about Susquehanna was how rural it was and that they really lacked public transit. We saw this as a major problem without a car. We thought getting home could be a pain as well.</p>

<p>JMU gives you an option to “purchase” 2 years of housing when you enroll. This means you will be guaranteed housing on campus for sophomore year. I have heard of some instances where the family did this and then the student later regretted it because they wanted to move off campus with their friends for sophomore year - so you just never know.</p>

<p>When we toured Vt in April - our tour guide said he lived on campus as a sophomore and that there was enough housing to do so if that was what you wanted to do. It seems like they overenrolled their freshman class and that is what is now causing this housing crunch. I think they typically renovate a dorm every year - meaning one dorm is taken out of the housing pool while being renovated.</p>

<p>I happen to prefer the housing at Elon and SU - but that’s just me - not sure it is as big a deal to S2. </p>

<p>pamom - staying over and spending time in the Amish area sounds great to ME - but I’m guessing S2 will not want to desert his busy social calendar for that long!</p>

<p>Quick question. I see some of you are re-visiting schools for second looks (while in app process). If you’ve done the tour and info session on your first trip, what do you do on your second trip? Some things I was thinking: talk to prof in dept of interest, sit in on a class, explore the area further, visit Hillel. Anything else you have found beneificial after the school has passed your S/D first round of approval?</p>

<p>(JBE: Welcome back and good luck on your second round. I guess she is ready now? Hope B and A are having a good summer! My A hasn’t been home the entire summer; visited her yesterday; she is working hard but is happy as a clam!)</p>

<p>Emmybet, you are right–when I was at UPenn, being confused with Penn State was common. There was debate about whether it was too late to be named after our founder, Benjamin Franklin, who was also a much more notable person than John Harvard or Eli Yale-and whether the initials “BFU” would be a minus.</p>

<p>As you note, the educational experience should be more important than name recognition—Amherst, Swarthmore and Williams, for example, are recognized by only a small part of the public and being recognized for strong football teams or because you have a self-explanatory name does not necessarily help you later in life.</p>

<p>Pamom asked about UConn–it is very popular with B/B+ kids in our NJ town who want East Coast big sports and a fun atmosphere, competing with UDel, Penn State and UMCP. The kids I know there like it. UMass attracts kids who are less sports-oriented and UNH and Maine have not been on the same radar screens as the others or UVM.</p>

<p>Lehigh certainly has very strong engineering and frats and a pretty campus (although, like Bucknell, it is not a B student school) and its sports teams, like UDel’s receive strong student support despite not being in the top 50. Its neighboring archrival, Lafayette, has similar attributes.</p>

<p>rvm- yes now I remember something mentioned at the info session about a 2 year housing contract at JMU, but how does that work? Do you have to pay a larger housing deposit? I just looked online at the JMU office of residence life and I don’t see anything on the page that explains the 2 year housing contract. [JMU</a> Office of Residence Life - James Madison University](<a href=“http://www.jmu.edu/orl/rooms/contract.html]JMU”>http://www.jmu.edu/orl/rooms/contract.html)</p>

<p>linymom: I think that the best thing a student can do on a second visit to a school is to spend some time with students. Some schools offer something like “lunch with a student,”, but it’s best to find someone who isn’t part of the admissions marketing machine. I think that the thing that convinced my D1 to apply ED was when she met a neighbor for lunch in the dining hall. She met lots of friendly students who were very enthusiastic about the school. It’s worth contacting aquaintances or friends of the family for an informal tour or meeting. </p>

<p>I think that my friend did the two year housing thing at JMU. I"ll ask her how it works.</p>

<p>overnight stay in the dorm</p>

<p>For smaller schools, my son did some interviewing on campus during a second visit. Also, just did things we had no time for the first time around (ie: perhaps sampling dining hall food). The reason he did not interview everywhere on the first visit was either because I felt it was too premature, or because we did not have the time if we were seeing 2 schools in one day.</p>

<p>Linymom, glad A is having a good summer. Mine are enjoying but looking forward to getting back to school. not sure E is ready to start looking but I am so she has no choice :wink:
pamom: majority of the kids who graduated in my son and daughter’s high school class go to new england schools. uconn, umass, northeastern, uri, unh and the likes. uconn, as been discussed here is in the middle of nowhere. however the friends of my kids who go there LOVE it and do not seem to mind the remote location. i know they love the school spirit and the size because there is always something going on. unh is on our list to go look at with my youngest. it enjoys a good reputation and supposedly has a ton of school spirit. has a set up similar to delaware where the school is next to the town so everything is within walking distance…not a very large jewish population.</p>

<p>The job placement issue at schools raised by Pamom is probably underexplored by parents (and not thought of at all by most kids). It would be interesting to see ratios of job counselors/kids, similar to to faculty/student ratios. Do kids at giant state schools, especially in an era of cutbacks, get good access to counselors? Does having more on-campus interviews help if the number of applicants overwhelms the number of interview slots?
There will be no universal answer, just as with whether it is better to be a top student at a less prestigious school or a bottom student at a more prestigious school.</p>

<p>There are several kids from our area that go to UCONN and like it.</p>

<p>Yabe, BFU!! That cracked me up, no pun intended ;)</p>

<p>Liny, for a 2nd visit, have some hang out time. Sit in the student center for a while or the local coffee shop and just observe what i happening. Does your S feel like he would fit in? If you can find someone to do an unofficial tour, see more dorm rooms, eat in different cafs. Hillel usually will set you up with someone for a meal or coffee. Spend time in the local area. Look through a course catalogue. My S was told about a religion class being awesome and his reaction was no way I would take a religion class. Then we passed a bulletin board that talked about the religion of the Samurais and he was already signing up! SO–read bulletin boards to see what is going on for classes and around campus.</p>

<p>I would not recommend having your kid do an overnight visit unless they know the host. I’ve heard two many horror stories about kids having bad experiences with hosts that drink or ignore them. Sometimes a bad experience will make a kid decide to eliminate a school that is actually a good fit.</p>

<p>Mine was plied with ice cream and Scrabble. :-)</p>

<p>Lots of great second visit suggestions! We are planning to attend Open Houses at JMU, Susquehanna and Towson this fall. Will also try to meet up with one or more students at each school - either someone we know or through Hillel.</p>

<p>I found this reference on their housing website:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>So - given that it is now Fall 2011 - if you have already signed a contract for 2012-13, I am assuming you did sign 2 years of contracts prior to entering as a freshman.</p>

<p>Samtalya’s advice about the value of hanging out and checking out bulletin boards is excellent, as your child can get a campus flavor without feeling on the spot and without the filter of a recruiting pitch. Overnights can be very helpful, but can also be misleadingly good or bad, depending on the individual host.</p>

<p>Those placing a high value on Hillel encounters should be sure it is in accord with the child’s preferences, not just your hopes. </p>

<p>As jbe points out re UConn, most rural colleges, even small ones, have a lot going on weekends. Unless your child has a deep interest unlikely to be met outside a large city (jazz concerts; Broadway shows) or is very confident socially, they are unlikely to venture off campus that often (one exception for some is seeking out easier access to underage drinking). This, too, is often more of a concern for parents (Great=cute shops and restaurants) than kids (Great=cineplex and Fridays). Some of the shyer kids I know who went to city schools found that the campus events were underattended because the cool kids were off to city clubs.</p>

<p>I love big cities for the wealth of activities, but the kids whose idea of a fun weekend is sleeping late, playing an intramural sport and then a video game, followed by pizza and a movie are very numerous and should focus more on fit with other students.</p>

<p>yabeyabe - as always - the bridge of reason between parental expectations and teenaged reality!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I know someone who is a recent grad from one of the “coop” brand name schools (majored in business). He still has not been able to find a job! There is nothing “wrong” with him. It has to do with our economy.</p>