<p>Here’s one list S2 will like:</p>
<p>
</li>
</ol>
<p>Here’s one list S2 will like:</p>
<p>
</li>
</ol>
<p>Re: additional requirements homeschooled students face in the college admissions process</p>
<p>These days they’re actually posted on many of the college websites. Handy.
And yes, there are Jewish homeschoolers!</p>
<p>In speaking of Ohio Weslyan, their website has has great tips on the college process that are applicable to any school: [Ohio</a> Wesleyan University | Admission | College Admission Advice](<a href=“Admission | Ohio Wesleyan University”>Admission | Ohio Wesleyan University)</p>
<p>So far, I can’t get my S very interested in the Ohio schools, but I think there are some good choices, like OWU, Wooster and Denison, for our B kids.</p>
<p>rvm- my D was very impressed with the dining at JMU- I think there are 17 different dining halls- we had lunch there and it was great :)</p>
<p>I think that creature comforts like food and dorms can be important to some kids; and if the food is terrible I think that can make any homesickness that much worse.</p>
<p>For the record, I didn’t ever really refer to my D as a “B” student, either. For me, the point was that she didn’t have a 4.0, which is sadly the great dividing line it seems between “top” students and “not top” students. I remember with my 4.0 D as each semester passed we had to worry if she would drop out of that top group. Sometimes I wished she HAD gotten a B early on, so we didn’t have that strange suspense. It was surreal - I never had a 4.0 in HS and never felt an obligation to, but in this day and age 1 B suddenly creates this enormous chasm. It’s a shame. </p>
<p>We’ve had threads with various names referring to a 3.something, and I’ve chosen to use the “3.X” term. It just means they got grades other than As some portion of the time. Weighted, unweighted, whatever their test scores, whether they have a mix of As, Bs, and Cs, or whether it’s straight Bs all across - the point is they’re not on the other side of the 4.0 bridge, for whatever that’s worth.</p>
<p>I think it’s so funny that 2 of rvm’s S’s top 5 schools made the best food list. D claimed throughout her college search that dorms and food weren’t important, but when it came time to pick schools she did focus on that as part of her choice criteria. I’m concerned with just 2 main dining halls she is going to get sick of the options (although the food itself is fine). I guess we’ll just see - she’s all right with it.</p>
<p>I remember visiting one school where we got a lunch coupon as part of the tour. She already had been turned off by much of what she’d learned and while the food was excellent it certainly didn’t sway her back into liking the school itself.</p>
<p>emmybet…</p>
<p>the ridiculous part of the whole thing is that schools grade and calculate GPA’s so differently and who knows how the colleges muddle through all these transcripts and how they actually perceive each student.</p>
<p>Our school uses a 100 point system. So it is very possible to be an A student and still have some B grades. But the question is how are these number grades actually translated back to a 4.0 gpa? So is a 90 a 3.5 or a 3.7? And is that an A, B+ or A-? I’ve heard all of the above.</p>
<p>And then how does rank play into all of this? A 90 in our school is ridiculously ranked as top 40th percentile. But that is because a lot of students with 89 to 92 averages were taking non-honors and non-AP classes. Although honors/ AP classes are ranked, if you get 88’s or so in those classes, you still have a low rank.</p>
<p>But I guess it somehow all sorts itself out in the end. But it is a roller coaster of a ride getting there.</p>
<p>I always participate in college week live, a web site that throughout the year has a virtual college fair and lectures. It has been helpful in getting some basic info and there are times when there are students to live chat. Tomorrow there is day of info lectures. Here is the schedule: check it out if you haven’t been on the site.</p>
<p>[College</a> Financial Aid, College Essays, Test Prep, and other Presentations](<a href=“http://www.collegeweeklive.com/en_CA/guest/app-agenda/refcode=NWS-HStudents-ANNOUNCEMENT-B2S]College”>http://www.collegeweeklive.com/en_CA/guest/app-agenda/refcode=NWS-HStudents-ANNOUNCEMENT-B2S)</p>
<p>Yup. Which is why we might as well not sweat this - it is what it is, and things will turn out as they turn out.</p>
<p>I do think that someone looking at a transcript that with a wide lens has A after A after A (even with a few Bs sprinkled in) or pretty much all scores in the 90s, is going to get a particular impression, basically a “top kid” impression. These threads are for people whose kids just don’t really - or quite - give that impression. </p>
<p>I’ve known some homeschoolers of various types, and when they were applying to colleges they did have to go through a bunch of quantifying evaluations. They knew - and their parents knew - what kind of record they had. Often by the time they are in late HS they are using curriculum that provides a grade, whether it’s online APs, or whatever. </p>
<p>It would be nice not to think of kids as a number. This particular moment - late HS - is probably one of the peak times in their lives when they are defined by their stats. Most kids, unless they are heading to law or med school, can really easy up on GPA worries in college. A 3.0 in college is usually pretty doable, if (as with my D) it is a requirement for a scholarship or something like that. Mixed As and Bs in college are GREAT grades, and Cs are perfectly understandable once in a while. That’s a huge change!</p>
<p>D1 and I were talking just yesterday about the post-college letdown for many top students - most of the kids she went to school with had 4.0s in HS, and many of her friends graduated with very high grades in college, too. But it’s a whole new ballgame when you’re done, a life no longer based on grades or any other regular, quantitative measures of your worth. She has a friend who finished magna cum laude, and has no job yet; he’s pretty down on himself right now, sadly. Kids like that often don’t have perspective.</p>
<p>D1 has had a lot of successes, but in her experience applying to (and being rejected from) lots of research internships she’s finally gotten a real taste of humility. She’s grateful for that. Our kids who’ve gotten plenty of Bs, and Cs, too, have learned that lesson already. I wouldn’t be surprised if they end up a lot more confident and balanced in the long run, maybe better at taking risks, and maybe less likely to measure people - including themselves - by their stats.</p>
<p>Emmybet, my D1 will apply for jobs this fall, and she has been told that GPA does matter for the first job out of college. I was surprised because I thought that it would only matter for grad school applications. Fortunately, she previously considered applying to law school, so she worked very hard to keep her GPA up. I think that she will miss the “quantitative measure” of her worth a lot when she finishes college.</p>
<p>Brandeis University</p>
<p>Over on the Learning Differences forum, I’ve seen a few mentions of Ohio Wesleyan as a school that has good resources for students with LD. One poster said there was very strong support for highly intelligent students with learning disabilities. </p>
<p>Interesting thought about how homeschooling parents don’t refer to “A” or “B” students. I suspect we each bring our own preconceptions of what those terms stand for. For example, I give you D1 (rising college frosh) and D2 (rising HS sophomore). If you looked at their transcripts with EmmyBet’s wide range, you’d peg D1 as the “B” student and D2 as the “A” student. But that’s without giving a closer look to their courseloads (AP/honors vs not) and their schools (entry-by-test magnet vs teeny nurturing private).</p>
<p>Hi everyone:</p>
<p>I haven’t posted in awhile. Been quite busy and now need to get my act together with S1 and college buying.</p>
<p>Question for any of you: If your child takes honors/AP classes and gets a B in them, are they considered a B student? What about if they take honors/AP classes and get a C or C+? Is that considered “pushing themselves” in the eyes of the colleges? Or are they better off taking no honors and getting A’/A-'s/B+'s?</p>
<p>My older S took all honors across the board and still got A’s. My younger S takes 3 honors and got B’s. So he’s considered a B student up to this point?</p>
<p>Confusing, but I suppose the colleges DO like to see that they challenged themselves with honors/AP classes even if they got B’s or C+'s?</p>
<p>Thanks.</p>
<p>Okay Jewish friends, help me with this one. I am Sephardic. Spanish was the first language for both of my parents. For one it was Ladino, for the other Castillian. Both families migrated to the US from Turkey. So, my son’s college application asks specifically under race, “Are you Hispanic or Latino? (a person of Cuban, Mexican, Puerto Rican, South or Central American, or other Spanish culture or origin, regardless of race)” What would you make of this? It was pretty clear to me until I got to that other Spanish culture part. For now my son just left it blank. My father in particular took a lot of pride in what he considered his Spanish roots, but somehow, I’m thinking that my kind of Spanish isn’t what they are thinking of. I don’t understand why Spanish is singled out from any other immigrant culture anyway. Any thoughts? I’m a little bit stumped by this one.</p>
<p>Hi Spectrum:</p>
<p>You are Turkish background, no?
I think your S would be American and Jewish as far as boxes to check off?</p>
<p>spectrum I would go for it if his heritage is Spanish why should it matter he is also Jewish? This just goes to show how silly it is for colleges to make these type of distinctions based on ethnicity.</p>
<p>Everyone we know with Sephardic and Cuban heritage classify as spanish; not sure I necessarily agree with that but it does seem to be a common practice around these parts</p>
<p>If the question specifically states “other Spanish culture” then I think you are fully justified checking “yes.” This is his heritage.</p>
<p>Also, re:ccc’s question about grades in AP classes, I think that if a student is getting C’s consistently in AP classes, the impression is not necessarily challenging him/herself, but that perhaps the classes are too challenging.</p>
<p>chocchip - my sons have the same pattern as yours - S1 took numerous honors/AP and got straight A’s - so clearly I think of his hs performance as that of an “A” student. S2 takes a mix or regular and honors classes - and gets a mix of A’s and B’s. A typical semester for him is 4 B’s and 3 A’s - so I think of him as a “B” student - maybe a B+ if we are splitting hairs. </p>
<p>I have had the opportunity to meet with hundreds of college reps - and they all say pretty much the same thing - they prefer to see rigor. A “B” in an honors/AP class is more impressive to them than straight A’s with no honors/AP. Now "C"s is where it gets dicey - they don’t want to see "C"s. Maybe 1 or 2 in a particularly challenging class could be forgiven - but try to avoid "C"s at all costs.</p>
<p>For example - S2 had a friend who started last year in honors Physics and was really struggling - he was clearly on the way to getting a “C” for the semester. My advice was to switch him out of honors into regular physics - which they did - and he was able to get an A. So in that scenario - I think the less rigorous class was the better option.</p>
<p>spectrum2 - here’s the conundrum - if you check Spanish/Hispanic - you have now put your son in the URM category - which can bode well for admissions. And you seem to be able to back it up - so if you are comfortable with it - I say go for it. My issue would be with someone who checks off the Hispanic box clearly hoping to get an admissions boost while their claim to that ethnicity is ridiculously far-fetched - as in having one great grandparent who was supposedly of Spanish descent. But how can anyone prove this? You could easily find someone with one Hispanic grandparent - who has a WASPy surname and looks completely Caucasian - but colleges want to count him as Hispanic because it adds to their “diversity”. I don’t think there is any right or wrong answer here - you certainly have a legitimate right to acknowledge your Spanish culture - so I would say go for it.</p>