Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Thanks C43 and RVM for your quick responses.</p>

<p>I’m talking specifically about my S2. He just finished freshman year. Took 3 honors and ended up with an End of the Year grade (The ones that appear on the college transcript) of a C+ in honors Bio. That’s an average of the 4 quarters. He was sooooo close to a B-!</p>

<p>B’s in other honors subjects, with one B+ and one A- (non-honors). I’m talking about main subjects and end of the year final grades.</p>

<p>Yes, I tend to think that honors is better than non-honors. We are hoping that the one C+ is a freshman year fluke only, but you never know.</p>

<p>In our h.s., there are 3 levels of physics. Regular, honors and AP that are taken in Junior year. My S1 took AP, my S2 will probably do honors, hopefully. Is it frowned upon to be on the honors track in Science and then switch back to regular? Thanks.</p>

<p>First - I would not worry at all about one C+ freshman year in an honors class. No worries there whatsoever. I’d be more concerned with C’s during junior year and really try to prevent those. I think it is fairly typical for there to be some fluctuation in the levels of classes as kids progress through hs. For example, as a student becomes a junior and senior - they have more AP options available to them. But in order to balance their workload - they might choose to move up a level to AP in a strong subject area - and maybe move down a level in another subject area that is weaker for them. </p>

<p>It would not be good to go from 3 honors classes one year to only 1 honors class the following year. But if you went from 3 honors classes to 1 honors and 1 AP or 2 honors and 1 AP - that makes sense to me.</p>

<p>I think on the matter of science - most colleges want to see at least 3 years of science and 2 lab sciences - so as long as you have covered the basic chemistry, physics and bio - you should be fine. I would expect a kid who was planning to major in science to have more courses and more rigor - honors/AP. But for a kid who was not planning to major in science - I would not worry about the level of classes they were taking. My son took honors level bio in 10th grade and got B’s. He’s not a huge science fan - dropped down to the regular level this past year for chemistry and had an A each semester. Doing on level physics next year. I think the fact that he has 4 years of hs science will look good - even if he dropped down from honors to regular.</p>

<p>Thanks, RVM.</p>

<p>Yeah, he wants to go into engineering, so for now we are planning 4 years of Science and hopefully can maintain the honors track. We will play it by ear for AP classes, but at least honors will be better than regular when it comes to Science classes.</p>

<p>Ok, I’ll try not to worry about his C+ in freshman year as long as HE promises that it won’t happen again, lol! :)</p>

<p>I’ve also decided that with him, we’ll look at the 5 year plan and go that extra year for a Masters. Otherwise he’ll never do it on his own. Then, once he’s done, he’ll really be done and then look for an entry level engineering job, with hopefully a Masters in hand already. (Do I plan ahead, or what? He’s not even 16 yet!)</p>

<p>So again, when colleges look at the overall GPA, they also take into consideration the level of challenge the child took. We have a friend here that does not push her children into honors classes at all. Now that the older one is in college, there is quite a struggle. My feeling is to introduce them to honors in h.s. so that by the time they get to college, they have a better feeling of what is expected of them, and hopefully will be a bit more prepared.</p>

<p>And that’s exactly why colleges want to see those honors/AP classes - they want to see that the applicant can handle the rigor of college classes - and looking at their performance in their hs classes is the only gauge they have to go by. If they are looking at the transcript of a 4.0 student who did not take any honors/AP classes - they really don’t know if that student will succeed in college or crash and burn. The student with the honors/AP classes - even just a few - shows that they can handle a more challenging workload - more reading - more independent research and so forth.</p>

<p>I LOVE your 5-year plan by the way!</p>

<p>For the Elon fans on our thread:</p>

<p>[E-net</a>! - Princeton Review gives top rankings to Elon?s study abroad and theater programs](<a href=“http://www.elon.edu/e-net/Note.aspx?id=954008]E-net”>http://www.elon.edu/e-net/Note.aspx?id=954008)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Thank you for your replies, on the Sephardic question. Chocchip, My family never identified themselves as Turkish (or Phillipino) although they lived in those countries. Rodney, thanks for mentioning other Sephardic families. I don’t know any here and growing up it was never a question I thought to ask. When asked the origin of my last name I have always called it Spanish Jewish, so this is the orientation I have grown up with. Personally, I frequently acknowedge Spanish roots but this is the first time I can remember this question posed in this manner. College4three, and RVM “other Spanish culture or origin, regardless of race” that was the specific quote from the application. but I should clarify, there is a section on the application that says “Select a racial category” and all the typical categories are listed. Then there is a second question called “Ethnicity or Race” in this section the question is basically are you of Spanish descent or not. No other race or ethnicity is mentioned and I have already quoted the criteria they list for being Spanish. Since they say “regardless of race” and there is another racial category altogether I am thinking this wouldn’t categorize him as a URM. I don’t understand why it would make any difference if an American came from Spain any other country. BTW this is the ApplyTexas application. Panmom, I agree it is ridiculous for colleges to make these categorizations. I’m just curious do those of you from German, Polish, Russian or other countries, do you identify yourself with that culture?</p>

<p>Chochip: I completely agree with you regarding the introduction of rigor to better prepare students for college. My S2 was planning to cruise and take the easy way out for his senior year but over the summer he started thinking he may go into engineering and he decided to go with BC calc and AP Physics. He hasn’t made a clear decision about his major but I think it will help him know if engineering is the way to go if he takes these classes and knows how he feels about them. Unfortunately for him he will have to have his choice of major made before he knows very much about how he feels about these classes. (I’m at the edge of my seat waiting to see what he will pick.) My point is that if engineering is a direction your son is considering now, then taking challenging courses that support this major could help your son decide if he is on the right track. As RVM said, schools don’t just want to see that a student has taken on challenges they want to see a level of success with the challenge. I don’t think that one or two of any grade high or low will make or break a student especially for freshman year. The best thing I can suggest is to have your S take the advanced classes he believes he can be successful with and then try to be proactive (but not a nag) if you see a problem developing. ( Haha, if you asked my S there might be a difference of opinion on the nag part, but I try not to.)
One of my peeves about our school is that they celebrate students getting all A’s regardless of class choices. A student taking a schedule with rigorous classes but all A’s and one B there is no celebration. I see this as discouraging students from taking on a challenge. It would seem that a student getting straight A’s in regular classes should take on at least one l class with more rigor and this would better prepare them for what is to come.</p>

<p>College Board has definite criteria when it comes to who they consider Hispanic or not. It becomes an issue when students check the Hispanic box when taking the PSAT. This makes them eligible for the National Hispanic Recognition Program if they get a certain score on the PSAT junior year (generally a minimum of 184). There is no scholarship through College Board with this recognition, although some schools will give $ to scholars.</p>

<p>College Board sends lists of students who have been named to the program to colleges in the fall of senior year. Schools are asked to confirm whether idenitified students are Hispanic using the basic criteria that at least one grandparent was from a Hispanic country (1/4 hispanic.)</p>

<p>Hispanics can be of any race or religion according to their definition–this follows the questions asked about Hispanic heritage/ race on the Common App.</p>

<p>In our case, my husband’s family lived in Argentina, having come there from Poland in the 1880’s/1890’s. Two generations were born/ lived there. My husband’s passport shows that his mother was born in Argentina which is how we confirmed D’s background.</p>

<p>Most Sephardic Jews would not meet these requirements unless a grandparent lived in a Hispanic country. In the case of the family who lived in Turkey (probably having fled Spain hundreds of years before), they would not be considered Hispanic by College Board’s criteria.</p>

<p>There are those that will argue that one can just self report oneself as Hispanic if one feels that it is their heritage. I personally would be uncomfortable with that. As it is, people question whether D has the right to check the box even though her grandmother and great-grandmother were born in Argentina and were fluent in Spanish and citizens of the country. They were fully immersed in the culture and spoke Spanish in my husband’s home when he was growing up.</p>

<p>I think that the issue of rigor can get a little tricky. All colleges say that they want to see HS students challenge themselves with rigorous courses. They also prefer high GPAs and class ranks. I think that it can hurt a kid to take too many difficult courses if the GPA suffers. I saw this with one of my D’s friends who had a 3.4 unwieghted GPA with 19xx SAT scores and a rigorous schedule. She had the same admission results as another friend with a much higher GPA, lower SAT scores and an easier schedule.</p>

<p>I do agree that the more difficult classes will offer better preparation for college. I think that sometimes it’s worth mixing the rigor it it yields a higher GPA.</p>

<p>uskoolfish: I understand what you are saying. I didn’t recall the collegeboard definition but the way they stated it I knew we didn’t qualify. The criteria of being 1/4 Hispanic with one grandparent from a Spanish speaking country is not on this application. On this particular application (ApplyTexas) they seem to define things more broadly “or other Spanish culture or origin”. I have no idea why or why they are even asking. It is a separate question from the one about race. I haven’t seen that they have defined “Spanish culture”. Its probably not all that important, I’ll explain it to my son and leave it to him to decide which box to pick or leave it blank.</p>

<p>spectrum - I always find that questions of ethnic heritage are particularly interesting among Jews - as so many people were forced to flee the Holocaust and ended up in unusual places. My paternal grandparents fled Poland and thankfully made their way to the US - to the Lower East Side. They HATED Poland with a vengeance - I would never under any circumstances consider myself of Polish origin. Maternal grandparents made it out of Germany a little earlier - but again - they never looked back either. So - I see myself and my children as American Jews - and that’s it. I have no interest whatsoever in any German or Polish roots - would never ever identify myself as being of Polish or German descent.</p>

<p>I agree with everyone about creating a balance with rigor. That’s why he’s taking 3 honors instead of 5.</p>

<p>Freshman year he had honors Math, Science and Spanish
Sophomore year we’re dropping honors Spanish and picking up honors History.</p>

<p>I’m mainly trying to keep Math & Science in honors all the way.
He says he wants Mechanical engineering. He likes “working with his hands and building things” as opposed to Computer Science or programming. Any other majors I should look at besides ME? If he can handle it, I think ME would be perfect for him…</p>

<p>I guess this next year will be a telltale sign of what he’s stronger in. Spectrum: thanks for your words of wisdom…so far, so good in the “nagging” dept!</p>

<p>Momjr: How was your trip out west?</p>

<p>Choc, our trip was great, but a little rushed. We started with a night in Scottsdale, and then went to Sedona, the Grand Canyon and Las Vegas. Sedona and the Grand Canyon were beautiful. Thanks for the suggestions - we all loved the Pink Jeep Tour in Sedona.</p>

<p>I have heard such amazing things about Sedona - on my wish list for when we hit “empty nest” status next year. Of course - with 2 in college - we’ll be living on rice and beans - but one can always hope.</p>

<p>chocchip - making a generalization here - I would say it is best to keep science, math and foreign language in the schedule - even at a lower level. I think adcoms are impressed with a 4th year of foreign language - a 4th year of science and so forth. So many kids dislike one or more of these subjects and drop foreign language/science/math after junior year. I would rather see kids with these subjects senior year if possible - even if it means they are taking them on-level. Some hs allow students - particularly seniors - to have 1 or 2 study halls - and while the kids may love this idea - it can result in a pretty light senior schedule. Which may hurt them in admissions - it may also leave them unprepared for freshman year of hs. So - that’s my two cents.</p>

<p>Sedona is breathtakingly gorgeous. It is a MUST on everyone’s “bucket” list…Momjr: that’s a lot of territory to cover! Did you see Hoover Dam too? Yeah, those Pink Jeep Tours are fun, especially in Sedona where you have such rugged terrain! Glad you had a fun trip.</p>

<p>RVM: I agree with you as far as taking the 5 main subjects all throughout h.s. Not 100% sold on a language in the senior year…depends on the child. My S1 is obsessed with foreign languages. Took AP Spanish in Senior year as well as being a teen aide for the Spanish teacher as well as creating his own Independent study on Spanish Culture and Literature. For him it was a no-brainer to have Spanish all 4 years. However, with S2 interested in ME, I might allow him to have 3 years of Spanish and then pick up a few electives in his senior year in the Technology/Computer area since that is his interest.</p>

<p>We’ll see. Right now his courses are picked for sophomore year and hopefully he’ll be on an upward trend.</p>

<p>RVM: What year in college is your S1 going into? My boys will overlap one year in college, Senior and Freshman, so we’ll be eating a lot of rice & beans then too! :slight_smile: Glad I like them!</p>

<p>Here’s the latest:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>chocchip - S1 is going into his junior year - so we have the same overlap - S1 will be a senior when S2 is a freshman. I keep trying to estimate how much money we might possible need in July 2012 to pay for the fall semester for each of them - so not fun.</p>

<p>FWIW in Texas four years of math, science, social studies and English are currently required. This doesn’t leave much room for electives or other required courses. Dropping Spanish for both of my boys was a no brainer. (A little irony there considering my recent discussion about Spanish culture.)</p>

<p>RVM: Yes it is a slippery slope for Jews to pin down a nationality. Because our surname is unusual in the US it is a question I am often asked.</p>

<p>RVM I usually go with “Eastern European descent”, though that means something somewhat different today than it did before the fall of the former Soviet Union. But I can’t just go with “American” since my grandparents came off the boat maybe 85 years ago.</p>