<p>Visits are good… ;-)</p>
<p>“There are approximately 400-600 Jewish students at Alabama, and we are growing every year!”</p>
<p>“Can prospective students visit Alabama and stay overnight with a Jewish student?
You bet! The best way to get a sense of the Alabama experience is to visit our incredible campus. Hillel can help arrange for prospective students to stay overnight with a student. To arrange a tour and information session with Alabama’s admissions office, click here. Prospective students who wish to visit Hillel, speak with Jewish students and/or attend a Hillel program should email us.”</p>
<p>[Hillel</a> - University of Alabama](<a href=“http://www.bamahillel.org/faq.htm]Hillel”>http://www.bamahillel.org/faq.htm)</p>
<p>I did see the Hillel stuff online for Alabama, but of course I know they’re not going to say “it’s horrible here, don’t come down” LOL. And I didn’t mean Alabama specifically, so maybe I AM generalizing. Don’t know, just too late for me to be articulate! Will re-read tomorrow and see if I can make any sense of it in daylight!</p>
<p>Deborah: Ditto on that!..We cross posted I was dittoing a couple of posts ago when you mentioned this online community.</p>
<p>Sujurmilk: I’ll try and help you. We have touched on stuff like this earlier in the thread so some of what I am saying may be redundant. I live in Texas and not it a major city, but was Brooklyn raised so I have some perspective on what you are saying. Without a doubt antisemitism exists but more times than not comments that are made such as “Jewing down” and assumptions that everyone celebrates Christmas are based on ignorance rather than anything more sinister. Any Jewish student from a Jewish “bubble” area should be prepared that this ignorance exists and that from time to time the pressure will be on them to educate. The good news is that more times than not people are interested in learning and sometimes go out of their way beyond any expectation to make you feel comfortable. Whether this type of situation is the right thing for a student is a personal decision. I would strongly suggest that any bubble raised kid be aware that ignorance exists and be able to calmly and graciously educate. I would also suggest that they not take things too seriously. By that I mean they can expect things like being wished Merry Christmas several times a day in that season. There really is not need to explain or discuss. It is just an expression of good wishes, it is just easier to move on or smile and return the greeting. As I understand it Alabama has some healthy Jewish communities so I would expect a large university would have diversity and a Jewish community. In spite of this I would also expect there are many who know nothing about Judaism. If your student can see this as an opportunity to teach it could be a good fit, if they find it appalling and uncomfortable it is probably a poor fit. I think that many kids like yours can be happy in a southern school but they should go in with their eyes open and prepared. I think as a parent you have to be concerned but understand that “antisemitism” and “church going influence” are not even close to being the same thing, at least not most of the time.</p>
<p>In a rush this morning - but Spectrum2 - fabulous response! Particularly in differentiating between antisemitism and simple unfamiliarity. And this issue is one we have really tried to investigate - to find colleges suitable for “B” students where they may be a small minority - but still feel welcomed and comfortable. But again - I agree 100% with Spectrum - a Jewish student coming from a large Jewish community may feel very uncomfortable at a southern school - even without experiencing any overt acts of discrimination - and this is why visits and conversations with current Jewish students are so critical.</p>
<p>Our (south Carolina) Jewish community has three students at Bama. All reports back have been excellent, although those students are both Jewish and Southerners, so they didn’t experience the culture shock someone coming from the North may feel.</p>
<p>“Without a doubt antisemitism exists but more times than not comments that are made such as “Jewing down” and assumptions that everyone celebrates Christmas are based on ignorance rather than anything more sinister.”</p>
<p>I have to disagree with the claim that making a comment like “Jewing down” is based on ignorance. It may not be sinister, but it is insulting, plain and simple.</p>
<p>Mutti, agreed, it’s insulting; however, that unfortunately may not even occur to the person who uses the expression in a place where not many Jewish people live. To some of the people there it may simply be an idiom that’s part of their vocabulary and wouldn’t offend anyone they personally know, sad though that may be.</p>
<p>Mutti: Yes it is insulting but sometimes this slips into people’s speech without them even thinking about what they are saying. There are a few times this has been said to me or in my presence and I have gently but definitively explained to them about the problems with using this term. Each time people were appologetic and while I don’t know that they never used the phrase again I never heard it used again. From the responses I received I felt that these people had learned from our encounter. BTW my expaniation was often, something like, “I have kids and you have kids, grandchildren or whatever, if your kids meet mine I don’t want them to be prejudging them and thinking that they will cheat them because they heard you say that. Please don’t use those words. I might also add: To Jewish people that is similar to using the N word.” If you are going to be a minority in an area it serves you well to have thick skin. Of course it would be better if this type of speech never occurred at all but it does. happily I haven’t heard the phrase in a long time.</p>
<p>…once again Deborah and I are cross posting, yes idiom, that’s the word I was looking for.</p>
<p>We also get “Jewing down” comments here in NY. It’s not just a southern thing. Would love for some of the northern parents with kids at Bama (and other southern schools) to have their kids actually post their experiences here (or PM). Bama may have 400-600 Jewish kids, but how are they treated by the 20,000 other students? Do they blend in easily or are they somewhat forced to find each other to feel comfortable?</p>
<p>Without going into too much geographic detail, I will say that I live in both a Jewish bubble and a PC bubble here in the NE. I’m trying to get into the head of someone who benignly uses the term “Jewing down”. Maybe it’s like “Indian giver” or “going Dutch” (both of which I’ve long understood to be insulting), some sort of very longstanding standard usage that’s lost its original sting. I’ve never lived anywhere but here; I do understand the bubble I’m in. It’s still hard to wrap my brain around the innocent or ignorant usage of such terms. It’s a big old world out there, I guess. Fwiw, and I expect to get flamed for this: I’d never send my kid to live in the deep south for 4 years or 4 months.</p>
<p>You are going to find a lot of ignorance and some racism at any school. My daughter was amazed at how many kids she encountered at the University of Florida (which has a significant Jewish population and 3 Jewish Frats/2 Jewish sororities) that had never met a Jew before coming to college. She told me that a few of these ethnocentric types actually treated her differently after learning of her ethnic origin. A significant life lesson for a child who was raised in a bubble.</p>
<p>spectrum - fabulous response. it describes exactly our experience in semi-rural OH. we’ve done a lot of educating in the 10 years we’ve lived here.</p>
<p>
and I have to disagree with you on this, Mutti2012. case in point: I have a good friend here in small town OH, who has lived in this area all her life. she used the expression in a conversation with me and, after I explained to her why it was insulting, she was absolutely mortified. really. she was horrified and apologized profusely. she was simply ignorant of the derivation of the expression.</p>
<p>Looking for opinions… S has taken the SAT twice and results were certainly less than stellar! He worked with a private tutor for test # 2, but only improved slightly. Have no experience with the ACT at all. Do you think is would be worthwhile for S to take the ACT? After his fruitless effort prepping for the SAT, I strongly doubt I will be able to get him to study for it this time around. Are the tests that different? Would a student be able to go in cold, or is some level of preparation required?</p>
<p>Mom 2009: There are others here more familiar with the ACT than I am but I would suggest if there is a PR or Kaplan or other service that offers free practice testing have your son do that for the ACT. That will both give him a feel for the format and pacing of the test and will also give him an idea of if the test is worth taking. The ACT isn’t a test for someone who works slowly esp without prep. Many folks here have experience with getting much better results on one test than on another. Be sure your S knows there is no penalty for wrong answers on the ACT.</p>
<p>Mutti: Just to show how easily one can use an offensive phrase it never occurred to me that using the phrase “going Dutch” could be construed as offensive, Yikes! …No flaming here, that is why it is great that we have choices. I think that the original post by Sujurmilk that got this conversation going misrepresented the typical southern experience. I would hate for folks to base their opinion of southern living on that stereotype.</p>
<p>^ absolutely try the ACT. The tests are very different, and many kids do much better on one vs. the other. S got 1950 on SAT, lower than expected for him. Took the ACT, got 32 first try (roughly equivalent to 2130) just by reading the book and taking a few practice tests. Click on over to the ACT forums on CC for more info.</p>
<p>Mom2009, my son refused to even take the SAT after having sat through the PSAT. He so much preferred the ACT. This article might interest you:</p>
<p>[ACT</a> vs. SAT - New York Times](<a href=“ACT vs. SAT - The New York Times”>ACT vs. SAT - The New York Times)</p>
<p>I SOOOO did not mean to represent or misrepresent anyone’s experience at all, just wanted to hear perspectives from a likely empathetic and experienced group. I don’t remember who commented on the difference between anti-semitism and church-going influence but that was a very apt distinction and I appreciate the clarification. I think our “bubble” in suburban Chicago is not nearly as large as the ones on the east coast so even here it is possible, if not routine, to meet people who have never met a Jew.</p>
<p>I was the token Jew at the company I worked at for 12 years. I did my share of educating, most of which was taken in the spirit it was given (e.g., don’t call your Jewish clients to make a sale on Yom Kippur) but also dealt with plenty of ignorance due to lack of exposure and parochial school educations. I also dealt with people who didn’t give a rat’s ass about respecting others’ differences. </p>
<p>I also appreciate the calm and intelligent discussion that followed my comment. As I said upfront, I wasn’t trying to stir anything up! And I happen to highly doubt that my D will end up at Alabama. I still think it’s a valid subject for discussion on this particular thread. Thanks to all who participated.</p>
<p>PS: there’s no L in my screen name. My youngest kid’s name is Mike…;).</p>
<p>Before changing directions and entering medical school I taught at the university level for 11 years. When I moved from Seattle to Austin I expected and encountered many differences in local culture, but the culture of UT was very much like that of UW. My impression is that UT has had a thriving Jewish population for many years, and that Jewish professors have found Austin to be a very comfortable environment. </p>
<p>I think Jewish students from Texas generally have a very positive experience at UT. I did have one student from New York who seemed to be having difficulty. She was a student in an American literature class I was teaching and complained that the inclusion of Jonathan Edwards’ “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” was an inappropriate promotion of Christianity. I tried to explain to her its importance in the historical context and, in particular, to our later study of “Huckleberry Finn” (as when Huck says “All right then, I’ll go to hell” when he decides not to turn Jim in), but she couldn’t be persuaded. I think this in a example of someone who was disoriented when outside the “bubble”.</p>
<p>Of course, I am also certain that fraternity boys anywhere with enough EtOH on board are capable of boorish behaviour but that is perhaps another topic.</p>
<p>Older D was an A student with a 97+ GPA in hs–top 5%. She was hoping to top 1350+ on her SAT’s so that her scores were aligned to her GPA.</p>
<p>It turned out she was not a great test taker, and her math SAT was stalled at 630 after Kaplan and private math tutoring. (She had taken all honors math and as a senior, AP calc.)</p>
<p>Decided to try the ACT and her math score shot up to 33 (99th %ile) without any more prep.</p>
<p>In the end she took the ACT twice and got 33 on math both times. Her math on SAT finally increased to 650 (maybe 87th %ile.)</p>
<p>Of course the kicker is that on her 2nd time taking the ACT, her reading dropped to a 24 from a 31 without any explanation. But I think all her schools superscored it anyway.</p>
<p>BTW, for younger D–who is not a great math student–ACT math never budged from a 23. However, it did go up to a 610 on one sitting of the SAT (so we are done.) For her, she would get a lot right on the ACT, but she would run out of time at the same point on every sitting. Yet, she was able to complete the SAT math. She also randomly went up 40 points on her last SAT reading section–without any prep at all (to a 720.)</p>
<p>So, my advice is to definitely try the ACT and if you can afford to take these tests as many times as possible and use score choice, do so! Scores do go up and down randomly, so take advantage of that. (Older D went up to a 780 in SAT writing in one sitting–all others were 670. For that matter younger D got a 35 on English ACT followed by a 30 the next time???)</p>