Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>sujormik: Oops so sorry, I got the spelling now. (A little dyslexia shining through there) Also I’m sorry if it sounded like I was scolding you, I was just trying to say that I didn’t think your friend gave you accurate information and I was trying to site your post not point a finger at you. I am really glad you sought out other experiences.</p>

<p>BTW: If ya’ll wonder why I’m so attentive today it is because I am sorting through the test sections of two blue SAT books trying to figure out which parts of which tests my S2 hasn’t done yet. Both boys used both books in different sections on each test. Its pretty maddening. I would just get a new book but that won’t help in avoiding repeating tests S2 has already done. He starts tutoring on Saturday and he needs materials to work with. Soooo, thanks for the distraction!</p>

<p>Best wishes to all of this thread’s alumni who are about to start college! I wish them all great experiences and hope that they wil take a moment down the road to recount their experiences, especially those who chose schools which were not among the usual suspects for kids on this thread.</p>

<p>Ditto from me too! Best wishes to your son also, yabeyabe2!</p>

<p>My Son will be working with an SAT tutor for 8 to 10 hours in preparation for the Oct SAT. This is an independent tutor who also works with a company but will be working with us privately. The downside to this is that there are no materials included. My S has already worked through much of the Official SAT book and I want to be sure we have good materials to work with. Since the tutor usually works with his company’s materials and these aren’t available without the course I am searching for additional materials. Our tutor isn’t really familiar with materials aside from the ones the company he works with provides. I have looked at the SAT online course, Majortests.com and some books by Princeton Review or Kaplan. I looked for official SAT tests online but could only find questions not answers. Can you suggest any resoursces to supplement what we already have? Thanks!</p>

<p>sujormik - I love our conversations on Jewish identity and being Jewish in different parts of the country - one of the things I really enjoy about this thread as we get so many varying opinions and experiences. Don’t worry at all about stirring things up - this topic has been an ongoing one and a very important one. One of the things it brought to my mind was the use of the Washington Redskins name here in DC. Many Indian groups detest this usage of the word “Redskin” even though Dan Snyder can go on and on about the positive attributes associated with the name. And many people don’t understand why American Indians are offended. People are more sensitive to it when it is the ethnic or religious group that they belong to that is the victim of the slur. I love the idea of turning these occurrences into teachable moments when possible.</p>

<p>Mom2009 - I am a huge fan of the ACT. Both of my sons did better on it. Buy the red ACT prep book and have him take 1 practice test - just to get a feel for it. ACT is more fact-based and does not penalize for wrong answers. Many kids do better on the ACT - but you won’t know unless he gives it a shot.</p>

<p>“American literature class I was teaching and complained that the inclusion of Jonathan Edwards’ “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” was an inappropriate promotion of Christianity. I tried to explain to her its importance in the historical context and, in particular, to our later study of “Huckleberry Finn” (as when Huck says “All right then, I’ll go to hell” when he decides not to turn Jim in), but she couldn’t be persuaded. I think this in a example of someone who was disoriented when outside the “bubble”.”</p>

<p>Im pretty sure we read Jonathan Edwards in HS English lit at Stuyvesant in NYC - stuy was then 40% or so Jewish, and NYC was, well, NYC. As much of a bubble as you can get short of Day School. I suggest this is a different issue, indicating some lack of intellectuality.</p>

<p>As for the Skins, I want to see them make it to the Super Bowl, but I want to see them renamed. Snyder is doing a hillul hashem on this issue (though at least he seems to have learned something about not micromanaging the team). Abe Pollin, may he be remembered for a blessing, OTOH, who renamed the Bullets to the Wizards out of concern for the children of DC, that was a kiddush hashem.</p>

<p>Brooklynborndad, after reconsidering the incident I think you are right.</p>

<p>Elon was mentioned in an article in the September issue of Town and Country magazine:</p>

<p>[E-net</a>! - Town & Country picks Elon among nation?s top 10 ?up-and-coming? colleges](<a href=“http://www.elon.edu/e-net/Note.aspx?id=954279]E-net”>Town & Country picks Elon among nation’s top 10 “up-and-coming” colleges | Today at Elon | Elon University)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>The Fall 2011 issue - including the annual college section - is now available online. Here is the link:</p>

<p>[Reform</a> Judaism Magazine - College & Youth](<a href=“http://reformjudaismmag.org/browse/youth/]Reform”>http://reformjudaismmag.org/browse/youth/)</p>

<p>Congratulations again to Elon University:</p>

<p>[Reform</a> Judaism Magazine - Admissions 105: Unexpected Welcomes](<a href=“http://reformjudaismmag.org/Articles/index.cfm?id=2865]Reform”>http://reformjudaismmag.org/Articles/index.cfm?id=2865)</p>

<p>Selected as one of 6 universities that are welcoming to Jewish students.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Top 60 colleges chosen by Jewish students:</p>

<p><a href=“http://reformjudaismmag.org/_kd/Items/actions.cfm?action=Show&item_id=2888&destination=ShowItem[/url]”>http://reformjudaismmag.org/_kd/Items/actions.cfm?action=Show&item_id=2888&destination=ShowItem&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Last year at this time, I remember lamenting that so many of the schools listed were not in reach for a “B” student. This year - I see the list a little differently and want to highlight a number of schools that we have been discussing on this thread - that are in reach for “B” students. They are:</p>

<p>Muhlenberg, University of Hartford, University of Denver, Penn State, University of Maryland, Tulane, Binghamton, Goucher, Northeastern, GWU, American, Boston University, Syracuse, Indiana University, Rutgers, University of Wisconsin and Hofstra.</p>

<p>This list is not meant to be all of the schools - see the article/chart for the entire list. And I understand that some of these might be reaches for a “B” student - or maybe more for a “B+” student, etc. Just mentioning these as suggestions for families that want a strong Jewish presence at their child’s college.</p>

<p>I think many of those would be a reach, at best, for a B student. Do you consider B to be 3.0? In particular, Denver, Maryland, Northeastern, GW, American, Boston, Rutgers. These schools are OK for maybe a B+ student–as a reach in some cases–but a 3.0 average will not get you in. My D had a 3.3 and was rejected from American. She got into Denver RD after being deferred from EA but received no money, and it is a very expensive school. A B+ student from NJ could get into Rutgers, but a solid B (3.0) student will not–some of my D’s friends who were B students were rejected. If you are OOS a B+ may not be good enough either. Similarly, a B student from NY will probably not get into Binghamton, though an OOS student will have a better shot (NY likes OOS for their higher tuition rates). Northeastern had a huge surge in applications last year, and I don’t think a B student would have been accepted. I think Tulane is probably out of reach for a B student, as well.</p>

<p>With regard to American in particular–it seems to be viewed more favorably the farther you get from the DC area. My sister is a “rockville mom,” literally, and BIL a DC lawyer, and they couldn’t believe I was allowing my D to apply to American–they view it as a school for rich suburban kids who weren’t smart enough to get into Georgetown or GWU. I explained that while that may have been true 20 years ago, the school has become much more competitive and is much more respected now. Thoughts?</p>

<p>We have a very broad definition of a “B” student on this thread. When I started the conversation - I just wanted to eliminate competitive commentary from parents of “A” students about Ivy League schools, Vanderbilt, Tufts, Wash U, etc. My reasoning being that if you were a strong enough student to apply to such top tier schools - you really were not going to be lacking in Jewish life and options.</p>

<p>So - I define a “B” student as anyone who is not an “A” student - how’s that for broad? Whether it is a 3.0 or a 3.8 does not matter to me - I’m simply targeting that segment of the Jewish population that will not be applying to Harvard, Princeton, Yale, Cornell, etc.</p>

<p>In my experience - a B+ student can get into Maryland, Denver, Northeastern, American, etc - particularly if they have reasonably decent test scores - say a 1200 SAT or 28 ACT or higher. Some will improve their chances by applying ED at schools like American. And I have certainly seen B+ students be accepted at Tulane - particularly if they apply very early in the fall. So again, using the terminology of “B” student very loosely - and certainly not implying that a student with a 3.0 would be accepted at all of these schools.</p>

<p>On American - it certainly does function for many as a safety school to Georgetown and GW. While it does have its share of rich suburban kids - it also has more diversity than that - many international and minority students. I do feel it is more respected academically now than it was 20 years ago - absolutely.</p>

<p>From the IU newspaper:</p>

<p>[Still</a> looking for Lauren | Campus | Indiana Daily Student](<a href=“http://www.idsnews.com/news/story.aspx?id=82426]Still”>http://www.idsnews.com/news/story.aspx?id=82426)</p>

<p>The photo of the parents really says it all.</p>

<p>The updated website:</p>

<p><a href=“http://findlauren.com/[/url]”>http://findlauren.com/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>

</p>

<p>Eastcoast, a belated welcome. Congrats on Bing–my friends are about to drop their son off for his soph year after a great freshman year. I hope your belief that your child will text you back regularly comes true–mine became much less responsive at college, which I hope was a sign of being independent and busy, unsatisfying as it was to just read “ok” or to get nothing at all in response to questions. </p>

<p>I was intrigued by your comment that Rutgers is more selective OOS; from our friends’ kids there, we had the sense it, like Bing, did not attract as many OOS kids as UMass, Penn State and UDel do, despite being a quality flagship, even after its football success.
I think you encapsulated the value of this and similar threads very well in your story about your sister and BIL saying “they view it as a school for rich suburban kids who weren’t smart enough to get into Georgetown or GWU.” If your student is in the 3.0-3.5 UW range in an affluent HS, when you want information about private schools for your child, people at home and on CC will often make patronizing comments like that–would they refer to GW and Georgetown as for “rich suburban kids who weren’t smart enough to get into Penn?” </p>

<p>Rockville’s mitzvah was establishing a thread where parents could get neutral information and positive reinforcement about such schools. Yes, you will find schools mentioned often which will strike you as being well out of the reach of what you understandably consider an actual B student. As with the occasional post by someone who seems to be enjoying being on a CC thread where their child has better stats than the norm, it is a small negative in a very positive thread.</p>

<p>A good option is having your child rely primarily on a debit or credit card where you can receive online access and optional email alerts to the balance and spending. This generation is often much less reluctant than its parents to use cards for very small payments (granted, it may reflect or foster a lesser appreciation for cost).</p>

<p>I also found that with the more frequent college breaks at many schools than in my generation, it is easier to supply kids with adequate cash without worrying about a substantial amount being in a dorm room.</p>

<p>So the tennis pros my son has been working with the last couple of weeks are telling him that – with work – he can play D1 tennis. OMG. This is going to complicate things.</p>

<p>As far as American Univ goes, DD really liked it. Was one of her top choices. Not as much as city school as the others in DC (not likely she would have gotten in to the others anyway). In the end, she picked UD over American. For the money (for us), it just wasn’t worth it. However, if she was a poli sci kid, with interest in politics and government, we probably wouldn’t have come to the same decision.</p>

<p>Hoping everyone stays safe this weekend. We are really in for it on the south shore of Long Island. A direct hit looks likely. University of Delaware cancelled move-in this weekend and already cancelled classes on Tuesday. Who knows when we will go down there. Will have to see what the damage is to Newark.</p>

<p>Yabe, some of us who post here fit one of the criteria but not the other in the thread title. The thread is often near the top of the parent’s forum, so sooner or later we were bound to click on it. :slight_smile: I think it’s supposed to be open to all cc users, no? There are really nice people on here, some of whom I’ve corresponded with privately, and that’s why I’ve continued to post. I’m guessing that’s the same reason some others do, too. </p>

<p>As I’ve probably said before, I understand but see limitations to thinking strictly in terms of “B student” because I’m used to hanging out with people who don’t so much operate this way. We’re used to helping kids find their strengths and pursue their interests – figuring out how to help them get where they want to go. That is something parents do regardless of GPA, so even though my child doesn’t fit the “B student” criteria I haven’t automatically excluded myself from participating here. </p>

<p>I would also like to say I have enjoyed the collaborative, as opposed to super competitive, orientation here. My daughter is well into college now, though, so I guess I should probably move on soon, anyhow…</p>

<p>Hey Deborah, I hope you stick around! You’re great at research and at bringing quick humor to the thread. </p>

<p>Classifying kids is difficult. As I think about this I’m really not sure what box my S2 falls into. I know that the climate (and I’m not talking weather) of his hs is very different than on the eastcoast. We just do our best to find the best options for our individual kid’s needs. I think that is what this thread is about. </p>

<p>“Rockville’s mitzvah was establishing a thread where parents could get neutral information and positive reinforcement about such schools” Yabe, I second that! While my S2 probably will not go to any of the schools discussed in this thread, the wisdom it has helped me to gather to keep my eye on S2’s individual needs has been huge. His search is so different from S1’s. Initially I felt I was being unfair to him by not traveling the country doing a college search. You have all been really helpful in allowing me to feel good about embracing his goals and desires.</p>

<p>I’m glad they are keeping up awareness for the search for Lauren. Brutal reminder that this hurricane is just an inconvenience.</p>