Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Good point, Linymom. I was thinking about Lauren the other day. What a nightmare for her family.</p>

<p>Good luck to everyone in the path of the storm. We’re supposed to drive my D to Boston on Monday, but it will probably be delayed. We might have to fly up and then drive up over the weekend with the rest of her stuff. After all the planning this is rather unsettling.</p>

<p>Deborah - you are welcome to remain part of our online community - whether you are going through the college search process or not. My goal has always been to make the conversation as inclusive as possible - while trying to keep the focus on kids who are not straight A students aiming for top 20 schools. Considering that we often discuss other topics that would be of interest to Jewish parents - and to some non-Jewish parents as well - everyone is welcome.</p>

<p>I mean really - do you think I’m going to abandon ship once S2 is in college?</p>

<p>“We have a very broad definition of a “B” student on this thread. When I started the conversation - I just wanted to eliminate competitive commentary from parents of “A” students about Ivy League schools, Vanderbilt, Tufts, Wash U, etc. My reasoning being that if you were a strong enough student to apply to such top tier schools - you really were not going to be lacking in Jewish life and options.”</p>

<p>Thank you for that. My DD was a B + (weighted) student at TJ, so many of the schools discussed here were of no interest, but the top schools with the huge Jewish student bodies were still reaches for her, so this topic and much of this discussion was useful for us. I think the way you framed it is just right.</p>

<p>momjr, not to make this thread into a hurricane/weather report :slight_smile: but I believe Monday the weather is going to be gorgeous! Hard to believe with what’s coming through on Sunday but it looks like it will move quickly out of the region by Monday morning. Good luck with your move-in!</p>

<p>Does anyone have up to date information on accepted applicants information for American University and GW?</p>

<p>I know that AU is often perceived as the “safety” for students who want to be in DC, yet my son didn’t even check out GW because he wanted a real campus. He wanted the quintessential “frisbee on the Quad” experience as much as he wanted the DC experience and so American was the proper choice for him. He didn’t consider Georgetown–not that he could have gotten in anyway, but he was uncomfortable considering any Catholic school.</p>

<p>From their respective Common Data Sets:</p>

<p>American: overall admit rate: 51.3%; men: 45.5%; women: 54.9%</p>

<p>GU: overal admit rate: 31.7%; men: 33.0%; women 30.8%</p>

<p>Edited to add: American gets TWICE the number of women applying 4600) as men (2300). I wonder why?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>SPORTS: American does not have a highly visible basketball team (or any other sports) like the other schools in DC.</p>

<p>There you go; interesting. Thanks!</p>

<p>Also, American has a pretty highly regarded school of education, which tends to draw more females too.</p>

<p>Thanks to everyone for their insight on ACT vs. SAT. Now I just have to convince my stubborn S to take yet another test!</p>

<p>Have a trip planned next week to visit Quinnipiac, UConn, UMass and URI. Hope this will help S to narrow down his college criteria. Wish me luck!</p>

<p>Thanks for the quick response! Do you know how the two schools’ average test scores and gpas compare?</p>

<p>One of my nieces wants to apply to all the DC schools, and wants to visit my son at AU, but her mother thinks AU might be “beneath” her daughter…not a fancy enough diploma, and not fancy enough kids (ie., not a huge greek system, although there is one, and my son did join a fraternity…)–her mom thinks Indiana would be much more prestigious. And I happen to think Indiana is a fantastic school, too, and that any of these schools would be good choices–depending on what my niece wants in a school. And Indiana has one of the most brutal greek scenes in the country, with many more girls going through rush than there are spaces in the houses…</p>

<p>Greek = fancy? [shrug]</p>

<p>You can find alot of the information you are seeking by searching “common data set” + “college name”. Good luck!</p>

<p>Mutti: Thanks for the reassurance about Boston. I hope you’re right!</p>

<p>National Naviance:</p>

<p>Freshman Applicants
Received: 16926
Accepted: 7357
Percent Accepted:43.47%
Enrolled: 1502</p>

<p>Test Score Ranges (Mid 50%)
Test Name High Low Avg.
ACT Combined: 31 26 28
ACT English: 33 26 29
ACT Math: 30 25 27
ACT Reading:<br>
ACT Science:<br>
SAT Combined: 2075 1745 1910
SAT I Math: 680 580 630
SAT I Critical Reading: 710 590 650</p>

<p>National Naviance:</p>

<p>Freshman Applicants
Received: 19842
Accepted: 7292
Percent Accepted: 36.75%
Enrolled: 2592</p>

<p>Test Score Ranges (Mid 50%)
Test Name High Low Avg.
ACT Combined: 30 27 28
ACT English: 33 27 30
ACT Math: 31 26 28
ACT Reading:<br>
ACT Science:<br>
SAT Combined: 2060 1790 1925
SAT I Math: 690 600 645
SAT I Critical Reading: 690 600 645</p>

<p>Mom2009 - please do post about your trip when you return - those are schools I am not that familiar with and I’m sure others would appreciate some info as well.</p>

<p>boysx3 - I find the idea that Indiana is more prestigious than American to be puzzling - I personally would either equate them or rank American higher - with maybe an exception for Indiana’s business school. Indiana is an easier admit than American from what I have seen.</p>

<p>National Naviance for Indiana University</p>

<p>Freshman Applicants
Received: 36719
Accepted: 25391
Percent Accepted: 69.15%
Enrolled: 7020</p>

<p>Test Score Ranges (Mid 50%)
Test Name High Low Avg.
ACT Combined: 29 24 26
ACT English: 30 24 27
ACT Math: 29 24 26
ACT Reading:<br>
ACT Science:<br>
SAT Combined: 1910 1580 1745
SAT I Math: 650 540 595
SAT I Critical Reading: 630 520 575</p>

<p>Indiana clearly has a higher admit rate and a lower test score average than American. I’m not knocking Indiana - I just would not personally consider it to be more prestigious than American.</p>

<p>Thanks for all the info, RVM…I was being a bit sarcastic, my niece’s (not my real niece, but a person close to the family who has always called me “auntie”) mom is just very worried that her daughter meet the “right people” and I think she is stuck in the 1970s mode…to her, being in the right sorority is of major importance, and that people recognize the name of the school is mixed of with prestige in her mind. Rather warped, in my opinion.</p>

<p>By the way…I was surprised at the lack of test score disparity between students at AU and GWU.</p>

<p>It seems there isn’t much difference between the two schools any more as far as the qualifications of their student bodies.</p>

<p>Not reflected in AU’s overall admit rate of ~40ish% is that there is a huge range across the schools. The admit rate for CAS is much lower and the admit rate for SIS is much higher.</p>

<p>The applicants don’t get admitted into a specific school, but they designate a major which places them in a particular school. It seems that the strongest applicants (grades and test scores-wise) are in the SIS pool, and they make up a disproportionate number of the admits.</p>

<p>Here is the data book from a year ago (this year’s students were considered even stronger).
<a href=“http://www.american.edu/provost/oira/upload/41st-Ed-ADRB-2.pdf[/url]”>http://www.american.edu/provost/oira/upload/41st-Ed-ADRB-2.pdf&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>You can see the admit rate/yield across schools in Table 30.</p>

<p>Ahhh… but Indiana gets time on ESPN (remember all those years with Bobby Knight) and American does not. So it’s a good NAME or is it a better-known name… and for what. You still have to pick a school based on your particular academic interests, culture and other variables that are important to you (costs (tuition plus cost for local entertainment), location, etc.).</p>