Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>So happy for you, RVM!</p>

<p>Also happy for everyone who has got their power back. We were only out for 7 hours - so lucky. Was with a friend last night who was in the evacuation zone in my town and decided to hunker down. While the water came over her dock, she never even lost power! Another friend in CT is still without power. Then I met a mom I know at the nail salon yesterday - although her block was without power until Thursday night, she escaped with her DD for a planned college visit trip to DC earlier in the week!</p>

<p>Welcome to all the new people on this thread! This is a great group here - I hope you find as much information and camaraderie as I have!</p>

<p>So we have about 4 days until junior year of HS starts and AP homework still not finished. Par for the course. Hopefully, it will get done this weekend so DS can relax on Tuesday before school starts on Wed. He has an insane schedule this year, between classes, ECs and, of course, SAT tutoring. I would say this is the calm before the storm, but the past two weeks have been nuts here – with DD home for 12 days (part of the time with out-of- town friends staying here), the hurricane, three days of fun at the US Open. I think I’m ready to go back to my regular schedule (but first a couple of days reading by the pool would be nice).</p>

<p>DD seems to be off to a good start for soph year of college. Dorm is amazing compared to her freshman dorm (feels like a hotel!). Has a random roommate who has already been MIA. DD says she’s nice, but has no idea where she disappears to. Suitemates are great. Loves her classes. Fingers crossed for a great year.</p>

<p>DS and I have a few college visits planned for the fall. Right now on the list is UMD, Bucknell, Binghamton. Plus, we will go back to University of Miami when we are in FL in February. If DS is serious about that school (which he seems to be), we have more investigating to do. I will report back here (as always).</p>

<p>Hope you all have a safe and enjoyable Labor Day Weekend!</p>

<p>Thank you all again for all of the mazal tovs! Much appreciated.</p>

<p>socaldad - here is national Naviance for West Virginia:</p>

<p>Freshman Applicants
Received: 14229
Accepted: 12496
Percent Accepted: 87.82%
Enrolled: 4589</p>

<p>Test Score Ranges (Mid 50%)
Test Name High Low Avg.
ACT Combined: 26 20 23
ACT English: 26 19 22
ACT Math: 25 18 21
ACT Reading: 27 20 24
ACT Science: 25 20 23
SAT Combined: 1700 1400 1550
SAT I Math: 580 480 530
SAT I Critical Reading: 560 460 510</p>

<p>As you can see - it is a fairly easy admit. From our suburban MD hs - 32 applied last year and 31 of those 32 were admitted. 11 matriculated. It is typically viewed (in our area) as a safety school for those who do not get into University of Maryland.</p>

<p>I have never visited - but understand the campus is divided into 2 sections with a hill between them - not entirely sure about this. Party school rep - but opportunities are present for strong and motivated students.</p>

<p>Hillel website:</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.wvu.edu/~wvuhillel/WVU_Hillel/Welcome.html[/url]”>http://www.wvu.edu/~wvuhillel/WVU_Hillel/Welcome.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Article on a Yom Hashoah program back in April:</p>

<p><a href=“http://wvutoday.wvu.edu/n/2011/04/06/holocaust-victims-to-be-remembered-at-wvu-ceremony[/url]”>http://wvutoday.wvu.edu/n/2011/04/06/holocaust-victims-to-be-remembered-at-wvu-ceremony&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Nice article from last year about Jewish life at WVU:</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.thejewishchronicle.net/view/full_story/7163895/article-Anonymous-gift-gives-WVU-Hillel-major-facelift-[/url]”>http://www.thejewishchronicle.net/view/full_story/7163895/article-Anonymous-gift-gives-WVU-Hillel-major-facelift-&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>

</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Another mention of WVU Hillel from last year:</p>

<p><a href=“Welcome to nginx!”>Welcome to nginx!;

<p>

</p>

<p>COA is about $26,000 for OOS. Decent merit scholarships for OOS:</p>

<p><a href=“Scholarships | Financial Aid | West Virginia University”>Scholarships | Financial Aid | West Virginia University;

<p>I think West Virginia could absolutely be on the list for a “B” Jewish student who wants a large university experience.</p>

<p>socal, lots of jewish kids from jersey go to wvu. have a friend whose daughter loved it.</p>

<p>Hillel
[Welcome[/url</a>]</p>

<p>looks active. why not give them a call.</p>

<p>There is a jewish frat:
[url=&lt;a href=“http://wvusammy.com/]WVU”&gt;http://wvusammy.com/]WVU</a> Sigma Alpha Mu](<a href=“http://www.wvu.edu/~wvuhillel/WVU_Hillel/Welcome.html]Welcome[/url”>http://www.wvu.edu/~wvuhillel/WVU_Hillel/Welcome.html)</p>

<p>where jewish boys are, you can find jewish girls!</p>

<p>worth looking at.</p>

<p>Socaldad, WVU is popular in my area with B-C students who want a large rah-rah school and can’t get into UMD, Penn State or VT. It has great sports spirit but also has a reputation as a party school. Most kids really like it a lot, and they seem to do fine academically. I’ve only heard of a few Jewish kids attending, so I don’t know much abou Jewish life on campus.</p>

<p>Socal,</p>

<p>I know 2 Jewish student from Ohio who went to West Virginia…both loved it.
I have been told that while there are not all that many Jewish students, they make an effort to find each other and take care of each other. Very tight knit Hillel group.</p>

<p>Rockville - congrats!</p>

<p>WVU - I do know of some Jewish students who have gone there. From what I hear they are enjoying it, especially the social life :)</p>

<p>Off to set up a time to meet with D today to edit her resume and look at her edited essay (which I don’t believe she has edited yet!). Wish me luck!</p>

<p>Since at least a few families have Rutgers on their list - here’s a recent article about their Hillel:</p>

<p>[New</a> staff expands outreach at Rutgers Hillel | New Jersey News | NJJN](<a href=“http://njjewishnews.com/article/statewide/new-staff-expands-outreach-at-rutgers-hillel#.TlRcGwgAcrw.email]New”>http://njjewishnews.com/article/statewide/new-staff-expands-outreach-at-rutgers-hillel#.TlRcGwgAcrw.email)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Wow! That’s more than I realized.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Since there are a bunch of NJians here, I was wondering if you could tell me anything about Rutger’s College of Pharmacy (in Piscataway). My daughter was a B student in high school who is currently a senior at UCF in Florida and looking to apply to the third year (of a 6 year pharmacy program) after she graduates in December of 2012 (when she has a BS in Health Science AND all the Pharmacy school prereqs for years one and two completed. She would love a change from Florida and would like a school in the northeast with access to a major city. She has a 3.5 GPA at UCF (which she has worked very hard for) and plans to take the PCAT exam in June. </p>

<p>I saw that Rutger’s Pharmacy is very competitive. Does anyone know anything about it? She is also looking at 2 schools in the Philadelphia area. </p>

<p>I was brought up in Bergen County and my family lives in the area still but I have no knowledge of Rutgers.</p>

<p>RVM, thanks for the article. An increase of 800 kids in 1 year seems astounding to me–I am sorry the article did not explain how that happened.</p>

<p>Seiclan, the Rutgers pharmacy school is among the best such schools, as is the former Philadelphia College of Pharmacy Science (which changed its name because its own students, referring to the initials, laughlingly called it “P–S P–S”). As you will recall from your NJ days, NJ has so many many pharmaceutical companies that it refers to itself as “America’s medecine chest” and the Philly area also has a long pharma tradition. With so much local funding and employment available, those schools have great industry reputations. I do not know their admission stats.</p>

<p>From Piscataway, getting to both NYC and Philly by commuter train (from neighboring New Brunswick) is easy and about an hour; with faster, pricier Amtrak service available.</p>

<p>S and I drove to Allentown last week to visit Muhlenberg College. I suggested S add it to his list as a more likely admit. We had to postpone earlier in the week due to Irene and he told me he was “happy” to skip it if our schedule could not longer accommodate it. I insisted, and he seems glad that I did. In our opinion, Muhlenberg is a terrific option for a B student, and especially for the Jewish B student.</p>

<p>The campus is small but sparkling with a lovely mix of old and new buildings, but all beautifully maintained, with their signature red doors. The admissions office is one of the “stately” ones, as I’m sure you’ve all experienced at different schools, very warm and welcoming. I’ll note here with interest that this is the one school of 15 or so S has now visited where students could only register for admissions events via telephone, with info and parking permit snail-mailed to him in a hand addressed envelope.</p>

<p>The one-hour info session was led by a charming associate admissions dean who has been at the school since graduating 20 years ago. The buzzword here is Community, with little being said with much specificity about academics, but a lot of emphasis on dorm life, activities, and the bond among students (there are approx 2,300). Average SATs out of 2400 is about 1850 though they are SAT optional; SAT IIs not required. The most important consideration is rigor of high school schedule and performance in same.</p>

<p>Performing and fine artists out there: this school was Rated #1 for the Arts this year. By whom was not mentioned  but it does seem like this is a serious school for serious arts majors. It is not a BFA program and the audition process is “warm and low-stress”. Otherwise, popular majors seem to lean towards the pre-professional; they also pride themselves on med and law school admissions although I’ll add that the pamphlet they provided about the Class of 2009 listed no first tier med or law school admissions. School is 20% Greek but no Greek residential buildings. Hillel house has been recently expanded and it is beautiful.</p>

<p>The tour was ourselves and one other parent/child (we saw about three other tours out at the same time with 2 or 3 families each.) Our tour guide was knowledgeable, articulate, and adorable. We passed lots of kids walking in groups, greeting each other; most were dressed what I would call casual-prep (T-shirt, shorts, flip flops on both boys and girls; we saw one girl in cutoffs and fishnets). Dining Hall: gorgeous. Sports complex/gym: gorgous. Academic buildings: spiffy if a little older. Upper class dorms at one end of the campus looked fairly new on a nice common green. The freshman quad on the southern end of the campus was pretty much concrete with boxy cinderblock dorms. We were shown a freshman double and my kind adjective is “classic” .</p>

<p>Possible drawbacks? Tiny campus and small pop mean you’ll see a lot of people you know coming and going. Surrounding area is very pretty but my sense is this is a campus where the social scene is on-campus. Geographic and racial diversity are pretty low with 30% from NJ, about 25% from PA, 17% from NY; you get the idea. For some students all of the above may be plusses!</p>

<p>Oh and did I mention that there is no supplemental essay? But the adcom stressed the importance of having an interview, in person if at all possible. This is a school that says openly that they’re looking for students to show the love. S walked away already feeling wanted….</p>

<p>Great visit report Mutti! We saw Muhlenberg last summer and I loved it. DS was less enthused. He is really a A-/B+ student and is looking for a more intellectual vibe to the campus but I thought the vibe at MC was great. I also think that DS is looking to be closer to a major city and not in the suburbs. My sister went to MC 25 years ago and had a wonderful experience (also very nurturing then).</p>

<p>SUNY Binghamton was pretty much a non-starter for my pretty much open-minded S. To his credit, he has been consistently saying that he wants a small LAC (< 3000) or university (<5000) but Bing is in-state for us, on the small size for a public, and lord knows the price is right. He was actually willing to apply sight unseen but I really want him to see as many of the schools on his list as possible.</p>

<p>Of course, Bing was going to present differently than anything he’s seen so far but unfortunately a number of things conspired against any sort of decent first impression. We arrived for 10 AM info session at class changeover time so we sat in traffic on the campus ring road as students weaved around cars to cross the street. S noted that most seemed to walk singly. We parked and tried to make our way to the info session, highlighted map in hand, but there was a ton of large scale construction going on, with hurricane fencing cutting off many routes. When we finally found the theater where the session was held, I joked that we had already taken the tour.</p>

<p>The session was good, with a charming young admissions rep cruising through the important points. Stress here is on GPA and SAT; the word holistic was never uttered. The numbers are probably more B+ than B. “Results” were stressed: grad and professional school admit rates, a slide listing corporations hiring grads. They do list a long, varied and even unusual list of majors. </p>

<p>Our tour guide was truly terrible. I don’t even know how to explain it: she’s a senior, very bubbly and truly a sincere booster of her school, but she was unable to put together a coherent, let alone articulate sentence. When she opened with “This is the infamous clock tower” she had me wondering what terrible thing had happened there but no elaboration came. By the time she identified “the infamous sundial” and then “the infamous Hinman community”, we realized that she thought infamous meant “very famous”. Everyone has experienced better or worse tour guides and S and I can persevere with the rest of them, but when S noticed we were passing our parking lot, we made our escape. I’m afraid I can’t tell you much about the rest of campus. Regardless of our experience, of course, YMMV; I think I speak for all NYers on this thread when I say we know a lot of different kinds of kids who are very happy at Binghamton.</p>

<p>Mutti, those are excellent and very helpful trip reports. It sounds like your son has a clear preference for size of school and that the visit to MC bore it out. I had a very similar positive impression of MC 2 years ago. I do note that your stats of 30% NJ; 25% PA; 17% NY are somewhat different from their website stats: “Geographic Distribution
New Jersey 36% New York 19% Pennsylvania 19%”. I think this speaks to the surpisingly small number of similar schools in NJ and NY.</p>

<p>I am sorry Bing did not present itself better. Your experiences reflect what so many parents are struck by on such visits–the small schools use enough tour guides that you never walk around with more than 2 other prospects and the large publics stress stats in admissions, perhaps because the moving away from stats opens them up to charges of favoritism and less ability to turn down politically connected applicants with poor stats.</p>

<p>I imagine your son liked the high ratio of girls to boys at MC (I think the theater program makes it even more so than at other LACs). I note that MC gives very strong preference to ED applicants. The graduates and current students we know there like it.</p>

<p>Seiclan: Another pamphlet we received from Muhlenberg described its Honors Programs which, in addition to a $4,000 annual “stipend”, provides “a four-year enriched experience emphasizing small seminar style classes, research and independent study opportunities with a faculty mentor, and an active learning style”. It’s offered to 30 kids out of a little under 600 freshman. S would definitely need more details on that, but it could offer a more challenging environment for the A-/B+ kid.</p>

<p>Yabeyabe: I was actually doing the geographic distribution from memory but I got pretty close: NJ 34%, PA 22%, NY 19%. This is from the Fall 2011 Freshman profile pamphlet we received.</p>

<p>Having done previous school visits during Feb break, Spring break, at at a summer open house, we alway had pretty large tour groups regardless of the college size. So the personal tour at Muhlenberg was pretty great. At Bing, since it was a quiet week (and the week of the hurricane!), they took out maybe 4 groups of 20; not too large at all.</p>

<p>It’s interesting you mention the M/F ratios; I don’t think this is really on S’ radar. At least it hasn’t been a criteria either way. Males at Muhl stand at 39% (pretty low), about the same as Conn College, and 3-4 points below Vassar and Brandeis. There seem to be relatively few schools in the NE that are better than 45/55 M/F.</p>

<p>Thanks for reading and sharing your thoughts, I appreciate it.</p>

<p>Edited to add: Regarding ED, I was surprised to see that Muhlenberg’s ED and RD dates are the same: Feb 15th! So they likely give weight to ED, but it’s OK if they’re your second, third, fourth, or fifth choice!</p>

<p>mutti - great trip reports - very interesting. Muhlenberg was one of the schools I had on S2’s list and he never seemed that interested in it and so we never got there. I am pretty sure they doing rolling ED - so 2/15 might be the latest to submit an ED app - but you can submit it earlier and get an earlier decision.</p>

<p>Just checking in with this group…my S1 is all moved in (launched?!) to his college as of last week and S2 has officially started his sophomore year of h.s.</p>

<p>Mutti: Thanks for Bing report. Does anyone think there is a similarity between Bing and Syracuse? Except the price of course…what would be some of the differences?</p>

<p>I’m probably not going to be on cc that much for the time being…I promised myself that once S1 was settled into college, that I would take more time to go and exercise and get projects done around the house. </p>

<p>Hope everyone’s fall application season goes well and I’ll check in from time to time.</p>

<p>Take care choc and we will see you around!</p>

<p>You are right on about the importance of applicants “showing the love” for MC. Their official statement on ED is: “When you apply Early Decision, you’re expressing your preference in a way that is powerful and important. Nothing else in the application process provides this same opportunity. Last year, 322 of the 580 students that became the freshman class were admitted Early Decision.” On Naviance, the ED/RD stat difference is significant. As with many schools, because they are used as a safety so often, which both hurts their USNWR yield % and causes them to waste a lot of money recruiting kids who go elsewhere, they give a big preference to ED kids. As you noted, you can apply ED as late as 2/15, which seems the equivalent of the ED II date at other schools. I wonder if the increase in the PA % for the class of 2011 reflects the recession keeping more kids close to home?</p>

<p>Perhaps going on tours during breaks gave you larger tour groups at small schools, vs. our Saturday visits. </p>

<p>Unfortunately, small school ratios skew heavily female, as many lack such “male magnets” as big time sports (or even football teams), engineering, IT, business, ROTC and sports management. But in this NY Times article, they say that nationally, men are only 42% of college students: [At</a> Colleges, Women Are Leaving Men in the Dust - New York Times](<a href=“At Colleges, Women Are Leaving Men in the Dust - The New York Times”>At Colleges, Women Are Leaving Men in the Dust - The New York Times)</p>

<p>Choc, the biggest difference other than price between Bing and Syracuse may be that Syracuse has a perpetually Top 20 basketball team and a Division 1 football team, while Bing has no football team and their recent attempt at going bigtime in basketball resulted in a huge scandal. As a result, the large numbers of kids seeking rah rah big sports campuses are more likely to apply to Syracuse and Penn State or UConn rather than Bing.</p>

<p>Mutti, thanks for the reviews of Bing and Muhlenberg. Muhl is on my daughter’s list of colleges she wants to look at so I was glad to see such a positive review.</p>

<p>That article in the NYT was pretty hair-raising, both in thinking about my daughter (a junior) but also my two boys. I want her to have a nice variety of guys to meet and date while she is at college. Not because that is WHY she is going but it is certainly a fun benefit! And I want to somehow ensure that my boys don’t grow up having little drive and ambition. I just hope we are doing the right things now!</p>