<p>yay! my D has officially completed all of her apps! </p>
<p>Yesteday in the car she mentioned one of her friends (a top student) is planning to apply to 18 colleges! Yikes!</p>
<p>As to Muhlenberg, all the kids I know of who attend there are very happy. I think it is a self selecting bunch, though. As was mentioned, it is a small nurturing school with an artsy side and a large Jewish presence; but there is not much diversity- and that can feel comfortable to some but stifling to others.</p>
<p>pamom: Happy for you that the apps are done! One less thing to worry about now!</p>
<p>choc: I totally understand the stepping away. We are always here if you want to chat!</p>
<p>Mutti: Great report on Bing. Didn’t mirror our experience there when we toured a couple of years ago, but appreciate hearing about how it went for you. Going back with DS this fall (and it doesn’t fit what he wants either, except that it is a better fit for my budget!). DD had a close friend there who already offered to show DS around so we will get an “insider” tour too. That seems to help.</p>
<p>chocchip - hope you come back to visit from time to time! Good luck to your son.</p>
<p>pamom - congrats on having the apps done! Such a relief. S2 just has one more essay to go - submit that last app and then we are totally done as well.</p>
<p>Wow, pamom, how great for your dd and you! I wish I could light that fire under my dd, but the first attempt at all apps is done and the essays for almost all are at least in first to second draft. Her portfolio will be a work in progress until it is submitted, but very positive feedback from schools that told her to work on it for merit money. So, I am hoping to have a mid October time frame, at least at some of the rolling schools. </p>
<p>I hope you have all had a wonderful holiday weekend! I believe the temperatures are finally out of the hundreds today but still no rain. I will say that my stamina for swimming laps is much improved :). But please nobody light a match.</p>
<p>RVM: Congrats! I’m so happy for you! Good luck with the new job and you too Levirm.</p>
<p>RVM: So, so happy to hear of the new job! Especially now that S2 has the end is sight for his applications, you’ll be able to dive right into your new job knowing that the part of the college app process that you can control is checked off! What an enormous accomplishment (for both you and S2)!</p>
<p>Good luck! I know from going through a re-fi last year that the market is busy!!!</p>
<p>I think that the addition of the countdown clock makes the rankings seem like more of a marketing ploy (i.e., selling magazines; selling colleges). I find myself torn: do I hope that schools my S is interested in haven’t increased their rankings (and therefore perhaps, selectivity)? Or do I hope that rankings confirm the value we see in various schools?</p>
<p>The USN rankings have always been about selling magazines. USN does not even sell an actual newstand news magazine anymore, just the the moneymaking guides. There has been so much written about how easy–and common-- it is to game the USN system that I suggest you not worry about them and stick to that which you can control.</p>
<p>Thanks, yabeyabe, I didn’t realise that USN didn’t sell a newstand mag anymore. I use the Internet so much for all my news content.</p>
<p>Not really worried, per se, just more “interested” to see where colleges are this year. For example, we’ve talked about Elon on this thread a lot and I wonder whether the “rankings” for a school like Elon have translated into an increase in applications. I’m sure that’s what Elon would like. They are very quick to post rankings data on their website.</p>
<p>so when it updates in a few days you’re not going to be seeing the Fall 2011 acceptance rate. You’ll be seeing the Fall 2010 acceptance rate, which you can figure out from information which is already available on the common data set. See C1 for the volume of applications. You can look at the CDS from the past few years to compare and see changes or trends.</p>
<p>It is an understandable interest, but it can add to anxiety, for both you and your child. The validation which comes from a higher ranking of the school to which your child is applying comes at the cost of more applications to that school. More applications will lead to a higher ranking, which may then trigger even more applications, etc. It is unlikely that a single year’s change in ranking will lead to dramatically higher odds of acceptance, but a moderate effect is certainly possible, just as it has always been, as colleges have employed consultants to dramatically increase their applications through mass emails and mailings of free “priority applications.” Colleges sometimes take a year to figure out how many of the increased applicants are actually likely to attend.</p>
<p>The guidance to parents, however, does not change. A rise in USN ranking is far from a guarantee of a good fit; no child or parent should get their heart set on any one school, because strange things happen; your child’s interest in a school is much more likely to be influenced by the tour guide than the USN ranking; their happiness is much more likely to be influenced by a roommate than a ranking; and their success is much more likely to be influenced by them clicking with a teacher than a ranking.</p>
<p>Parents also need to beware the common trap of the parental spy wars at competitive high schools, where parents will mislead or lie about where their child is applying and try to find out who else is applying there. </p>
<p>Ranking mania now crosses borders: international students on CC frequently post references to purported international rankings of universities; one of the most common ones lists Penn State and Minnesota well above Dartmouth, Rice, Vanderbilt and the University of Chicago, which no US-based ranking would do unless referring to a specific department.<br>
Best of luck.</p>
<p>911C2S - I don’t have the source handy - but applications at Elon were actually down 6% in the Fall 2010 as compared to the previous year. I asked Nancy Luberoff of Hillel what she thought about this - and I rcvd an email from the head of admissions in response. His take was that fluctuations will occur from year to year - and that if you looked at 2008, 2009 and 2010 - the numbers were fairly consistent. I believe the acceptance rate at Elon increased to slightly over 50% for the fall of 2010.</p>
<p>Some additional info/speculation on Elon’s admission rates from last fall:</p>
<p>congrats to those who finished apps. It is a great feeling to start the school year and not have those hanging over S’s head.</p>
<p>At party this weekend and the Questions came up, where is S applying. I proudly said ED to Elon to get the where is that, never heard of it question. Thanks to you all I didn’t quote stats or rankings. I just said where it is located and how it is the perfect fit for S!</p>
<p>samtalya - I have been pleasantly surprised that everyone who has asked where S2 is applying has heard of Elon! It’s Susquehanna that gets the “huh” and blank looks!</p>
<p>The Elon rep will be at S2’s hs next week - so that gives him one last chance to ask whatever questions he has and make the ED/EA decision.</p>
<p>Samtayla: It sounds like your handled the Elon question quite well.</p>
<p>At the BU Freshman Matriculatition on Sunday, the university president mentioned rankings and that there are many more important factors in choosing a university, as yabe pointed out. He basically told the kids who were hung up on the rankings to get over it and embrace all the opportunities they were about to encounter. </p>
<p>My D has made a lot of friends at BU who, like her, attended the summer program, fell in love with the school and applied ED. Those kids are very happy to be there. I’m very thankful that she found a good fit.</p>
<p>Thanks, Deborah and RVM for the links. I found the info on Elon especially interesting since the adcom during our summer visit seemed to indicate that Elon was getting to be a tougher admit, and maybe this has to do with the rise in average stats of the applicant pool. The adcom said that Elon admitted 80% ED, 40% EA and 20% RD. (I don’t recall the exact numbers, they may have been 82/42/22, but were definitely with this type of breakdown). He basically said that if you’re interested at all in Elon, you need to apply EA.</p>
<p>Thank you, Yabe, for the rankings insight. It’s especially good advice about the parental spying. This is my first time through the college process since my own experience and it’s definitely changed in the past 30 years!</p>
<p>My use of the rankings data has been as a starting point for researching colleges. There are so many LACs that I’ve never heard of prior to using various tools, including rankings data and sites like this. Dickinson, Wooster and Denison are examples that come to mind. When the new rankings come out, I’ll again take a look to see if there are any schools that we hadn’t considered before.</p>
<p>Speaking of rankings, I was surprised to see Elon listed as a Regional college. If the parents on this thread are any indication, that may be changing soon! Actually, is that a designation made by USNWR or some outside force?</p>
<p>Samtalya, thanks, I enjoy writing up the trip reports and am only sorry I wasn’t on this thread back in Frebruary when S and and I visited 6 schools over his break. Since then, until our trip last week, he’s looked at schools with DH and with friends so I don’t have first hand knowledge to share.</p>
<p>I definitely got a few quizzical looks re: Muhlenberg. Huh? Where? But one friend lit up; apparently a number of her staunchly Lutheran aunts, uncles, and cousins went there back when the major draw was the school’s religious focus. Times sure have changed there, in a relatively short while.</p>
<p>First day of senior year: tomorrow (bittersweet!)</p>
<p>Mutti: I enjoyed your visit reports. I think that we had the same tour guide you had a Binghamton at Syracuse. She was so perky and annoying that we escaped early also.</p>