Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>I’ll put in another voice about rankings. I won’t be so glib as to say that they are meaningless. But rankings are different from quality - there is a lot of flim-flam in how the rankings are done. I do think that the top 50 schools are in many ways the top 50 schools. I think the top 100 are probably different - and likely “better” in real ways - than the ones ranked below them, although even in that group it starts to get hazy. After 100, anything goes. I think there are truly “second-rate” colleges, but really that’s 4th-tier in this system (where you can get in no matter what you did in HS). My personal “quality” system puts lots of schools about even at the highest level, and lots more at a high level. Name recognition, in my opinion, is useless. ONLY Harvard, Yale and maybe MIT (and a few sports schools or ones recognizable by location name) are known to the general public. So for me, name is completely irrelevant. This fact has been driven home to me because I have lived half my life in one region and the other half in another. It is completely arbitrary how and why people “know” about a school. The only exception is within academia itself and with certain employers, but no one has proved that “name” schools are the key to anything there, either.</p>

<p>My D1 went to a top-50 (probably top-30) school with only OK name recognition in the “regular” world, but among academics and serious employers is extremely well respected. She was a top-stats student and it was a wonderful school for her - she went there for fit, but she also wanted the most academically challenging experience she could get. She is finding now that her diploma is definitely raising eyebrows as she looks for jobs. I can’t say that she would have had worse luck without the “name.” But she also has had a sense as she gets out with people from other schools that while it’s truly all about the individual, she can’t deny that the kind of education a “top” school gives does have a certain value. I only say that because I just can’t say that it “doesn’t matter at all” where a school is ranked. There are ways in which it might. </p>

<p>HOWEVER: The more kids I know, and the more people I meet, and especially since I’ve just gone through a very different admissions process with D2, I have to say that I agree 100% with yabe’s statements. We HAD to go with fit for D2, for lots of reasons - she had lower stats, but also was looking for a different kind of program and a different kind of experience. And we had to tell people that, if we even bothered to explain where she was applying. Luckily for us, “out east” was usually an interesting enough answer, and “special programs” absolved us of any expectations that she’d go to a “known” school.</p>

<p>Yet as I have mentioned a few times here, we hit the “rankings” wall late in the game - she did get into a few top-100 schools, one that’s more like top-50. She went through a quite hellish couple of weeks, in a very personal way, coming to terms with giving up a name, a sense of family legacy (not at that school, but that so many of us have gone to top schools), and a strong fear that she would be giving up “quality” at a highly “ranked” school for a school that gave her better fit and exactly the program she wants.</p>

<p>I can’t tell the end of her story yet - but I can say that as we drove east to move her into this lovely, unknown school, I felt so happy. I know I would have felt terrible if we were sending her to one of those “top” schools where she truly didn’t feel she’d get what she needed in the long run, no matter how nice it would have been to say she was going there. </p>

<p>And as we went to matriculation, we all got just as excited and special a feeling as we did at D1’s matriculation 4 years ago. It’s all about GOING TO COLLEGE. Plus, H turned to me and said, “I have to admit that while it was great for D1, at her school this part was much more stuffy. It really feels right for D2 here.”</p>

<p>A friend who’s daughter daughter is interested in Muhlenberg wanted me to ask you this: What if she applies ED and is not given any kind of aid. she doesn’t qualify for financial aid, but are there other merit possibilities? Is Ed binding if you don’t get the money you feel you need?</p>

<p>What other schools are similar to Muhlenberg in terms of a caring community, but less money? (2-6000 students) Of course i told her what i think, but she wants others’ opinions.</p>

<p>thanks</p>

<p>ps wish she would come on this board, but she works ooooooodles of hours and won’t.</p>

<p>Samtalya, that’s an interesting question. I always thought a student could legally withdraw from ED if *need-based *financial aid had been applied for but didn’t come through in sufficient amount, but I don’t know if that extends to merit aid. You might want to post this in the Financial Aid forum too.</p>

<p>For Mutti</p>

<p>“Regional Universities: Like the national universities, regional universities (as defined by the Carnegie Foundation as universities-master’s larger, medium and smaller programs) provide a full range of undergraduate programs and some master’s level programs. They offer few, if any, doctoral programs.”</p>

<p>[Methodology:</a> Best Colleges Ranking Category Definitions - US News and World Report](<a href=“http://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/articles/2011/09/05/methodology-best-colleges-ranking-category-definitions]Methodology:”>http://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/articles/2011/09/05/methodology-best-colleges-ranking-category-definitions)</p>

<p>samtalya, The cut and dried answer to your question about how binding is ED, is that one is plain not supposed to apply ED unless they are prepared to pay whatever the colleges thinks their need is. Two colleges that I think are similar in terms of friendliness as Muhlenberg are Hartwick College in Oneonta, NY and Roanoke Colllege in Salem, VA. I attend church within 10 minutes of Muhlenberg and it has a very good reputation in the region. It’s in a consortium with Lehigh and Lafayette, and a few other Lehigh Valley colleges.</p>

<p>My youngest son was accepted to Hartwick and was given very good merit aid. If the program he was interested in attending were just a bit stronger there, it may have made the cut. Our oldest son graduated last year from Roanoke and the admissions person for our region actually went to college with that son and she agreed about the similarity of the two colleges. Since this is the Jewish B student thread, I will give the nod to Hartwick with regards to a better Jewish tilt.</p>

<p>Thanks DebT. That makes sense.</p>

<p>Samtalya, re “lower cost Muhlenbergs”, I would give your friend 3 pieces of advice:</p>

<ol>
<li><p>A slight drop in selectivity can yield substantially more merit aid, so do not go by sticker price alone.</p></li>
<li><p>Generally, moving west from the East Coast helps, as the college’s costs drop, but if flying is involved, the difference between airports with more than one incoming airline and those can will add up to thousands of dollars over the course of a year with 5-8 flights, often at peak holiday fares.</p></li>
<li><p>I have not compared their 2011 sticker prices with Muhlenberg, but people looking for small nurturing schools in this category often choose among Juniata, Alfred, Roanoke, Susquehanna, St. Olaf, Hartwick, Moravian, Alleghenny, Dickinson, Lycoming, Washington and Gettysburg.</p></li>
</ol>

<p>(trying to catch up after two weeks of vacation and dropping D1 at school huzzah huzzah)</p>

<p>Great article on the usual kid-off-to-college theme, but with a lovely Jewish twist. [To</a> my child on the way to college | Opinion | Jewish Journal](<a href=“http://www.jewishjournal.com/opinion/article/to_my_child_on_the_way_to_college_20110831/]To”>http://www.jewishjournal.com/opinion/article/to_my_child_on_the_way_to_college_20110831/)</p>

<p>samtalya, regarding Muhlenberg and ED and merit aid, I remember reading on the Muhlenberg site that unlike many schools they preferentially give merit aid to ED applicants rather than RD. The philosophy is that they should reward those that love them the most. That said, I read that a couple of years ago, and have no idea if it’s still the case. And if your friend’s child’s stats are in range for merit money, it might still be fine for RD.</p>

<p>As far as getting out of an ED commitment if the merit money isn’t up to scratch, my first thought is to ask on the Financial Aid forum and also on the general parents forum. My second thought is to have the student apply for FA, even if the family’s numbers indicate that they’ll be full-pay. That would give a (perhaps ethically murky) back door to be let out of ED if no merit money comes in. It also signals the admissions folks that this is a student/family that is looking for merit aid. </p>

<p>If it were any school but Muhlenberg, I’d say go for just RD. Based on what I’d read before, I think more due diligence is called for.</p>

<p>My understanding is that if you apply to a school ED and then back out because you think it’s a financial hardship, the school will let you, but they will tell the other schools in that cohort, who will be much less likely to accept you. The exception is if you back out and choose an in-state public, which would prove that money really did make a difference. This has been discussed many times on this site. Here’s one thread about it: <a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/473601-what-exactly-happens-if-you-back-out-early-decision.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/473601-what-exactly-happens-if-you-back-out-early-decision.html&lt;/a&gt; This article explains ED and EA very well: [Early</a> Decision and Early Action FAQ](<a href=“http://www.top-law-schools.com/early-decision-early-action.html]Early”>Early Decision and Early Action FAQ)</p>

<p>I understand that Muhlenberg encourages ED and rewards those students, but I would never suggest that for someone that was not prepared to pay almost full price.</p>

<p>ST</p>

<p>“Listen to the word of Torah: Separate the light from the dark.”</p>

<p>Loved this line. :)</p>

<p>Re applying for FA you do not think you will get to give a (perhaps ethically murky) back door" to backing out of an ED acceptance, I agree it is ethically murky (at best) and do not think people should engage in “perhaps ethically murky” behavior and, especially, not involve their children in it. As kathiep noted, applying ED usually involves promising to accept whatever FA is offered–including none–unless your cirumstances have had a dramatic downturn, such as losing your job after the application is filed. </p>

<p>This flunks the “front page” test–would you want a story about your doing this read by the public? Or, in CC terms,would you consider doing this if after you did it, every other college your child was applying to was notified of what you had done?</p>

<p>On the Muhlenberg question - I would suggest she have a very frank conversation with their admissions rep. Ask for an “early read” on both need-based and merit aid. They should be able to give some feedback - and if the result is not encouraging - she should not apply ED. Muhlenberg is small enough and the reps I have met are certainly approachable enough that this can be done.</p>

<p>From their website:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Note in particular the last sentence about requiring test scores for merit aid.</p>

<p>And more info on the ED/FA question:</p>

<p>

</li>
</ol>

<p>I find these 2 paragraphs somewhat in conflict. On one hand, saying you will be told about FA before being required to deposit sounds like an escape clause - but then paragraph 4 negates that. </p>

<p>Am I missing something?</p>

<p>RVM, to me the blanket nature of par. 4 and the lack of an explicit escape clause suggests that they are strongly discouraging applicants from thinking there is an escape clause, rather than just an early warning to gather money from other sources.</p>

<p>In addition, I do not know national averages, but roughly 25% of an incoming class receiving any merit aid–including some who receive need-based aid, seems so me lower than many schools at that sticker price and selectivity level. At our HS, the ED stats are well below the RD; taken together, it might suggest that ED works for kids whose parents are willing to pay full sticker and think their kids need the less selective ED selectivity.</p>

<p>I’m just hoping that once every college has their net price calculators on their websites - deadline is the end of October - some of this chaos will be resolved. There is no other purchase process that I can think of where you don’t know the price of the good/service you are purchasing until after you have agreed to purchase it! (Speaking strictly of ED).</p>

<p>For S2 - I’m still waiting to see FA calculators for Elon and Susquehanna. JMU and VT have them up already. Of course - it is just an estimate - but an estimate from the actual school is better than what we have to work with now - which is basically - assume you are paying the full price.</p>

<p>@samtalya
Here is an interesting article from the NY Times on how binding ED is, by Dr. Robert Massa, vice president for communications at Lafayette College:
[The</a> Case for Early Decision - NYTimes.com](<a href=“http://thechoice.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/12/13/the-case-for-early-decision/]The”>The Case for Early Decision - The New York Times)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Hi all…thought I would Check in…</p>

<p>RVM: mazel tov!! A slightly diff direction but best of luck!</p>

<p>Re: Muhlenberg and FA: the early read is supposed to eliminate any guesswork. I would be curious ( if interested) to find out if any early reads have been unpleasantly surprised. I, personally, have not heard of any disappointing FA results from the 'Berg and, honestly, could not imagine that given the way they operate, that there would be any.</p>

<p>Re: merit aid: every student we know that received merit at Muhlenberg applied and was accepted ED and was awarded the merit after acceptance.</p>

<p>Re:elon: one thing that I think was left out of the discussion was the fact that they intentionally increased the # admitted this most recent cycle in an effort to increase the size of the class. Goal is 1500; it’s not there yet. and while they do care about certain rankings, changing categories from regional to national has not ever been mentioned to my knowledge.</p>

<p>Good luck to all the rising seniors as the application process begins… I applaud all the parents on this thread and the rest of CC; I am literally pulling my hair out with families who have done nothing with the process yet and are looking for miracles</p>

<p>Never mind; it’s late. You were talking about Elon, I was still reading Muhlenberg (as in…going from 2,500 to 6,000!)</p>

<p>LC82, bear in mind his next paragraph: “It’s not that colleges are being deceptive in failing to disclose this practice, but they certainly don’t want to encourage students’ “bailing” from an early-decision commitment based on the “I can’t afford it” excuse.” </p>

<p>Again, it should matter to people not just whether they can get away with reneging on an ED committment because they think they might do better elsewhere later, but whether it is the ethically right thing to do.</p>

<p>The author’s motivation was to dispel the view that needy students were needy students had no option in the case of meager needs-based aid, stating that was a 'misinformation" which "disenfranchises lower income students by legitimizing their tendency to avoid early-decision programs that could benefit them significantly. That is very different from condoning reneging on ED because merit-based aid was not as much as you hoped.</p>

<p>If the morality argument does not persuade people, Kathiep’s warning that colleges will inform other schools should.</p>

<p>On ED and ethics:</p>

<p>" There is no other purchase process that I can think of where you don’t know the price of the good/service you are purchasing until after you have agreed to purchase it! (Speaking strictly of ED)." ( quoting RVM)</p>

<p>Because this is the case I don’t see a lack of morality in withdrawing for financial reasons. If an applicant has in good faith made a decision that a particular school is their clear first choice, and that he/she will attend the school if it the cost doesn’t exceed a maximum limit; if this limit is realistic, then I don’t see any ethical obligation to attend the school if the school does not meet need as the family sees it. I really like RVM’s suggestion to get a read on the school from the front end. I agree with Yabe that when you apply ED you give up your chance to find your best offer. There is however, nothing unethical about saying that you cannot afford the final price of the school. Unfortunately we often don’t really know this until after the acceptance comes in.</p>

<p>Having said that my S1 did not apply ED even though he did have a clear first choice. We just didn’t want to have to deal with determining if we could meet the dollar amount offered and the stress of being released from obligation if we felt we could not afford it.</p>

<p>On attending a school flying distance away:
Since this was mentioned earlier today. If you are looking at the possibility of a student attending a school that is far enough away that they will have to fly home, I can make a huge difference in cost if you accumulate frequent flyer miles well in advance. (Those of you with HS sophs this can really help if you start accumulating early.) It also helps to know your kid and know how important it will be for you to visit or for them to come home several times a year. Some kids will get by with 2 round trips a year. Others may need many more.</p>

<p>Poking a bit more at bowing out of ED if it doesn’t work out financially for the family: the specific wording in the CA ED agreement is “Should a student who applies for financial aid not be offered an award that makes attendance possible, the student may decline the offer of admission and be released from the Early Decision commitment.” </p>

<p>I think that’s a real escape hatch. In the past two years in all my reading about ED on CC I’ve never seen anyone comment that a school that’s spurned for financial reasons in ED will ‘spread the word’ to the cohort. Since schools have huge variations in the amount of FA awarded, the amount of loans in a package, and the school’s interpretation of what is “meeting full need”, I believe that the schools have no option but to let people out of ED for financial reasons without blackballing them. ED is a huge advantage for any student whose family can afford full pay. The schools that offer ED use the financial escape clause to say that nonsense, anyone can apply ED without risk regardless of their financial situation. If they then turned around and slimed the poor people who can’t make the package work…well, that would end up biting them on the tuchis. </p>

<p>The schools can also offer the escape hatch because people will be so happy about good admissions news that they’ll take on a less-than-optimal FA package.</p>