<p>I’ll put in another voice about rankings. I won’t be so glib as to say that they are meaningless. But rankings are different from quality - there is a lot of flim-flam in how the rankings are done. I do think that the top 50 schools are in many ways the top 50 schools. I think the top 100 are probably different - and likely “better” in real ways - than the ones ranked below them, although even in that group it starts to get hazy. After 100, anything goes. I think there are truly “second-rate” colleges, but really that’s 4th-tier in this system (where you can get in no matter what you did in HS). My personal “quality” system puts lots of schools about even at the highest level, and lots more at a high level. Name recognition, in my opinion, is useless. ONLY Harvard, Yale and maybe MIT (and a few sports schools or ones recognizable by location name) are known to the general public. So for me, name is completely irrelevant. This fact has been driven home to me because I have lived half my life in one region and the other half in another. It is completely arbitrary how and why people “know” about a school. The only exception is within academia itself and with certain employers, but no one has proved that “name” schools are the key to anything there, either.</p>
<p>My D1 went to a top-50 (probably top-30) school with only OK name recognition in the “regular” world, but among academics and serious employers is extremely well respected. She was a top-stats student and it was a wonderful school for her - she went there for fit, but she also wanted the most academically challenging experience she could get. She is finding now that her diploma is definitely raising eyebrows as she looks for jobs. I can’t say that she would have had worse luck without the “name.” But she also has had a sense as she gets out with people from other schools that while it’s truly all about the individual, she can’t deny that the kind of education a “top” school gives does have a certain value. I only say that because I just can’t say that it “doesn’t matter at all” where a school is ranked. There are ways in which it might. </p>
<p>HOWEVER: The more kids I know, and the more people I meet, and especially since I’ve just gone through a very different admissions process with D2, I have to say that I agree 100% with yabe’s statements. We HAD to go with fit for D2, for lots of reasons - she had lower stats, but also was looking for a different kind of program and a different kind of experience. And we had to tell people that, if we even bothered to explain where she was applying. Luckily for us, “out east” was usually an interesting enough answer, and “special programs” absolved us of any expectations that she’d go to a “known” school.</p>
<p>Yet as I have mentioned a few times here, we hit the “rankings” wall late in the game - she did get into a few top-100 schools, one that’s more like top-50. She went through a quite hellish couple of weeks, in a very personal way, coming to terms with giving up a name, a sense of family legacy (not at that school, but that so many of us have gone to top schools), and a strong fear that she would be giving up “quality” at a highly “ranked” school for a school that gave her better fit and exactly the program she wants.</p>
<p>I can’t tell the end of her story yet - but I can say that as we drove east to move her into this lovely, unknown school, I felt so happy. I know I would have felt terrible if we were sending her to one of those “top” schools where she truly didn’t feel she’d get what she needed in the long run, no matter how nice it would have been to say she was going there. </p>
<p>And as we went to matriculation, we all got just as excited and special a feeling as we did at D1’s matriculation 4 years ago. It’s all about GOING TO COLLEGE. Plus, H turned to me and said, “I have to admit that while it was great for D1, at her school this part was much more stuffy. It really feels right for D2 here.”</p>