Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>

If the affiliated schools use the same financial aid calculator, there’s no point in making the same FA offer; if the student couldn’t afford it at ED time, other schools will assume the same at RD time.</p>

<p>But if another school can afford to offer more aid, and/or wants the applicant more than the ED school did, it may very well offer a better aid package than the ED school did.</p>

<p>many thanks to all of you for your advice. i sent all your comments and links to my friend re: the berg. u r all awesome as usual.</p>

<p>Saving frequent flyer miles for trips home is a good plan, but check your airline’s destinations and blackout dates first. Unfortunately, an increasing number of airports are served by only 1 carrier and it is common for airlines to prevent FF miles from being used for trips near the holidays.</p>

<p>On ED, everyone agrees that genuine need issues are an appropriate out; the disagreement is over using not receiving hoped for merit aid as a justification. The preview option urged by RVM and Rodney seems to be a fine solution for any parent whose decision would hinge on merit aid.</p>

<p>If your child ends up at a school that requires flying, I recommend getting an airline credit card for an airline that serves that city. We got a Southwest card this spring, and we’ve already gotten some free flights to Boston. We’re actually very lucky because 3 airlines currently fry from BWI to Boston. Generally, flights are frequent and cheap. That was one of the things we considered considering schools.</p>

<p>Yabeyabe: Good point about the frequent flyer miles. We were lucky that the miles we had saved for no particular reason work to get my S to and from school. Sometimes not the most direct flights and definitely not S’s airline of choice, but free works for college students and fortunately we have been able to book early and haven’t had a problem with blackout dates because of this. I’m sure all programs are different.</p>

<p>On the ED question, I’m not sure how colleges look at it but I have known lots of folks whose EFC’s are high enough to preclude FA but still do not feel that they can afford the sticker price of a college. When the cost of college is 200K+ this is a very individual decision and need isn’t always cleanly defined by calculations or even by the more flexible CSS. I don’t see it as any less ethical to decline a school for lack of funds if the EFC is too high to qualify the student for FA than it would be for a student with a low EFC. In the former case merit aid is probably the only hope the student has to make the school affordable. This is still a different thing than declining an ED school because of a better offer elsewhere.</p>

<p>From what I understand, in the ED process, once you get an admission, you need to notify other schools you’ve applied to in order to withdraw your application and this may often be prior to the Spring when the merit and FA decisions are made. Therefore, you need to know when you get that ED admission that you can go (and therefore withdraw the other apps).</p>

<p>Don’t know how much the schools communicate regarding whether or not the app has been withdrawn. Certainly the GC would know and would not want to see the name of the HS get muddied.</p>

<p>If you apply for FA from the ED school, you can wait until you’ve received your FA package before notifying schools that you’re withdrawing apps.</p>

<p>ED schools typically even give two weeks to a month to decide if the offer is enough to support attendance.</p>

<p>^^Slithey: that would make sense;</p>

<p>unless, of course, it’s like Emory, who does not release final FA packages until after RD decisions (unless something has changed recently)
There are stories on CC in years past of nightmarish scenarios down in Coke land…</p>

<p>rodney, that problem with final FA packages being issued at RD time is a problem for all ED schools. My impression is that it’s a big problem when the family doesn’t use accurate numbers when submitting the FA docs during the ED round. Or does Emory have a reputation for giving out seriously different final FA packages, even when the family accurately filled out their FA info at ED time?</p>

<p>^ no idea if the families were accurate or not; all I know is what I have read on here</p>

<p>Here’s an interesting little story for you guys …</p>

<p>D had her first discussion class in Lit yesterday. Said a girl was “incredibly opinionated, obnoxious” and dominated the conversation. Said, “the worst thing is that she was Jewish,” very conservative (as opposed to liberal, not reform) in her views, and D felt defensive.</p>

<p>So here is an unexpected tidbit in going to a school with more Jews (as in more than just D) … I don’t think she thought she’d feel quite so same-but-different. It’s all a big education, isn’t it? She said she knows people are going to be all over the spectrum, Jewish or not. I just think she was surprised at how personally she took this girl’s behavior. She has a new friend in that same class who happens to be African-American - not that she’s never known anyone who isn’t white, but I get the impression they both were offended by this girl and this will spur them to discuss their feelings and various perspectives. I think the cultural broadening we all hoped for will be even richer than we anticipated. Hurray!</p>

<p>Interesting observation EmmyBet - kind of reminds me of how I feel when I read a news story about a Jewish person being charged with a crime (Madoff, etc.) it always seems more personal.</p>

<p>In other news, S2 has been trying to request his transcripts be sent out from his large public hs. Right now - I think he is attending their satellite campus in the former Soviet Union - lines, bureaucracy and stupidity abound.</p>

<p>Yesterday he waited in line for nearly 40 minutes - his entire lunch period. He finally made it to the front of the line - only to be turned away because he did not have his SS# with him. I have never seen or heard any mention of needing it for the purpose of sending out transcripts.</p>

<p>Today - he waited in line for his entire lunch period again - made it to the front - completed their form and paid for his transcripts. But - the moron at the desk insisted that he needed an Early Decision form for Elon. I had warned him that this question would come up - so he was prepared with the answer - Elon is not a Common App school and there is no ED form that needs to be signed by the counselor. Moron did not believe him - and told him to come back with the form tomorrow and that his request would not be processed without it.</p>

<p>I have now called the GC and emailed the GC, the head of guidance and the college coordinator. We’ll see how easily this gets resolved. Meanwhile - gray hairs sprout.</p>

<p>RVM: I gather that the big decision to go ED to Elon has been made. Anything in particular made it the strong fave?</p>

<p>Actually - that decision is still pending. The ED deadline is 11/1 and pursuant to our conversation above about the challenges of ED and needing FA - I want to wait for him to submit the actual application until I have been in the new job for at least 2 weeks and feel it is going ok. So - I don’t see us finalizing the decision and him submitting the application until mid-October.</p>

<p>Our hs requires 6+ weeks lead time to send out transcripts. So - even though the ED deadline is not until 11/1 - he needed to turn in his transcript request now - and we decided that it made more sense to request it for the ED deadline of 11/1 rather than the EA deadline of 11/10 just in case he does want to do ED. But - not 100% definite yet.</p>

<p>He is more comfortable now running through the pros and cons of each school. And if we remove the financial issue and just look at what he likes - he ended up putting Elon at the top followed by James Madison. The sports mgmt major became the biggest factor - with those 2 being the schools he liked best that offered it. He is hesitant about schools like VT where he would pretty much need to plan on being a business major - which he thinks might not be the right choice for him. He really likes the 4-1-4 schedule at Elon and the study abroad option in January - and the size feels right - not too big and not too small.</p>

<p>The Elon rep will be at his hs next week - so that will be his opportunity to get any lingering questions answered. </p>

<p>I do think he has had a very careful, thoughtful process. Started with Elon at the top of the list last year - branched out a bit and considered some larger schools and one smaller one - really kept an open mind - and now he seems to have come full circle and be back at Elon. So - we are happy with his tentative decision - but still waiting a few weeks to press submit.</p>

<p>RVM: doesn’t your HS have an earlier deadline for ED transcripts? And if they don’t, curious as to how they prioritize.</p>

<p>Rockville - I am glad my D hasn’t tried to get her transcripts yet! She was going to go today, but had to stand in line for her parking permit instead! Then it turns out, since she hasn’t done her senior picture yet, she doesn’t have a current id card and can’t request transcripts without one. Nice to find that out today! What ED form are they talking about? D will probably be applying ED but I just looked on the common app and can’t find any form to print out. Under the schools supplement, you check off ED, but other than that, I can’t find anything. Help please! Thanks!</p>

<p>It’s basically that any November deadlines - whether EA or ED - need to be turned in this month - I think by 9/23. But they can only turn them in before school and during lunch - and there is often a huge line - so I wanted him to get it done this week. My concern was that while he could take until mid-October to finalize his decision on EA vs. ED - he had to turn in the request now - so it was easier to say it was ED - which it most likely will be. If he changes his mind and does EA - he will certainly let his GC know - but my focus is on getting the transcript sent out.</p>

<p>How do they prioritize? Who knows. I understand they send out 4000 transcript packets each year - and that’s a big undertaking - but they make the process fairly painful.</p>

<p>mdmom - here’s the link for the Common App ED form:</p>

<p><a href=“https://www.commonapp.org/commonapp/Docs/DownloadForms/2012/2012EarlyDecision_download.pdf[/url]”>https://www.commonapp.org/commonapp/Docs/DownloadForms/2012/2012EarlyDecision_download.pdf&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>print out the form - fill it out - you sign and student signs - and then she brings it to the registrar when she requests her transcripts.</p>

<p>See - you know what I’m talking about - S2 also stood in line for his parking permit today. He missed lunch - missed part of his AP class - all he did today was stand in line. I swear - satellite campus in former Soviet Union is the image that comes to mind. </p>

<p>On a funnier note - he was very proud that by the end of the day he had accomplished these 2 tasks and had been very determined as far as going back several times. I suggested he might want to put the same level of focus on his senior year academics - he laughed.</p>

<p>Okay, I know I’m just lazy for not going over 662 PAGES of comments—but I’m facing a real dilemma. D wants to apply ED to a school because of its academic philosophy, involvement of professors, individualized education–it’s reputed to be both extremely liberal and anti-Israel. BTW, relatively high percent of Jewish students… I worry about the campus tension. Anyone have similar experience?</p>