Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Rockville - Thanks for the link. Ok, I think it will be Friday when she turns in the transcript request form. Must get the ID card tomorrow. Why can’t they show a drivers license…who knows. Wonder how many kids were turned away the last two days because of not having a current ID card. D stood in line twice today for her parking permit. She was just about at the front of the line, but left to go to class. Then stood in line again at lunch. But she has a permit…yay! Good spot too! Was surprised at that.</p>

<p>They could probably put waiting in line as an EC in High School!</p>

<p>mothek - welcome. Would you care to name the school? You don’t have to - but you might get a better quality of responses if you do - because chances are someone on here has a student at the school or has visited or has other firsthand insight.</p>

<p>You mention a high % of Jewish students - so that’s good - have you or your D spoken to any of them on this issue? Spoken to the campus Rabbi or Hillel leader? I would want to hear their viewpoints on the issue and the tensions.</p>

<p>On a different note - I have to add that I rcvd an email this evening from my son’s GC - and she promises to resolve his transcript issue tomorrow. So - great response from her and I feel better.</p>

<p>mothek: I don’t have a similar experience but I’ll try and offer some thoughts. It is a little difficult to answer without knowing the school or what other schools your daughter has looked at. Involvement of profs and individualized education are both hallmarks of LAC’s so this can be found in a number of schools. My first question is has your daughter visited other LAC’s that stress this focus? I also wonder if this school’s philosophy is so unique for an LAC. Is the liberalism of the school a plus or a minus to her? Most LAC’s tend to have a liberal bias, some more than others. So the question I would ask is, is your daughter attracted to this particular LAC because it is unique, or because it is the LAC that she visited or is it because the presentation at the school was more polished? I expect that an anti-Israel faction will be present on many campuses. How powerful is this group and is there known tension on the campus, and how does your daughter feel about that? Does your daughter want to be involved with the Jewish community and if so has she had an opportunity to visit with anyone from Hillel or similar organization to give her another perspective of the campus vibe and how these students respond to the anti-Israel sentiment? Do you think your daughter is loving this school with a full understanding of the anti-Israeli position or is she ignoring it because she heard so many other things that she loved? If you have not visited the campus a second time and this is at all possible it might help to see if she visited different things on campus if she is still sure this is the school she wants to go to. If there is a substantial Jewish population there is also probably substantial support for Israel on campus but I suppose this is not necessarily a given. Varied perspectives on a college campus present opportunities for growth and education. They can also make a student very uncomfortable. It seems to me the question regarding too much campus tension would depend a lot on the particulars of this campus and also your daughter’s take on these positions.</p>

<p>It’s a small LAC in central Mass, has other campuses very nearby with stronger Hillels. I don’t really want to turn this into a pro- or anti-school X discussion, but I think you can read between the lines that it’s extremely liberal and has a unique curriculum. Believe me, if I could get her to look out of Massachusetts (e.g. at Kenyon) I would, but she wants to be in Massachusetts and doesn’t want a women’s college, doesn’t have the grades for Brandeis or Tufts. Clark just didn’t resonate.</p>

<p>Both the rabbis in our town sent their daughters to this school but one has become radicalized (anti-Israel). I don’t think the same would happen to my daughter, but on the other hand I don’t want her to feel antagonized. </p>

<p>DH says she should watch the radicals protest on campus, while she goes straight to Capitol Hill (AIPAC)—but she does have to live there for 4 years.</p>

<p>P.S. RVM–I grew up in Montgomery County!!</p>

<p>RVM: Congrats on your and S2’s success with the college evaluations/decisions! I feel like I’ve been through a similar experience with my S starting with trying to raise interest in visiting schools, going through the mental gymnastics of how the schools fit with S’s needs and desires, to focusing on getting the apps underway. At least I feel that we have a roadmap for negotiating the next several months.</p>

<p>I guess we lucky with S’s HS. He used comm app to assign school form and recommendation requests followed by transcript request via Naviance. If it’s a comm app, all school forms are submitted electronically for the college to download. I’m not quite sure how it will work with non-comm app schools.</p>

<p>Saw this and although we have older kids, still think it is relevant.</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.cnn.com/2011/09/06/living/teachers-want-to-tell-parents/index[/url]”>What teachers really want to tell parents - CNN;

<p>Welcome Mothek.</p>

<p>re: transcripts. Our HS won’t take reuqests for transcripts until end of September. Makes me a little nervous since that is just a month for all hs materials to get to ED school. Month may seem long, but sometimes it takes several times to get anything done. rvm and momfromli you are lucky your school has a process on place so early.</p>

<p>Thank you for the warm welcomes, and I don’t mean to hijack the topic–transcripts are definitely important, and we’ve had our share of concerns with the GC. At D’s school there are 400+ seniors and 7 GC’s, they generally expect a two-week turnaround on transcript requests. </p>

<p>Now (per above discussion)…I’m more nervous about radicalized anti-Israel element on campus than D is. She’s aware of the atmosphere and is still ready to run with it-- understands it’s part of what makes the school unique, intends to speak her own mind. She does plan to attend AIPAC/ David Project training sessions. Per Spectrum2’s comment, campus anti-Semitism is pretty widespread–even schools that most of her peers consider strongly Jewish are having significant issues. See the article below, from the Jerusalem Post:</p>

<p>[US</a> colleges to receive warn… JPost - Jewish World - Jewish News](<a href=“http://www.jpost.com/JewishWorld/JewishNews/Article.aspx?id=237118]US”>US colleges to receive warning letters on anti-Semitism - The Jerusalem Post)</p>

<p>samtalya - well that makes me feel better! Different hs - different procedures. Ours still mails everything. But you make a valid point - I am glad they have started this process already. But I am sure a month is plenty of time for yours.</p>

<p>By the way - the link you posted does not work - maybe you could post a little bit of the article?</p>

<p>911C2S - thank you. I don’t want to give ourselves a “cunahurrah” yet - (no idea how to spell that in English) but between his college decision process and my new job - feeling quite relaxed and happy these days.</p>

<p>mothek - no issues on hijacking topic - we typically have at least 2-3 different conversations taking place simultaneously!</p>

<p>I know that several folks have discussed their kid’s interest in pursuing a Sports Management major. My S is interested in this major as well, however, I am concerned about it. When you think about it, it really is such a narrow field, and I would imagine that the perceived “glamor” of working in sports would be appealing to so many. Seems like there would be so much competition and very few available positions… especially in the economy. Is anyone else concerned that this major would be limiting? Anyone have a positive experience with this path?</p>

<p>rvm, always glad to make you happy.</p>

<p>here is the article:</p>

<p>(CNN) – This summer, I met a principal who was recently named as the administrator of the year in her state. She was loved and adored by all, but she told me she was leaving the profession.</p>

<p>I screamed, “You can’t leave us,” and she quite bluntly replied, “Look, if I get an offer to lead a school system of orphans, I will be all over it, but I just can’t deal with parents anymore; they are killing us.”
Unfortunately, this sentiment seems to be becoming more and more prevalent. Today, new teachers remain in our profession an average of just 4.5 years, and many of them list “issues with parents” as one of their reasons for throwing in the towel. Word is spreading, and the more negativity teachers receive from parents, the harder it becomes to recruit the best and the brightest out of colleges.</p>

<p>So, what can we do to stem the tide? What do teachers really need parents to understand?</p>

<p>For starters, we are educators, not nannies. We are educated professionals who work with kids every day and often see your child in a different light than you do. If we give you advice, don’t fight it. Take it, and digest it in the same way you would consider advice from a doctor or lawyer. I have become used to some parents who just don’t want to hear anything negative about their child, but sometimes if you’re willing to take early warning advice to heart, it can help you head off an issue that could become much greater in the future.</p>

<p>Trust us. At times when I tell parents that their child has been a behavior problem, I can almost see the hairs rise on their backs. They are ready to fight and defend their child, and it is exhausting. One of my biggest pet peeves is when I tell a mom something her son did and she turns, looks at him and asks, “Is that true?” Well, of course it’s true. I just told you. And please don’t ask whether a classmate can confirm what happened or whether another teacher might have been present. It only demeans teachers and weakens the partnership between teacher and parent.
Please quit with all the excuses.</p>

<p>The truth is, a lot of times it’s the bad teachers who give the easiest grades, because they know by giving good grades everyone will leave them alone.And if you really want to help your children be successful, stop making excuses for them. I was talking with a parent and her son about his summer reading assignments. He told me he hadn’t started, and I let him know I was extremely disappointed because school starts in two weeks.</p>

<p>His mother chimed in and told me that it had been a horrible summer for them because of family issues they’d been through in July. I said I was so sorry, but I couldn’t help but point out that the assignments were given in May. She quickly added that she was allowing her child some “fun time” during the summer before getting back to work in July and that it wasn’t his fault the work wasn’t complete.
Can you feel my pain?
Some parents will make excuses regardless of the situation, and they are raising children who will grow into adults who turn toward excuses and do not create a strong work ethic. If you don’t want your child to end up 25 and jobless, sitting on your couch eating potato chips, then stop making excuses for why they aren’t succeeding. Instead, focus on finding solutions.</p>

<p>Parents, be a partner instead of a prosecutor
And parents, you know, it’s OK for your child to get in trouble sometimes. It builds character and teaches life lessons. As teachers, we are vexed by those parents who stand in the way of those lessons; we call them helicopter parents because they want to swoop in and save their child every time something goes wrong. If we give a child a 79 on a project, then that is what the child deserves. Don’t set up a time to meet with me to negotiate extra credit for an 80. It’s a 79, regardless of whether you think it should be a B+.</p>

<p>This one may be hard to accept, but you shouldn’t assume that because your child makes straight A’s that he/she is getting a good education. The truth is, a lot of times it’s the bad teachers who give the easiest grades, because they know by giving good grades everyone will leave them alone. Parents will say, “My child has a great teacher! He made all A’s this year!”</p>

<p>Wow. Come on now. In all honesty, it’s usually the best teachers who are giving the lowest grades, because they are raising expectations. Yet, when your children receive low scores you want to complain and head to the principal’s office.
Please, take a step back and get a good look at the landscape. Before you challenge those low grades you feel the teacher has “given” your child, you might need to realize your child “earned” those grades and that the teacher you are complaining about is actually the one that is providing the best education.</p>

<p>And please, be a partner instead of a prosecutor. I had a child cheat on a test, and his parents threatened to call a lawyer because I was labeling him a criminal. I know that sounds crazy, but principals all across the country are telling me that more and more lawyers are accompanying parents for school meetings dealing with their children.</p>

<p>Teachers walking on eggshells
I feel so sorry for administrators and teachers these days whose hands are completely tied. In many ways, we live in fear of what will happen next. We walk on eggshells in a watered-down education system where teachers lack the courage to be honest and speak their minds. If they make a slight mistake, it can become a major disaster.</p>

<p>My mom just told me a child at a local school wrote on his face with a permanent marker. The teacher tried to get it off with a wash cloth, and it left a red mark on the side of his face. The parent called the media, and the teacher lost her job. My mom, my very own mother, said, “Can you believe that woman did that?”
I felt hit in the gut. I honestly would have probably tried to get the mark off as well. To think that we might lose our jobs over something so minor is scary. Why would anyone want to enter our profession? If our teachers continue to feel threatened and scared, you will rob our schools of our best and handcuff our efforts to recruit tomorrow’s outstanding educators.</p>

<p>Finally, deal with negative situations in a professional manner.
If your child said something happened in the classroom that concerns you, ask to meet with the teacher and approach the situation by saying, “I wanted to let you know something my child said took place in your class, because I know that children can exaggerate and that there are always two sides to every story. I was hoping you could shed some light for me.” If you aren’t happy with the result, then take your concerns to the principal, but above all else, never talk negatively about a teacher in front of your child. If he knows you don’t respect her, he won’t either, and that will lead to a whole host of new problems.</p>

<p>We know you love your children. We love them, too. We just ask – and beg of you – to trust us, support us and work with the system, not against it. We need you to have our backs, and we need you to give us the respect we deserve. Lift us up and make us feel appreciated, and we will work even harder to give your child the best education possible.</p>

<p>That’s a teacher’s promise, from me to you</p>

<p>mom2009-usually a sports management major is sports and leisure or sports and events, so that it is not as limited. look at the name and description of the major at the colleges that your child is interested in. i imagine that this major could be very worthwhile for all event planning and the hospitality industry.</p>

<p>mothek – we were looking at a different school that you are talking about (located in a different state) several years ago where anti-Israel sentiment was a concern. at many schools we spoke with people at the Hillel about this issue since it is an issue to at least some extent on many campuses, but what was particularly disturbing about this one school was that people in the Jewish student organization were heavily involved in anti-Israel, pro-Palestinian sentiment on campus – in fact the person we spoke with claimed that they deliberately didn’t affiliate with Hillel because of Hillel’s pro-Israel agenda – and we at least got the feeling that someone who supported Israel would be in a decided minority even within the Jewish community on campus. (this was quite a few years ago and I have been told by people who have looked at this particular school more recently that this atmosphere has changed). And this was a school we were looking at because it had a fairly decent sized Jewish population. It fell off my oldest’s list.</p>

<p>so I think the issue to consider is not just the school itself, but where the Jewish students on campus stand. will they be a supportive community for your d, or will she find them to be part of the “problem.” you cannot assume that Jewish = pro-Israel. we’ve seen a number of bright young Jewish students who seem to think it is part of their liberalism and independent thought to be pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel, taking a position that upsets their parents. I will also note there can be a huge difference between being pro-Palestinian and being anti-Israel. One can advocate for the rights of Palestinians and oppose Israeli policies without being “anti-Israel.” (I don’t want to get into a discussion of why such positions may or may not be “right,” just pointing out it can go to the issue of how hostile the environment may feel.)</p>

<p>Has your d spent an overnight at the school? that may be the best way for her to determine whether she would be comfortable in the environment there. talking to students there will likely carry much more weight than you expressing concerns she may not want to hear. ultimately, she will have to decide whether the overall fit is right for her.</p>

<p>MotheK- you should start a new thread. Many savvy posters no longer read this thread due to its extreme length (and lots of chatty asides). I think you raise a very important question.</p>

<p>I have seen a couple of campuses such as you describe where the rhetoric is downright anti-semitic (not just pro-Palestinian or anti-Israel.) There are campuses where social service organizations (frequently a big draw for Jewish students) are virulently anti- and most Jewish kids would really not feel comfortable participating. And then these students become magnets for your run of the mill holocaust deniers, etc.</p>

<p>So post a new thread. I did not screen my kids colleges on this dimension- but if any of them had come back from visits aware of an undercurrent, I would have definitely taken a closer look. It’s one thing for your kid to learn to articulate a minority point of view- it’s another to be demonized by a professor during a classroom debate; it’s another to have a professor selectively pick texts and books with a theme of marginalizing Jewish suffering and trivializing pogroms or historical anti-semitism as “Jews are quick to claim discrimination but as we see they can dish it out but not take it”. This does happen and I feel for the kids who have to listen to it.</p>

<p>mothek: I know of an incident with a friend of mine’s daughter who went to one of the Claremont colleges (can’t remember which one) in California four years ago. She had gone to a boarding Jewish day school throughout high school and was very involved in Jewish causes. One day, she was participating in what she thought was a pro-Israel rally and went in a bus to LA where the group was apparently supporting Palestinian issues and was very anti-Israel. She was very disturbed by the incident and discussions she then had with other students on campus. She decided to transfer to another college after her first semester. I imagine it would be difficult to gauge the political leanings of a campus without actually seeing which groups were active in the community.</p>

<p>samtalya - thanks for posting that. Having worked at a private hs - I very much saw the points raised by the author firsthand.</p>

<p>Mom2009 - on the sports mgmt major issue - my older son is a sports fanatic. he was interested in this major and was accepted to programs at Michigan and Elon. We had a concern - as you mentioned about the narrow focus of the major - and he decided to major in finance instead. He also works for a sports team at his university and still plans a career in sports mgmt.</p>

<p>Younger son has similar interests, but is not as strong a student. We have a concern that the typical business major curriculum including economics, accounting, finance, etc. might be too much for him. The curriculum for a sports mgmt major seems more down-to-earth - and he plans to try a business minor to go with it. </p>

<p>I agree with samtalya that it is useful to look for a broader definition of this major - whether it is sport and event mgmt at Elon or sports and entertainment mgmt at South Carolina. Some sports mgmt majors have are located in the kinesiology department and have more of that focus - more suited to someone who wants to run a health club or fitness facility. Some have a stronger business core. It’s an interesting major in that there is no one department for it - sometimes it is in the Communications dept, sometimes in business, etc. And the required courses can really vary from one program to the next.</p>

<p>As far as job results - I have heard varying results. Many do warn that entry level jobs are pretty low paying. The presentation we attended at Elon did make the point that this field is more for those who want to do something they love and are less concerned with an impressive starting salary.</p>

<p>I’m no expert on sports marketing majors but we have a dear friend who just graduated from Endicott College’s program. They have a wonderful co-op (i.e. internship) requirement that’s great for so many reasons. I just want to point out that, for those interested in actually working for a team, in addition to an expectation of low starting salary, there is the distinct possibility of having to relocate to a pretty remote place.</p>

<p>so now we are getting bashed for being chatty…so be it…</p>

<p>MotheK: there was definitely a discussion here earlier re: anti-Israeli sentiment on campus and if I remember correctly, levirm was a very active contributor to the discussion…you “could start another thread to avoid the chattiness of this one” (LOL) but you could also use the search function at the top of the page to either look for levirm’s posts or for the specific topic of “Israel”</p>

<p>blossom: thanks for the insults; have a great day…they would have been more appropriate in a PM to MotheK rather than a public posting…</p>

<p>There are certain schools we steered around because they were infamous for their anti-Israel stance. I’d heard things about Columbia (Israeli army vet, a student, being kicked out of class by a professor), and had a vague frisson of discomfort about Wellesley although I forget the details. UC-Irvine I think is the famous one. But I think those were not places where the anti-Israel sentiment was coming primarily from other Jews. I think that would make it all the more miserable.</p>

<p>Taking an anti-Israel position is kind of a hip thing for young Jews these days. There was some controversy about whether or not an anti-Israel (but Jewish) group could be included under the Hillel “umbrella” on the Brandeis campus last year. If there are enough Jews on both sides of the issues, then a Jewish kid would be able to find a sense of community either way. Brandeis has plenty, so they manage. If a school was all “Students for Justice in Palestine” all the time, I think my kid, anyway, wouldn’t have been happy.</p>

<p>MotheK- I’m intrigued by this conversation - so there is an LAC that has a large Jewish presence but is also heavily anti-Israel… seems contradictory…but without knowing the school the whole conversation seems kind of meaningless to me…can you tell us the name of the school?</p>

<p>There’s an organization called the “International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network” that has several campus affiliates–most notably UC Irvine, UC Berkeley, UC San Diego and Hampshire–and various campus groups of Students for Justice in Palestine have Jewish members. There is no reason, in the abstract, that a student could not be pro-Israel and pro-Palestine, or at least pro-peace----but there are definitely tensions.</p>