<p>I think this is exactly the conversation that does belong on this thread, rather than on a new separate one - although that is certainly up to mothek. For some of us - a school with these pro/anti Israel tensions would not be a desirable place for our teen. For others of us - these tensions would not rule out a school necessarily - but we would want our teen to be prepared emotionally and from an educational standpoint to deal with this issue. Some may feel that this is exactly the campus that needs more pro-Israel Jewish students and that we should not back away and avoid conflict. Certainly it is an important issue for Jewish parents and college students to discuss.</p>
<p>In Elon’s E-net today:</p>
<p>Sophomores seek others interested in forming Jewish fraternity
Are you interested in starting a Jewish fraternity at Elon? Sophomores Garret Mann and Mason Sklut have been working together on gauging interest in starting a Jewish fraternity here at Elon.</p>
<p>Jewish fraternities are non-discriminatory social fraternities that were established from core values in Judaism to help students develop into responsible citizens with high moral character through living together in a brotherhood whose purpose is not specifically religious, but social and cultural in nature.</p>
<p>Jewish fraternities are non-exclusive and open to all who are willing to espouse its purpose and values. If you are a Jewish or non-Jewish male student, and have an interest in a Jewish fraternity, please contact either Garret Mann (<a href=“mailto:gmann@elon.edu”>gmann@elon.edu</a>) or Mason Sklut (<a href=“mailto:msklut@elon.edu”>msklut@elon.edu</a>).</p>
<p>RVM:My thoughts exactly ^^^^^</p>
<p>However, I can see where a new thread might attract folks who are not drawn to this one, such as parents with kids in college already or parents of kids with A or C students. So Mothek I hope you find your answers by looking wherever you look. As you can see we are happy to provide assistance and support.<br>
I can understand if you don’t want to post the name of the LAC. You might also use the search function that Rodney mentioned to see if the particular campus you are looking at was discussed on this thread. Just put in the college name. I hope I’m not overstepping by suggesting that if you found that some posters were familiar with your school you could PM them regarding your concerns and you might get more specific information. All of the folks that I have chatted with from this community, both on the thread and in PM’s have been very willing to help. My short answer to your concerns is that I would do all I could to dissuade my student from a school if it seemed that their attendance at the school would be unsafe for them. If my student was aware of prevalent anti-Israeli sentiment, but was also going to have a pro-Israel niche on campus that they were comfortable with and my student was comfortable about discussing his perspectives with people who disagreed with him I think I would support my child’s decision. Again, and this is true for any ED application, I would want to be very sure that my impressions, and more importantly my child’s impressions of the school were accurate.</p>
<p>Reading between the lines, mothek is talking about Hampshire.</p>
<p>I mostly lurk on this thread, having already launched my kids into college, but I enjoy the “idle chatter.”</p>
<p>If it is Hampshire, I graduated from there 25 years ago!! Yes, Hampshire is liberal and leans to the way left. I concentrated in Modern Jewish studies with an emphasis on Zionism. My DIV III (thesis) advisor was AAron Berman. He still teaches courses on Zionism and Arab nationalism and I would consult with him. The thing about Hampshire is that there is activism on everything that is politically left. There are not really traditional organizations like Hillel on campus then or now, although they do list a JSU and an Israel Culture group.</p>
<p>I went to UMASS Hillel and Chabad for that kind of traditional go to group.</p>
<p>Mothek if you are not talking about Hampshire this is irrelevant, but if you are, there are definitely people who you can talk with to address this issue. It is a serious consideration and you must explore. </p>
<p>glad you came here for help. this thread has helped so many and hopefully we can help you.</p>
<p>If it is Hampshire College, I have a friend whose DD is a junior there now. She is “half-Jewish.” I can ask her about this issue over the weekend.</p>
<p>FWIW, I know of a young lady who is starting at Hampshire College who is half Jewish and half Muslim, but was raised as / identifies as Jewish and is quite proud of her Jewish heritage and actively participates in Jewish-related activities.</p>
<p>Thank you all for your supportive comments, stories, and PM’s. (Pizzagirl–that’s really interesting…hopefully D will meet her next year) We are going up this weekend, she’s got an interview Monday a.m. I contacted the Rabbi and we may meet a student or two on Sunday. </p>
<p>D is a lot less worried about all this than I am. She’s very independent-minded, which is part of what attracted her to Hampshire in the first place. When I stop and think about it, I realize that it’s part of any college experience to recognize new perspectives, and the reality is she’s more to the right on Israel than most of the kids she knows NOW…she’s used to it. Things came to a head last February and the campus has become more sensitized to the need for fair, open discussion. I also think that this issue is going to be particularly difficult for the next month or two as the UN vote comes up. </p>
<p>Will keep you posted how the visit goes. As I’ve written on other threads, first visit was absolutely great–she had a one-on-one info session with Director of Admissions; private tour; really felt comfortable with campus, academic philosophy and culture. We were fully aware of Hampshire’s take on gender (e.g. bathrooms are gender neutral, about 20 different LGBT student organizations); hideous late-1960’s architecture; no fraternities or teams (except Ultimate Frisbee), but kayaking and rock climbing are popular; vegan vibe from dining services. We just didn’t quite get the full read on the Jewish campus life.</p>
<p>Rodney- apologies, it was not my intent to insult anyone and I am embarrased if my comments did so.</p>
<p>My point was that there are savvy folks on this topic who do not have a B student who do not participate on this thread. There are many students at Hampshire- I imagine some of them Jewish- and if you are the parent of a Hampshire senior (who was an A student in high school) you probably wouldn’t ever think to click on this thread.</p>
<p>I am sorry if I offended anyone. But it will be hard for mothek to get a range of views from the parents of HS juniors and seniors who are the mainstays of this thread since many of them are first time college parents and don’t have an older sib whose experience might be relevant.</p>
<p>A colleague at work has a kid at the Air Force academy- a not especially supportive environment for a Jewish kid although so far hasn’t been a problem-- and the anti-semitism is of the evangelical type, not the anti-Israel type (so far.) . But even though I know those parents are active on CC they are not likely to notice this thread.</p>
<p>peace and apologies.</p>
<p>nicely said, blossom.</p>
<p>mothek - sounds like your D can handle whatever she encounters, but I agree it’s always better to go in with your eyes open. I’ve been concerned about this issue as well for my D12 so thank you for raising it here and on the other thread.</p>
<p>one more data point: DH’s cousin’s S left Hampshire a couple of years ago for a variety of reasons (some of his own making), but I know anti-Israel sentiment, both on campus in general and apparently directed at him personally, was a factor in his decision. I only know this third hand so take it FWIW.</p>
<p>I have not seen anyone post about what is going on at the universities along the Susquehanna so I thought I’d share. As many of you know my D is at Binghamton. Classes have been canceled since Wednesday afternoon due to flooding. The gym and events center are red cross shelters. Many students who live off campus have been evacuated. The city is isolated due to roads and bridges being flooded or destroyed. Limited dining service is available on campus. Students are being asked to donate time and money to help local residents. Nursing students are helping to staff red cross shelters. The campus itself is not flooding and the dorms are dry, so the students who are there are being told not to leave.</p>
<p>A friend has a son at Wilkes University which was evacuated yesterday. The university is completely shut down and students who cannot go home were sent to the University of Scranton. </p>
<p>I am reminded of the students at Tulane in the aftermath of Katrina. Hopefully things will get better and the students can get back to classes soon.</p>
<p>eastcoast101 - thank you for that update. I have been wondering how that was affecting colleges. Such crazy weather of late!</p>
<p>Today I am frustrated with Towson University. S2 applied one month ago using the Common App - and nothing has happened since. They have not even begun to download or process the apps yet - which I might understand if they were offering EA with a November deadline - but given that they are rolling - this seems a bit ridiculous. The admissions person told me to check back in October. So - I guess there are times when being the early bird does not accomplish all that much - although it is still good to have it out of the way.</p>
<p>Rockvillemom don’t worry. Once Towson starts rolling you will hear fast. Dd applied in late December and heard back before any other college in mid January. She got a very good package from them even with being later.</p>
<p>Thank you for the encouragement. I just find it odd as he heard from every other college immediately after applying - acknowledging that they rcvd his application and providing the link to their online status checker if they have one. I just don’t see the point of Towson deciding to accept the Common App and then letting those applications sit for weeks. If I had it to do over - I would have had him use Towson’s own application rather than the CA.</p>
<p>RVM thanks for voicing that…I had my D apply to Alabama after the acceptances got mentioned on here, I figured it’s a financial safety (she truly has no interest in going there) and it would be nice to start the serious efforts with an acceptance in her pocket. NOTHING. She called to be sure her stuff went through, but there’s been no movement on her status and I’m actually feeling guilty for pushing her into it when we all thought it was a slam-dunk.</p>
<p>And what’s the deal with rolling admissions that don’t start evaluating apps til November 1? I mean, that just does NOT sound like rolling to me! ;-)</p>
<p>On the positive side - the communication on his application status from Elon, Susquehanna and James Madison has been great - and while some may argue that you don’t judge a school by the quality of their admissions office - I think it does factor in - even subconsciously. It’s hard to feel positive about a school when the admissions process is frustrating - whether it is a poor info session or delays/confusion in the application process. Towson was at the bottom of his list anyway - but it certainly is not moving up.</p>
<p>Speaking of Towson…has any one heard from MDCISSP? I was wondering how her son’s experience there has been.</p>
<p>And speaking of the city of Binghamton, has anyone heard from Holliesue? </p>
<p>Apparently Cornell and the town of Ithaca has been impacted as well.</p>
<p>holliesue just posted on another thread–said her power is back on!</p>
<p>Hi Rodney !! I am fine. Was without power for 36 hours, damage to my road, but I live in the hills to the northwest of Binghamton so no flooding . However I work in downtown Binghamton in the area that was flooded so I haven’t been able to work. So many displaced people. I couldn’t get to the BU shelter as it across the river but dropped off supplies at another shelter closer to me. This is devastating to our community. The university is fine but some of the hard hit areas are in neighborhoods with lots of off campus student apartments so imagine that there are many effected students.</p>