Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Someone said a few posts up that it’s “off their radar.” I think that’s right. But you’d think at a college where there is a Jewish student population of more than 10%, they should be more cognizant. At UD, the holiday absences are excused, but DD just doesn’t want to miss class. I don’t really blame her (although I’m sure Hebrew will be cancelled). I sort of asked what she’s doing for Rosh Hashanah and DH sent her an email about how great the Hillel events look for the holidays, but I’m not following up. She knows who she is, regardless of whether or not she does what I would like her to do for the holidays. It’s there for the taking. And, most notably, it’s out of my control</p>

<p>On the other hand – what I can still control: DS was given an aliyah on Yom Kippur morning at our temple (we’re not high rollers, they just want to keep the teens involved). I’m happy about it, but you should have seen the face he made!</p>

<p>RVM: I’m with you on the bridal shower on Yom Kippur. That’s just not considerate (whether you want to go or not).</p>

<p>I grew up conservative, but am now reform. My temple does not have services on the second day of RH. It has taken me time to reconcile this (Jewish guilt?). But, I think I’m over it and am driving down to UMD with DS that day and then spending the weekend at UD with DD (honor society induction on Oct 1 at night).</p>

<p>Off to my second to last open school night at the high school…</p>

<p>CD, I was also delighted to see that D1 took her (also memorable!) tallit. That was a lot of biting of the tongue on my part when I saw it out on her desk as she was packing, but I didn’t see it migrating to her luggage. I didn’t want to flat-out ask her, because that might mean it wouldn’t be brought. </p>

<p>RVM, for what it’s worth–one of brother married a non-Jew, but they are raising their children as Jews and this SIL is actually quite interested in all things Jewish, though she doesn’t intend to convert. Another brother married a Jewish woman who wasn’t very affiliated, but a recent move meant they found a synagogue where they’ve become quite involved. In short: you never know what will happen.</p>

<p>rvm- that does sound extremely inconsiderate and hard to believe that no one noticed it was yom kippur? Maybe they would just like you to send gifts and not come. I would not blame you for sending nothing.</p>

<p>Take care, all. See you around.</p>

<p>pamom - I can assure you I will not be sending a bridal shower gift! Really - I have no idea why I am even invited - given that I have only met her once or twice and am a cousin of the groom - not a sibling. </p>

<p>Slithey - I know there are wonderful stories of intermarriages where both traditions are respected - I have a cousin who married an Indian woman in a very interesting Jewish/Hindu ceremony - and they started out with the idea of incorporating both religions into their children’s’ lives - but from what I have seen - the wife’s Hindu background is now dominant. Another cousin married a Catholic girl 2 years ago - same good intentions - now the children are being raised Catholic and they did not have a bris for either son. From what I have observed - it seems to be the wife dictating such matters. The track record in my extended family has been horrendous on this issue of late and it worries me tremendously.</p>

<p>Changing topics - S2’s transcripts - that he requested 2 full weeks ago - have not yet been sent out. I am out of patience and plan to start asking questions tomorrow. (I warned that I was cranky!)</p>

<p>RVM: On the YK shower. I don’t exactly know why this is the case but most Christian people I know don’t realize that a holy day is observed all day and its not just that you go to Temple and then get on with the day. When you mention this scheduling it seems that it was up to your cousin to be careful about the dates. It is a bit of a lesson for those of us who may encounter a family member who is planning an interfaith wedding to be proactive about blacking out dates for events pertaining to the wedding. I can see how this could fall off the radar of a young man. That is very poor planning, but either the bride doesn’t care about how her husband’s family feels or she is uninformed. I would guess that most brides would like to begin married life with the love and blessings of their husband’s family. It is so easy to loose track of dates with all the planning that goes on with a wedding this is a good reminder to families experiencing this to remember to be proactive.</p>

<p>Have you seen this?</p>

<p>[Hillels</a> Launch Talk Israel: Join the Conversation](<a href=“http://www.hillel.org/about/news/2011/sep/21sept11_talkisrael.htm]Hillels”>http://www.hillel.org/about/news/2011/sep/21sept11_talkisrael.htm)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>PS I hope I did not offend anyone who is a Jew married to a non-Jew or who is a non-Jew married to a Jew. I do know that many intermarriages are respectful of both religions and expose the children to both faiths. This has just not been my personal experience from what I have observed in my extended family.</p>

<p>rvm: re the shower, my guess is that the groom is totally out of the loop with regard to all things shower related. Still, I’d be concerned for his immediate family that this young lady and her family will not be entering this union with the idea of respecting each person’s religious traditions.
re classes on the holidays: I think that most private colleges/universities give excused absences to those who take off, but classes remain on the schedule. In my state, it is the public system which gives time off for the Jewish holidays.</p>

<p>emmybet: I’ve been reading some of your other posts and am really sad to hear that your D is having a difficult transition. Perhaps the holidays are a good time for her to meet some new people. Will she be going to services? It might be worth suggesting.</p>

<p>As for my S, I asked a week ago if he had plans for the holidays and he said he hadn’t thought about it yet. He did bring his tallis with him, so hopefully he’ll put it to use. I am putting together a care package to send, with apples, honey, apple cake and chocolate. I’d love to send a mini challah, but don’t know where to get one. Does anyone have a bakery that makes good challah and ships?</p>

<p>rvm, I suppose we’ve been lucky–in my and my sib’s marriages, our wishes regarding Jewish affiliation, regardless of gender, have prevailed. :slight_smile: We are a very persuasive family. :wink: :smiley: </p>

<p>college4three, dunno about the mini-challah. The ones that we get hereabouts seem to go stale quite quickly. How about sending a larger challah? Trader Joe’s should soon be selling the round holiday challahs, and that’s in a nice size for a college student. You could add a jar of Nutella as well if you think that your kid won’t be eating the challah by itself.</p>

<p>Slithey Tove - I am very glad it has worked out for you and your family. You are very fortunate. </p>

<p>I have apparently very much offended another poster by my criticism of the bride’s friend who is hosting the shower on Yom Kippur and my “judgement” of this person. Presumably - the friend consulted with the bride on the date selection. Presumably - the bride knows that her fiance and his family are Jewish. Is it possible that between the 2 of them - they had no idea that the shower was being scheduled for Yom Kippur? It’s problematic no matter how you look at it. If they realized the conflict and decided it was irreverent to their plans - that’s offensive. If they were ignorant of the conflict - that does not bode well for the concept of a successful interfaith marriage where both partners respect the others religion. Am I judging and finding fault with this planned bridal shower? An emphatic YES! And while it is not my intention to offend anyone - I really cannot understand why someone would take offense at my criticism of this scheduling conflict.</p>

<p>And if it was my comment that I was not excited by this wedding that caused offense - that’s my personal belief. It was not meant as an indictment or criticism of any Jewish person who has married a non-Jew. I would prefer to see my Jewish family members marry within the Jewish religion. That’s it - final comment on this topic for tonight.</p>

<p>Rvm, I politely wrote you off list. I’m sorry to see you bring the discussion here. I will also say that you have not interpreted what I wrote correctly. I’m not wanting to continue this here, or at all at this point. </p>

<p>~ ~ ~
Don’t worry so much about the apps. It’s still early and bureaucracies move slow.</p>

<p>Good night.</p>

<p>D got an invitation for an “exclusive” interview opportunity with a college (in which she has no interest) on Wednesday evening, erev Rosh Hashanah. I thought about sending a note to the adcom who invited her, then decided against it. </p>

<p>For schools with a big Jewish population, or who want to increase their Jewish population, it would seem wise to be aware of significant dates like RH and YK. Now that we’re Reform I’m a little more flexible and do send my kids to school on the second day (our schools are closed on first). I also don’t want my D to have to educate everyone every year she’s at college, one of the reasons I think she favors an urban location.</p>

<p>As far as educating people goes there is just so much educating you can do. Things fall through the cracks. Not only are our publics open on the high holy days, our district is having a large college fair Wed night. I would have liked S2 to go but of well.</p>

<p>college43, can you send me a care package? :slight_smile: how sweet of you and what a good idea to wish our kids a sweet new year at school. also gives them an excuse to hopefully call and say thanks.</p>

<p>News about about Pitt today [Pitt</a> to receive $125 million gift](<a href=“http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/11266/1176865-298.stm]Pitt”>http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/11266/1176865-298.stm)</p>

<p>I recently hosted a bridal shower in honor of a friend’s daughter. Lots on conflict between the two families (but not over religious differences.) My co-hostess and I tried really hard to bring both families together, and you know, everyone left feeling a lot more comfortable with one another. The wedding was far more relaxed and enjoyable than anyone expected.</p>

<p>Whoever hosted that shower did a grave disservice to the bride and groom. By including family members from both sides but not considering the needs of those guests, they set a terrible example and caused unnecessary hurt. I could understand a friend of the bride throwing a shower for girlfriends only, on YP if none are Jewish, but once you invite the grooms’ extended family, you have to be more considerate. Was the groom’s mother even consulted on the date?</p>

<p>(Sorry to flog this dead horse, but the situation really got to me and I entered the convo late. Totally understand where you are coming from, RVM.)</p>

<p>I also agree completely with rvm and you, stillnadine…and C43 and anyone else:</p>

<p>Anyone with any respect for another person’s soon-to-be family members would or should be aware of what that date signifies in our religion. It is NOT okay to be unaware, if you are marrying someone that this is important to.</p>

<p>then again, scheduling on Yom Kipur would cut down on catering costs …</p>

<p>Also entering the conversation late. I think its pretty telling that the bride would allow a shower to be held for her on YK. She is clearly sending a message to the Groom’s family that their religion/beliefs are not important to her and will not be taken into account. Whether that was her intent or not, that is the result. </p>

<p>I don’t think Rockvillemom did anything wrong in expressing her disappointment in the way that the interfaith marriages in her family have turned out. She sees the trend continuing and is distressed. Why is that wrong? </p>

<p>The majority of us are posting on this thread because we want our Jewish children to attend school in an environment that is welcoming to them and will be a comfortable atmosphere to be Jewish. The Jewish atmosphere in Rockvillemom’s family is disappearing. I also find that sad.</p>

<p>On another note…D is cranking away on her supplemental essays…Yay! Hope everyone else is proceeding on plan with applications!</p>

<p>My D continues to prove that when I don’t stand over her, she gets things done. While H and I were at her (LAST!) back-to-school night, yesterday, she emailed me her supplemental essay… she announced that she wants the whole packet submitted by Yom Kippur. Sounds good to me! </p>

<p>The college already has her scores and transcript, the last piece will be the LOR’s–that was part of our mission at the Back-to-School. We stopped by to say “hi” to those teachers, hoping to jog their memories.</p>