Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>

</p>

<p>Oops, I dropped in at the tail end of the conversation and without going back a page or two to read, misinderstood the situation and reference. The attempt at levity was probably not clear, or appropriate.</p>

<p>mhc,
I liked your comment…With that in mind, All of you here are invited to my house on Yom Kippur for a wonderful catered dinner of Pork and shrimp. RSVP please…Airfare and hotel not included’t …
If you can’t make this one, the next one is on Passover… I will be serving bread pudding for desert…</p>

<p>No way to find out, but I do wonder if the bride-to-be checked on shower dates with the groom-to-be. If she didn’t, then that’s a major oops. If she did, and the groom-to-be said “nope, nothing going on that day, I’m clear”, well, that’s a different type of major oops. </p>

<p>Definitely saving on catering costs, lol, but also cutting down on the potential attendees means fewer presents, so not good planning. I’m not being catty here–the entire purpose of a wedding or baby shower is the presents!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I’ll be serious now, because there’s a serious issue for all of us to consider: no matter how we have raised our children, no matter how central Judaism has been to our lives, no matter how we try to find them schools where they will be able to continue to be part of the Jewish community, there are absolutely no guarantees that our children will choose Jewish mates. The ways in which we respond if this happens impact not only our relationships with our children and potential grandchildren, but also if our children will pass on the religious and cultural traditions that are so important to us. The ways that we respond as a community have been evolving. The conservative movement synagogues in my area, which once had a hardline stance against families where both adults weren’t Jewish, now welcome these same families. They’re seen as an opportunity to bring the next generation into the fold, and possibly to encourage the non-Jewish spouse to convert. </p>

<p>And maybe this is something we should be discussing–how do we react? How do we stay connected? How do we encourage? Most of us are at least a few years away from directly facing this, but it’s most certainly going to be an issue.</p>

<p>“how do we react? How do we stay connected? How do we encourage?”</p>

<p>My husband’s cousins include one family of six where, of the four married children, one daughter married a Chinese-American who converted; another married a Catholic, who converted; a third married a traditional Conservative Jew–and the son married a Sephardic woman. Of the four marriages, his was the only divorce (kina hora…) The parents brought their kids up with a strong Jewish identity, kosher home, family holidays, summer camp, etc., and when the girls fell in love they made it clear to their boyfriends that they planned to raise the children to be Jewish. The family embraced the young men and, over time, they felt comfortable enough to choose to participate.</p>

<p>My D is not particularly attracted to the boys she’s met through USY, etc., but she firmly intends to raise her children to be Jewish. She is seriously considering making a similar ultimatum to her future spouse. </p>

<p>P.S. My husband’s sister married a Jewish man and they serve pork and shrimp at their Thanksgiving dinners…I’m guessing it’s as much her choice as his.</p>

<p>Thanks, socal dad, the my wisecrack was actually stolen/paraphrased from a Menashe Skulnick (a Second Ave Yiddish Theatre precursor of Woody Allen) 78 record I used to listen to as a boy.</p>

<p>The truth of the matter is, surely the groom himself must have been aware of the Julian Calendar date for his bride’s shower and either didn’t care or maybe was unaware himself that it was Yom Kipur. If so, whatever message the bride or her friends and family are “sending” via the mailed invite, the writing was probably long ago already on the wall.</p>

<p>Hi - interesting comments on the Yom Kippur bridal shower. I’m glad most people understood where I was coming from. I spoke with the groom’s mother yesterday - and she is upset. However, she will be attending the shower - as she does not want to alienate the bride. Both of her sons have married or are marrying non-Jewish women and it has been extremely painful for her and her husband. She basically walks on eggshells so as to not alienate her d-i-ls. I wish I could identify a specific reason as to why this has happened. Both boys had Bar Mitzvahs - participated to Jewish teen activities - and the older one did do Birthright and has always struck me as somewhat observant. I don’t know - it just saddens me greatly.</p>

<p>So - being me - and not having any reason to care about alienating the bride or the hostess of the shower - I rsvp’d to the hostess explaining - very politely - that I would not be attending the shower as it was being held on Yom Kippur. I wrote 2 sentences about what the holiday means to Jews - prayer, fasting, etc. I wrote that I hoped the shower was lovely but that it would be impossible and inappropriate for me to attend. No response as of yet - I’ll let you know if I do hear anything back.</p>

<p>mhc - don’t worry - I found your catering comment to be funny!</p>

<p>levirm - thanks for posting about the Pitt gift - that is amazing!</p>

<p>If the groom mentioned the date to his MO, then she could say something about the plans falling on Yom Kippur. In my family, no one would be attending. Of course, likely a shower would be in a different state, so I’d schedule something at later date and verify with bride’s prents.</p>

<p>My professional organization planned a seminar on this date, and just cancelled it. The idea was offensive to many people, and the president realized he and staff had forgotten to check a broad calendar. </p>

<p>ST, This topic is discussed by my friends, as our sons all college grads. My son is seeing a Chinese young woman. If they make each other happy, I’ll be totally supportive. He didn’t date much, so she must be special. I’ll adapt. I’ll teach them my traditional recipes.</p>

<p>Sometimes people marry outside their faith and come back to it when the are older or have children. That’s why it is important to stay open and positive. When I married my non-Jewish husband 25 (!) years ago, religion was not important to me. I’m sure my parents were disappointed but they never showed it and also have always been kind and loving towards my hubby.</p>

<p>Once I had children, I started rethinking my beliefs and realized I wanted my children to be Jewish. Both my kids are Jewish and my husband is very supportive. I think my family’s attiitude made him feel comfortable and not threatene. </p>

<p>Now, of course, I want my children to raise Jewish children so I understand all your concerns. Yes, I do want Jewish grandchildren. I guess I just want to say, things change, people change, attitudes change. Hopefully, one day this bride will understand why it was so hurtful to hold a bridal shower on YK. And hopefully, that will happen before her son’s Bar Mitzvah.</p>

<p>RVM: I think you did the right thing. I wonder why the groom or his mother didn’t explain the signifigance of the holiday to the hotess and ask her to choose another date. In my experience, non-Jews have been very respectful and accomodating about scheduling once they understand the conflict.</p>

<p>Both of my daughters have mentioned that if they don’t marry another Jew, they would still raise their children in the Jewish faith. Fortunately, they’ve had the example of my BIL, who participates in the holidays and drove his kids to Hebrew school. I’d love for them to marry Jews, but I know that we need to be realistic.</p>

<p>stillnadine - I like your story - pressing the imaginary like button. And I agree - if that is the decision the adult child makes - to marry a non-Jew - the best we can do is try to be positive and make the best of it. I would be heartbroken - but would try to establish a good relationship with future d-i-l. And bookworm - I agree with you - if the non-Jewish spouse is willing to make an effort and learn a bit about Judaism - whether it is holidays or other traditions - that would be great. I’m just seeing a pattern right now in my extended family where that is not happening.</p>

<p>momjr - my impression is that the groom’s mother has not been included in much of the planning. I don’t think she was given an opportunity to express an opinion on the date. I fault the groom for not recognizing the conflict and speaking up - but I really have no idea of what transpired.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I’ve been reading this thread for a long time but have never posted. What SlithyTove writes is so true. My husband is Jewish and I am not. We married young and I was honestly unaware of the assimilation issue. I do feel a bit of guilt about it now but I am not sorry we married. Anyway, my mother-in-law was so very, very horrible about our marriage that it poisoned my relationship with her, and her relationship with her son, for many years. And it caused tensions in our marriage. In the months before our wedding, she would call him multiple times each day, crying and screaming and telling him she was glad her own parents had not lived to see this happen. She enlisted my husband’s cousins to meet with him and try to talk him out of marrying me. She told him that I would insist on having my kids baptized as Christians and that I would make them wear rosaries and crucifixes around their necks (I am not Catholic). Well, we did get married but the whole thing left me with very bad feelings toward her that lasted for years (and probably still do secretly linger). Of course now she loves her grandchildren (and she loves me) so she’s over it. And my daughter is dating a Jewish boy, so she’s thrilled.</p>

<p>You probably can’t stop someone from marrying the person he or she loves, but what you can do is destroy your relationship with your future son- or daughter-in-law. Don’t do that.</p>

<p>I did not convert but became a UU because I wanted to be part of a more inclusive religious community. We celebrate Hanukah and Passover at home. I would have been happy to send the kids to Hebrew school but my husband did not want that. I read this thread because my son is a B student and my preference would be for him to attend a college that is religiously diverse.</p>

<p>I come from a family of 4 daughters. I am the only one who married a non-Jew. Ironically I am much more involved Jewishly than is my youngest sister. My daughter was bat mitzvahed and confirmed and her children never went to religious school. I know many examples of non Jewish spouses who help maintain a Jewish household. When I told my dad I was marrying DH, he said that he decided he was not going to be Tevye…and has never made my DH feel like an outsider. I have always been grateful for my parents love and support of my marriage.</p>

<p>Simpkin: I’m sorry that you MIL treated you so horribly. You have been very generous to
continue a relationshp with her.</p>

<p>My biggest hope for my daughters is for them to find someone who loves them and treats them well. I will welcome anyone who fits that description.</p>

<p>simpkin - thank you for sharing your very moving story - it is really interesting to hear your point of view and your experience. I think your story and holliesue’s show examples where mixed faith marriages can respect and embrace both faiths. But it is hard and it adds one more challenge to the marriage dynamic. I know there is a saying that when you marry - you are marrying not just your actual spouse - but the entire family. I guess this will vary in degree by family. I can’t change the way I feel on this issue - I strongly believe Jews should marry other Jews. But I respect your stories and simpkin - I am sorry for the way your mil reacted and treated you. All I can say is that I don’t want to find myself in her position a few years from now - but if it should happen - I will try to build a bridge rather than wage a war.</p>

<p>holliesue - you are very lucky to have had such support. My parents repeatedly told me while I was a teen that I would be disowned if I married a non-Jew. It was very upsetting. While I better understand their sentiment now that I am an adult with teenagers of my own - I have never said such a thing to my boys and never would do so. But I do very much want them to marry within their Jewish faith - and this desire is a huge part of the reason for my putting so much emphasis on finding colleges that will support their Jewish identity and give them at least the possibility of dating Jewish girls.</p>

<p>And in other news - I just read S2’s essay for his Elon app and it was very moving. He wrote about a spontaneous public speaking event that took place at at BBYO regional convention. I did not know until discussing essay topics with him that this experience had even taken place. He’s generally a shy kid - so for him to volunteer to represent his chapter by speaking in front of hundreds of peers is really something. His account of how he felt about himself prior to this experience and how he viewed himself differently after rising to this challenge just brought tears to my eyes. BBYO has given him so much - I just hope that he finds the same connection in Hillel or AEPi (or both) at college.</p>

<p>so in light of the conversation, i have a S who is a senior and a D who is a freshmen in high school. happy to entertain introductions in 8-10 years!</p>

<p>rvm, our S’s will be in hillel and AEPi together!! don’t forget that drink. big bbyo dance tomorrow night. D going for first time…and so it begins.</p>

<p>simpkin thanks for sharing your story.</p>

<p>mhc and socal, thanks for the humor. bread pudding sounds good right about now, why wait for passover?</p>

<p>RVM - Why attend the wedding? You feel that it’s a burden, but perhaps an obligation as well. But is it really? Since you don’t approve, it could be uncomfortable for you and the bride/groom and their guests. If you’re somehow able to hide it so that it’s not obvious (is it already too late?), then how will you feel being the only unhappy attendee? Why put yourself through that?</p>

<p>While not thrilled about the non-Jewish bride - we will attend in part to support my cousin and her husband - parents of the groom. I also think it is important for the groom to have family members in attendance and I will certainly congratulate bride and groom and behave like a well-mannered adult. My attendance is certainly not an important issue to bride or groom - I see no point in trying to make a statement of any kind. The wedding is not in a church at least and I am curious to see how the ceremony is conducted. It also provides an opportunity to visit with other family members from out of town. So - that’s why we are going.</p>

<p>@samtalya: I have been thinking about making my own challah…if only you knew how BAD I am in the kitchen…also, I will hold you to those introductions…</p>

<p>I, too, think it’s vital to consider the outcomes of our kids marrying outside of our faith. As a result of this turn in the conversation, I have been giving it some thought. I won’t lie. It will crush me inside, but I will always support my kids in their choices. If they are lucky enough to find mates who love them and respect their traditions, then I will accept that. I guess the one piece that I’d offer would be that it is difficult enough to have a successful marriage, why make it more difficult? This, of course, is a conversation to be had in the next few years, not once they are ready for marriage.
@simpkin: thank you for sharing your story. It is quite a testament to you and your husband that you weathered this together successfully.</p>

<p>To all whose kids are working diligently on the apps, YAY!</p>