Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Also, by its very nature, this thread is going to raise some sensitive issues. We are here to share, vent, and gain additional perspectives.
The fact this forum is anonymous gives us the chance to speak candidly to each other. I am sorry that feelings have been hurt, though.</p>

<p>rvm - Do you think the bride and groom are unaware of your feelings? What is the meaning of a wedding? Can you really support the parents of the groom without supporting the groom and his bride?</p>

<p>OK, I’m not exactly young, either. :slight_smile: But I am a part of that generation where Jews married non-Jews. News flash: it happens every generation. I understand.</p>

<p>Here’s the trap that I will warn you about: the danger of becoming the caricature of the disapproving elder. Don’t let yourself play that role. You’ve seen it played out before, by other folks, when you were younger.</p>

<p>On marrying out of faith: I think College43 said it well. I think for me it would be similar to choosing a college. I really didn’t want my S1 to go to school so far away but when I left him at school and saw he was in the right place for him, I was happy and proud. Similarly I think if either of my S’s found a woman who was not Jewish who was a wonderful match and they were responsible, enjoyed, loved and respected each other and planned for a solid future together that would be more important to me. Am I thrilled that my younger son wants to stay within an easy commuting distance from home, youbetcha! But I wouldn’t want my older S to be closer in a school that didn’t suit him as well. Similarly I would love for my S’s to fall in love with Jewish women but I hope I would love my DIL’s regardless, if they seemed right. Its one thing to look at it in the abstract and another to look at having a particular person as a member of the family…However should this happen I would hope that I could prevent a shower that our family was invited to from being thrown on YK. :).</p>

<p>spectrum - lots of wisdom there. Marrying another Jew does not guarantee happiness or a long lasting marriage. I think the concept of mutual respect is key and that’s another reason I want to attend this wedding. While the bridal shower on Yom Kipppur does not bode well - I am curious to see what - if any - Jewish traditions are incorporated into the wedding. Maybe I will be pleasantly surprised.</p>

<p>RVM: I hope you are!!!</p>

<p>No response to my email from the hostess of the bridal shower. I guess I was hoping for an explanation that they were unaware of the conflict. Oh well - silence speaks volumes too.</p>

<p>Where to start. I was disowned by my parents when I was dating my DH (whose step-father is Jewish and step-brother is an Orthodox Jew). This was after they brought me to a Holocaust survivor to yell at me (really). What they did was so wrong for so many reasons (some of which I would never put in writing). Long story short, we were reconciled to some extent by the wedding, where we were married by a rabbi after DH converted (his plan from the start). DH has even served on the board of our temple (although not a services-going-kind-of-guy). My parents gave my brother only minor problems when he got engaged to a non Jew (their kids have absolutely no religion, so sad) and didn’t blink when my sister got engaged to a non Jew. I suffered the brunt (and suffered in so many ways, I can’t even describe). The grandchildren with the not-Jewish last name (my kids) are the most committed Jews in the family.</p>

<p>I share RVM’s disappointment in mixed marriages in the family but I try not to judge, particularly after what I went through. I hope my kids choose Jewish spouses for all the reasons stated here - I’m pretty sure this is important to them, but you never know who they will meet - but I will never, ever, ever, ever act the way my parents did to me.</p>

<p>From my personal interactions, many non-Jews don’t understand why marrying within the religion is important (and I didn’t understand either when I was in my 20’s – although I was sure, and told DH, that I would stay committed to Judaism and my yet-to-be-born kids would go to Hebrew school). It’s not personal. They just didn’t get it.</p>

<p>Interesting conversation here based on our different experiences. Would love to share more if we ever could get together in person. I’m happy to have this discussion with a group who I feel are “my peeps.”</p>

<p>Off to pick up DS from new SAT tutor. Hope it went well…</p>

<p>LINYMOM - thanks for sharing. I didn’t mean to go off on such a tangent - and on such a touchy subject - but it really is fascinating to hear all of the personal stories on this topic. I think that intermarriage is particularly hard for Jewish families to deal with - when your ancestors have suffered so much simply for being Jewish - it is hard to see younger family members marry outside the faith. Many perceive it to be a slap in the face to those who perished in the Holocaust. Yet - it also seems that we as parents need to cultivate flexibility and communication skills - as yelling/threats seems to be extremely counterproductive. So again - quite a tangent - but it’s a timely conversation for many of us.</p>

<p>So - turning the conversation to Rosh Hashana. Any interesting programs happening on campus for those of you with freshmen (or older) away at college? Are your students attending services on campus? Off campus?</p>

<p>Here is my take on the shower issue. As this is being hosted by the brides girlfriend I think the shower is really intended to be for the brides good friends and brides side of the family and quite possibly, so not to offend anyone on the grooms side for feeling left out, you were invited even though they figured you would not attend no matter when it was. Usually, the grooms family also hosts a shower for the bride where invited guests are his family and the groom mother’s friends. </p>

<p>My extended family (including my DH) is about 50/50 now and we all get along fabulously. We have even, when there has been a conflict, served fish to several in laws when Passover conflicted with Good Friday.</p>

<p>Parents weekend at my son’s school starts Sept 30th. Parents are invited to Hillel for evening services and dinner. Since my son couldn’t care less we aren’t going.</p>

<p>Ok - I have to turn the conversation back one more time. Just got a call from the groom - very nice call - very apologetic about the shower date. He explained they had selected the date because it was a 3-day weekend - thus making it easier for more of the bride’s extended out of town family to attend - and that they had not realized it was YK. I think they are so focused on the wedding that is all they are thinking about. He was very happy to hear we are attending the wedding - he asked if we eat shellfish - I said it would be fine. I do feel better having heard from him - communication and flexibility will be my mantra.</p>

<p>RVM:</p>

<p>I don’t usually comment, but this struck a timely nerve. I am Jewish, although my husband is Catholic (our kids were raised Jewish even though he is frankly more religious than I am). Several months ago I booked our flights for parent’s weekend at Brown. I was going back and forth with our dog sitter about dates so that we could spend a little extra time in New England. She could only come sit the week before so I booked our flights on October 7. It never occurred to me to check the date for the High Holidays. Somehow in my head the Holidays were in September. Didn’t even think about it back in May when I booked. So, I totally understand how someone can make that mistake. Of course, I blame the Iphone calender. It doesn’t have any holidays filled in, unlike our old paper calendars. That is my story and I am sticking to it!<br>
Oh, and if it is any consolation, my kids both identify as Jews, had bar mitzvahs and my youngest joined a Jewish frat.</p>

<p>You know what they say, the Jewish holidays are either early or late but they’re NEVER on time!</p>

<p>And of the 4 kids in my DH’s family, 3 married Jews and the one Italian Catholic is hands-down THE favorite in-law by a mile. Go figure.</p>

<p>My D told me yesterday, after I made a lovely shabbat dinner, that she isn’t doing anything Jewish, doesn’t believe in G-d, and just goes along to shut me up. Kinda like her dad. And my S has decided he’s a Wiccan. Anyone wanna trade?</p>

<p>This really is such a great thread! Thanks for making me laugh.</p>

<p>I want to weigh in on the shower too. My guess is that there is some underlying issue between the groom’s mom and the bride and her family, although I have no idea if it is real or imagined on the part of your cousin, Rvm. When you said that your cousin did not want to rock the boat with her new DIL, it really made me think. She is always going to have communication problems with her and her son, if she can’t feel comfortable around the DIL. I so agree that when a child picks a spouse, we must be supportive and loving, and frankly, at that point, your desires are just too late to discuss. The time to let your child know that you would like them to marry someone Jewish was from the time you started having talks with them, I have brought it up over the years, and will continue to mention it on occasion. What happens at the time, will not be my call and, as
Ong as my child is happy, loved and respected, I will be happy. Getting off my soapbox now. :)</p>

<p>RVM, it is nice that the groom called and that he asked re: shellfish.</p>

<p>phillyartmom, completely agree with your post.</p>

<p>I do agree with poster who said that showers are mainly for the bride, her friends, her side of the family, BUT it is also the start of joining two families together. Hopefully, the future MIL is also valued and important to the bride, as are other close female members of the groom’s family. Making the shower on YK really does not demonstrate that, IMO. Perhaps the MIL is wise to let it go, perhaps not. I don’t know and I would not judge. She was put in an awkward position.</p>

<p>Thanks again for all of the input - I like the fact that I can get a range of opinions here. Nice to see some new posters to the thread as well. Clearly this topic resonates for a lot of people. I feel better about going to the wedding now - still don’t know exactly what to expect as far as the service and how various traditions will or will not be handled - but I am going with a happier frame of mind than I was previously at least. The wedding is not until November - I will let you all know how it goes.</p>

<p>sujormik - parenting teens is not for the faint of heart! :slight_smile: Good luck.</p>

<p>rvm - I’m glad that he called, and that you’ll be able to attend with a good frame of mind. They’re probably very, very busy with all the wedding and shower arrangements, and didn’t intentionally schedule the shower to conflict with the holidays. They’re probably just barely holding things together, with so much to do. It’s best to give them the benefit of the doubt.</p>