Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Great news Spectrum!
Have fun on the visits.</p>

<p>Yeah spectrum and family. very happy for you. let us know about your deliberations.</p>

<p>Sorry for barging in as a non Jewish person on this thread, but as a liberal muslim, i was wondering if there is a list of church affiliated colleges that could make non Christians, some what, uncomfortable by requiring them to possibly attend mass or certain religious courses or restrict non Christians from having their own religious associations etc.? i would think Duke, Notre Dame, Boston College etc would be safe. It seems harder to tell about the other schools. Thanks for any help you can provide or light you can shed on this topic.</p>

<p>There isn’t a straight answer to that question. Many the Catholic universities, especially ones that operate significantly in the mainstream (like the ones you mentioned), have a religious presence, but tend to be quite broad in their approach and understanding of diversity.</p>

<p>The first step I would take in looking at a school was to read their mission statement. If there was anything about God, Christ or Church in the mission statement, I figured that meant there was a permeating Christian atmosphere at the school. I don’t know that many schools require attending services, unless the school is extremely religious. You also can tell from the website if there are ecumenical groups, organizations for a diverse ethnic and religious community, etc.</p>

<p>My kids’ friends have gone to Christian colleges and usually say “There’s hardly any religious feeling here at all.” But we are aware that if you have grown up in a Christian home, you don’t notice the things that a non-Christian would feel uncomfortable about.</p>

<p>You have come to a good place for advice - best wishes!</p>

<p>perazziman: Villanova is another college that has a ‘religion’ class requirement, but my neighbor (whose DD graduated from there recently) said it was more ‘philisophical’ than ‘religious.’ Maybe it depends what you take. </p>

<p>spectrum: Congrats!</p>

<p>Looks like DS and I will be meeting up with Vitrac and her DD on Sunday at the Miami open house. Can’t wait to meet another CCer from this thread!</p>

<p>LINYMOM - you and I do have a date, someday. I promise!</p>

<p>Here’s a funny story (maybe I posted this a couple of years ago, but it bears repeating). I asked a friend who was from an area where we were interested in a college, if that college was a “Christian” college, because it was affiliated with the Presbyterian Church.</p>

<p>She thought for a minute and said, “Well, it’s Presbyterian the way some hospitals are Presbyterian.”</p>

<p>MAZEL TOV to your S, Spectrum! We wish him luck making the decision! :)</p>

<p>perraziman, emmybet gave you give advice. looking at a school website can tell you a great deal. look at student organizations. you may find different student religious groups representing all religions. then you can reach out to an organization and ask questions. also a call to admissions may help.</p>

<p>linymom, i thought i was your ccer date! now i am jealous. just wait til i get to meet rvm and other elon ccers! ;)</p>

<p>Spectrum: Congrats to your son. Good luck with the decision.</p>

<p>@ LINYMOM, thanks for the tip on Villanova and may i ask is this a Jewish neighbor? As EmmyBet said, Christians can sometimes underestimate what non Christians can notice. I am a little disappointed, since Villanova was one of the schools that S was considering as a possibility. </p>

<p>It seems like some colleges can be quite difficult for non-Christians, such as Baylor University:</p>

<p>[Baylor</a> University || Spiritual Life || Chapel](<a href=“Spiritual Life | Baylor University”>Spiritual Life | Baylor University)</p>

<p>Others, such as Gordon College in MA actually requires a Statement of faith from students.</p>

<p>@EmmyBet, thanks for the help. I am guessing Emory and Wakeforest are okay. It is tedious work looking at the websites and not knowing whether you missed something. Perhaps I should make a list for everyone and post it, so non Christians can refer to it. thanks for your help. Salam.</p>

<p>No worries regarding Emory:</p>

<p>[Grits</a> and Gefilte: How did a southern Methodist college become a destination for America’s Jews? | The Emory Wheel](<a href=“http://www.emorywheel.com/detail.php?n=17852]Grits”>http://www.emorywheel.com/detail.php?n=17852)</p>

<p>Sometimes a “religion” class requirement, even at a Catholic (and sometimes at a Christian) affiliated school, is not a negative sign. Often it is a very broad option that promotes open-mindedness. But you do have to poke to find out.</p>

<p>I am sure there are religious school consortiums that would provide names of schools with a certain bent - for their own purposes, to help kids who are looking for them specifically. That makes lists easier to make. Also, I would think that looking for schools with Muslim student organizations would accomplish your goal much more quickly - taking the front-seat approach, so to speak, just as this group tends to look for Hillels. There was a piece on NPR (Weds morning morning edition?) about a Muslim chaplain at UMich who seemed to belong to some national university chaplain association - maybe you can find a link to that group?</p>

<p>perazziman, another thread with a related theme: <a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/1228139-searching-colleges-becoming-pain-neck.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/1228139-searching-colleges-becoming-pain-neck.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>This is like searching for private K-12 schools. Of those that are church-based, some would consider anyone, others wanted a baptismal certificate, and others wanted a statement of faith. As far as colleges go, anything discussed on the Christian Colleges subforum would immediately be off our radar. That would take care of places like Baylor and Gordon. Places like Pepperdine get discussed there too (on the “liberal” end), and they might be acceptable to some non-Christians, but really, there are so many other schools, why bother?</p>

<p>I agree with all of EmmyBet’s suggestions, including looking at the mission statement first off if you’re not familiar with the school at all. </p>

<p>And welcome!</p>

<p>perraziman, I’ve even gone so far as to check the “viewbook” or photos/videos of a college on it’s own website - and specifically looked for Christian crosses on buildings. Villanova and Loyola have very prominent crosses…viewing that on campus day in & day out would make my D uncomfortable.</p>

<p>and ditto, slitheytove - there are many wonderful schools out there for your S, so why bother with those that even questionably espouse any faith of which he may not feel comfortable?</p>

<p>@EmmyBet: Good advice thank you, I have found a list of Christ centered colleges put out by some Christian organizations. By the way, we are a little outside mainstream Islam, so not comfortable calling muslim orgs. Most of their stuff seems to be about gaining concessions for prayers and holidays at American universities & colleges, which is really not what we were looking for. </p>

<p>Changing the subject a little bit, any advice for Brandeis? I have read there is a MSA there. Is there anything one should be aware about this school as a non Jewish person? They seem to have an engineering certification program with Olin College of Engineering that S is interested in. </p>

<p>Thank you SlitheryTove and quakerstake</p>

<p>Back-read of This Thread Update</p>

<p>Up to: Page 225 - Post # 3375 - Nov. 8, 2010</p>

<p>And it has been great fun. Lots of information.</p>

<p>And it reads like a novel with various family threads and events. R/Mom going on her various college visits, MDCISSP’s son getting accepted to Towson, etc. I’m starting to feel like I really know these people.</p>

<p>Please don’t spoil the ending(s) for me. I want to be surprised.</p>

<p>Thank you for the good wishes. Vitrac, is it UT or A&M that you will be visiting? I’m guessing since you greeted me with a Hookum and not a Howdy it’s UT. I wish I could meet you there but we haven’t pulled things together enough yet to schedule a day. However Austin is just a1.5 to 2 hour drive so it won’t take too much planning except to figure out exactly what S wants to see. I’d love to hear how your visit goes. If there is any chance we’ll be there next week I’ll PM you. When do you expect to be there?</p>

<p>It was pretty fun within about an hour of finding out about his acceptance S2 was in touch with a bunch of camp friends, including communicating with a friend who just graduated in his major and friend who invited him to come up a stay a weekend and several friends in the Jewish fraternity. My S who has always said he was not interested in fraturnities is suddenly saying he might want to join the Jewish one. There are still advantages and disadvantages to both schools but I was amused by how quickly the Jewish community embraced him when he got the word out about UT. </p>

<p>perazziman: There are several schools here in Texas and I expect around the country that have Christian names but are very welcoming to diversity and have very loose to no religion requirements. On the otherhand, a student who is raised in a multicultural community without living in a place where there are many students who never met non Christians may feel uncomfortable being the first Muslim, Jew or whatever that many students are meeting. We’ve discussed that a bunch on this thread. Once you rule out the seriously Christian schools this is another consideration.</p>

<p>You are probably pretty safe in the northeast which is generally more diverse. If you look in the south it is something to be aware of. I agree with Emmybet, schools that have a strong religious vibe of anykind usually put that out there on their websites because it is very important to who they are.</p>

<p>MarkBass: You are amazing me, I love hearing our history!</p>

<p>spectrum2 - Mazel Tov on the UT acceptance - wonderful news!</p>

<p>MarkBass - “don’t spoil the ending” - too funny</p>

<p>perazziman - first - welcome. Second - I’m going to use High Point University in NC as an example of what you probably don’t want and different things from this school that have jumped out at me. They hold a worship service on Wednesday evenings and do not schedule undergraduate classes at that time so all can attend. It is supposed to be open to all faiths - but if you look at the quarterly chapel publication - everyone involved with it is Christian. The university President makes a statement in their university magazine that they are a “G-d, family and country” school - admirable values for a person to hold - not so sure about a university. It’s like saying atheists and agnostics need not apply. I could go on and on - but this is an example of a university that while it won’t come out and say it is a Christian school - it is a Christian school. </p>

<p>For any university - look at the religious groups available on campus - look for any requirement on religious classes and what you can choose from - look at the composition of the professors in the religion department - look at the school newspaper - particularly issues that fall around Easter and Christmas to see how much those holidays are incorporated into the social fabric of the school. Bottom line - visit. Nothing can take the place of visiting the school - meeting students - and forming your own personal opinion on the religious vibe.</p>

<p>On Wake Forest - my older son is very comfortable there. But I have to add that he is not a religious Jew by any stretch of the imagination and the majority of his friends are Christian. It does not seem to bother him and Wake Forest is actively seeking more diversity.</p>

<p>Perazziman- I have heard that Brandeis is very welcoming to Muslims. Certainly worth checking out.</p>

<p>@ Vitrac: Boston area is very attractive. So many good colleges and young minds there. S has also been considering Boston University and Northeastern. Now he can throw Brandeis in the mix. </p>

<p>@ Spectrum2: First of all, congratulations to you and your son on his acceptance to both A&M and UT. We live in TX, and can appreciate how difficult and thrilling this choice can be. :)</p>

<p>As far as my S is concerned, he is going to have to make a choice between attending college locally and moving away. i guess the final decision will depend upon what he decides to study and where the jobs are going to be in that field. </p>

<p>@rockvillemom: S is not very religious either. S just needs to make up his mind about what he wants to study and where? Until recently it was engineering. You are probably right we need to visit some schools. ps what a marvelous thread you have created.</p>

<p>@ LuvMomN8ur: Thanks for the info.</p>