Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>@perraziman: I’m seconding the recommendation of Brandeis. Regarding Villanova, I have heard firsthand accounts of overt anti-Semitism. I think that would not bode well for religious tolerance of Islam, either.</p>

<p>@emmybet: you and I will definitely meet at some point, I hope!</p>

<p>Yup - great times will be had in central Long Island someday!</p>

<p>GWU - a little reachy for the typical “B” student - but within range for a strong B+/A- student who wants an urban environment.</p>

<p>[Third</a> time’s the charm as Chabad GW finds a new home - The GW Hatchet](<a href=“http://www.gwhatchet.com/2012/02/09/third-times-the-charm-as-chabad-gw-finds-a-new-home/]Third”>Third time’s the charm as Chabad GW finds a new home – The GW Hatchet)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Just back from two weeks in Israel and catching up with this thread. It’s been interesting to read the opinions of those with kids there or planning on being there. What an amazing place…</p>

<p>Welcome back Mutti, so glad you had an amazing safe trip!</p>

<p>perazziman: Nice to see another Texan here. If your son is interested in engineering then you probably know that UT and TAMU both have very strong engineering schools. I’m sure everyone can find their niche at UT. I was initially skeptical about sending my Jewish kid to TAMU but I did find a very welcoming Jewish community there so this may be true for the Muslim community as well. Three Texas schools that I did a little research on were TCU, SMU and Trinity and I would have been comfortable with my S attending any of these if i didn’t think he was looking for a Jewish community to be part of his college experience. All three while welcoming have small Jewish communities. I have heard that SMU has a good engineering program and I don’t know about engineering at the other two schools. .</p>

<p>Socaldad, this means nothing until we visit again but my hubby heard my fickled S telling some friends that he is probably going to UT. It is pretty funny how strong the opinions are of the two schools here. I think we are the only folks living in Texas that don’t have a clear preference.</p>

<p>Spectrum, glad to hear your report. I will send silent longhorn chants his way. you should have him visit during roundup. That will seal the deal, or not…</p>

<p>@spectrum2: Yep, UT is almost always ranked among the top ten engineering colleges in the country. A&M is neck and neck with it. My understanding is that A&M is better for kids who want to go straight out into the field and start earning some money in the corporate world, especially with the energy companies. UT is better for those who are focused on graduate school. </p>

<p>S is interested in the field of engineering and has shown some aptitude for it. However, he is essentially still on the fence, academically, waiting to finish this semester and see how he does in science/ math, before deciding whether engineering is a viable career choice for him. I think it is a lot easier for kids to know whether engineering is right for them, who have been preparing for math and science careers since middle school (by participating in math/ science competitions and summer programs etc) and getting straight As in class. Unfortunately, S has not had that type of upbringing. Up until high school, he was basically the do your homework and that was it type of kid. Nobody expected anything more or asked him to do things differently. Fortunately, he is at a high school where he is pushing his boundaries.</p>

<p>S has a shot at getting full tuition scholarships at A&M and Northeastern which make them attractive. I am not certain he will make it into UT or get the type of financial assistance that A&M and Northeastern usually offer. He is not in the top 8% or 10% for that matter, of his class.</p>

<p>Can anyone recommend a ‘Clemson’ type school (For the B/B+ student, leaning more towards technical/business than LAC, yet still well-rounded, school spirit) that is closer to an airport/city and has more MOTs. We’re looking for residential minimum two year Honors college and merit aid, and wants West coasters. Pub or Priv.</p>

<p>Hi everyone. So i went to see URI and the consensus from most of you was right, she didn’t like it:(. She is going by herself this weekend to stay with her brother and check out IUB. I am nervous because she hasnt liked any of the schools shes’s seen! Quinnipiac, Wheaton, Mulllenburg, UVM, Syracuse, or Rhode Island. After Indy she has CofC and the Roger Williams. These trips are breaking my bank and making me nuts. Has anyone picked from IUB or CofC? Maybe even roger williams? Feedback please…</p>

<p>^^^</p>

<p>Can you please mention some of the things your D didn’t like about URI, Quinnipiac, Wheaton, Mulllenburg, UVM and Syracuse?</p>

<p>Thanks.</p>

<p>Yes, I think for your sake she needs to start being very clear about what she is learning from these trips. It’s not shopping (i.e. “I’ll know the right one when I see it”): it’s developing a sense of what is important, and there are lots of very specific criteria she could gain even from 7-8 negative impressions.</p>

<p>My questions are: Is there an idealized vision of “college” that she has, like so many kids? These are very different schools - maybe she just doesn’t get what college is really like. The only thing I’m noticing is that she hasn’t seen any truly urban campuses. Maybe she’d prefer that. Is there one near you that might be able to see, just as an experiment?</p>

<p>My older D found out early on that she did NOT like urban campuses. The very same day that she learned that, I drove her immediately to a nearby pretty, grass-lined quads type of school. She said, “Yes, this is how I see college,” and we never looked at anywhere that didn’t fit that mold.</p>

<p>It sounds like maybe your D needs to take the lead in looking at websites and identifying what she likes from there, regardless of the campus. Maybe that will make schools she visits feel more attractive even before she gets there.</p>

<p>Names1, I, too, would be interested to know why she didn’t like them as my D is also very interested in Muhlenberg, & slightly interested in Quinnipiac. CofC & Roger Williams are also on our list.
Emmybet is right on in suggesting that your D take a moment to id what she wants & doesn’t want from your visits & research.</p>

<p>Lately, I’ve been checking out small public colleges for the B student. 2 on my radar that have received plenty of recent accolades are University of North Carolina at Asheville and University of Pittsburgh at Bradford.
My NC born & raised friend scoffed when I mentioned UNC-Asheville and my Pitt born & raised sister-in-law had a similar reaction when I mentioned UPitt-Bradford (though, for the record, the Bradford campus is apprx 160 miles from Pittsburgh, PA).
UNC-Asheville has a Jewish Student org & a Muslim Student org which bodes well for the diversity/tolerance on campus.
UPitt-Bradford has a new non-denominational chapel, but no mention of any religious student groups oc other than Christ In Action, though they do have an African-American Student Union, an Asian Student Alliance, a Latina org & a LGBTS Alliance.
However, they both have very low 4 year graduation rates.
Though we would only consider these as safeties, does anyone have any sage advice regarding either of these schools?</p>

<p>perazziman,
Tufts may be a bit of a reach, but my Jewish son has made many Muslim friends there. One of his classmates spent part of winter break with us last year to do research on a project for a class they were both taking. Might be worth investigating.</p>

<p>perazziman, another vote for Brandeis. my Jewish D is a junior and like CountingDown’s S at Tufts, she has several Muslim friends. as a family, we learned more about Islam during freshman move-in which fell during Ramadan, because her RA was Muslim.</p>

<p>from the Brandeis website: “The Muslim community is served by Dr. Imam Talal Eid, the Muslim chaplain. The imam leads prayers every Friday for the Islamic community and other interested observers. He is also available for counseling and other spiritual matters. The imam also comes to campus for feasts of the Islamic community. He is engaged in many interfaith discussions and shares with the other chaplains in the overall spiritual life of the university.”</p>

<p>names, another way to help your D see what she wants and doesn’t want is a very hands-on sorting of college attributes into piles. Look at <a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/599371-daughter-hates-her-matches-safeties-21.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/599371-daughter-hates-her-matches-safeties-21.html&lt;/a&gt; starting with post #314.</p>

<p>Names,</p>

<p>I must agree with your d. URI was not appealing to us when we visited. I would not let that upset you. I think many others before me offered good insight about getting her to articulate what she didn’t like. It appears that small schools don’t appeal to her. I can’t figure out if she also doesn’t like big schools. IU has a great beautiful campus. Very large. The college town is vital, and offers a lot. It is a huge sprawling campus. My D1 loved it, and D2 felt overwhelmed. Though lately she is talking about going back for a second visit if she does not get in to her first choice.
CofC might offer a great alternative to many of the schools she has looked at. It is only 10k students, in a great charming southern city. While D2 has not yet visited, she will if she has to choose. I have been to Charleston, and think it is a greg place to go to school. A potential downfall is the extreme female/male ratio. That might be a deal breaker.
I do wonder if there might be some underlying issue happening. Perhaps the fear of change, leaving home, or something else is getting in her way. You have seen many interesting options. I wish you the best of luck. We are all now getting in to the crazy months of deciding.</p>

<p>@ CountingDown: I too believe Tufts would be a high reach for him. He has a B average (3.5/ 4.0 unweighted GPA) and a class rank that puts him in approx. 20-25 percentile range. </p>

<p>There are some mitigating factors, which may convince a Boston University or Brandeis to accept him, but it is unlikely they will convince the most competitive schools. We also do not want to put him in a school where he becomes the proverbial road kill- and drops out of college. </p>

<p>Factors such as,</p>

<ul>
<li><p>Attends a competitive high school, where average SAT score is about 1700.</p></li>
<li><p>Most rigorous courseload, taking five AP classes, in addition to pre AP Physics and Pre AP PreCalculus as a junior this year.</p></li>
<li><p>PSAT score that puts him in the top 1/2 of 1 percent of juniors in TX (less than 1% of all juniors nationwide), that should qualify him for National Merit Semifinalist.</p></li>
<li><p>He is half Hispanic and attended wishy washy public elementary and middle schools in a mostly poor Mexican American neighborhood. We thought he was doing well in school, until he came to the current suburban high school, where he is working very hard to catch up with the rest of his class.</p></li>
</ul>

<p>perazziman, sounds like he’s catching up extremely well considering his 5 (holy cow!) AP classes next year…no worries.</p>

<p>LuvMom - on UNC-Asheville - was on my initial list for S2 - but I was also very concerned by the low graduation rate. My impression was that it was mainly in-state students - many of whom were putting themselves through school - working and attending p/t and so forth. I didn’t think it fit what we were looking for from that regard. It is highly regarded as a public LAC - but it seemed as if there were a lot of older students and students who were taking 5-6+ years to graduate.</p>

<p>I believe this is from 2010:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Perraziman, if your S is a national merit finalist, you might want to look at Alabama. I believe that they give very generous scholarships and the kids that go get into the honors college. Two of my dd’s friends will be going this year.</p>