Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>palmhabor, we toured Momouth in 2005, so this info is a bit dated . At that time there was a housing shortage. You might want to look into the number of years one is likely to live on campus and % of students moving off campus. It seemed to me that after freshmen year one needed to move off campus and needed a car to get to campus. Buying a car and paying for auto insurance would have made merit money a wash for us. The beach area there is beautiful! Classes are small, and lots of green open space. My son never applied because of the housing situation primarily. We liked the school but it would have been a safety and we weren’t really loving it.</p>

<p>that is a fun tool. I learned that PA has the most out of state freshman with 27,625. The top 3 states sending students to PA are New Jersey (9200), New York (5400), and Maryland (2900).</p>

<p>Drexel’s freshman classof 2554 is is 44% from PA (1,124). The states with the largest number of out of state students are New Jersey (611), New York(201) and Maryland (122). There are 92 from California putting it in 4th place of states sending students to Drexel from out of state. There is a 73% chance that any two students come from different states.</p>

<p>Thanks for the comments on Elon & Binghamton. I am working my way through earlier postings, now at May, 2010! Finding much of interest, and I’m impressed by the support you’ve given one another.</p>

<p>Palmharbor, I visited Monmouth last weekend! Also saw Drew in November so I can speak to both schools based on current conditions.</p>

<p>Drew–DD loves this school and it is currently her first choice. Beautiful campus (they call it the university in the forest or something like that). Fabulous arts programs, some interesting NY-based internship programs (depending on the major). Very small–less than 2000 students in total, I think. I first visited this school a few years back with my OD and remember thinking back then that it would be a great school for YD. They are having an open house on April 21 you might want to look into. Plenty of housing on campus. The local town is cute for NJ but not a reason to attend. Not big on sports. They do have an equestrian team, which makes them stand out. DD loves horses and they accept beginners. </p>

<p>Monmouth used to have a reputation of being a party/beach school, but they are trying to move away from that. Some of the buildings are beautiful historic mansions–the building that houses the admissions office was used in the filming of Annie and Daddy Warbucks’ home, and the library used to be the summer home of the Guggenheim family. For me, the biggest turn-off was the freshman dorms. I thought they were horrible, by far the worst I’ve seen in the 3 years I’ve been doing college visits between my 2 Ds. I believe they are building new dorms but don’t know the status of them–it would be something to ask about. You are not required to move off campus after freshman year–there is on campus housing available for upperclassmen. In addition to on-campus housing, they have off-campus affiliated apartments within a mile of campus, including one building right on the beach. (We didn’t see these but our tour guide said they were new and very nice.) They also have on-campus apartments for juniors and seniors which our tour guide said were brand new and beautiful (but they never take you to those places on the tours). We were told it isn’t really a suitcase school anymore–kids are coming from NY, NJ, CT, PA mostly which can be a few hours away. They have a D1 football team which helps keep kids around on the fall weekends and a popular basketball team and are much more of a sports school than Drew. It is a very pretty campus–we could tell that even on a cloudy overcast day. The dining hall looked nice, though we didn’t eat there. It is a bigger school than Drew. They have a lot of grad students, but my impression was that they are mostly adults from the local area who go part time and don’t really mingle with the undergrads. Academically, they have small classes, no TAs, the typical stuff you see at small universities. Freshmen are permitted cars on campus, and this was a concern–our DD will not have a car and will she feel left behind? Not sure. Our tour guide (we liked her) said not having a car was really no big deal. We were told that although close to half the students live off campus, only 10% are living at home with parents; the kids who are living in the university-affiliated buildings are counted as off campus, for example, so the statistic can be misleading. Also since it is a beach community, they said sometimes groups of kids will get together and rent out a beach house for the academic year at a fairly good rent, because the owners make their money on summer rentals and consider anything they get during the school year to be a bonus. They have a school of social work and a 5 year BSW/MSW program which is something my D is thinking about. Also seemed to have a good theater program. My D is a B student, no honors classes, similar to your D. D’s SAT tutor and history teacher both went to Monmouth and loved it there. Depending on where her SATs come in, it would probably be either a match or a safety for her.</p>

<p>It is good to know that at least Monmouth’s upperclass housing seems to have gotten better since we toured about 5 years ago.</p>

<p>BTW, we also toured Drew and liked it. We also liked the area better those around many other LACs. One of my sons applied. He did not attend because the choice in majors for him were less than perfect for his interests at the time.</p>

<p>Welcome new posters. </p>

<p>Spectrum. Good luck with S. hopes he enjoys his weekend.</p>

<p>To all UT fans: Today’s New York Times: 36 hours in Austin</p>

<p>Hi All:</p>

<p>While searching the internet on the everending task of finding a small/medium college (<10,000) with a Jewish vibe for the B/B+ student, I have stumbled across this wonderful thread. A quick perusal of the over 12,500 posts (wow!) indicates a discussion of the following schools:</p>

<ol>
<li> The old standbys (Tulane, Syracuse, Miami of Florida)</li>
<li> The new favorites (Elon, Muhlenberg)</li>
<li> The midwestern choice (Beloit)</li>
<li> The Rocky Mountain choice (University of Denver)</li>
<li> The alternative alternative (Goucher)</li>
<li> The surprise selection (College of Charleston)</li>
</ol>

<p>I saw some other schools discussed, but they were either too big (JMU, Miami of Ohio, UDel, Northeastern); not jewish enough (Susquehanna, Juniata, York) or more of C+/B- school (Monmouth).</p>

<p>So did I miss anything? Your insights are greatly appreciated. I hope this thread continues after rvm retires.</p>

<p>Thanks so much.</p>

<p>Welcome EvanstonDad! I am sure that you have missed a bunch, especially those in the “surprise selection” category. How about Ithaca College? Just the first school not on your list that came to mind. Also, SUNYs (public Us in NY).</p>

<p>Spectrum,</p>

<p>Yes Towers has pros and cons. Great space, convenient location, nice amenities, and in the middle of west campus. It is a very social party dorm. That can be viewed as a plus or minus. Minus to a parent, plus to a kid. I am not surprised to hear that on a saturday afternoon, you experienced some of the partying that takes place. I would say that Thursday night-to Saturday night, you can expect the usual crazy frosh dorm partying. As I said in a private email, if you live there, and want to study on the weekend, you will prefer going to go to the library.
I know your Son will be in a tough major. I know distraction is your concern. I think it will be a great social place for him. He needs to understand the complete picture of the dorm, be willing to leave to study on weekend, and he will be ok. If that is a concern, Dobie might be an option. Very quiet, not very social. It also does not have the jewish scene that Towers does. Send me a pm, with the rest of the rundown.</p>

<p>Evanston Dad,
Welcome…</p>

<p>I do think you did a nice job of summarizing some of your choices.</p>

<p>I might suggest you at least look at a JMU or Delaware. They are bigger than 10K, but really do a nice job of giving a much smaller feel. Beautiful traditional looking campuses, good jewish scene, in your grade range, and yet they don’t feel like the 15k population that they are. It might be worth checking out as a comparison. They certainly do not feel any bigger than Syracuse as an example.</p>

<p>Thank you all for the information on Monmouth. eastcost101 I appreciate your in depth details for both Monmouth and Drew.</p>

<p>I also want to throw a school out there for anyone interested- HobartWilliamSmith. It hasn’t been mentioned too often in this thread.
We visited in Novemeber. Lots of Pros- Beautiful campus- right on the Finger Lakes. We definitely got the sense that the professors care a lot about the students. Small classes,
Lots of sports. If your child really doesn’t have a major in mind, they work very closely to help them decide.<br>
If I were choosing the school, it would have been a top choice. But as we all know, the choice isn’t ours to make. My D thought it was way too preppy and that was the end of that!
Happy to answer any other questions if anyone has an interest.</p>

<p>Hi EvanstonDad and welcome. To add on to what socaldad wrote - you may want to widen your criteria just a bit - at least initially. I agree 100% that JMU and Delaware are worth consideration. If you look at Muhlenberg - check out Dickinson, Franklin & Marshall and Susquehanna as well. If you look at Goucher - Towson is nearby. </p>

<p>It’s hard to find the absolutely perfect school. The 5000-8000 student range does not have a ton of options at the “B” student level. If you are comfortable around 2000 students or so - lots of options. Add Drew in NJ, Lafayette in PA and so on. If you are willing to go to 10,000 students - then you really should consider Delaware, JMU, Ithaca, Binghamton and Miami of Ohio. </p>

<p>If you care to share more info - I know you’ll receive lots of input from the parents on this thread!</p>

<p>palmharbor - I have heard good things about Hobart and William Smith. My concern would be weather-related. Kind of cold and isolated, isn’t it? But for someone who loves cold weather - might be a great option.</p>

<p>The Hillel website for HWS is not updated - but here is a bit from their “About us” section:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I saw an estimate for 10% of the student body being Jewish - which would be about 200 students.</p>

<p>They do offer test-optional admissions:</p>

<p><a href=“404”>http://www.hws.edu/admissions/sat_optional.aspx&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Evanston Dad–</p>

<p>Hello and welcome.
You have a good list already, but I would add American University in DC to your list, especially if your student is a male.
Have fun with the college search!</p>

<p>We looked at HBS; it never really dropped off the list but was not a top choice due to cost (and the knowledge that a “B” student was not going to get any merit)…</p>

<p>Beautiful school; the main issue we had with it was lack of transportation options (even though it was only 4 hours away)…hard to get home without a ride, especially in an emergency…closest airport is Syracuse, over an hour away…D technically ended up closer in NC…</p>

<p>If I recall, there was some issue with the two schools Hobart for guys and William Smith for girls, having different dorms/ facilities, but it would be a lie to say I actually remember; it has been awhile…</p>

<p>We also toured HWS. One of my kids applied there too. Rodney, yes, Hobart is for males and I believe the male graduates’ diploma reads Hobart College and the female graduates’ diploma reads as William Smith College. Yes there are seperate dorms as well, although there may also be some coed (I don’t recall).</p>

<p>They seem to have a lot of flexibility in ways to fulfill requirements. The school is situated along the water and is really beautiful. There is a sailing team, in case anyone might have an interest in that. I had the feeling that studying abroad is pushed very strongly. We did get that “prep” vibe, but we also got a similar vibe at Drew. We also came across plenty of students at both schools who did not give us that preppy feeling. For us at the end of the day, the bottom line was just not there. We participated in their online FA info sessions for parents. When the package came, it was what I anticpated despite what I had heard during their FA info sessions, which means not a good package for us. They did not come close in making their school affordable for our family.</p>

<p>Editing to add that my son was offered merit aid at HWS.</p>

<p>Have you folks seen this yet? Really well-done purimspiel by HUC rabbinical students. It’s a parody of The Book of Mormon, so familiarity with that score will enhance your appreciation of their efforts.
[The</a> Book of Purim - Official Parody of “The Book of Mormon” - YouTube](<a href=“The Book of Purim - Official Parody of "The Book of Mormon" - YouTube”>The Book of Purim - Official Parody of "The Book of Mormon" - YouTube)</p>

<p>Thanks for the welcome and all the suggestions:</p>

<p>I would like to point out that we live in a Chicago suburb, which makes finding a small school with a jewish vibe even more difficult. Not much nearby. And going out East has its drawbacks. Travel to the mid-Pennsylvania schools can be challenging. In addition, the lack of midwestern classmates is not ideal. For example, the addicting “Chronicle Geography Game” shows that the 2010 freshman class at Muhlenberg had only two members from Illinois. Drew had only one member. (But as rvm noted, there is no perfect school.)</p>

<p>Forgot about Ithica, Susquehanna, American, Lafayette and F&M. All good choices. </p>

<p>Susquehanna probably does not have enough of a Jewish “vibe” for our liking and I am not sure about Lafayette. Does anyone have any thoughts about Lafayette? I hear it is preppy.</p>

<p>Finally, my D participated at the Maccabi games at Towson two summers ago. Was not expecting much and was surprised. Miami of Ohio will probably be our mid-sized state school choice. Have tons of great choices in the Big 10 (along with Kansas) if we want to go big.</p>

<p>While sitting at the airport I wrote a lengthy trip report about Elon Fellows weekend, but when I went to post the Internet connection was lost and my report didn’t upload. </p>

<p>Basically we had an awesome time. S met lots of friends and can’t wait to get started. Saw residences, heard about all the fellows stuff (biz), and spent a lot of time meeting other kids. loved it.</p>

<p>He had to interview, take a class and write an essay. He doesn’t feel so confident, he thinks he did ok. It looked to me that he did great, but who knows. 97 kids interviewed for biz fellow, they will accept anywhere from 25-30 and then there will be alternates. biz program exceptional and very impressive. kids will travel to poland and ukraine next winter term all paid for by donor. great internship connections, senior project, and seminars.</p>

<p>went to hillel on friday eve. small group, but very nice. most of the kids sam met last year, so it was like hanging out with old friends.</p>

<p>even in the rain, campus looks beautiful and lots of new building going on. new apts for junior looks really nice.</p>

<p>in the eves, kids hung out in the lobby. went out to dinner in groups and met some terrific parents too.</p>

<p>great weekend. too short and very exhausting.</p>

<p>we will have a decision before April 1. fingers crossed.</p>