Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>EvanstonDad:
Closer to you, Kalamazoo College is a really interesting small college with a Hillel & Chabad. Kalamazoo, a small city with a couple of shuls and a Federation, is halfway between Chicago and Detroit. The students I’ve known to go there have all been Jewish (one a product of day school) but I can’t speak to the Jewish vibe.</p>

<p>Also in Michigan, Albion College has a Hillel. </p>

<p>Speaking of Chabad, on a growing # of campuses, Chabad, rather than Hillel, is now the spiritual or social center of Jewish life. Some Hillels don’t have a dedicated Rabbi or director, just a part-time advisor, while Chabad Houses always are run by a couple and often have better food!</p>

<p>According to non-observant D1, Chabad has much better food and she loves the Rebitzen! I never would have predicted that.</p>

<p>Welcome Evanstondad and Palmharbor. You’ve come to the right place.</p>

<p>Samtalya: It sounds like you have a wonderful weekend at Elon. I’ll keep my fingers crossed for your son.</p>

<p>Evanston Dad: Is Lake Forest College too close? It appears to have a sizable Jewish population: </p>

<p>[JUF</a> : College : Blog](<a href=“JUF : College”>JUF : College)</p>

<p>Would it be a good option for people on this thread looking for a smaller school near Chicago?</p>

<p>Welcome to Evanston Dad. I was an Evanston undergrad, but I’ve been back and, wow, how the town has changed!</p>

<p>I visited Lafayette on Veterans Day in November 2011 with DS (you can go back to that part of this thread and see what I wrote). I didn’t get the impression that it was preppy, but we weren’t really focused on that. It didn’t stand out to me as preppy though, and we attended a class (small! only 20) and ate lunch in one of the dining halls. DS will apply (note that he is an “A” student).</p>

<p>Regarding Delaware, I agree that you might want to take a look. It’s not far from PHL (does Southwest fly from Midway to PHL?). Delaware has a very active Hillel and Chabad. My DD, who is now at Delaware, also loved American - very different schools, but it was another top choice and she was accepted. I would definitely check it out.</p>

<p>Samtalya, I’m so happy that you had a great time this weekend. Rooting for your DS to become an Elon Fellow. </p>

<p>As so many of you are looking at colleges with juniors and others have seniors who will begin college in the fall, I want to share some advice. While you are looking at schools for majors and fit, PLEASE emphasize to your DD or DS that is is up to THEM to take advantage of all the school has to offer. Talk to them about taking risks and not pre-judging any activity or any group of people. Just get involved. In anything. Try things. Just do it. I really can’t emphasize this enough.</p>

<p>Evanstondad: not sure if your post “means” you are trying to stay local…</p>

<p>I do know a bunch of people here on CC who literally built their college list based on Southwest airlines flight path…direct, nonstop only with free flight changes…</p>

<p>May be a thought to check that out…and fwiw, teriwitt, a frequent poster elsewhere, had a daughter at Muhlenberg from the Chicago area…I think they used to fly in and out of Newark; literally an hour’s drive from the 'Berg…</p>

<p>Evanstondad, did you look at Bradley?
[JUF</a> News : New Bradley University Hillel House welcomes students home](<a href=“JUF News : JUF New(s)!”>JUF News : New Bradley University Hillel House welcomes students home)</p>

<p>Thanks for the Purim video-- it’s great also to Spectrum- I hope your son feels better quickly.</p>

<p>Thanks to everyone, and especially to rockvillemom, for contributing to this thread - it is invaluable! Unlike many of your kids, my DS is interested in very small schools (she prefers around 2000, although liked Ithaca which is larger). I’m interested in finding out more information about Allegheny College in Meadville PA. We have visited and were impressed, especially with the time and attention given us by virtually every adult we came across. Meadville was okay at best, at least what we saw of it, but that is not an issue for her. Does anyone know anything about Allegheny - especially Jewish life, but also about the school as a whole?</p>

<p>Thanks for all of the suggestions. Gave me a lot to think about. Here are my thoughts:</p>

<p>Rodney: In addition to a Jewish vibe, I think my D would appreciate a “Midwestern vibe.” East coast Jewish kids can be a little sophisticated for my D. That being said, it may not be possible to find a small school with both a Jewish and Midwestern vibe. As rvm has noted, there is no perfect school; something has to give.</p>

<p>Quakerstate: The only Jewish kids I know who go to Lake Forest College are transfer students where college #1 did not work out. Not a place with a Jewish vibe.</p>

<p>DeskPotato: Bradley is Muhlenberg 10+ years ago. Like many schools, it is trying to raise its stature by recruiting Jewish kids. It worked for Muhlenberg, Elon and Vanderbilt. While it’s a good school for B students, I am not sure whether the Jewish recruiting effort will take. </p>

<p>Lisztserve: Kalamazoo is an option. It’s been off and on our list. It shares a Hillel with Western Michigan University. We are not sure about the Jewish vibe. I have never met a Jewish kid from Chicago who went/is going to Albion.</p>

<p>Hello motherto2 and welcome! I love that your son likes the smaller schools - as there are so many great options. In PA - do consider Susquehanna, Dickinson, Lafayette, Muhlenberg, etc. If you are looking at western PA - there are also many good small schools in Ohio. I think we have discussed Denison, Ohio Wesleyan, etc. Jewish life will vary - but it’s not always just the actual student headcount that matters - but the level of activity on campus. Susquehanna, for example, has a small Jewish population, but it does have a dedicated Hillel house and a part-time Rabbi - so you can see they are trying hard to grow the Jewish population on campus. For a small group - they seem quite well established on campus.</p>

<p>On Allegheny - I have a cousin who graduated about 8 years ago, Overall good experience. His only negative was that most kids came from the Buffalo/Cleveland/Pittsburgh area and seemed to already have groups of friends established. He felt a little isolated freshman year. I think that with smaller schools - you really want to visit and spend time talking to students - getting the vibe of the student body. My opinion is that when you select a larger university - simply by virtue of the size - many different groups will co-exist and you should be able to find your niche. At a smaller school - this may be more of a challenge - depending on how mainstream or how offbeat your interests are.</p>

<p>EvanstonDad - how do you feel about western PA? Would Pitt be an option? Yes - it is bigger than 10,000 - but nice Jewish population - I have read such great things on this thread re Pittsburgh. Has rolling admissions - so if you apply early - as in over the summer - you could have that first acceptance in October. (I am a huge fan of having an acceptance in hand by Thanksgiving). Lots to do in Pittsburgh - and it might fit better with the midwestern vibe you desire. And you might want to also check out Allegheny.</p>

<p>from the website:</p>

<p>

</code></pre>

<p>Hillel link:</p>

<p><a href=“http://sites.allegheny.edu/admissions/hillel/[/url]”>http://sites.allegheny.edu/admissions/hillel/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p><a href=“http://sites.allegheny.edu/religiouslife/program/hillel/[/url]”>http://sites.allegheny.edu/religiouslife/program/hillel/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p><a href=“http://www.facebook.com/pages/Allegheny-Hillel/125849004139277[/url]”>http://www.facebook.com/pages/Allegheny-Hillel/125849004139277&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>This quote is 4 years old - it is from an article in Inside Higher Ed - in turn quoting from Reform Judaism magazine - focusing on colleges that have historically not had large Jewish populations and were trying to change that.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Read more: <a href=“http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2008/10/29/jewish#ixzz1oIOzHuJe[/url]”>http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2008/10/29/jewish#ixzz1oIOzHuJe&lt;/a&gt;
Inside Higher Ed</p>

<p>Finally - the national Hillel website shows the Jewish population at 85. We all know those figures are just estimates - but I think it supports my impression that the Jewish population is increasing.</p>

<p>samtalya - so glad your Elon visit went well - fingers crossed on the Fellows results. We are looking forward to our visit this weekend. Hillel is having a program Friday afternoon which we hope to attend.</p>

<p>I’ve only glance through over the past couple of days but thank you all so much for your good wishes. I am thrilled that over the past few days my S has been feeling soooo much better, and that I have my happy energetic kid back. He got through the dorm visit with flying colors even after eating some offending foods that would have been trouble a few days earlier. For now we are hopeful that he continues to feel well as we are introducing new foods and backing off the steroids. As for the decision, we’re not there yet but he loved UT.</p>

<p>RVM: I have hear wonderful things about Pitt. It has become much more popular in our area. Kids who have applied to BU and GWU are now also applying to Pitt.</p>

<p>I have a sister-in-law from Squirrel Hill, so I am familiar with the area. Have dined at “the O”. I think, however, that my D is looking for a more traditional campus. But you never know, if the weather is nice and the tour guide is cute, she may want to go there!</p>

<p>Spectrum, I’ve been away from CC for a while and hadn’t noticed your posts about your son and his diagnosis of ulcerative colitis. I am happy to hear that he is feeling so much better.
As a retired pediatrician I know that finding good specialist care for a 17 or 18 y/o can be difficult. Pediatric specialists may think they are too old and adult specialists may think they are too young for their patient populations, It sounds as though you have found a good, caring physician to manage your son’s care. At least I hope so. Management of chronic conditions like UC requires both attention to the individual’s response to treatment and staying up to date with the latest treatment modalities. For your son’s age group it is very important for the physician to be aware of developmental issues and concerns: late adolescence/early adulthood is a transitional stage, not an abrupt transformation. </p>

<p>Having been a faculty member at UT Austin (in an earlier career as an English professor), I think it is very good choice for a Jewish student. There are sufficient numbers and such good support that every Jewish student in the range from secular to Orthodox should be able to find a place. Although Austin is not a major medical center like Houston or my old home base of Seattle, it has excellent medical care, including access to first-rate specialist care. In fact, we used to send some patients to Austin for pediatric specialist care that was not available in San Antonio, where I practiced, even though we had a medical school and Austin didn’t.</p>

<p>We visited Allegheny. The young Hillel advisor is lovely and very proactive. The school seems very nurturing. Allegheny has a lively theater & communications department and sends a lot of students on to medical school. </p>

<p>Lafayette is a nice size, lots of discussion-based & interdisciplinary classes. It offers a liberal arts engineering major, which is an interesting approach. The tour was worthwhile - two students assigned to our family for an hour, completely focused on our interests, no canned patter. The guides raved about their internships, research projects, relationships with teachers, opportunities to participate in new activities. Students run an organic garden among other eco initiatives. I saw kids working together on projects all over the place. My impression was of busy, engaged, friendly, down-to-earth students. Lafayette has a Jewish studies minor. About 10% of the students are Jewish. Hillel is active, with programs through the year and a kosher kitchen students can use.</p>

<p>spectrum: I’m glad that your son is feeling better.</p>

<p>Upstream a bit, I think someone mentioned Franklin and marshall. I know it’s a good fit for Jewish kids, but can anyone comment on their reputation for grade deflation?</p>

<p>On another note, have any of the NY parents here been to Chap a nosh in Cedarhurst for Passover catering?</p>

<p>Evanstondad,
My daughter also played in the Maccabi games at Townsend. We were also pleasantly surprised. It was still a bit small for her. What sport does your daughter play?</p>