Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Hi HouTxmom,
So nice to see another Texan here. Will your D be going for her avodah summer this year? No doubt our kids paths have crossed. Ha, that question, about how many times these kids have been told they are going to hell, I didn’t think to ask that one. Both my kids have had the experience of being told that they are going to hell but not to the point of it becoming tedious. They both barely mentioned it to me although my older S had a discussion that nearly ended a friendship that went along those lines but ended in a heart felt apology and they are still friends. The general feeling I got from the A&M kids and staff was that having some faith, any faith was probably easier than having no religion at A&M. This is generally what I found to be true with my kids growing up here. My older S had a burning desire to leave Texas and is really enjoying being in a “liberal” state in college. I don’t think that this has a lot to do with his Judaism but more his perspectives on life. My younger S wanted no part of leaving TX and likes both of his choices a little too much. I would bet if your daughter has any interest in TAMU you could contact Hillel and ask any questions you might have to the very welcoming staff and possibly some students they put you in contact with. I understand your thoughts about TAMU because there was a time that I told a friend that I would never send my child there. Then we visited and it is an entirely different feeling. I would say that if your daughter wants to leave Texas it could be a refreshing change for her, but if she wants to stay you might keep an open mind about TAMU you could be very pleasantly surprised. Please feel free to PM me if you have any specific questions. Good Luck! BTW if it works for you, you might check this out in April, <a href=“https://sites.google.com/site/jewishaggiesopenhouse/[/url]”>https://sites.google.com/site/jewishaggiesopenhouse/&lt;/a&gt;. This event would no doubt give you the opportunity to ask your questions to students face to face and to explore Jewish life as an Aggie. If you do go I’d be interested in hearing what you find out. If my S picks TAMU we might even see you there :).</p>

<p>Yes, she’ll be an avodah this summer. She’s not set on leaving TX for college. Actually, she likes her HS a lot. There are kids of every religion and no religion, and Jews are definitely not considered unusual. There aren’t many people there who’d lecture her about hell; she just tells them that she thinks hell is fictitious. </p>

<p>It sounds like the Hillel at TAMU is pretty impressive. I’m not sure if TAMU itself would be a good fit for her.</p>

<p>Just so you know it’s not just TX, my daughter was told she was going to hell when she was in kindergarten in Ann Arbor, MI. (Though to be fair, the lesbian principal was horrified when I informed her, and I was then invited to the classroom for every Jewish holiday to read stories, bring cookies, teach draydel games, etc.)</p>

<p>Hi all, S and H attended an admitted students event at Case Western and returned quite positive but still considering several schools (and waiting to hear from a few more). S is an undecided liberal arts major. (GPA 3.2-3.3 UW; 2240 SAT)</p>

<p>As expected, found an overwhelming engineering presence at the event and on campus. But the non-engineering departments are strong, and present/see themselves as an LAC within the larger university. The growth in undergrad #s in the past few years has been liberal arts or at least non-engineering. It’s a bit hard to tease out as the economics department is located in the business college and the Arts & Sciences college includes premeds and hard science students. But students are admitted to the U as a whole, are free to take classes in any of the 4 undergrad colleges, with lots of interdisciplinary offerings. (Can also easily cross-register in Institutes of Art and Music located within the University Circle area.) A number of premed/engineering students do change their majors to liberal arts. </p>

<p>S is interested, at this moment, in humanities and social sciences. He attended a psych class and was highly impressed. He liked the kids he met. I was pleased and frankly surprised to hear no negative report about a “nerdy scene.” In HS, he has taken challenging math and sci classes, but doesn’t hang out with the science or academic crowd - far from it. I’m sort of hoping he finds his “inner nerd”, in fact. </p>

<p>Courses are hard, but seems to be plenty of support - a big issue for us. SAGES program is interesting: intended to build skills in writing, critical thinking & research through a series of 5 required general education classes. First semester prof is your academic advisor until you pick a major, suggesting remediation, helping direct class choices, etc. Several weeks into each semester, students get an interim grade, which seems very helpful. We will be talking to the disability office this week re ADHD. Would anyone like me to share that info?</p>

<p>There’s a well-established Hillel, offering the usual Shabbat & holiday services and meals and social activities. Director came from SUNY-Binghamton, one of S’s other acceptances, which is 30% Jewish. CW is more like 7% Jewish. It’s a big difference! At Case, if he doesn’t get involved with Hillel, unlikely to have many Jewish friends.</p>

<p>S liked the campus and the feel of a small U in a big city. He did wonder why, on a warm & sunny afternoon, he didn’t see anyone playing on the outdoor courts or hanging around outside. He was told that a lot of kids have afternoon internships.</p>

<p>Should I post visit report on CWRU forum?</p>

<p>Hi - absolutely. I think that a good CC technique its to “belong” to one (or more) parent thread such as this one - and to also post/read on the individual college threads that interest your student. That way - you get both the broader perspective - and specific info/feedback on colleges that are of interest to you.</p>

<p>Our experience was similar Sop14, I did a Chanukah program each year when kids were in grades 1-6. When S2 had his first hell encounter in 1st grade it was close to the high holy days so his teacher asked me to do a program about that as well.</p>

<p>Houtx: There is so much polarized discussion about both UT and TAMU, don’t buy into it, check them out before ruling them out (or in). I found some of the smaller schools were friendly but the numbers are so small that we didn’t want to bank on the Jewish population from one year to the next. Most of the kids from here that I know who are looking for a Jewish presence go to UT or leave the state, many to schools discussed on this thread. I do know a few kids who did get into UT who were not in the top 9% (I think next year it will be 8% for auto admit) so your D still might make it into UT which sounds like her first choice. Keep in mind also that all (or most) of the state schools have a criteria for automatic admissions based on class rank beyond top 10, 9 or 8 and standardized test scores. If you Google the school name and automatic admissions you should find their criteria. Good luck.</p>

<p>Lisztserve - Thanks for the review of Case Western, we are taking my junior son to visit over spring break and I would love to hear your impressions of the disability office since my son has both Aspergers and ADHD.</p>

<p>I have read all the posts, but haven’t posted much because junior year has been such a roller coaster. Great test scores, but grades have been all over the place and we will have to wait to see his 4th quarter grades to determine what schools are reaches and what schools are matches. I think we are set with safeties (UMBC and University of Alabama.) Even Alabama is in the air depending on his grades this year, because he needs the 3.5 to get the National Merit Scholarship. I have been more stressed about grades since his PSAT scores came back and realized he could qualify for merit so many places if his grades stayed up - of course that was the moment his grades started to tank.</p>

<p>Also, after being in a pre-engineering program he is starting to question majoring in engineering. He may want to major in pure math or physics so we are bringing him to some liberal arts schools over break to get a taste of them. I feel like we know less then when we started the college search.</p>

<p>Over Spring Break we are visiting UMBC, Dickinson, Kenyon, Case Western, U of Pittsburgh and Carnigie Mellon and have no idea if he will get into any of them. He could finish the year with a 3.7/3.8 UW or a 3.3/3.4. His SATs are 1600 and 2330 and SAT 2s Chemistry 800 and Math 2 800.</p>

<p>socaldad - Thank you for sharing information about Pitt. My son and I spent a lot of time researching it this weekend, and we planned a visit during April break. It seems to fit what he is looking for, other than its large size . I guess you can’t have everything! According to Hillel website - Jewish population is 2000. I guess it isn’t a big deal, but it appears to be mainly in-state students. Just hope this doesn’t take away from campus life? Wondering if kids go home on the weekends. This is a question to ask when we’re there next month. </p>

<p>I also appreciate the feeback about BU. Although I felt it wasn’t a campus-feel, this was not an issue for my son. So it’s on his list (possibly 1st choice). But when I compare the price with Pitt, it’s unbelievable. Nearly $20K difference/year - hope he enjoys our visit next month! Is the “name” worth that much?</p>

<p>Wondering - given that the tours/info sessions are marketing tools… how do you really assess a school if you don’t know someone who has recently attended? Is this site the answer??</p>

<p>There are about a dozen freshman at Pitt from our HS this year, and we’re a good 5 1/2 hours away. I don’t think freshman are allowed cars. I was talking to a parent of a young person who is a junior majoring in engineering at Pitt and she told me that her son was in China for Spring break - [Programs</a> > Brochure > Study Abroad Office](<a href=“http://www.abroad.pitt.edu/index.cfm?FuseAction=Programs.ViewProgram&Program_ID=11017&Type=O&sType=O]Programs”>http://www.abroad.pitt.edu/index.cfm?FuseAction=Programs.ViewProgram&Program_ID=11017&Type=O&sType=O) I thought that was pretty cool! Pennsylvania is a big state and Pitt offers a substantial discount for being in-state. It stands to reason that most students are going to be from Pennsylvania, the same is true at Penn State, Ohio State, University of Maryland, etc. Does not mean that they are suitcase schools! ;)</p>

<p>Champs, If my memory is correct, Pitt is 30% OOS. That is a reasonably high number for a state school. When we visited, many kids from Jersey, NY, and Maryland. Also met one from Mass, Illinois. These were just the tour guides. I do not get the sense it was a suitcase school.</p>

<p>Pitt is definitely not a suitcase school. With about a third OOS, and about a third from the Philly metro area (which is a 6 hours bus ride), at least 60% of students are likely very far from home. My D at Pitt so far has only come home for one weekend plus thanksgiving, winter and spring break. There is a lot to do on campus and in the city, so there is no reason for kids to go home. For kids that come from Central PA, the attraction of Pitt is getting away from their small towns where there is nothing to do, so they are not anxious to return for weekends.</p>

<p>champs - try to allow time for the unscripted when visiting campuses. Do the info session and tour - but then wander around on your own - eat lunch on campus - stop in the student center, etc. I find it interesting to observe the students on campus - how they are dressed (too preppy or quirky for son’s taste - too many Greek letters) - whether they tend to be walking alone or in small groups - are kids eating alone or in groups - are the groups racially diverse or segregated, etc. If your son is comfortable doing so - encourage him to start a conversation with some random students other than the tour guides - in order to get the real vibe of the school.</p>

<p>lisztserve, thanks for your report. Mom24boys, we too will also be visiting Case Western over spring break.</p>

<p>Sop14’s Mom - Looks like a lot of people have discovered Case, I wonder what the next “unknown” school is going to be. Husband is turning the trip into a “Man v. Food” pilgrimage and the 7 yr twins are looking forward to zoos and hotel pools. I just hope for some direction regarding DS1’s college search. I can see DS2 (HS freshman) at a liberal arts school somewhere so if DS 1 doesn’t get anything out of the trip DS 2 may.</p>

<p>After reading the responses about the OOS’ness at Pitt, I feel better, because it certainly sounds like a good “fit” in so many ways. I was concerned that it might be a suitcase school, but I feel reassured now - many of you have raised some great points. </p>

<p>RVM - appreciate your suggestions for our visit. Thanks!</p>

<p>So to all you “regulars” on this thread: As I mentioned on Friday evening, I have been reading this thread… currently in August 2011 (2/3 through your posts)… Very enlightening! Now I wish I had thought to take notes - do I need to start over? There have been many valuable references regarding lots of schools (although some would not be for my son, for example if it doesn’t offer Engineering), I could share my new information with friends! It sounds like Elon and UDel were on your “radar” last summer… And UMiami, UConn. Oh… and I plan to start using your abbreviations - including nicknames for one another!</p>

<p>At the time of these posts last summer, many of you were mentioning your kids’ choices, so I’m curious where they are all attending!</p>

<p>Mom24boys–Case has been well-known in the Midwest for many years.</p>

<p>I have been AWOL for awhile from this thread since my kids are in college now and no longer on the hunt, but I thought I would give my thoughts on Case Western. I got my Masters degree there several decades ago, so things have probably changed a great deal, but here are my recollections of the campus. Good programs in engineering and graduate programs in law and medicine. I grew up in a western suburb of Cleveland and commuted to Case. I had the sense that it was not like a traditional campus (and nothing like Miami of Ohio were I went undergrad.) Few people hung around outside of buildings. The area around the school is not the safest (this may have changed, but I dreaded taking the bus every day that year) and it is very near downtown. Let’s be frank, an urban campus in Cleveland is not like an urban campus in New Orleans or D.C., Cleveland is just not that much fun (one of the reasons I left the area.) I think it has a great reputation, and I enjoyed going to afternoon concerts in the symphonic hall which is on campus, but your child should know that it will not be your typical college campus, or for that matter, a typical LAC with a campus culture. I understand that not every student wants that type of campus and so CWRU may be perfect for them. In Jewish terms, CWRU is near the suburb of Shaker Heights (large Jewish population) and kids might be able to locate synagogues nearby.</p>

<p>Hey, Molto - welcome back! Can you tell us more about your undergrad years at Miami? I’m sure things have changed but as an alum, you can probably give us some info on then and now. It’s on our list…</p>

<p>Mom24Boys: Please provide details on UMBC after your visit. I was just PMing with someone on the UMBC thread (her DD is a freshman there now). Two things she said concern me: there’s not a lot going on on campus over the weekend and 50% of the freshman seem to go home on weekends. Can you ask about this when you are there? I would also be interested in any other information you can report back on. I would love to have a better match;/financial safety for DS than Binghamton, which he really doesn’t like.</p>

<p>It’s been a long while since I went to Miami U, but my next door neighbor’s son is a senior there and one of my son’s best friends is a freshman. The campus is beautiful, lots of red brick buildings with white pillars, very colonial in architecture. Unfortunately, it is in the middle of nowhere. The nearest big city is Cincinnati, so make sure you enjoy your weekends in Oxford! The Greek scene is big and essential to having a busy social calendar on campus. I was not in a sorority and had to find my own group to hang out with, but after a couple of years, we were pretty tired of the same bars in Oxford. My favorite semester was my year abroad in Spain. The professors are great (I majored in PolSci), the business school is good (although my neighbor with a decent GPA still hasn’t found a job and will be going to a 5th year masters.) I had friends in engineering and architecture and those programs were solid. My son’s friend is majoring in photography, so I assume the arts are good. The football team is good, but hockey is king at Miami. I know they are building, or have built, a new rec center which looks amazing from the pictures I get. The kids tend to come from middle to upper middle class families and suburban areas, so what I remember is that the campus was very homogeneous, which was not what I wanted when I went to college (I was a latter day hippie type with visions of politically active discussions in a ratskeller. my sister demonstrated at Miami when the Kent State shootings happened). I couldn’t wait to graduate and move on, but it would be a lovely experience for the right kid. There are only 1 or 2 to Jewish fraternities, but the kids I know there now say the Jewish presence seems to have gone down since I attended.</p>