<p>ctyankee, I think Carleton is an amazing school for the right student, but it is very different than St. Olaf. It is comparing apples and oranges. I can see St. Olaf as a college that will change lives because of its atmosphere and culture. They have a mix of students at different grade levels, although their selectivity has risen lately. Carleton is basically an Amherst in the midwest. Both are outstanding colleges for the right fit. I recently visited both schools and there is no question that St. Olaf would be a much better fit for my daughter.</p>