Common app essay too "heavy"?

<p>I have writte an essays for the common app, which people are finding “too heavy” :confused: I am from Bangladesh (Asia).</p>

<p>Important background essay: I went to pick up my younger brother’s school report to find out he had done poorly in maths. I was explaining fractions to him near the front gate when another boy answered the sum the question correctly. He was not a student, but worked odd jobs at the school. Interested, I asked him more questions to find out he was very sharp minded but had discontinued studies after the 3rd grade to help his family.At the time I was depressed because I was not able to afford the tuition fees at a private medical school I had gotten accepted to. I thought that was the end of my dreams, and basically the end of my life, since I had so single minded-ly concentrated on studying medicine. But on seeing him I realized that at least I had the opportunity to study and probably have (harder and longer maybe) more opportunities to study medicine. Basically at least I was lucky enough to be able to help myself, whereas he wasn’t.</p>

<p>So this taught me to see the bright side of basically every situation, because I would count the opportunities I had instead of the ones I didn’t get. And it also taught me to make the best out every situation to respect the people over whom I got it. </p>

<p>I am sponsoring Hossain’s (the boy) complete education at Jaago Foundation for 40 US dollars per month (which I easily earn through private tuitions).</p>

<p>So should I scrap this essay and write something more light and easy to read? Does it concentrate more on Hossain than me?</p>

<p>You seem very privileged, but it is hardly heavy. The main conflict with this essay is that there is no character development and aside from seeing that you are philanthropic, there isn’t much a college will learn from it. Essays should be self reflective. Question yourself and why you do things. Try to learn about who you are and then write about it. Explore one small 1x1 snapshot of your character and go as in depth as you can.</p>

<p>It is a fine topic. Just make sure the focus on on you and how your life, your outlook, your future plans etc. have been impacted by your relationship with Hossein. It is wonderful that you are giving back such in a meaningful and personal way.</p>