<p>Maybe this was discussed before, but the current system of admission does not sound right. I think all IVYs should get together and have a common application or supplement and in that application/supplement ask what are the preferences amongst the IVY colleges.
Once a cadidate is deemed admission worthy, they should look at the preference of which IVY and then make him just one offer. If that preference is not available they can go to the best available based on his/her list of preferences.</p>
<p>All the admission officers from 8 IVYs can get together, spend 3-4 weeks/cull the candidates and then make admission offers based on preference amongst the the list of IVYs. They can even shortlist candidates for interviews if need be.
Lots of duplication and applicant consternation can be eased with this approach.
The number of application and the overlap has come to a stage where this needs to be looked seriously. I thought IVYs teach and practice proactive out of the box thinking!!!</p>
<p>This is followed in India amongst at IIMs (Indian Institutes of Management) and IITs (Indian Institutes of Technology)</p>
<p>Besides seemingly making less work for applicants, I fail to see how such a system would be of any benefit. It seems to me that if anything that would substantially increase the length of a single application even for students who are only interested in one Ivy, limit choices for students who are not totally decided either way, shut more applicants out of admission due to a more standardized procedure for all Ivies, and ultimately create internal conflicts between the Ivy League colleges in who gets which applicants. However, I may be misunderstanding your proposal. Could you explain exactly who this would benefit?</p>
<p>That all sounds like a terrible idea to be honest. </p>
<p>-Why on earth are you aggregating “Ivy League” like it’s one big homogeneous body? It isn’t. It’s made up of very individual and distinct schools, with very distinct personalities and shades of nuance in what they look for in applicants. It would make zero sense whatsoever for them to “pool” applicants. </p>
<ul>
<li>Also, why this focus on “if one ivy doesn’t accept, the applicant moves down a list until one eventually does” - because it sounds to me like you’re just prestige-whoring, hoping for an Ivy, any Ivy, rather than considering fit and personality. </li>
</ul>
<p>To sum:</p>
<ol>
<li><p>You haven’t actually shown, nor proven, nor really raised any good points to show that there’s anything wrong with the current system.</p></li>
<li><p>What you’re proposing sounds like it will do more harm than good. </p></li>
</ol>
<p>Thank god no school administrator will be taking your advice.</p>
<p>Uhmm, I think your suggested system would lead to antitrust violation charges by the Dept of Justice.</p>
<p>In the 1990s, I think, the US DOJ brought charges against Ivies for colluding on financial aid. (Financial aid people from the Ivies and MIT got together at the end of spring and tried to offer basically single financial aid.) I think the Ivies this did to prevent bidding on candidates. Some schools tried to get around this by offering research scholarships (Princeton).</p>
<p>How would you like to have heads of all major international airlines getting together once a year, and agreeing on price for various routes. Bette yet, at the meeting, airline heads divvy up geographic region, and agree to not to compete in certain regions.</p>
<p>Dont know about the legalities, but seems overstretching to apply antitrust to this.
But in my view there are at-least two advantages:</p>
<p>1) How different are supplement for all these schools? Other than why you want to attend a particular university, everything else in supplement can be made common to all IVYs. There are a few questions like why you want to apply for PLME(Brown) which can be resolved through some other means like interviews after shortlisting. I claim that the applicants can save lot of time doing this one consolidated application with an attached order of preference list of ivies (if they are admitted). Also there will be some consistency which gets lost when you are doing up-to eight different applications.</p>
<p>2) Why should the same candidate get in multiple universities? Why should someone who gets into Harvard (his first choice) also get in 7 other universities and then reject them. Other than bragging rights, it serves no purpose (waste of paper it is printed on). The candidate can do the pre-homework to decide his preferences at the time of application and get one offer (could be first choice or eighth choice).</p>
<p>3) I am sure the capitalists in you want all universities to act autonomous and base their decisions completely independently. But at what level of inefficiency and end user frustation. From a consumer point of view, I feel it does not violate capitalistic principles. Still you get the best choice you were eligible for.</p>
<p>4) It is an idea and am sure has merits/demerits. Needs to be tweaked if the overall goal makes sense.</p>
<p>Hey, if someone has the skills to get into all of those schools, he has the prerogative to reject them. Also, that’s what waitlist is for. Life isn’t fair. If you were the kid getting into all 8 ivies (if that’s your aspiration), then I bet you wouldn’t want this idea either. Also, why should you have to rank schools? That’s why many ivies have done away with ED and EA, because it puts those who have to factor in FA packages into their decisions at a disadvantage.</p>
<p>Being and Indian in America, I can say with experience that the Indian university system is much, MUCH different from the American secondary education system. They are not in anyway, shape or form similar.<br>
I see your first problem: You wrote the Ivies as IVY. They aren’t like IIT. They aren’t connected in anyway. Ivy league is a reference to the sports division they are in. They don’t have sports divisions in India, but here college athletics are a big deal. The Ive league is an athletic conference. Here’s some info on the two terms:
[Athletic</a> conference - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia](<a href=“http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Athletic_conference]Athletic”>Athletic conference - Wikipedia)
[Ivy</a> League - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia](<a href=“http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivy_League]Ivy”>Ivy League - Wikipedia)</p>
<p>In short, the Ivy leagues are separate entities. They don’t have the same sources for funding, the same classes, majors etc. They are very different. They are still referred to as Ivy Leagues educationally (even though the term isn’t an educational term, rather it’s an athletic related term) because they are known to be some of the best schools in the world.<br>
Also, there isn’t a “criteria” per say. They claim that they look at people as a whole. When it comes down to it if you’re qualified at one of these schools, chances are you’re qualified at the rest. It all comes down to how many spots are available. You might not make the cut for spots available.
How does that happen, you ask? Well… not everyone applies to all the Ivies. so someone amazing might get into Harvard and Yale but not apply to any of the other ivies, creating extra space for others who are qualified. Also, the ivies won’t typically fight over academically strong students… however, they will fight over international/national award winners or athletes. </p>
<p>I think the first word that helicopter parents have their children learn is “ivy.” They write it out in big block letters like this–IVY–and then they have their children stare at it for hours every day. When their children finally begin to learn how to write, this is the first word that they are taught, and they have to write it over and over again in big block letters just like this:</p>
<p>IVY.</p>
<p>And, when they’re finally rejected from the IVY League schools, after so many years of painstaking toil and misery, that is what they begin to carve into their arms and thighs–IVY–at their first year at Stanford/MIT.</p>
<p>I completely agree with the OP, and have advocated for that for many years on CC. Creativity is possible for the willing. It’s going to require, though, that these instititions understand that the advantages of such a system ultimately outweigh the initial withdrawal syndrome associated with letting go of bare-knuckle competition.</p>
<p>I have no idea what post #10 is talking about For the vast majority of parents I know, on and off CC, Ivies are variously (1) a surprise admit, (2) included among many options on the college list, (3) definitely not the be-all and end-all of education, let alone of life. Maybe, though, my experience partly reflects regional differences in worship practices.</p>
<p>Re Post #9 (and others logically thinking along those lines), a true admissions consortium would not erase differences among these U’s, but in fact acknowledge them. It would be more of a combo of a match system (a la Questbridge), combined with ED I and II. I haven’t yet figured out whether it would be good to offer an opt-in/opt-out, but it would be designed to favor those who opt in.</p>
<p>I’m sorry, but this just doesn’t sound like a very good idea. I’m going out on a limb here, but if Ivies can do this, who’s to say that a unified admissions system for top LACs, or top technology institutes, or the Pac-10, or whatever, is not justified? Like other posters have said, Ivy League institutions are completely separate entities, and there’s nothing really to justify the existence such a system among them any more than there is for any other grouping of schools.</p>
<p>I do love the creativity of the idea though.</p>
<p>No one “says” it. That’s the entire point. Colleges could organize themselves along the most logical common denominator. It hasn’t been tried yet. The idea hasn’t been developed it. And one consortium would not cancel admissibility to another; one could apply to multiple consortia, but always within the parameters of each.</p>
<p>It may be seemingly easier for the applicant but there are nuances.</p>
<p>Let’s look at how the UC system does it. I think most would agree that there are vast differences between the flagship UC Berkeley and the newest campus which just had it’s first graduating class last year, UC Merced. Yes indeed, the UC system has a common application. But when it comes to writing the two personal statements, imagine that you are really interested in, say, UCLA but really aren’t jazzed with Berkeley. Now, let’s throw in some mid tier campuses to ensure some matches, then maybe Riverside for a safety. Try writing those two essays that go to ALL the places you put an app fee down for. Are you going to want to write something different from Berkeley than Santa Cruz? Probably, but the same two essays go to however many campuses you apply to, there are no supplements. No letters of recommendation accepted, either.</p>
<p>^ Again, with EDI and EDII (or a limit of 2-3 EA schools per consortium), the applicant is choosing specific colleges by preference. There’s no mystery about it. If you only truly wanted Yale or Columbia or Penn, you wouldn’t apply to Dartmouth, let alone write an essay for D. And, just as now with Common App, there would be Supplements requiring a candidate to issue a Statement of Purpose for attending that U, and any other additions that U wanted to throw in there.</p>
<p>There would have to be other reforms which I listed in my earlier proposals. One would be that, if ED of any kind is in the mix, decisions would not be binding for any FA student. Right now that situation is very murky. One is supposed to be able to challenge, based on not enough aid, but there can be perception and definition differences between institution and family.</p>
<p>As I said, it would be best (both for the U’s and for the student) if there were still an option to include more applications to each consortium in a traditional, non-systematic process, but it would be designed to encourage the match concept.</p>
<p>And I’m not sure why the poster in #14 brought up UC, as the proposal is about private colleges.</p>