Comp sci as a newly added major at small college

My son is interested in Eastern University, a small Christian college in PA. He is a junior in high school, and wants to major in computer science. Eastern is just adding this as a newly offered major starting this fall. So when my son enrolls, the program will only be in it’s second year. This being a small college, I’m worried/curious about the quality they could offer. If it was a more established major, then he really likes the school but as of now, we are not sure. He will look into the program again in the fall. We like Eastern because it’s close by, but even if the comp sci major is good, with good professors, would it be looked down on since it’s so new? I think Eastern has a good reputation in our area (suburban Philadelphia).
Another top choice he likes is Taylor University in Indiana, which seems to have a fantastic comp sci major. But it’s far and he won’t know anyone there.
Any thoughts?

May want to find out how many faculty and planned upper level course offerings in the next several semesters.

The CS department at Eastern University appears to be very limited.
I count only 9 CS courses listed on the website. That is barely enough to cover the needs of a major even if a student takes every single one of them. The site does not list any CS faculty members (only 3 mathematicians for Math/CS).

Taylor University’s program does appear to be more solid. It’s quite normal to know few if any people at a college when you first arrive. Unless it’s a local public school, most other students are likely to be in the same boat and eager to meet new people.

To compare CS departments, you might want to check out CS programs at Swarthmore/Haverford/BrynMawr just to see what a more established CS program looks like at a small college in your area. Villanova is a larger, respected school in suburban Philadelphia; its CS department lists 18 full-time faculty. Or have a look at Drexel’s program. Any decent CS department, almost regardless of how selective the school is, ought to cover pretty much the same basic subjects (with enough CS faculty members plus adjuncts to offer most required courses at least once a year). Even at a small LAC, you’d probably want to see at least ~5 CS faculty members listed on the department pages (although some may get by with fewer full time faculty supplemented by adjuncts).

@ucbalumnus (^) has posted an informative survey of basic CS courses offered at many small colleges:
http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/math-computer-science-majors/1814245-computer-science-at-some-smaller-schools-including-liberal-arts-colleges-p2.html
(see post #18)

There is a big shortage of CS professors across the country. So I am not sure how a small regional LAC would have the resources to attract even a couple of CS PhD faculty members. A disturbing trend among lower tier colleges is to create a “new shiny” major without any resources (e.g. faculty) to support it.

Even top-tier Haverford seems to have challenges with staffing their CS department according to this recent article:
https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2018/05/09/no-clear-solution-nationwide-shortage-computer-science-professors#.WvLEqkngcG8.linkedin

^For the reasons pointed out in the Inside Higher Ed article above, UCBalumnus’ post referred to above it may be out of date.

I recommend against it. There is no way they have the faculty to do justice to a CS major program.

Yes, the post linked from reply #2 may be out of date, but you can get an idea of what typical upper level CS courses to check for as listed in that linked post.

9 courses total for the major? It’s likely this CS major isn’t abet accredited and won’t teach someone enough to really be comfortable in the field. Being a software engineer isn’t just writing code, you can learn that for free, it’s about the mathematical process and understanding a problem. For example at Ucla we have 5 lower division com sci courses alone for the major. Plus a lot more upper divs.

@10s4life FYI: ABET accreditation does not matter one bit for CS. To illustrate this, neither Stanford nor CMU are ABET accredited for CS, and they are considered some of the top programs in the country.

I just looked at Eastern’s CS major requirements, and while the courses are limited, the major does hit the courses you’d expect in a CS major, and appears to be very similar to majors at many LACs, except without flexibility in the “elective” choices. I would not rule out the school based on the requirements and offerings, but rather investigate further. Things like faculty and when courses are offered are very important.

Note the major requires 14 courses, of which 9 are CS courses. According to the website, the required courses are:
Intro to Programming (C++), Data Structures, Databases, Networking, Programming Languages, Operating Systems, Computer Architecture, Artificial Intelligence, Analysis of Algorithms, Ethical and Philosophical Issues in Computer and Data Science, Calculus I, Calculus II, Discrete Mathematics, Linear Algebra.

For comparison, I just completed the BS in CS at the University of Richmond, which has a well-established program, and our BS major (we also have a BA) consists of 14.5 units (basically 14.5 classes), of which 9.5 are CS courses: Intro CS (java), Data Structures, Discrete Structures (Mathematics), Software Systems Development (.5 unit course that teaches C++ and Linux, among other things), Computer Organization (Architecture), Algorithms, Programming Languages, Calculus I, Calculus II, Linear Algebra, 3 300-level CS electives (of which there are about a dozen courses to choose from, plus special topics- I took Computer Security, Simulation, and Operating Systems as mine), two science intermediate/advanced core classes (can be fulfilled in math, chem, physics, or bio- as a math double major I used math courses).

Agreed, ABET does not matter for pure CS. Computer Engineering I would assume the answer would be yes.

@guineagirl96 @MAandMEmom I agree abet normally doesn’t matter for CS but since the program is so new and limited its a big drawback. You went to a well established program like you said so yourself with a wide array of course offerings. I just think that going to a school with 9 required major courses and little outside CS electives isn’t the greatest program to pursue. Abet does provide a baseline standardization which is good as Stanford and cmu are good enough that abet acreditation doesn’t affect the quality already.

Yeah, but Eastern U – a tiny Christian school with zero track record in CS – isn’t exactly Stanford or CMU. There are real reasons to be concerned about Eastern’s cred as a CS school (which is precisely why this thread was started). If the CS program was ABET-accredited, then no one would doubt that the program was “legit”, and we wouldn’t be having this discussion. Stanford and CMU don’t need independent third-party accreditation to show that they are “legit”, but Eastern could use that kind of help.

I don’t think ABET accredits programs until they have graduated their first class. If the Eastern program is brand new, it may not even be eligible for full accreditation yet, although it could potentially qualify as an ABET candidate.

CS is in the Math Dept at Eastern and there are only 3 professors listed in the Math Dept
https://www.eastern.edu/academics/programs/mathematics-department/mathematics-faculty

If he wants CS, I would look elsewhere. There are other Christian affiliated colleges near Philadelphia that are stronger in CS.

For what it is worth, CS majors at many schools are not eligible for ABET accreditation, because ABET accreditation requires at least a year (30-32 credits in the typical credit scheme of 120-128 credits to graduate) of course work in math and non-CS science. It looks like Eastern does not have that in the degree requirements for the CS major.

Agree that ABET accreditation for CS per se is not very important (except for special situations like the patent exam), though, if present, it can indicate that the major does meet a reasonable minimum standard.

Another situation: as interest in CS continues to grow, more schools (including some big names) are introducing “dual-track” programs in CS + X (where X is often business). But it’s usually difficult to fit two such degree tracks into four years – unless the schools “water down” the CS (or the X, or both). Anecdotally, some employers look less favorably on CS + X degrees for that reason. So it can be helpful if the CS side has ABET.

I know a Lehigh grad from their four-year “Computer Science and Business” program, who claims that the dual programmatic accreditation (ABET for the CS side, AACSB for the Business side) has been a significant plus. No one questions the credibility of either credential.

I don’t see anything wrong with the list of classes required for the CS major at Eastern. The main issue is lack of options, but if you’re satisfied with the classes needed to graduate, it looks OK to me.