How would y’all compare these schools for mechanical engineering in terms of in terms of perceived achievement upon graduation? in other words, which are the most respected by employers, grad schools and so on?
Schools are
UT Austin
UW Madison
Vanderbilt
Colorado School of Mines
and Cal Poly SLO
All of them? The differences here are going to be pretty small - I’d focus on other factors for choosing between them.
Likely very very minimal differences.
Instead, ask: How do these schools admit to engineering specific major? Do I have to apply to my major after one year of first year engineering classes? If so, how competitive is it to get my major of choice?
If I’m admitted to my specific major but change my mind a few months in, can I switch engineering majors (cough cough, looking at you University of Texas!).
And secondly, look at cost.
What have your parents said they can pay for you per year to go to college?
Or, even if you are admitted directly to the major, is there an explicit weed-out procedure, like the 3.2 technical and 3.0 overall GPA needed to stay in mechanical engineering at Wisconsin?
https://www.engr.wisc.edu/academics/student-services/academic-advising/first-year-undergraduate-students/progression-requirements/
Go for whichever one costs the least. If they’re all out of state, scrap all of them and choose something in-state. Debt is not your friend!