Conflicted! Transfer from a full ride to a better-known school?

I am thinking about transferring universities. I currently have a full ride at a lesser known Texas school; I am in the honors college and am getting a degree in their personal financial planning program, which is one of the best in the country. Should I stay at the school or transfer to a liberal arts degree at UT? I am very conflicted.

A full ride is a pretty sweet deal, and an honors college hopefully makes it a good educational experience. What year are you in now? What would your out-of-pocket be at UT? Would you be able to do a semester or even a full year abroad, under your scholarship, from where you are?

This is an excellent personal financial planning case study :slight_smile: How much would you save, over the whole four years, by keeping the full ride? What post-graduate opportunities could that money buy you, and how do those opportunities compare to what 2-3 years of undergrad at UT would offer you?

Are you unhappy where you are, or just concerned about the “gravitas” of your degree? Are you considering grad school (in which the “name” of your graduate institution will matter more than where you got your bachelor’s)? Do you actually want to end up in a financial planning related career, or are you questioning that now?

I don’t see the benefit to transferring to UT, especially if you’re doing liberal arts. You’re paying more to get less employability. If you got into the McCombs business school, then quite possibly. If you’re doing liberal arts, there’s no benefit to going to UT and you’re far better off staying where you’re at.

Do you want to get a CFP degree & practice as a personal financial planner ? If so, stay where you are.

If undecided as to a career, then more information is needed.

Exactly. If you like that major, the only reason to change universities would be to move to a place that has a stronger program for your major. Since you report that this is one of the top programs, stay where you are.

Keep the full ride in the good program. How is this a question?

@aquapt I just finished my freshman year and I would be transferring Spring 2019. My out of pocket cost for UT would be about 5,000 a semester plus housing (which I know is super expensive in Austin). I am actually going to Spain in the fall, fully paid for and with a stipend. Honestly, I am pretty happy where I am, but I am very concerned about the gravitas of the degree. It is the 4th best public college in Texas and I am in the Honors College, but many people I know who are at the same intellectual level as me went to more well known schools and I am honestly afraid about how it looks to go to a lesser known school. My program has a 94% job placement with starting salaries of about 55,000-60,000 so I am not real worried about job prospects, but more about how it will look in the future if I were to change my career path. I would like to get an MBA one day in the Boston area (Harvard, MIT, Babson, and BU) and I am a bit worried that even if I graduate at the top of my class, they will not accept me because of where I went to undergrad. I am almost positive that I want to do financial planning; it something that really interests me and I enjoy doing and I can see myself having a career in the field. Also, my major at UT would be Human Dimensions of Organizations and basically what I know about it is that it is a major that prepares you to understand the “human side” of businesses.

@hbkatz ,

Graduate/professional school is not really that dependent on the undergrad institution. If you maintain high grades, secure strong letters of recommendation, study and do well on standardized tests (GRE, GMAT), and write a solid statement of purpose, you can still get into very good or even excellent graduate/professional programs.

It sounds like you are truly hung up on name recognition/brand. Really, if you go on to professional school, it is that school that will carry the most weight. Even if you didn’t go on to post-grad, the shelf life of one’s undergrad name is very short. Five years out of school, no one cares where you went to undergrad. Employers want to know what experience you’ve gained in the workforce, what skills you have acquired, and what you can bring to their organization. Honestly, this obsession with name needs to stop. Adults and parents especially should know better. Among my colleagues are several who went to UCF. I went to a very good but not super-known LAC. Another went to Cornell. We are all work colleagues and do not spend a nanosecond sizing each other up. This is how most workplaces are. If undergrad name reputation was so important, we would have a caste system, with people earning high incomes all coming from top schools, people with slightly lower incomes coming from the next tier, and so on. But that’s not how things work at all.

When you have a specialized, uncommon major, the important thing is the strength of your department, not the overall reputation of the college or university where that department is located.

Honestly, @hbkatz , you sound like you’d be giving up more by transferring than you’d be gaining. You’re in a highly-regarded specialty program for a field that you actually do want to be in. You have a full ride, an honors program, fully-funded study abroad… if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it!! @Hapworth is right - you can definitely get into a “name brand” grad program if you stay on track.

Look at it this way. If you have $25K plus housing costs to spare, think about all the other great ways you could be spending that money. Harvard, Babson, and BU all have summer sessions that are open to students from other universities. Go take some classes directly from these schools that you are interested in - you can broaden your academic background and prove yourself at one or more of your target institutions. (Plus, summer in Boston: fireworks on the Esplanade FTW :smiley: ) Or you could do a post-bacc year at a “name brand” school (in the US or abroad) to round out your “renaissance person” credentials and experiences. (One example: https://www.sas.upenn.edu/lps/postbacc/studies/areas-of-study ) Leaving your current school isn’t the only way to challenge yourself and add to your knowledge base.

The “human dimensions of organizations” major sounds cool, but it isn’t a monolith that you can’t get from other sources. Looking at the course requirements, there are basically only three courses that are unique to the major, and the rest consists of liberal arts distribution requirements. Meanwhile, if you walk away from your current program, you’re not only losing the free ride but also the immediate employability from the credential you’ll come out with. Think creatively about best-of-both-worlds solutions before you seriously consider giving that up just for the “name” of UT.

If you did transfer… would you have to transfer in your sophomore spring in order to finish on time? If not, then why not at least wait 'til Fall '19? You’ll save more money the longer you wait, and also give your current program time to convince you of its value.