Cornell (Full Ride) vs. Johns Hopkins (Full Ride) vs. USC (Full Tuition) vs. Emory

Hi everyone!

Some general information regarding my profile: I am a senior in high-school right now, I live in California and I plan to study the Humanities/Social Sciences when I go into college. I’m still undecided as to what exactly I want to major in, but for all of these schools I was accepted for a subject in the Humanities. I’m thinking of majoring in History as I am considering going to law school after undergrad, with a potential double major/minor in Government/Political Science, or some other subject like Literature or Philosophy. Alternatively I’m also thinking of studying Economics along with Statistics/Data Science if I decide I’d rather not go to law school.

Additional Info -

I’m leaning Cornell mainly because of the name brand/recognition - even though it’s considered the “joke” of the Ivy League, it’s still an Ivy League and that alone could open up a lot of doors for me, which may be crucial as a Humanities/Social Sciences major. I’ve also read that Cornell is more highly regarded in the international community than it is in the U.S. alone, so that could help if I decide to study abroad (which I would like to do). Being in the middle of nowhere isn’t a big issue for me, and I’m not bothered by the cold/snow (although truthfully I’ve never lived anywhere where it’s constantly below 30 degrees on a daily basis) - what I’m really worried about is potentially becoming really depressed due to the combination of the isolation/cold plus being so far away from my family, and mental health (from what I’ve heard) is already a bit of an issue at Cornell since academics are notoriously difficult and stressful at Cornell, and I’m worried that if I go to Cornell I’ll feel like I’m always in a state of homesickness/stress while being surrounded by people who feel the same. Johns Hopkins from what I’ve seen doesn’t have the strongest programs in the Humanities but it’s another prestigious university that’s offering to pay for everything so I’m definitely not going to count it out anytime soon. USC is the closest to home (close enough to where I can stay at home on weekends if I want, and driving up for family events/parties would not be an issue at all) and it’s where my family wants me to go to school. It’s a bit more expensive than the other universities, however, and I’d have to take out a loan to pay off the remaining cost and I would have to work a little bit more to pay for work-study than if I went to Cornell of JHU. Being the heart of LA is useful for finding jobs and internships, but the traffic is really annoying and the surrounding area is another turn-off. Additionally, I’m not sure if I like the “vibe” of USC - I’ve visited multiple times, and I was definitely able to feel that party culture that is pretty dominant at USC, and as an introvert I’m really not into that type of stuff, so I don’t want to go to a school where I feel like I’d be an outcast just because I don’t like to party or go to football games every weekend. My college counselor has been talking to me about Emory and she seems to be pushing me in that direction (I got into both the Emory and Oxford colleges), and the Humanities seem to be pretty strong, but they still haven’t sent me their FA packet and I’m not sure when I’ll have to chance to visit the campus.

In terms of activities, I’m hoping to join some type of community service or volunteer organization, and I’d like to work on campus as either a tour guide or a peer consultant. I did marching band in high school, but I don’t think I’m going to continue doing it in college. I also did competitive color guard throughout my high school career, but none of these schools have competitive color guard teams, so if I wanted to keep doing it I would have to join an independent group which cost a lot of $$$$$ and time.

I’m planning to visit Cornell over spring break, and hopefully I’ll be able to visit JHU’s campus after that as well. I’ve been to USC multiple times, and like I said I don’t know when/if I’ll have a chance to visit Emory’s campus.

Overall, I’m leaning Cornell/USC right now, but maybe that’s just because I don’t know enough about JHU/Emory to appreciate them as much.

JHU is in the middle of Baltimore. Much smaller and much more urban than Cornell. Glad you are making visits because they are very, very different!

Talk to all of your schools about what would be involved in switching majors.

FWIW, I would not pay more money for USC than Cornell or JHU.

You have great options on the table. Congrats!

1 Like

If you consider Cornell the “joke of the Ivy League,” it’s likely not a good fit for you.

1 Like

Thank you for the speedy reply! I know that at both Cornell and USC, switching your major within your school is generally very common and easy to do. It only starts to get complicated/difficult if you request a change to a completely different school, but I don’t plan on doing that as of now. Not too sure what it’s like for Emory and JHU but I’d assume it’s a similar story.

Just wanted to be sure you weren’t thinking of transferring to Dyson because I’m not sure how easy that is these days. Within CAS, you don’t even officially declare your major until middle of sophomore year so you have plenty of time to decide and try out different classes.

fwiw: Hopkins has a stronger History program than does Cornell. (sure, The Hop is known for biomed, but it is also extremely strong in lit/hume.)

USC+debt is not better than a full-ride (tuition+housing). Actually surprised that their calc of need is lower than the other two since USC finaid is not considered miserly. If 'SC is really where you want to go, you should call and ask for a review of your need: ‘I’m really excited to become a Trojan, but can’t put my family into debt to make it happen…’

Call Emory and ask where their FA offer is. I’m guessing they’ll match Hopkins & Cornell.) Oxford is a two-year program in a small town and then continue on at the main campus (Buckhead is beautiful). You’d want to visit that Oxford too, if you could.

prop: learn to write in paragraphs, and/or get off of your phone for long posts…

I was proud and happy to be admitted to Cornell.
You aren’t.
If you come in with all that negativity practically bursting out of you, you will no doubt find things there to confirm it.
Suggest go someplace else.

Not sure why you applied, tbh

1 Like

I don’t consider it the joke of the Ivy League, I was just making a comment on what some other people feel since I was talking about prestige and recognition. I even made mention of how Cornell is typically more highly regarded on an international level than it is in the U.S. Prestige is not a big deal for me and will not be a major deciding factor once I ultimately decide where I want to go, but it was worth mentioning.

Interesting, I’ll have to do more in-depth research into Hopkins’s History program. I’m not sure if that’s the degree I want to graduate with, but evidently I’m a very undecided person so it’s good to know I have that possibility.

We contacted SC to see if they’d match Cornell/JHU’s offers but they said no. I’m not complaining at all since they did give me 67k in grant aid, but yeah, finances are a concern. If anything I would have to take out a small loan and pay off the rest through work, so I don’t know how big of a deal it would be, but I want to graduate with as little debt as possible.

Not sure what you mean by that last part, I broke up the sentences at the end because I didn’t want to make the post look too much like a giant wall of text (even though it still kinda is).

@nervousnerd
“If 'SC is really where you want to go, you should call and ask for a review of your need: ‘I’m really excited to become a Trojan, but can’t put my family into debt to make it happen…’”
I agree. Let them know your offers from JHU and Cornell .
It can’t hurt to ask.

And btw- my DS was also an introvert at USC who was awarded a full tuition scholarship, but he had NO problem finding his “peeps” and avoiding the whole rah- rah, rich kid party scene.
It’s a BIG school, and there will be LOTS of kids like you there. And practically nothing beats being able to be closer to home, warm weather and wearing t shirts and flip flops all year long.

Why did you apply to JHU if ‘from what you’ve seen’ it’s not strong in the area you want to study- humanities?? As it happens you are wrong, not just about history, as @bluebayou pointed out, but for IR (aka Political Science/Government’s big brother), an area in which it is one of the top programs in the US. And I don’t know where you got the idea that “Cornell is considered the “joke” of the Ivy League”. I’ve heard of it being lumped in with Dartmouth, Penn & Brown as some sort of ‘lower Ivy’ (a ridiculous enough concept), yes, but never as a “joke”.

Seriously, I am glad that you are going to visit these schools, b/c your post suggests you are working on nothing but superficial stereotypes

Going into any debt for a vague humanities major/might-want-to-do-law-school kind of track - when you have 2 full rides to top-tier schools- is madness.

@momofsenior1 I don’t plan on going into business, and Cornell has an Economics department in the CAS so I think it should be fine. Dyson is Applied Economics which I assume is more geared towards Business and Management Economics?

@menloparkmom Ok, that’s good to know. I’m not worried about finding my “crowd”/group of friends since USC is so big, but as an introvert it’s still something that’s on my mind. USC is a really great school and I have a feeling I’d be better off staying close to home/family/friends, but it’s tough to turn up offers from schools like Cornell, JHU, and Emory. Thanks for the advice.

@collegemom3717 I applied because I have family in Baltimore, and because at the time I was still undecided as to what I wanted to do. Their generous financial aid was another draw, too. If it looks like I’m going off of stereotypes, that’s because I don’t have much else to work with. I’m glad I’ll be visiting the campuses soon. The only reason I’m considering going into debt for USC is because it’s close to my home and to my friends and family.

@monydad I was very excited and proud to have been admitted to Cornell. If it looks like I’m being reserved about the school, it’s because I am - I’ve never visited, and it’s thousands of miles away from home. Out of all the schools, I’m probably leaning Cornell the most, but I don’t want to get myself overly excited and then disappoint myself if I have to turn down the offer because I realize the campus’s location and weather isn’t for me.

Thanks for the comments everyone.

Actually Cornell is not well known at all in those fields. JHU has an excellent world renown IR program. It’s highly regarded in the diplomatic, strategic and other fields. Did you look at SAIS? If so, then why don’t you recognize its impact in those fields which you are interested in? I find this odd as it is very well known.
Emory isn’t in the same class but might be great. I really don’t know the school.
USC isn’t strong in those fields either, at all. Might be a good choice if you end up in economics which I’d imagine would be easier to do at any of your choices. While Cornell is a very well known school for good reason, the areas you cited aren’t the strongest fields. And Cornell isn’t as strong outside the US as any of the other Ivies. So, if you end up in international studies of some type, you aren’t going to have the same connections that someone at JHU or Georgetown would.
I’d suggest you look at the actual majors you are interested in and how they rank at the various schools rather than just looking at the schools. You have some good choices. Also, why would you pay for USC if Cornell is free?

@Happytimes2001 I’m not too interested in International Relations but I’m aware of the SAIS and it really made me consider going into graduate school for IR (as did Georgetown’s foreign service school). A lot of information I have about college has come from my college counselor and she never really talked to me about Johns Hopkins and its Social Sciences/Humanities. I guess it’s my fault for not being more aggressive about the research process and I probably shouldn’t have trusted her word as much as I did. :stuck_out_tongue: Admittedly when I was a sophomore I was pretty much set on studying IR but my passion shifted more towards History/Economics since I’m interested in the possibility of either law school or academia after I graduate. This is good to know, though, thank you for the information.

Main reason I would pay more for USC than any other school is so that I could stay close to home and remain in California. A lot of people don’t really take this into consideration when I give the differences in offers but USC is 45 minutes away from my house (in good traffic) and as someone who has never lived away from home for a long period of time, it’s hard for both me and my family to push USC aside just because it’s a bit more expensive. Maybe I’m just being irrational though, idk. Hard to tell, especially on a site like this.

Thanks again :slight_smile:

SAIS is a graduate school only…located in China/Italy along with DC so no presence in Baltimore…and wouldn’t be a consideration until senior year of college (and, even then, only 10% of the students accepted come straight from undergrad).

@nervousnerd For some families, the cost isn’t a consideration. So that’s fine.
Just FYI, government/policy science is very closely though not the same as international relations. There are definitely those who want to work and study US policy. These days most of these fields are international in scope. History and literature are a different story, however. Likewise, economics can be studied from a number of perspectives.

As a parent, I would push you out of your comfort zone and away from home. Going to college is the best way to learn about yourself and gain confidence. Being away from home, you will have to rely on making new friends, learning from others and integrating into the community. Even in a diverse university like USC, a new area will allow you to fully embrace a new experience. I do realize that many students stay close. But I don’t think many realize that this is one of the best and often only time it will be easy to leave their nest. But it’s all about how you feel about your choices. Best of luck to you.

@SouthernHope I’m aware, I think @Happytimes2001 brought it up just to comment on JHU’s IR program in both the undergrad and graduate realm.

Rankings for undergraduate majors usually don’t matter. You’ll get a great education at any of these schools no matter what you end up deciding on studying. I would chase the money in your case (assuming you feel comfortable at either Cornell or JHU).

I would agree with that but not necessarily for the poor. Sure, a full ride eliminates most – but not all – financial issues, but it can still be economically isolating when your dormie/friends are off for a weekend of skiing and you need to stay back to eat the ‘free’ dorm food. At some private schools, the wealthy gap is noticeable and can be uncomfortable (think Columbia and NYU kids living high in Manhattan).

Of course, that’s what’s great about Ithaca and Baltimore, not too many places in either locale that require extra money to visit. Emory, OTOH, has a lot of full pay students who could easily spend every Friday night clubbing on Peachtree.

@nervousnerd ,
My DS was also accepted at many east coast U’s, including 2 Ivy’s.
In the end, after visiting the 2 Ivys during accepted student days, he decided, as MANY kids do, that he would be happier staying closer to home. And he was! Most college students go to college within 400 miles of home. [Yes that does include students going to CC’s and local public colleges.]
The nightmare stories of trying to fly home [ we are in N Calif] from the east coast during thanksgiving and Xmas -10 hr travel times and frequently delayed flights due to bad weather- WERE a factor in his decision.

Mu recommendation is that you should go to USC. They are a top 25 U and are plenty “prestigious” enough for students applying to grad school.

They do offer many UG opportunities to study abroad. And USC is VERY well know overseas in countries in the Pacific region.

It’s often assumed JHU undergrad is “good” at something because of SAIS. SAIS IS good, very good. However SAIS is a [wholly-]separate master’s program located in Washington DC, not Baltimore, with separate faculty and no undergraduate cross-registration or majors. (AFAIK, you can check)

Just checking some grad rankings -

US News History, Poli Sci, English, Econ :
Cornell 11,19,8, 21
JHU 11, 49 ,15 ,23
USC 38, 51, 37, 33

NRC Rankings : https://www.chronicle.com/article/NRC-Rankings-Overview-History/124736

If I read these correctly:

NRC (S ranking range, R ranking range)
English: Cornell 7-28; 5-25
JHU 7-36; 21- 70
USC 48-80; 42-83
Poli Sci:
Cornell 27-50; 18-33
JHU 29-64; 35-68
USC 50-88; 57-90
History
Cornell 27-50; 18-33
JHU 29-64; 35-68
USC 50-88; 57-90
Philosophy
Cornell 16-34; 2-19
JHU 33-52; 28-44
USC 42-79; 39-65
Economics
Cornell 20-28; 20-31
JHU 30-63; 26-49
USC 30-45; 32-51

other rankings

Philosophy
http://cwsuat.philosophicalgourmet.com/overall.asp

Economics
https://www.chronicle.com/article/NRC-Rankings-Overview-History/124736

.