Dartmouth (full pay) vs Ole Miss (full ride) [physics (pre-PhD) and economics (pre-finance/consulting) major]

A few things have come to mind that I thought might be worth mentioning.

OP has mentioned at some point that they are interested in quantitative stuff. To me this includes math, quantitative algorithms and solution techniques, and many, many possible applications of all of this. Some of this is used for quantitative investing. However, quite a bit of this is used in other ways. As an example, there is another thread on this web site about the impact of AI (I am thinking that machine learning is implicitly included in this). AI and machine learning are likely to have a significant impact on a lot of things in our world. However, fully understanding how AI or ML works is not easy. Some of this may benefit from further education, such as a master’s degree or perhaps (?) two (wild thought: such as one to understand machine learning and one to understand whatever you are going to apply it to).

Which leads to the concept of opportunity cost. This is a concept that occurs in economics. At some level you can only do one thing at once, and you can only spend a particular sum of money once. If you spend your time and money doing one thing, you give up the opportunity to do something else. When an education potentially costs $400,000, this brings up the issue of opportunity cost. Do you want to spend that opportunity to get a bachelor’s degree at Dartmouth College, or do you want to get a very good education at Ole Miss for free with a great scholarship, and hang on to the opportunity to get a master’s degree or some other education (possibly in some quantitative / math-related field) after you get a bachelor’s degree?

Also, the impact of AI and ML on future jobs is hard to know, which is only one of many examples of how a master’s degree or some other unfunded or not-fully-funded education might turn out to be valuable at some point in the future.

I continue to think that there is no easy answer to this. I do not think that any of us can be sure which path is the right one. Unfortunately none of us have a crystal ball or the perfect ability to predict the future. I think that we just need to think about the options, and then go with whatever seems to be right at the time. We keep an open mind, and do as well as we can. For smart and responsible and motivated people this usually works out one way or another, although frequently it works out in a way that you could not have predicted up front.

3 Likes

I keep thinking actuary too - I know there’s a Clemson mom whose student is headed to NY or did internships there. Don’t know but guessing not as involved a career. OP wants to enjoy the diversity of NY. Don’t know but guessing that IB jobs may not bring that full experience.

1 Like

Lots said in the many posts here.

I do not agree that a candidate should not prominently present their merit scholarships on a resume and I also do not agree they cannot weave in something effective during the interview process. My daughter did it effectively in the IB world. On the other hand, I do believe Ole Miss will prove to be a challenge in the chance IB becomes a priority.

I love the questions around other schools, because if the parents would pay for UF, for example, that would improve OPs situation significantly IMO. It has become much stronger in finance for those who are following the trends.

Finally, if we are deciding between the two, I would choose Dartmouth if parents decide it is affordable, and Miss if they decide it is not.

7 Likes

I also think it should be presented on a resume. This is a very impressive scholarship with a lot to offer.

What I have an issue with is suggesting, through this award, that they somehow paid for or worked their way through college.

Congrats to the OP!

7 Likes

just to let everyone know, when I said IB I was just saying it to convey NYC high finance AND maybe consulting. I am also interested in finance jobs like trading, equity research, etc…(and would probably prefer those jobs to IB) in addition to banking. Just want to keep options open.

4 Likes

I thought I’d address this because I’ve gotten a few comments on how strange the choice is. TBH my parents kinda hold the belief that if your not going to go to a school of Dartmouth’s caliber its best to go to a state flagship school because there’s a clear explanation to others looking in(whether its true or not) beyond just not getting into other schools on why you went there(Ex: saving money and staying close to home(maybe your family didn’t want to go far) while going to a non top tier private school(even if you got a scholarship) implies you could have gone somewhere else but didn’t get in. I know there are many who get money at lower tier private schools but its my parents view that for outsiders going to a state flagship could easily be understood by outsiders as being a necessary financial/location choice(despite possibly getting into better schools) which does not go for non-top tier schools. So for this reason I only applied to schools like Dartmouth(I also got accepted at Brown and Swarthmore but didn’t like them that much and they were not different financially than Dartmouth) and Ole Miss.

4 Likes

OP, I hope you and your parents are able to come to a decision that is satisfactory to all.

I imagine it is very painful and frustrating for you to have secured admission to such competitive schools and only now learn that your parents are unwilling to pay the (admittedly steep) costs. As a parent, I do understand their concerns about the expense when a tuition free option is available. It’s unfortunate that your parents were not clear with you from the beginning of this process about what they were willing to spend and any conditions on that.

3 Likes

This is really well said and critical. We see this all the time. Have a budget.

If it was, we’ll pay for anywhere - then your expectation ( @jane18762 ) rightfully so - is anywhere you got in.

I suppose it’s hard to pre-suppose a full ride though, in fairness to mom and dad.

Brown and Swat - those are very impressive gets as well. I’m sure you’re going to do well in life, like you already have - no matter where the next four years is.

Congrats to you.

3 Likes

So I have helped screen resumes on a few notable occasions, including two in legal employment contexts, one for soon-to-be law school graduates, and one for soon-to-be college graduates. In both of those contexts, a named merit scholarship on a resume served as a sort of presumptive explanation for why a stellar candidate might have chosen a certain undergrad.

I discussed that with my fellow resume screeners a bit in those contexts, and also periodically over the years since with other people who have screened resumes in other contexts. I wouldn’t say any of us treated it as a huge qualification per se, but I think the consensus was something like that if, say, you were looking at two candidates, one who went to a highly selective private college and another who went to a less selective public college on a named scholarship, there was no particular reason to assume the latter could not have also gone to a highly selective private college. In that sense it sort of leveled the playing field in terms of implied assumptions about how competitive they were coming out of HS.

But of course that isn’t really a huge factor anyway. Mostly we were interested in what the applicants had been doing lately, so like what you had done in law school and during the summers for the applicants in law school, or what you had done in college and during the summers for the applicants in college.

I guess my point, though, is sometimes kids in HS seem concerned that if they don’t take an offer from the most selective college that admits them, future gatekeepers won’t realize what a fantastic HS student they had been.

And the most important response is that frankly, we probably won’t really care about that much to begin with. But it may be some comfort to know that if you go somewhere on a named merit scholarship, we will likely understand that was probably not in fact the most selective college that would admit you.

2 Likes

And to add to this fine post- employers don’t spend huge amounts of time worrying about coulda shoulda woulda.

Candidate majored in civil engineering- does that mean she couldn’t hack it in mechanical? Candidate majored in Sociology- too dumb for Computer Science? Candidate went to UMD- scores too low for JHU?

That’s not how it works. Employers know what they are looking for, and they want to hire people who will be successful long term (not just in the first job). And they develop assessment tools and screening protocols to make that process less open to “maybe” and more certainity.

A named scholarship is great. So is Phi Beta Kappa. So is departmental honors. So is Summa Cum Laude. As well as 50 other things which helps an employer identify the things that THEY are looking for. I have a colleague who runs Talent for a very large, well respected company and they LOVE “Tough Mudder” and those types of competitive athletic events. Works for their culture. They aren’t going to be blown away (necessarily) by someone who performed an original concerto at Carnegie Hall (but many employers will jump on that immediately). I’ve interviewed mid-level hires who had Yaddo (and similar) on their resumes. Some of them turned out to be stellar employees. Others have no clue how competitive it is to be chosen for a paid artistic fellowship– nor do they care once it’s explained to them.

2 Likes

But people use what they have.

It’s like a college app - some think they need to put down ten activities - even though they don’t.

If someone’s resume isn’t loaded - and most HS grads (looking for a college internships) and college grads (looking for the first job) - don’t have a loaded resume or loaded experiences - so you use what you have.

My daughter didn’t have Phi Beta Kappa on her resume because the schools just received it her Senior Year and she was named to the first class. If she moves on from her two year commitment next year, would she add it to her resume?

I’m guessing so.

Will an employer want it or mine for it? No idea - we don’t know what any employer truly seeks - beyond what goes in a job description - which often isn’t written by the person hiring.

When you have little, you use what you have - and some may talk about it - and every person is different - so no one truly knows how it will be received by the person doing the hiring.

We often talk in absolutes here but I would content there is no absolute to this type of thing - you can speak for your organization and maybe know about some more but not about all organizations. And certainly, putting a tangible achievement on a resume is a better use of space than saying I know excel…or just leaving it blank.

My question is @blossom, @hebegebe, @Mwfan1921, @cinnamon1212 and others who may know, if an applicant doesn’t get some preferential opportunity to apply (campus interview, target school, campus/alumni event, etc) and has to go through the “general population” application channel, would an AI screener pick up only certain colleges (or give them preferential placement on a “list”) and would it pick up a Stamps scholarship? Would the Stamps Foundation alum have their own network/pipeline to help a Stamps student at any school get in front of IB interviewers in NY?

Would a Stamps scholar from the South make it past a prescreener for an IB opportunity in NY?

1 Like

I am flattered to be included, but I can shed no light on this!

1 Like

Also flattered to be included, but I don’t know either. I would guess that, if we are talking a gen pop application, some firms screen on school name, others don’t.

Also don’t know about Ole Miss Stamps network, or if it extends across schools. No matter what school OP attends, they will have to hustle for IB, PE, consulting opportunities.

1 Like

Absolutely. As usual, gatekeepers typically aren’t interested in giving out offers as a reward for what you have done in the past. They are looking for the best bets to give their organization what it needs in the future. The past is only relevant to the extent it helps them refine their sense of your possible future within their organization.

Incidentally, I was never in a position to experience this directly myself, but people I know who are still doing this sort of thing all seem to be reporting AI is definitely taking on a bigger role. The final decisions are still human driven, but AI basically not only “knows” everything publicly knowable about everything that might appear on a resume, it can also be quickly “trained” to use that information specifically in a way that makes sense for that particular organization. And indeed refined and improved with experience.

My two cents is this is both good and bad news for future applicants. On the good side, anything you do will get whatever consideration it merits, and in fact there may be a benefit on both sides to organizations making better predictions about who will actually do well and persist at their organization (more below). The bad news is your potential competitive set for any given position is likely growing as organizations are potentially finding some strong candidates they would not have previously been able to identify without this help.

In the end, though, I think this is really a net positive. Big picture, there are not in fact a lot more talented and motivated young people than interesting next-step options available. Indeed, holding aside some economic or industry cyclicality, I would say the prevailing attitude among people I know is they are still always looking for more talent packaged in the right sort of person for their organization.

So it isn’t really like musical chairs where there are not enough chairs for the people who thrived in college. It is more a question of whether applicants and organizations are actually making good matches, the kind of matches where the organization and applicant both end up happy having found each other. And if AI can in fact improve the overall rate of successful matches, that will be a good thing.

I also don’t know the actual answer for what the AI screeners are currently doing at any given organization, but I do know enough to say that is precisely the sort of thing trainable AI is actually supposed to help an organization do. Like, you are supposed to be able to feed it all the public and proprietary information available, and it is supposed to be able to tell you how all sorts of different possible factors not only individually, but interactively, can point you to candidates that are better or worse bets to choose for the human-driven phases of your process.

So basically, you should not be telling your AI how to factor Stamps into its resume-scoring process. It is supposed to be telling you.

Most of the ATS (applicant tracking systems) now in general use (past the testing stage, validated for use across countries, divisions, roles, levels, functions, etc.) are not actually using much of what is technically AI. They are using good old fashioned key word searches, and they are not “robots” who decide who is in and who is out. They screen based on human inputs and can be changed around at will. So a company hiring attorneys can screen on JD and bar admission; the same company can make sure that candidates who make it into the interview pipeline have a series 7 or a CPA or a CFA if that’s required; if there’s a division that does business with the federal government where security clearance is required the ATS will screen out (or take a first cut at screening) candidates who wouldn’t be eligible or at least would take a long time (years in some cases) to get clearance at the appropriate level.

That’s it. Screens. Doesn’t assess, doesn’t make value judgements (Stamps at Ole Miss beats Chancellor’s award at BU which beats National Merit at Tulsa). It doesn’t replace the humans who actually read resumes and doesn’t replace human judgement. But it speeds up the process of taking 100K+ resumes and cutting them down to a reasonable size for further assessment.

As I said upthread- Stamps is prestigious; departmental honors is prestigious; Summa or Magna is prestigious; writing a senior thesis is prestigious, etc. I pushed back on the idea that a candidate could describe winning a lucrative merit award in HS as “working my way through college” which in general, has a specific connotation. But that doesn’t detract from how great it is for a HS kid to win such an award!

I do not know if Stamps alums maintain their own “pipeline”. The most active and influential pipeline (in my experience) is military vets, particularly officers in certain branches, who have developed separate recruiting streams in some organizations. But the reason for that has nothing to do with “prestige” per se. It’s because the timeline for an exiting military officer is different from someone graduating (undergrad, grad school) or switching from one civilian role to another. And it’s because interviewing from a base in Bahrain is more complicated than interviewing from a college campus, and because very few civilian employers know how to read a military resume. I do not believe that “Stamps alums” have those complications such that they require a separate pipeline. Perhaps in some companies they do- I’m not aware of such. But there are designations in the military which are truly “one tenth of the top one percent of officers in this cohort” and it’s helpful to have other veterans explain how truly distinctive they are, even if the general public neither knows nor cares. We all know Navy Seals- but there are even more elite units, especially in intelligence, cyber, etc.

But none of this matters for the OP who will get a fine education at either university and may or may not end up getting a doctorate in physics or landing a role in a financial institution. There will be ample opportunities for cool paths regardless of the path chosen right now.

4 Likes

My daughter is in an analyst program where PE and other similar roles to investment banking are options. So far, she has avoided those rotations. I have also worked with several investment bankers over the years as well as PE firms.

My take is that if a normal adult who has worked for 10+ years got into the field, they would find that even if you get a good group, “the career” does not respect you and your time. they need to jump on calls seven days per week, they need to travel at a moments notice, and a 12 hour day would be considered routine. 18 hour days are considered hard and really do happen maybe weekly. And for that, people get paid more and receive larger bonuses. Yes, Dartmouth kids who want this kind of a life have a reasonable chance of attaining it. Ole Miss kids are not often given the “opportunity.”

I started a company backed by a financial firm when I was in my late 30’s, and I found the experience unpleasant. It had banking influence.

4 Likes

Again, the distinction under consideration is not Ole Miss versus Dartmouth, it is Stamps Scholar at Ole Miss versus Dartmouth College. Huge difference.

The Stamps Scholar network is, at least, national in scope.

4 Likes

At this point it really is up to the OP’s parents.

I think it safe to assume that the OP is an outstanding, thoughtful student who will find a path to success one way or another.

5 Likes