Dealing with inlaws

The “I’d argue” means it reflects my opinion. My opinion is based on the history of marriage and its purpose in society, and the historical lack of options for women, neither of which is the case in 2015. Additionally, societal mores are more accepting of cohabitating, children out of wedlock, and a range of relationships outside of the traditional male/female model.

Sure, folks are still getting married and, most likely, always will but the rate is definitely declining. The large number of weddings among your D’s peers is a reflection of her age (marriage age historically) as well as her social circle.

My s and his new wife have been on the wedding circuit pretty regularly for a few years. It seems to be slowing down but it isn’t stopping yet. Younger s’s seem to be just gearing up. He’s been to a few but it’s not the nonstop that older s had. He even had 2 in one day.

@jym626 - How old are your son’s friends? Similar in age to @Nrdsb4’s duaghter? Because even in my time, most of my friends were getting married later than 25, more in the late 20s to early 30s.

None of my girls’ college or hs friends have married yet, the only one we know of is next summer.

Don’t forget how many relationships are now found on social media, the match sites. Both of my girls found theirs that way- and the parallels, coincidences similarities for D1 and her bf are just plain unbelievable.

I think she’d be interested in marriage if he were settled in a career. But he has some grad school plans and it’s a “we’ll see” situation. I think my other kid is rushing. I think she saw the way DH and I had settled into marriage, the challenges and the good times, and doesn’t realize the hard work involved, skips that.

@doschicos one of the reasons it’s more popular in Western Europe and Canada is that they provide protection to cohabitating couples.

The US does not, and I don’t believe will for a very, very long time.

We were the first in our close friend group to get married. We’re 24 but most of our friends are 25-27. Most of them are partnered and cohabitating but none are even engaged (that I can think of off the top of my head).

That’s the right age range, doschicos.

So mid 20’s to low 30’s is the age group getting married these days?
My brother is 31 and we keep bugging him asking when he is going to settle down.
He has attended a lot of classmates weddings usually flying to different cities on weekends.

I would think that college years would be the best time to meet somebody but with many going to work and then back to graduate school I can see someone reaching close to 30 and still trying to settle down in life with their career.

I know several students who got engaged last year of medical school just before residency.

I think it has to do with how you’re raised and where you live. Both of my kids plan on getting married. Where I live I notice the less educated tend to not get married, but the college grads do. Stats in this area bear that out.

This is something I don’t understand. My sister is going to be 30 in a few months and no where close to marriage. I’d be surprised if she ever ends up marrying, and if so it won’t be for a good long time.

But who cares? That’s her choice and she’s happy. Why do people feel the need to “bug” people about their marital status?

^^ After 4 sisters weddings we just want to enjoy our brothers wedding and be on the grooms side for once.
He is the baby of the family but we all have to look up to him because he is the tallest.
We just want to enjoy a family wedding since its been a longtime. After him next in line is my daughter.
He thinks she will settle down before him.

The “problem” has been solved, and there is no need for us to text him. DS called and we were told what he would do during Thanksgiving on the other coast.

My mother would have said you were psychic, or some such thing. Your thoughts, and the act of expressing them here, were felt by your son, and now you have the answers you need. I am sure that is a good feeling for you.

We have been waiting for our son to let us know what his plans are, but he is rather single-minded and will not even think about getting back to see us until after his last class. More than likely on Wednesday, mid-day, he’ll figure out that many of the other kids have left campus, and , Oh, I’d better see if they expect to hear from me.

W2E, i must say I’m stunned, unless your son is fairly local. Does he know your plans? If you are the hosts, he may feel content to come home sometime Thursday, after a good sleep.

My son has lived 1000’s of miles away from home, so he makes plans to go to a friend’s house, fly home, or be with g/f. He is never in a position to be spontaneous.

Both of my parents were killed when my dh and I were engaged. I am an only child. EVERY holiday involves the in-laws, and it is difficult for me. I get along really well with my mother-in-law. She has good boundaries. I struggle mightily with my f-i-l. He is narcissistic and critical. He has said some very hurtful things to me throughout the years, and I have difficulty in forgetting them. He is extremely disrespectful/demeaning to m-i-l. Very “king of the castle” mentality. He also tries to be very controlling. Ds is also an only, and his senior spring of high school just about did me in with the number of times that I had to be around my in-laws. Ds has an excellent relationship with my m-i-l (she is a terrific grandmother) and I would say a so-so one with my f-i-l. F-i-l is very conditional in offering his “approval.” It’s all about what sort of success one is having, because f-i-l wants to take credit for all of it. With that said, my dh is very successful, and f-i-l still treats him like a child and tries to tell him what to do. Dh is so used to it, that he tolerates it far better than I. Now that ds is in college, I don’t have to see them as often which is a good thing for me. I have only had to see them three times this year and will see them one more time at Christmas. They live three hours away. Four times a year is just about right for me. I would be perfectly happy with only two.

I have two tactics for tolerating f-i-l: The first is to choose something I want but don’t need to buy for myself. I usualy find something on-line and take a screen shot of it. I tell myself (this is on the honor system) that if I can refrain from being snarky to f-i-l during our visits, that I will buy it for myself as a “reward.” When I can feel the snark coming on (honestly, it often isn’t snark, it’s just refraining from saying anything because it isn’t worth it), I glance at the screen shot on my phone to help me bite my tongue.

The second tactic is Jack Daniels.

@Hoggirl … I LOVE your reward system!!! That is so awesome and so motivating to get you through those long holiday days. Your FIL sounds a lot like my FIL was. The criticism and the “everything revolves around me” mentality were so exhausting when they would come visit. He was so demanding of MIL and she buzzed like a bee around him making sure he was taken care of promptly. She would jump out of her seat to get him something even though he was perfectly capable. Made me crazy!

FIL has passed away and I have to say I LOVE being around MIL now. She is so fun and so spontaneous and just a joy. She even got on a jet ski this summer on our big family vacation( she is 81! )She would have never done that when FIL was alive because he disapproved and was scared of the water also.

Some people are not intended or called to marriage.

I do think there are more high quality marriages, but fewer as the article states. Some of the average quality marriages go forward, but only if someone doesn’t decide to bail out. For some people, choosing the spouse that isn’t marriage material is the big mistake - but some people are very good at hiding their true self too. Can’t change the past, so deal with the present and plan for the future.

People do change in transitions through life - but it is up to them to decide how to behave and how to maintain a marital relationship. Very common ‘mid-life crisis’ and change in behaviors, spending, younger GF/BF, etc. If one spouse wants to end a marriage, it ends.

@romanigypsyeyes I know if we lived around each other we would be friends, but with our differences in opinions; we are a product of our family, env’t, generation, faith/church experiences, etc. and our feelings about what is the best path in moving through life.

Europe has a big downturn in people participating with traditional church; they figured out their standard of living can be higher w/o kids or low # of kids; and other socio-economic-other influences that affect a low marriage rate. Some influence also with state sponsored church in many countries - that does change one’s thinking about faith and institutional church. Very common for people to live together, and some have a child together, later perhaps marrying.

US stats are sound that living together before marriage is not conducive to higher marriage success but the opposite. Some of that I am sure is due to people not feeling a marriage commitment but like the sex, want an exclusive relationship, like sharing household. Some date or see each other a short time and then live together. Some people don’t want to get married for a big variety of reasons. One may have hopes of marriage and settles with living with their partner while they hope the partner eventually will want to marry them.

I feel pretty strongly that you will be in the long term marriage stats @romanigypsyeyes because of many things. To comment, your parents’ first marriages - obvious reasons for the failures – I am not talking about those situations, but the starry-eyed in love people, that marry and have a few kids, and then they don’t feel the excitement for their spouse any more or look for fun times outside of the responsibilities/challenges with spouse/kids - as soon as they divorce, they realize they are happier being with someone in marriage, so find someone compatible to remarry – often have a more complicated situation but they all hang in to make it work because they don’t want to go through what they had splitting up, and also maybe facing their own responsibility in their mess/failures. Sis has seen many of these situations in her area in Iowa; I see some in N AL. Sis who works in a school system also sees a lot of cheating going on - so people staying in their current marriage while being unfaithful.

Brother was married to a serial marrying/cheating gal - he was H #2; she put on a big show like she was a very devout Lutheran. He knew her before her first marriage. She had a DD that was young when her first divorce happened, and the mom’s ex remarried and had more children - since the mom was sure to ‘stick it’ financially every chance she got, I think the relationship between dad and DD was strained. The mom then had affair while married to brother, dumped my brother and moved in and on to marry #3 when she ‘accidentally’ got pregnant with her son. That marriage didn’t last; she almost was married to #4 but he wised up. Brother has now married a gal that had three children with her first H but he had died many years ago when the children were young; her second H ran off with another gal. Brother and his current wife married later in life, with her grown children loving my brother.

You never know 100% if someone is going to stay by one’s side ‘in sickness’ or with the other situations spelled out in traditional marital vows.

@raclut it is shocking about your former in-laws totally ignoring your DD. Yes I agree with you that if you had a son, the likelihood of ignoring the grandchild would be reduced. I have seen where paternal grandparents have adopted their grandchild because GC was a boy and the mother allowed (mother and father were not in a relationship, it was just sex). A number of cultures highly value the male child.

@Hoggirl - I’m so sorry for the loss of your parents. To deal with a FIL like that must make the difference seem quite stark. I’m wondering if any of you with really difficult/awful in-laws have tried talking to the person and just saying something like “we could all be a lot happier if you tried to be more pleasant”. I hate the thought of a controlling and mean person getting away with this meanness for years and years and no one is happy until they die. They could live far too long!

@greenwitch - thank you.

I can’t speak for everyone but for those who have in-laws with a proprensity to narcissim, I don’t think such a statement (even if helpful and true) goes very far. I would be being too sensitive. F-i-l could never be at fault.

Yep. The real tough ILs won’t change and will think you are the problem.

But having said that, if I am ever out of line or an issue with my future DILs, I hope sons will say something to reign me in.

I have said things on a few occasions to my father-in-law, about his mean behavior and comments. His response was to, first, lie about his behavior and comments and then, say even worse things. He considers himself the aggrieved party because I called him out on his behavior. (I did it by letter. I did not do it in front of other people.)