I am in the middle of an extremely tough decision: college A or college B. I have been admitted to both and have also received scholarships from both. I would love unbiased opinions, or advice from anyone who has experienced this.
Here are some pros and cons of each.
College A Pros: -my top choice for two years -3.5 hours away (originally wanted to branch out) -accepted into the honors college -great town -nice dorms
College A Cons: -few to no connections -socially will be harder to make friends, which is huge to me -sorority recruitment will be hard, that has always been a dream of mine -friends have not been happy at this university -no direct physical therapy major
College B Pros: -in my hometown so many, MANY connections -great social aspect -close to family/friends -easier rush
-pre physical therapy major -direct connection to doctorate program -extremely comfortable
College B Cons: -might be missing out on an amazing experience at college A -don’t want to “settle” because I am scared -not as nice dorms -been in this town my whole life
Thanks, everyone!
How committed are you to DPT? That is what matters.
If you are fully committed, then where you study is less important than being directly on the pre-DPT/DPT track.
I’m a big believer in stepping out of your comfort zone, and college is the “safest” way to do that. It seems to me that most of your reservations about college A are about leaving your comfort zone. (You’ll be in a dorm, I wouldn’t worry about making friends .) The major is more of a concern, but there is obviously some pathway for you or you wouldn’t have considered it, and so many students end up changing their major during college that it’s not something in itself I would have a college decision revolving around. That said, you also need to consider why your friends have not been happy at college A, and if those reasons would be the same for you.
If you are certain about your major and College B is better then that might be the determining factor. Can you study abroad at College B? That may be a way to spread your wings.
Some students I know who were pre-DPT or DPT did participate in academic semester exchanges in the US or abroad. Depending on where the clinical rotations can be arranged during the DPT program, that can also provide an “away” experience for you. Dig a bit deeper into what A and B have to offer along those lines.
Are you waiting on any other admissions, or are A and B the only places that you applied? Do you have all of your aid packages finalized and is there any difference in the numbers?
This often helps: pretend you decided, it’s A. Carry that in your head a bit. See what your emotional and gut reactions are. Excited? Satisfied? Or gloomy? The flip it. You acepted B, what reactions? Works in many situations.
Yes, cost matters. Can you easily afford both choices?
“This often helps: pretend you decided, it’s A. Carry that in your head a bit. See what your emotional and gut reactions are. Excited? Satisfied? Or gloomy? The flip it. You acepted B, what reactions? Works in many situations.”
Different version of this: look at yourself in 5 (or 10) years time. Which choice do you regret not taking? Which experience do you regret not having?
Is college B a direct entry into a DPT program or merely another major such as Biology or Psychology that also emphasized the pre PT curriculum? If it’s a direct entry program that could be a real benefit to attending school B. If it’s the second it might not be too much of advantage. It would require you limit your majors and because DPT programs vary in their requirements it might not give you the edge you expect.
If it’s not a direct entry program you can major in nearly anything anywhere.What is necessary is completing all of the prerequisites for the DPT programs you would apply to. It would be nice to have a school with a decent health sciences department who might have advisers for pre medical programs. Most DPT programs have core courses that you are required to have that are similar for nearly all schools. Physics, Chemistry, Biology, Anatomy and Physiology are required at nearly all schools. From there each DPT program will have similar but different requirements. While an adviser would certainly be helpful you can keep up with each schools requirements on your own.
Another consideration is cost. Living close to home could be more cost effective. DPT programs can be quite expensive especially at private schools. Good luck in your choice.
If you are sure you want a DPT then College B seems the more direct pathway to your goal. But not knowing the two colleges makes it hard to opine.
I would not discount a college just because it is close by. After looking at schools up and down the east coast, my S ended up at a college a half hour or so from our home – he lived in the dorms. Before he chose that school we all sat down and discussed ground-rules. We (mom. dad, and even grandma) agreed never to just “pop by” campus and he (son) agreed to not use being close to home as a crutch (no coming home to do wash etc.) – we all kept to our promise and it worked out extremely well. He basically just came home for school breaks. His college was much more urban than where we live so he got a different life expereince although he was close to home and he did a summer abroad. Then he went to grad school halfway across the country!
OP, would be nice to know the names of the two schools.
That said, your choice is not as difficult as you think. How important is the physical therapy major to you? If this is an absolute requirement, you know where you need to go: B.
If you are not that sure (students do change majors or focuses), then A is a serious possibility. All of your cons for “A” are no cons at all. They are the typical adjustments that all students make. I do not say that to be dismissive. Indeed, a common sight on move-in day is kids crying. The female students (not all, of course!) hug their parents and cry. The male students hug their parents and pretend that they’re not crying (inside many are). It’s a big deal. But it’s totally normal, and most everyone makes the adjustment just fine.
Commitment to major or commitment to exploration/experience.
I agree that it would be useful to know the names of the two schools.
“no direct physical therapy major”
If you intend to go into physical therapy this concerns me quite a bit. I think that having a good program in your major is very important. I personally have benefited enormously from physical therapy and see it as something that is going to help a lot of baby boomers as we age.
If you live on campus then you can be 5 minutes from your parent’s house and it will still be a genuine college experience. You will wake up surrounded by other students, set your own hours, decide when to study (hopefully enough) and when to party (hopefully not too much). If something goes wrong, then you can get help quickly.
“friends have not been happy at this university”
This also concerns me a little bit. Can you describe why your friends have not been happy at university A?
Is there any significant difference in the cost of the two universities?
To me the big point is that university B has your major. Being close to home is a plus. Knowing the names of the university and/or more information might make it easier to give informed opinions.
By the way, the fact that you are deciding between two good options with scholarships, and it is still November, is a big plus. Congratulations on your acceptances and scholarship offers! 