Decision advice: Reed v Vassar v Brandeis

I got waitlisted to my dream school (Williams). I got into Reed, Vassar, and Brandeis. I plan on a math major and music minor. I am a nerdy intellectual, but the most important think is that I want to go on for a PHD in math. The scholarships are enough that the decision is fit not money. I got into UCSD and my parents suggest I go there because it is in-state and they are worried a recession will mean less scholarship for my sophomore year at a private. I want a smaller school. Any thoughts?

From your choices, Reed appears in a Princeton Review sampling, “Great Schools for Mathematics Majors.” (For perspective, Williams does as well.)

Based on your preference for an intellectual environment at a smaller school, I think you might generally like Vassar as well.

I second Reed for your academic interests, if you can make the $$ work.

This is just one story but my friend’s S is graduating from Brandeis this year and he’s had a rough experience there, mostly b/c he has significant mental health challenges. The college has not been supportive. She said the parents FB group for Brandeis has a lot of complaints about how the college is run.

Vassar’s open curriculum would suit your varied educational interests best.

“Scholarship” or “Need based financial aid” ?

Regardless, UC-San Diego may be the best option due to cost, location, & size.

I think Vassar would be great for a nerdy intellectual who is also interested in music. Unless your parents’ income goes up significantly from what was used to determine your financial aid, I would think you would not get less “scholarship money”. You may want to call the colleges to discuss.

If you are interested in a PhD in math, I would think that your best choices would be Reed or Vassar. If you look at the NSF top 50 rankings on baccalaureate origins of math PhDs, you will note that Reed is #4 on the list and Vassar is #39 (table 4) I did not see Brandeis listed.

I don’t think either school gives merit aid but only need based financial aid. I think the risk of a financial aid cut at either school would be minimal assuming no increase in your parents’ income
https://www.nsf.gov/statistics/infbrief/nsf13323/

You may want to compare the upper level courses at all four of the colleges to see which one best covers your math interests. Pre-PhD students should consider the availability of rigorous courses in such areas as real and complex analysis, abstract algebra and number theory, geometry and topology, numerical analysis, logic and set theory, as well as other areas that may be of interest.

Be aware that if you are not admitted as a declared math major at UCSD, you need to earn a 3.0 college GPA in the lower level prerequisite courses to apply to the major. The threshold for admission is competitively set and may be higher, but has been 3.0 for the most recent five quarters through winter 2020: https://www.math.ucsd.edu/~handbook/undergraduate/cappedstatus/ .

Brandeis parent here. I’m on the FB page–don’t see the complaints referenced above. In general, parents posting are very happy with the school, as are our students. Can’t comment on the math major but physics major very rigorous while also very supportive of students.

Thank you! These are very helpful comments!