<p>The real thing hurting you the most? Being out of state. </p>
<p>Your GPA and SATs are below the median, especially if you consider the pool of applicants you were being compared with (out of staters), but no so much as to guarantee you won’t get in. No teacher recs definitely hurt you a little too. I can guarantee you not filling out the additional information section isn’t what got you deferred.</p>
<p>I’d try applying again with teacher recs, you never know! You look like a very strong applicant; I’m sure you’ll get in somewhere great even if it’s not W&M!</p>