Desperately in need of some liberal arts matches and safeties

I am a white guy, low-income HS student living in Colorado. Neither of my parents graduated a four-year college program, so I am also first-generation.

I am desperately in need of some matches and safeties. However, my college choices are highly constrained by financial aid available from the institution. I completed my FAFSA and the CSS profile for colleges I have applied to.

My unweighted GPA is 3.83. I’ve only taken one honors course and another AP course, however I battle waves of depression and anxiety. I am certain that without these constraints, I could’ve managed a very rigorous courseload in HS.

My SAT is 1260 (700 writing, 560 math). Given another opportunity to take the SAT I am confident I could’ve scored better.

I need some safeties and matches because my current college list is composed of almost all reaches. My high school counselors have given me little to no help in the process and I’ve been lost.

Applied to reaches:

Reed (Early Action), Whitman, Skidmore, Wesleyan, Denison

Matches:
CU Boulder, University of Denver

Safeties: NONE

Can you give me any ideas on where I can apply? I am running out of time very quickly. I look towards the direction of liberal arts, however I don’t quite know what I want to study.

Thank you for your help.

You’d qualify for $30,000 in merit with those stats at Ursinus. Susquehanna also gives good merit. Juniata and Washington & Jefferson may also be an option. I think they would all be considered safeties. Do you know your EFC?

Are there any colleges of interest with full rides in this list that you qualify for?

http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/discussion/comment/21015126/#Comment_21015126

How much will your parents contribute per year?

Have you considered Northern Arizona University? You’d be eligible for WUE tuition discount and some merit aid in addition to whatever need based financial aid you might qualify for. https://www7.nau.edu/finaid/NetPriceCalculator/ Have you looked at other WUE options? http://wiche.edu/wue

For safeties, you should look at the Colorado state schools - Greeley, Mesa, Ft Lewis. You could also consider Wyoming, Utah, Boise State (the WUE schools, but you need to hurry as the awards aren’t unlimited). Did you apply for Daniel or Boettcher?

Take a look at Lawrence University (WI), Beloit College, Coe College, Hamline University, and Cornell College (IA).

Have you considered New College of Florida?
https://ctcl.org/new-college-of-florida/

It may not quite be a safety for an OOS student with your stats.
They do offer merit awards/discounts to OOS students.
https://www.ncf.edu/admissions/cost-and-aid/scholarships/out-of-state-freshmen/