DESPERATELY need help picking a college!

Sorry for the crazy title just don’t want my thread drowned by others. Here are my stats (and they kinda suck):
Major: Poli sci; minor in either economics or environmental studies. Looking to either get a JD later on or go to grad school for Public Policy.
ACT: 27 (30 superscored)
SAT: 1260
GPA: 3.8 uw/4.28 w
APs: 8 total, 4 being taken this year. 3 on AP Lang (rip), 4 on AP gov and 4 on AP physics 1. Intending on taking 3/4 of the tests for the classes I’m in this year (AP macro, AP micro and AP Lit). I also have a college credit for a CCP program in a statistics class (couldn’t fit AP stats into my schedule)
EC: section leader in marching band (in it for 4 years), student ambassador, link crew leader, member of student advisory board all 4 years and now on the senior advisory board, national honors society, stage crew manager and jazz band. Also have had a job for a year.
Essays: pretty good, really strong emphasis on growing as a student/leader
State: OH
White Female

Applied to 7, accepted to Purdue, Pitt, UToledo and UDelaware. Rejected from NYU (knew it was a stretch, tried anyways), deferred from UMich as an EA applicant and waiting to hear from Fordham. I wanted to know which college others would find best for me? UMich is definitely my top choice but I don’t think I’ll get in (comment if you think I have a chance?? Doubtful but still).
If I get into the ones I’m waiting on my top three would be UMich, Fordham and Purdue. Just looking for some guidance and to see what others think!

Your stats definitely don’t suck, and you’ve been accepted to some terrific schools. Congratulations! Enjoy your hard work and success, and be proud of yourself.

I’m a fan of Pitt but looks like it’s not too high on your list. I don’t know much about Fordham but know a few local students who attended in recent years, and they all loved it. Purdue is terrific. It is a big science/engineering school. Obviously many students major in other areas. You would be with a lot of STEM students. Would that be fine with you?

Delaware has a nice, kinda classic campus with classic college town vibe. How does that appeal to you? I know less about Toledo, although I do hear it’s an underrated school. I loved Michigan/Ann Arbor when we spent a couple of days there. Good luck with that!

You can get an outstanding eduction at any of your choices. You’ll be the one living and studying there. So, if cost is not a significant issue (and you don’t mention it), then go with what feels like the most comfortable place for you. Good luck!

Asking someone else – especially strangers-- is like asking us to choose your husband.

All the schools on your list meet your basic qualifications.

How many of them have you visited? Is it time for another round of visits to your top choices?

What can your parents afford?
Beside UToledo, did you apply anywhere in Ohio (tOSU, OU have excellent Poli Sci depts)?
Am surprised you didn’t apply to American Kalamazoo, Macalester for a reach.
The best for polisci on the list of schools that admitted you would be UDel, but is it affordable for your parents from income and savings?

as bjkmom said, it’s tough to choose a college for someone we don’t know, that being said, some of these colleges are different in how the campus will feel to a student. Fordham (private, Bronx, Catholic) and Purdue (public, rural Indiana) would be two examples of that. If you prefer city or suburban that would probably eliminate a couple schools. Similarly, you should look at things like Greek life, how important sports is, etc. Given the sports at Michigan, maybe that would eliminate a couple others. Purdue is stronger in STEM so I would lean to Pitt of the ones you got admitted into and wherever you go, good luck, and invite us to the wedding!