Do I have a problem child or a normal college kid?

Coming late into this discussion…I totally agree with Oldfort’s post #50, from actual experience. My d went to school 700 miles away. She was doing post-grad work prior to getting an actual graduate degree and was 22 yrs old. I spoke with her probably 5 times a week, she had a car that we had bought her but we were not paying the insurance or most other living expenses at that point. She worked 25-30 hr per week and needed a car to get to work. Late one evening (around 10 PM) received a call from her advisor (who we knew fairly well at that point) that she hadn’t shown up for an opera rehearsal, did I know where she was? I had spoken with her the day before but not that day. This was totally unlike her and he was concerned. No answer on cell, went straight to voicemail. He said he’d make phone calls and check around town. An hour later he called back with really awful news–she had spent the night IN JAIL after being picked up for DUI. She tried to call her older brother but not us, but he didn’t pick up on the one phone call she was allowed. The advisor got her released and made her talk to us. Since we didn’t know the local area, the advisor helped her get a very good (and expensive) attorney who eventually got her off because the arrest was made improperly. We fronted the money for the attorney, but required repayment of the attorney fees over time, and she also had to pay to get her car out of impoundment (we did not front her that money). She didn’t immediately have the funds so had a hard time getting to work for a couple of weeks. Also, her license was suspended for 30 days until she took alcohol instruction classes (not sure that’s what it was called) as part of the no-conviction deal, so that made it really difficult to get to work again.

In her original confusion after being arrested, she thought she could get all of it taken care of by herself without us finding out!

My d learned a lot of lessons from this: it was not fun to be in prison all night wearing an orange jumpsuit, it was humiliating and degrading. Two, there are severe financial consequences to being arrested. Three, she was exposed to a group of people she normally didn’t hang around with both at the prison and in the classes she had to take. Luckily there are no convictions on her record, but as other posters have said a conviction can have long-term consequences to your career.

Six years later, my d still remembers all this and absolutely will not drink and drive and basically doesn’t even drink much at all.

As for smoking (sorry this is so long): I am a scientist who does research on chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, of which about 95% of cases are caused by smoking…I cannot figure out WHY anyone would smoke after you see the long term results of smoking. My company does not allow smoking anywhere on its property, even including sitting in your car if it’s in the company lot. Smoking is a liability for many reasons, including long term health. Some places will not even hire you if you smoke (I believe my company is headed in that direction), and health insurance costs are higher.

Just wanted to relay my story…I believe that the OPs daughter is having serious alcohol problems with this third encounter and needs to have a wake-up call.

From my understanding, right now she’s contributing nothing to her tuition. What is she spending her money on? Rent, food, sorority dues, cigarettes? If she’s paying her own room and board, books, cell phone bill, and everything else outside of tuition, then her spending money is already stretched pretty thin (in which case, why on earth is she wasting money on cigarettes is beyond me). But if she’s not, then her parents could have her contribute to those expenses as another consequence, until she can prove that she can demonstrate that she can make better choices. I’m not saying that she should work more (although she could if she chose to), but that her spending money could be going towards tuition, rather than the “extras” that she may be spending it on. It doesn’t have to be a lot, but enough to tighten up the budget and perhaps it will be a consequence that will make her life unpleasant enough to think before she acts. Her parents don’t have to use it, if they don’t want to, but it’s a way to get the “leverage” that you suggested they might want. OP already said her husband brought up the idea that they control where her paycheck goes, this is just another form of that. Instead of requiring her to deposit the check in an account they control, give her another expense that she has to spend the money on.

Yes, something will have to give. I worked over 20 hours a week (~30 on average, and much more during the summer) during undergrad and graduated with a 4.0. I get it. But the idea is that what would give is her ability to spend money on extra stuff. Would I actually recommend doing that? Probably not. But you suggested that they have no “leverage” besides pulling her out of school, and I just think that there could be a middle ground option.

I had to write a paper for one of my college classes and I chose to write about alcohol and the young (18-24 year old) brain. Here is an excerpt from that paper:

While most university students incorrectly believe that the average student consumes alcoholic drinks at least three times per week, the truth is that less than 20% of students ages 18-24 drink this much (Vinci, et al., 2010). Besides the typical concerns that underage drinking brings: death, assaults, sexual abuse, injury, academic problems, and health/suicide attempts; underage drinking affects brain development. Upon adulthood, the human brain is continuing to grow and develop critical structure and functional maturation (Silveri, 2012).

Heavy drinking reduces brain cell production in young adult/post teen brains (18-24 years) and drinking more alcohol causes a positive response to alcohol consumption; while at the same time the excessive alcohol causes a disruption in the brain maturation process (National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, n.d.). Therefore, the more a young adult drinks, the more they are capable of drinking.

And if you follow this link and go to page 740 is shows what happens to the hippocampus- http://ils.unc.edu/bmh/neoref/nrschizophrenia/jsp/review/tmp/1648.pdf

Very scary.

References:
Silveri, M. (2012). Adolescent brain development and underage drinking in the United States: identifying risks of alcohol use in college populations. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22894728

Vinci, D., Philen, R., Walch, S., Kennedy, R., Harrell, M., Rime, C., & Matthews, J. (2010, January/February). Social Norms Tactics to Promote a Campus alcohol Coalition. American Journal of Health Education, 29-37. Retrieved from http://www.eric.ed.gov/PDFS/EJ871143.pdf

Wow… even if it is just plain mistaken identity that got you arrested, and it became obvious afterward that you are not the guilty party?

Seems like that also can be indirectly illegally discriminatory against members of groups who are more likely to be arrested even if not guilty (e.g. black men).

This is why there are now laws/regulations prohibiting pre-employment background checks until an offer is made and then you have to show that the offense you are bouncing the person for is related to the job responsibilities.

"KKmama wrote:
My professional standing can be pulled if I have ever been arrested - even without conviction.

Wow… even if it is just plain mistaken identity that got you arrested, and it became obvious afterward that you are not the guilty party?"

Off topic, but yes, and I have to sign an affidavit on every pastoral job application that I have never been ACCUSED of child abuse and/or several other violations. It is an excellent way for someone to destroy a pastor’s career!

From the perspective of an Ex-smoker and daughter/sister/niece of alcoholics I am perplexed at the reaction to drinking v smoking.

Trust me - alcohol is a bad addiction too and much more socially accepted and easier to hide. Those kids will drop the cigarettes pretty quick when it infringes on their social life. Right now, alcohol enhances it.

Not everybody at college drinks to excess (not everybody drinks). Had a comment about this at the Auburn game last weekend “Why no drunk AU students?” I’m sure there are some but according to my son and his friends “sloppy drunks” are frowned upon… and if there ever was a game to get drunk at it was last weekend - trust me, the visiting students did all over the place.

I’d definitely take the advice of others and address the behavior as a problem now (hell, it is - you just don’t know to what extent) and take whatever action you think will make an impression on her.