Do you give handouts to the homeless?

<p>For my senior class’s senior project this year, we decided to focus on ending homelessness in my hometown.</p>

<p>We found that the biggest cause of the prolongation of homelessness was people giving handouts, for the following reasons:</p>

<p>-If the person on the corner knows that he/she can get whatever they need there, why would he/she ever get up and go to a shelter where they can turn things around?
-Giving handouts makes people feel as though they have done something to really help the issue. However, what you are really doing is putting a band-aid on the issue and prolonging that person staying on the street.</p>

<p>Some simple statistics that we discovered: (most of these come from the Long Beach Rescue Mission or our own research or experiences with the homeless throughout the course of the school year.)</p>

<p>-Thousands of people around the world are one paycheck, one illness, one missed payment away from being homeless.
-When a homeless person asks directly for money, there is a 96% chance they are going to use that money for drugs and/or alcohol.
-45% of the homeless are women and children…the fastest growing population of homeless in the world.
-Given a choice, only about 3% of the homeless population would choose to remain homeless.
-When you give anything to a homeless person…whether it be food, money, clothes, blankets, or anything else…you are enabling them to stay on the street.</p>

<p>So, what can you do???</p>

<p>Stop giving handouts and help end homelessness. The next time you see someone give handouts to the homeless, share these statistics with them.
If no one ever gave handouts again, how long do you think it would take the homeless to get up and get help???</p>

<p>And, the quote that we used as our sort of “slogan” all year…
“The truth does not change according to our ability to stomach it.”-Flannery O’Connor</p>

<p>I’m very sorry if anything I’ve said offended anyone. :)</p>

<p>Not offended here but I feel your solution is in large a simplification of the problem. What about the fact that many homeless people are mentally ill and in need of medical treatment?
I can’t imagine sharing these statistics with that segment of the homeless population.
Years ago I worked in an area with a large homeless population. Whenever someone asked my friend for money he would instead invite them to have a meal with him. Sometimes they would but not often. He felt that this avoided the problem of giving them money for drugs and alcohol.
I’m not sure this is a good option either and most of us probably wouldn’t feel totally comfortable with it.
I have personally become fairly well acquainted with two homeless individuals. Neither was an addict, one was a schizophrenic who would not take medication. The other was an older gentleman who chose to live in his car. He worked and enjoyed his life on his terms. He had gone through a lot in his life and did not want to be tied down in any way. He did not panhandle or approach anyone for money…I would say he was a very unusual example. Not the norm.</p>

<p>I don’t give handouts. For years, there was a woman who would sit in front of the building where I work, wearing nothing but a garbage bag. I and others, used to give her money and try to help. I came to find out that there was a man lurking across the street who would come and take the money and abuse her. All we did was continue that cycle. We made her degradation and abuse profitable to her abuser.</p>

<p>ebeeeee-of course there are mentally ill individuals, and we worked with that issue also. Our no-handouts solution was definitely geared towards those who do not have that issue, and you bring up a very good and valid point.</p>

<p>Unfortunately, there’s not as much we as individuals can do to help that portion of the homeless population. We worked all year trying to figure out what we can do for them. But aside from building a center strictly for the mentally ill (which seemed woefully unreasonable given we only had a 9-month time line to work with), we couldn’t come up with much.</p>

<p>zoosersmom-what a sad story.</p>

<p>We also had a woman bring up a similar situation…if you give money or food to a homeless person, and another one approaches you, they expect you to do the same for them, even if you really don’t have anymore money/food. And it makes the person you did give the money/food to more susceptible to abuse/robbery later.</p>

<p>“a simplification of the problem”</p>

<p>Right. I see food and money handouts as very different. There is no one so low that I begrudge them a baloney sandwich – murderers on death row get that. So food, yes, money, no.</p>

<p>“geared towards those who do not have that issue”</p>

<p>How are you supposed to tell the difference?</p>

<p>When you give anything to a homeless person…whether it be food, money, clothes, blankets, or anything else…you are enabling them to stay on the street…If no one ever gave handouts again, how long do you think it would take the homeless to get up and get help???"</p>

<p>Do you consider the possibility that without help they may perish?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>In our area, the mentally ill were an incredibly small portion of the homeless. There were very few people that we came across who had that issue, and it was pretty easy to distinguish those who were ill and those who weren’t.</p>

<p>padad-put yourself in the shoes of a homeless man. If all of a sudden, no one gave you food for…let’s say three days…and you were used to getting help every single day. How long do you think it would take before your survival instincts kick in and you go anywhere you can for help, even to a shelter?</p>

<p>It may seem harsh, but is it better that they continue living on the street and depending on others for what (very many of them, not all) they could just as easily accomplish themselves?</p>

<p>Now those of them who cannot should indeed have access to facilities that can help them. Which is why we as a class went to city hall meetings all year and tried to get council members on our side.</p>

<p>Wow. Reading these responses and then just read the original post again. So your senior class project was to focus on ending homelessness in Long Beach?
It’s a lofty goal but I can see why the oversimplification of the problem…
for whatever reason this thread is hitting a nerve with me and I will depart it rather than really offend anyone.</p>

<p>I used to buy McD coupons to give anyone who asks for money. </p>

<p>I agree with the mentally ill angle. I always give to people with visible infirmities like missing an arm or a leg or with pets.</p>

<p>ebeeeee-I’m sorry it’s hard for you, but it was hard for all of us as well. And it’s hard for me to explain the whole project over the internet.</p>

<p>We didn’t just walk around yelling at people not to give handouts. We attended city council meetings, we went and worked at shelters, we raised just over $3,000 dollars for the Long Beach Rescue Mission.</p>

<p>We also did a project called “A Day In the Life”…where we challenged students to carry everything they had in a paper bag all day instead of using backpacks/lockers/etc. We scheduled this day in the middle of winter and told students not to wear jackets. It was a voluntary activity, but almost half of our school participated.</p>

<p>If you’re interested, we do have a MySpace, but I don’t think I’m allowed ot post it here…just tell me if you’d like access to it and I’ll PM you the link.</p>

<p>

Here in New York help is abundant. In order for someone to be on the street, they must have actively rejected that. As for the mental illness aspect, that’s the saddest part. The courts here have rejected forced removal from the streets to receive assistance. People die every year. Handing them money will not help them. Forcing them into appropriate care would do that very thing.</p>

<p>HGFM, if nothing else, you’ve developed an awareness of and compassion for the homeless. That is a valuable thing and I’m sure it will guide you in your actions going forward. Good job sweetie!</p>

<p>Thanks, zoosersmom. :slight_smile: </p>

<p>I have to go get some shots at the doctor (wooo) but I’ll definitely check this thread as soon as I get back.</p>

<p>“padad-put yourself in the shoes of a homeless man. If all of a sudden, no one gave you food for…let’s say three days…and you were used to getting help every single day. How long do you think it would take before your survival instincts kick in and you go anywhere you can for help, even to a shelter?”</p>

<p>Are you saying that these people rather be homeless? Perhaps the problem lies in not giving them enough help? Afterall, you did indicate that a rising population of homeless includes children. Don’t you think more help should be extended to them?</p>

<p>Last fall we were in DC. We were waiting at a certain corner for our S to pick us up. It happened to be the same corner as a beggar - someone with one of those “just need bus money” stories. We said no, we didn’t have any money to give him. We’d been at the archives all day, had our laptop, etc. We decided to walk a block away. We had to walk back again, when S showed up. The guy was still there, now just wanting a little money because he was so hungry. His face lit up when my H reached into the laptop pocket – and fell again when H handed him an apple.</p>

<p>Rome was awful for beggars. They are very aggressive - grabbing clothing, getting in your face. Lots of deformities. Unfortunately some of the deformities are fake, and some are caused by self or others to increase profits. So we did not feel good about helping them, either - were actually advised against doing so. We did notice that Rome was extremely filthy - I wished they could start some sort of vagrant garbage collection - hand out certain type of distinctive garbage bag. Folks who fill it could then turn in it in exchange for a meal or other assistance.</p>

<p>This American Life had a good feature on some guys who decided to choose the homeless lifestyle. One they said was that anyone homeless who says they are hungry is scamming you are there was so much food around they gained weight. Both got tired of the life in a couple of years and moved into housing.</p>

<p>New Haven has a terrific program called New Haven Cares, where people can buy vouchers to give to the homeless. These can be redeemed at supermarkets, pharmacies, etc., but not for alcohol, drugs, or cigarettes. The following article was written in 1993; the vouchers are now 50 cents each:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>“There were very few people that we came across who had that issue, and it was pretty easy to distinguish those who were ill and those who weren’t.”</p>

<p>Maybe it was easy to distinguish those who were floridly psychotic from those who were lucid, but how could you tell whether the lucid individuals were seriously disabled by depression, anxiety, personality disorders, etc.? If you could do that without a great deal of personal probing, you’re way ahead of the psychiatric profession.</p>

<p>“Epidemiological estimates indicate that about one-third of all homeless, single adults have severe and persistent mental illness and have marked neuropsychological impairments in attention, executive functioning, verbal memory, and general intellectual functioning.”</p>

<p>[PA-04-024:</a> HIV/AIDS, SEVERE MENTAL ILLNESS AND HOMELESSNESS](<a href=“http://grants.nih.gov/grants/guide/pa-files/PA-04-024.html]PA-04-024:”>PA-04-024: HIV/AIDS, SEVERE MENTAL ILLNESS AND HOMELESSNESS)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Ah…if ONLY life was this simple!!! </p>

<p>I wonder what the statistics are for how many homeless commit criminal acts in order to survive? And how many would resort to criminal acts if the handouts disappeared?</p>

<p>This reminds me of an old proverb: “Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Don’t give him a fish - and he will find a job and buy his own food.” No, wait that’s not quite right, is it? ;)</p>